User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The only reason multiple coverage now results in a QB being able to attempt the pass is because people bitched about certain players never getting targeted, even if he's a better catcher than his defenders. If the receiver has a good chance of catching the ball vs his defenders' tipping abilities, he can still get the ball thrown his way.


Hey Bort,

I remember you saying something about a delay in the CB reaction to a route, was that just for WR or TE as well?

Also, since people seem to complain, about triple coverage, not sure if another second or half a second might help in reminding them that the dots are not an accurate portrayal of the on field play.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The only reason multiple coverage now results in a QB being able to attempt the pass is because people bitched about certain players never getting targeted, even if he's a better catcher than his defenders. If the receiver has a good chance of catching the ball vs his defenders' tipping abilities, he can still get the ball thrown his way.


Bort I understand people bitch about every move and it's hard to make it perfect but there are so many times where there is a safety over the top and a CB and LB literally covering up the WR dot and the WR makes the catch...doesn't this seem a bit crazy?
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Just because the sim didn't go your way, doesn't mean it's broken.


Except others who have won every game on good teams think otherwise.

Bort:

Targeting is something that should be controlled by the GM/OC. Progressions would be a nice thing to add.

I'm not a programmer, but there has to be a happy medium between a 50% completion rate into more than double coverage.

I've been on the plus end of it as well.
 
Blacksheep
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Second, you want it to NEVER be able to make a catch in triple or double coverage? Then what's the point of even trying? A defense can just double team a team's best WR all game and keep him at 0 yds.


DC's would be given complete control...imagine the complaints.

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Bort

The only reason multiple coverage now results in a QB being able to attempt the pass is because people bitched about certain players never getting targeted, even if he's a better catcher than his defenders. If the receiver has a good chance of catching the ball vs his defenders' tipping abilities, he can still get the ball thrown his way.


Bort I understand people bitch about every move and it's hard to make it perfect but there are so many times where there is a safety over the top and a CB and LB literally covering up the WR dot and the WR makes the catch...doesn't this seem a bit crazy?


Jrry,

That is why I asked about the delay he was talking about, as it is now, I see the delay there, but the QB doesn't find it quick enough and by the time he does, they are covered again, so maybe add another half second.

I guess this might depend on the QB vision as well, we played one team who passed, the QB was firing off passes on a 2 step count lol
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Also, if there are 3 guys there covering, that each should have a chance at the tip, and each should have a chance at the catch. If this is the case, then the settings are too imbalanced.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Well the other option to help the passing game not completely suck is to allow receivers to get open even more often, by increasing the likelihood of a fake, or reducing reaction time yet more. Of course, then people would complain that their CB can't stick to every receiver like glue all the time.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stahu miguel
Also, if there are 3 guys there covering, that each should have a chance at the tip, and each should have a chance at the catch. If this is the case, then the settings are too imbalanced.


Not sure I agree, I think that should be all dependent on the levels and attributes of each player,

Similar attributes, then yes,

But if you have a CB who is all speed and agility and no jumping and catching, he should have a drastically less chance of catching or tipping the ball.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Bort

I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


No Bort but I must say when a guy is in double and triple coverage he shouldn't be able to catch the ball.


That is the most absurd thing I have ever heard you say.
 
Pats Fan 81
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Well the other option to help the passing game not completely suck is to allow receivers to get open even more often, by increasing the likelihood of a fake, or reducing reaction time yet more. Of course, then people would complain that their CB can't stick to every receiver like glue all the time.


Either way people don't like it.
Being able to choose how much to target someone is a good idea
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Well the other option to help the passing game not completely suck is to allow receivers to get open even more often, by increasing the likelihood of a fake, or reducing reaction time yet more. Of course, then people would complain that their CB can't stick to every receiver like glue all the time.


I'd be more for this. It would at least be realistic.
 
hntrr31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Well the other option to help the passing game not completely suck is to allow receivers to get open even more often, by increasing the likelihood of a fake, or reducing reaction time yet more. Of course, then people would complain that their CB can't stick to every receiver like glue all the time.


But that would be more realistic. I'm not saying I like the thought, but I think that is the right thing to do.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Well the other option to help the passing game not completely suck is to allow receivers to get open even more often, by increasing the likelihood of a fake, or reducing reaction time yet more. Of course, then people would complain that their CB can't stick to every receiver like glue all the time.


Bort,

I understand your point, I wonder if it is possible to test that out, see how much more wide open or open they get, vs now, I think the perception is that if the Dot A is right next to Dot B, there is no way that Dot B should catch the ball, without realizing that the Dots are not exact placement of each player, the dots can be 3 yards apart which means, yes the guy will catch it.

I do see where they are coming from on this one though as I have seen it time and time again where Dot A is covering Dot B, and you can't see Dot B, but more than half the time, a catch is made, would it be worth testing to see exactly the average of catches vs non catches in that situation?
 
Vagrant God
offline
Link
 
The dots are three yards wide. If someone is covered by three people in the game, they could easily be three yards away from him each way. Also, the replays aren't exactly what happens, the text says what happens, go by that, and don't complain if the replay is a little off. And yes, recievers in real life can catch the ball in double coverage and even triple coverage.
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 10:48:30
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Bort


I guess you'd rather go back to 40% completion rates and 1.5 ypa? Players have to be able to catch the ball sometimes, especially when defenders play on aggressive and miss the int attempt. It's just a random roll - if the 3 players were in position, they get to make a roll vs the player's catching ability to tip the ball. If they all miss the roll, the receiver gets to make a roll vs the defenders' tipping ability to catch the ball.


No Bort but I must say when a guy is in double and triple coverage he shouldn't be able to catch the ball.


That is the most absurd thing I have ever heard you say.


How is it absurd at all? In real life, how many WRs can catch the ball when the LB and CB have them perfectly covered and the FS is sitting behind them? The only guys I can think of are guys like Moss and TO and no one on this game has 99 jumping and 99 catching.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.