User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I don't know what you're looking for...I've been responding to stuff in the bugs forum here and there for the last few days.

I can either work on real solutions or I can spend my days posting in the bugs forum. I've chosen to actually spend most of my time working on constructive things like writing and testing code, rather than trying to justify everything to the same people asking the same thing over and over about why their player is now able to make mistakes.

The thing is - you're going to end up with basically the same outcome that's happening now, numbers wise. It will just look a little different, since people can't seem to accept the idea of receivers catching the ball in traffic.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I don't know what you're looking for...I've been responding to stuff in the bugs forum here and there for the last few days.

I can either work on real solutions or I can spend my days posting in the bugs forum. I've chosen to actually spend most of my time working on constructive things like writing and testing code, rather than trying to justify everything to the same people asking the same thing over and over about why their player is now able to make mistakes.

The thing is - you're going to end up with basically the same outcome that's happening now, numbers wise. It will just look a little different, since people can't seem to accept the idea of receivers catching the ball in traffic.


Well, thanks, that's the most information I've heard from you in a long time.

I just hope that whatever changes there are, they make strategy relevant again.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I hope that didn't come off like I'm trying to be a jerk, because I'm not. It's just tough to balance actual work with pleasing the masses asking for answers. Sometimes I have to just ignore the forum in order to get anything done (it sucks you in, ya know?)
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I hope that didn't come off like I'm trying to be a jerk, because I'm not. It's just tough to balance actual work with pleasing the masses asking for answers. Sometimes I have to just ignore the forum in order to get anything done (it sucks you in, ya know?)


I fully understand where you're coming from. Heck, it's why I lost my temper and eventually got myself offline last night.

I couldn't do what you do, even if I could program like you can.

I think a lot of the difficulty in people not understanding catching the ball in traffic is that because a dot is almost two yards long, one can be on top of the other in the replay and still not be in the exact same place.

I do think it's better if it were more a question of people biting on fakes, as that would reinvigorate zone coverage, which ought to be more useful relative to Man coverage than it is.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Bort

I don't know what you're looking for...I've been responding to stuff in the bugs forum here and there for the last few days.

I can either work on real solutions or I can spend my days posting in the bugs forum. I've chosen to actually spend most of my time working on constructive things like writing and testing code, rather than trying to justify everything to the same people asking the same thing over and over about why their player is now able to make mistakes.

The thing is - you're going to end up with basically the same outcome that's happening now, numbers wise. It will just look a little different, since people can't seem to accept the idea of receivers catching the ball in traffic.


Well, thanks, that's the most information I've heard from you in a long time.

I just hope that whatever changes there are, they make strategy relevant again.


If you think game strategy is irrelevant, you are sadly, sadly mistaken.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
For me i have no problem at all with WRs catching balls in traffic. What i would like to see corrected is stuff like the example i posted on page 1 in this thread. WRs should be able to make catches with 2-3 backs on them **sometimes**, but what shouldnt be happening is a CB running 20 yds ahead of a WR to exactly the spot where the ball is being thrown, before the ball is ever thrown, and then not reacting to it once its in the air...unless of course our league is full of clairvoyant CBs.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I hope that didn't come off like I'm trying to be a jerk, because I'm not. It's just tough to balance actual work with pleasing the masses asking for answers. Sometimes I have to just ignore the forum in order to get anything done (it sucks you in, ya know?)


OK Bort, a design question for you.

If a CB and WR are equally well trained, what percentage are you looking to average for a completed pass? We won't get into what equally well trained is, but there has to be some kind of number you would be aiming for.

I'm not asking to start a flame war, I am simply asking to try to understand your theory on offense and defense, and the relevance of attributes, training, and tactics settings.

By the way, please don't let any complaining slow you down from the adjustments you feel the game needs. The longer it takes to get them in, the more complaining you are going to see. It's like a bandage, pull it off slow or fast, it still a pain.

PinTBC
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by dberner30

the game is becoming a joke.


and yet you keep creating players

The game is actually becoming more realistic...last season was a joke with overpowered defenses. We're only in season 4, 6+ seasons away from a first run through of players.

People these days have zero patience.


no i have stopped....and im disappointed...im glad to see some bort responses...the lack of patience comes from lack of communication...maybe a listing of the bugs/errors currently being worked...maybe an acknowledgment of what isnt working so we all know clearly instead of all these BS flamer posts making excuses...if it works it works...if it doesnt its nice to know that...


 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Bort

I hope that didn't come off like I'm trying to be a jerk, because I'm not. It's just tough to balance actual work with pleasing the masses asking for answers. Sometimes I have to just ignore the forum in order to get anything done (it sucks you in, ya know?)


OK Bort, a design question for you.

If a CB and WR are equally well trained, what percentage are you looking to average for a completed pass? We won't get into what equally well trained is, but there has to be some kind of number you would be aiming for.

I'm not asking to start a flame war, I am simply asking to try to understand your theory on offense and defense, and the relevance of attributes, training, and tactics settings.

By the way, please don't let any complaining slow you down from the adjustments you feel the game needs. The longer it takes to get them in, the more complaining you are going to see. It's like a bandage, pull it off slow or fast, it still a pain.

PinTBC


back to my original post...why does a level 22 CB struggle against level 26-27 WRs and the other CB on the opposite side of the field running the same defensive set that is a level 9 (and the b/u guys were level 9) absolutely succeed...

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Bort

I hope that didn't come off like I'm trying to be a jerk, because I'm not. It's just tough to balance actual work with pleasing the masses asking for answers. Sometimes I have to just ignore the forum in order to get anything done (it sucks you in, ya know?)


OK Bort, a design question for you.

If a CB and WR are equally well trained, what percentage are you looking to average for a completed pass? We won't get into what equally well trained is, but there has to be some kind of number you would be aiming for.

I'm not asking to start a flame war, I am simply asking to try to understand your theory on offense and defense, and the relevance of attributes, training, and tactics settings.

By the way, please don't let any complaining slow you down from the adjustments you feel the game needs. The longer it takes to get them in, the more complaining you are going to see. It's like a bandage, pull it off slow or fast, it still a pain.

PinTBC


I'm generally looking for completion rates in the range from 50-65% when everybody's pretty evenly matched and the QB doesn't completely suck ass. Sometimes a little higher or lower, depending on builds, etc, but I'd like to see things close to the realm of realism.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Originally posted by Bort


I don't know what you're looking for...I've been responding to stuff in the bugs forum here and there for the last few days.

I can either work on real solutions or I can spend my days posting in the bugs forum. I've chosen to actually spend most of my time working on constructive things like writing and testing code, rather than trying to justify everything to the same people asking the same thing over and over about why their player is now able to make mistakes.

The thing is - you're going to end up with basically the same outcome that's happening now, numbers wise. It will just look a little different, since people can't seem to accept the idea of receivers catching the ball in traffic.


Well, thanks, that's the most information I've heard from you in a long time.

I just hope that whatever changes there are, they make strategy relevant again.


If you think game strategy is irrelevant, you are sadly, sadly mistaken.


When LBs with run focus are doing this in man coverage: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92442&pbp_id=4073848

and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854

and when a level 7 does this to a level 26 because of whining about averages being low in season 3: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92493&pbp_id=2655910

...tactics and build become irrelevant.

Strategy becomes irrelevant.
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
and for what its worth man to man defense used to be too powerful...now its too weak...but thats okay...if you expect to be outmatched in M2M coverage you go to a zone...but zone is broken...so fix zone please...

if nothing else give a short explanation of the position and how the skills interact for us to work with...the strategy guide isnt worth the paper its written on at this point...maybe a short synopsis of what the skill does for the position...

and please slow down the DT that runs downfield 70 yards outrunning LB/S/CB types in pursuit...
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854


I don't see what's wrong with that play? It looks like he stayed pretty close to me...the guy just made the catch.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thunderdoozer


and CBs in Close Aggressive coverage do things like this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854


I don't see what's wrong with that play? It looks like he stayed pretty close to me...the guy just made the catch.


WHAT!?!?!

He didn't break on the ball or even react in any way to the play. He left a huge cushion considering the situation and didn't jump the route at all. The HAS to be a way to get our guy to make a play on that ball, even if he fails.

EDIT: Of course, ultimately, it doesn't matter about how closely he plays, because right now whether the WR catches the ball or not doesn't seem to depend at all on how close the coverage is. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92442&pbp_id=4075456
Last edited Aug 17, 2008 12:02:48
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
and i would suggest a special forum where access goes only to those who have payed over a certain amount or have a certain amount of game time or a certain amount of players/teams etc to discuss bugs or quirks that need some work...these threads in this forum turn into debates of the masses and are usually flame ridden...you could then limit your reading to the threads posted by 500 users where you could accomplish more reading of better quality faster...your problem now is too many users posting too much junk in the bugs area...if you find something you want comment on from the masses you post it for comment...plus the 500 user group is going to raise these issues because they are reading the postings of the masses...if you want productive criticism of shortcomings in the sim all you have to do is ask a small group of us...

but frankly until now i posted very little in this area or any other general forum area because its a huge waste of time and finger strength...your forums are generally out of control and your mods spend too much time locking threads that have legitimate concerns about GLB...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.