Anyway, i created the thread so that Bort and admin can think about all that. Because there's a problem. Regardless what the answer/solution is, there IS a problem. You guys sort it out. I made a suggestion is all...the 90 skills as rookie vs 100 skills as 10 year vet (max). There could be other ideas, better ideas, etc, but right now i see a problem with this long-term as well -- even just in regards getting people to sign up and persist etc.
bigtisme
offline
offline
Originally posted by GG
Long-term...do you see new people signing up, joining GLB, creating players and pumping $10 per season into them.....IF....they never get a starter job, never rise from 5th string on the depth chart?
You are going to have to start lower...you just can't come into this game and expect to start on a USA pro team when you first make your player.
There is a skill decline with age
There will be level caps and salary caps in the future
Your idea of making everyone get 90s in physical skills really makes very little sense at all as far as a solution goes to be perfectly honest.
Long-term...do you see new people signing up, joining GLB, creating players and pumping $10 per season into them.....IF....they never get a starter job, never rise from 5th string on the depth chart?
You are going to have to start lower...you just can't come into this game and expect to start on a USA pro team when you first make your player.
There is a skill decline with age
There will be level caps and salary caps in the future
Your idea of making everyone get 90s in physical skills really makes very little sense at all as far as a solution goes to be perfectly honest.
randomguymike
offline
offline
Originally posted by GG
Long-term...do you see new people signing up, joining GLB, creating players and pumping $10 per season into them.....IF....they never get a starter job, never rise from 5th string on the depth chart?
The whole idea of GLB is to make money, make people sign, have a huge demand to join, etc. Instead the opposite is occuring AFTER they realize they're never getting any game time etc. They stop funding these players. They complain and demand a trade, release. Looking for places where they can start. Which they never will because the theory is that those who've been here for 5 seasons will all be level 30 and therefore always infinitely superior such that these level 1-5 guys never get game time so they never pump money into that players development.
DO you see the catch-22?
No, I don't. Again, that's why there are levels. for some reason you seem offended that players would have to start in a B/C league. If they want to start, that's what they have to do. After afew seasons, they'll work themselves up.
I really don't get why you think that you should be able to create a player to compete at the highest level on day1. That's part of the challenge of this whole thing is building your player.
Long-term...do you see new people signing up, joining GLB, creating players and pumping $10 per season into them.....IF....they never get a starter job, never rise from 5th string on the depth chart?
The whole idea of GLB is to make money, make people sign, have a huge demand to join, etc. Instead the opposite is occuring AFTER they realize they're never getting any game time etc. They stop funding these players. They complain and demand a trade, release. Looking for places where they can start. Which they never will because the theory is that those who've been here for 5 seasons will all be level 30 and therefore always infinitely superior such that these level 1-5 guys never get game time so they never pump money into that players development.
DO you see the catch-22?
No, I don't. Again, that's why there are levels. for some reason you seem offended that players would have to start in a B/C league. If they want to start, that's what they have to do. After afew seasons, they'll work themselves up.
I really don't get why you think that you should be able to create a player to compete at the highest level on day1. That's part of the challenge of this whole thing is building your player.
GG
offline
offline
I'll give you a real example...
I bought a team, told all my friends, got them all to join, in that time frame, about 10 or so joined, we were all able to boost up, later i got more friends to join. By that time, half of us were all level 8 and the rest level 2-5. Never able to catch-up, and therefore being so inferior skilled, benched forever. They ended up complaining, and since then theres like a whole half of my team unhappy with GLB, unhappy with me as owner, all complaining that they just spent $10+ only to never get game time etc. So seasons end, some are not coming back, (lost $$ to GLB), some are saying they want a trade out to somewhere they can start. But if most other teams out there are ALSO similarly placed with a majority of level 8+ players, then they'll never start anywhere. Unless they somehow buy a team. But if there's always gonna be more players than leagues/teams then it's impossible for GLB to grow to a behemoth due to that. People stop spending. Stop playing. Lose enthusiasm.
I bought a team, told all my friends, got them all to join, in that time frame, about 10 or so joined, we were all able to boost up, later i got more friends to join. By that time, half of us were all level 8 and the rest level 2-5. Never able to catch-up, and therefore being so inferior skilled, benched forever. They ended up complaining, and since then theres like a whole half of my team unhappy with GLB, unhappy with me as owner, all complaining that they just spent $10+ only to never get game time etc. So seasons end, some are not coming back, (lost $$ to GLB), some are saying they want a trade out to somewhere they can start. But if most other teams out there are ALSO similarly placed with a majority of level 8+ players, then they'll never start anywhere. Unless they somehow buy a team. But if there's always gonna be more players than leagues/teams then it's impossible for GLB to grow to a behemoth due to that. People stop spending. Stop playing. Lose enthusiasm.
GG
offline
offline
The other point is that Im currently pro-league team. Ok. But if theres ever a rule brought in that says level 1 players cannot play for pro-leagues, say, then youre preventing me as owner from creating a player(s) and having them play on my team. Or my friends from playing on my team. I dont want to put money into a new player i created to be 4th string in some XXXX league team. I wanted specifically to create a new player for MY team, or my friends team. To help him or me out because he or I just lost 2 OT's to trades/releases and so I wanted to bring in a new player. But that rule would prevent me.
Theres a few catch-22's there. It's not about complaining that a level 1 is a level 1 per se. But that there's too huge a difference that it ends up preventing people from persisting with GLB, spending money on GLB, or joining GLB. Or rules brought in that prevent friends from playing together. Or team owners from creating/spending money on their own team as need arises. And...as well, that whole 21 pancakes thing as well which amplifies a team owners decision to bench everyone whose inferior level. Vicious circle.
Theres a few catch-22's there. It's not about complaining that a level 1 is a level 1 per se. But that there's too huge a difference that it ends up preventing people from persisting with GLB, spending money on GLB, or joining GLB. Or rules brought in that prevent friends from playing together. Or team owners from creating/spending money on their own team as need arises. And...as well, that whole 21 pancakes thing as well which amplifies a team owners decision to bench everyone whose inferior level. Vicious circle.
bigtisme
offline
offline
No its a limit like...in USA CCC you have to be under 15 or something. Thats the level limit we're talking about.
and level 2-5 can easily catch level 8s i think you'll see that next season. I think you might be looking too short term here though...this differecne will even out over time!
and level 2-5 can easily catch level 8s i think you'll see that next season. I think you might be looking too short term here though...this differecne will even out over time!
GG
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtisme
No its a limit like...in USA CCC you have to be under 15 or something. Thats the level limit we're talking about.
and level 2-5 can easily catch level 8s i think you'll see that next season. I think you might be looking too short term here though...this differecne will even out over time!
Level 2 cannot ever catch-up with a level 8. Both end up earning roughly the same XP over the lifetime of both players. You're looking at maybe 8 seasons before the level 2 catches up, only have a couple seasons in him before he retires as well.
The whole XP thing imo is flawed. Because it's just game time they both earn fairly similar rates. But at all times you will start the higher levels because of things like the 21 pancakes. But also because there's too big a difference between levels. Your team will just lose if you started all level 5's against a team of level 10's, just to give people on the team a chance to start.
I made another thread about training. Where XPs should only be something you gain thru training, like a real simulator, that you do, and the better you do at it, the more XP you earn. This way at least people on the bench can actually train during games, doing some True-False type of football trivia quiz (as a training simulator example) and therefore earn themselves say 10 skill points while the starter either didnt do his training or scored poorly, therefore might earn say 1 skill point. So what that would do at least is give back-ups a real chance to quickly catch-up and overtake based on training.
Simulator could be quiz, could be wonderlic, could be pointing the mouse over footballs falling from the sky and trying to get a high score etc. This done between every game would give people something to compete for, and a chance to rise up the depth chart.
But an XP system where all you do is make a training setting and that's it and then based on snaps per game, just means everyone rises at the same rates pretty much. 8 seasons would go by and a level 2 would never catch up to level 8 until both retire.
The problem is the skill settings for rookies are far too low. And the whole XP system.
No its a limit like...in USA CCC you have to be under 15 or something. Thats the level limit we're talking about.
and level 2-5 can easily catch level 8s i think you'll see that next season. I think you might be looking too short term here though...this differecne will even out over time!
Level 2 cannot ever catch-up with a level 8. Both end up earning roughly the same XP over the lifetime of both players. You're looking at maybe 8 seasons before the level 2 catches up, only have a couple seasons in him before he retires as well.
The whole XP thing imo is flawed. Because it's just game time they both earn fairly similar rates. But at all times you will start the higher levels because of things like the 21 pancakes. But also because there's too big a difference between levels. Your team will just lose if you started all level 5's against a team of level 10's, just to give people on the team a chance to start.
I made another thread about training. Where XPs should only be something you gain thru training, like a real simulator, that you do, and the better you do at it, the more XP you earn. This way at least people on the bench can actually train during games, doing some True-False type of football trivia quiz (as a training simulator example) and therefore earn themselves say 10 skill points while the starter either didnt do his training or scored poorly, therefore might earn say 1 skill point. So what that would do at least is give back-ups a real chance to quickly catch-up and overtake based on training.
Simulator could be quiz, could be wonderlic, could be pointing the mouse over footballs falling from the sky and trying to get a high score etc. This done between every game would give people something to compete for, and a chance to rise up the depth chart.
But an XP system where all you do is make a training setting and that's it and then based on snaps per game, just means everyone rises at the same rates pretty much. 8 seasons would go by and a level 2 would never catch up to level 8 until both retire.
The problem is the skill settings for rookies are far too low. And the whole XP system.
bigtisme
offline
offline
Well you dont get as much EXP at higher levels actually. And even the overnight goes down by 3-5 each level. But i am sensing you have your opinion and your just going to keep it that way no matter what so i think im done in this thread.
AF_Medic
offline
offline
Now maybe wrong, but those players that have played 10 seasons and start declining will retire/be cut and new free agents signed by the owner. they will be able to afford to pay those players that are high levels as they will have built up stadiums and have more revenue.
Now I think the system they are talking about makes sense. No you won't be able to create a player and expect him to compete in pro leagues. but as an owner you will be able to sign a player that CAN compete at that level.
Now I think the system they are talking about makes sense. No you won't be able to create a player and expect him to compete in pro leagues. but as an owner you will be able to sign a player that CAN compete at that level.
GG
offline
offline
Originally posted by AF_Medic
Now maybe wrong, but those players that have played 10 seasons and start declining will retire/be cut and new free agents signed by the owner. they will be able to afford to pay those players that are high levels as they will have built up stadiums and have more revenue.
Now I think the system they are talking about makes sense. No you won't be able to create a player and expect him to compete in pro leagues. but as an owner you will be able to sign a player that CAN compete at that level.
People with a player 5+ levels behind the starters are not gonna sit there for 10 seasons and pump $10 per season into boosting them if they have to wait 10 seasons before they become starters. The person who owns him will lose enthusiasm long before season 3 even and cease to spend money on boosting.
Then you get the added problem of if you create a team for all your friends and you to join and share in a team, ends up being thwarted from playing together if rules are brought in preventing level 1 players joining the team you own (including players you yourself created to play for YOUR team) due to the team growing over the seasons into a level 20 team across the starters.
All Im saying is that level 1 should be considered like a real NFL rookie and have higher base skills and equal physical skills/attributes from to a veteran player. Vets would have better football skills only. That there IS a difference but it's not absurd like level 15 players pancaking level 8's 50 times a game, or WRs scoring 20 TDs a game, or RBs breaking 50 tackles a game....it should be something like 1-2 pancakes a game or a crucial broken tackle for a TD. A slight but evident difference.
This would allow team owners to actually start rookies, or level 5 players against level 15's with more confidence, especially when 'injuries' come in and you're relying on back-ups who are 5-10 levels lower. It would also allow people newly joining GLB to actually feel like they CAN get games, starting time, and if there was a training simulator replacing XPs then you would be rewarding people dedicated to GLB as they COULD earn like 15 skills points after a few training sessions that helps them rise up the depth chart in a matter of a few games. Not XP for game time because then it's all based on being a starter or 2nd backup. Just skill points earned based on training simulators. Instead of people boosting three levels by buying FPs, they can buy training sessions for their players. The key difference is that the better you do at the training sims, the more skill points you can earn. Whereas buying FPs just means a one-off 3 level boost that everyone does and so there's never a way for anyone to catch-up.
Now maybe wrong, but those players that have played 10 seasons and start declining will retire/be cut and new free agents signed by the owner. they will be able to afford to pay those players that are high levels as they will have built up stadiums and have more revenue.
Now I think the system they are talking about makes sense. No you won't be able to create a player and expect him to compete in pro leagues. but as an owner you will be able to sign a player that CAN compete at that level.
People with a player 5+ levels behind the starters are not gonna sit there for 10 seasons and pump $10 per season into boosting them if they have to wait 10 seasons before they become starters. The person who owns him will lose enthusiasm long before season 3 even and cease to spend money on boosting.
Then you get the added problem of if you create a team for all your friends and you to join and share in a team, ends up being thwarted from playing together if rules are brought in preventing level 1 players joining the team you own (including players you yourself created to play for YOUR team) due to the team growing over the seasons into a level 20 team across the starters.
All Im saying is that level 1 should be considered like a real NFL rookie and have higher base skills and equal physical skills/attributes from to a veteran player. Vets would have better football skills only. That there IS a difference but it's not absurd like level 15 players pancaking level 8's 50 times a game, or WRs scoring 20 TDs a game, or RBs breaking 50 tackles a game....it should be something like 1-2 pancakes a game or a crucial broken tackle for a TD. A slight but evident difference.
This would allow team owners to actually start rookies, or level 5 players against level 15's with more confidence, especially when 'injuries' come in and you're relying on back-ups who are 5-10 levels lower. It would also allow people newly joining GLB to actually feel like they CAN get games, starting time, and if there was a training simulator replacing XPs then you would be rewarding people dedicated to GLB as they COULD earn like 15 skills points after a few training sessions that helps them rise up the depth chart in a matter of a few games. Not XP for game time because then it's all based on being a starter or 2nd backup. Just skill points earned based on training simulators. Instead of people boosting three levels by buying FPs, they can buy training sessions for their players. The key difference is that the better you do at the training sims, the more skill points you can earn. Whereas buying FPs just means a one-off 3 level boost that everyone does and so there's never a way for anyone to catch-up.
fore772
offline
offline
pretty sure what was said was that there wouldnt be a minimum (or there would be after a while, once some players are like, level 50 or something), but a maximum for certain leagues, so that there won't be level 15 players playing against level 8s or so. and the fact is its not really like nfl rookie ranked, they're different leagues. the pro leagues are w/ pros, so obviously they'll have higher levels. if you make a new character, you might want to put him on your team, but wouldnt it be better to put him onto a smaller team or league where you would actually get playing time and xp? its like in other mmorpgs, you cant expect to be able to be with the level 30s if you're just level 5 or something. the gap is gigantic. you'd be playing w/ other level 5s to be able to catch up w/ the level 30s. people who start before tend to have a headstart. that's just how things are.
brOUsterman
offline
offline
If you give it a while i see it all setting up like that as where your lower leagues your a and aa are going to be seasons 1 and 2 and then if will continue to move up as long as you keep up with your guy. Its only season 2 dont get to worried as of rigth now it will work its self out.
GG
offline
offline
Originally posted by fore772
pretty sure what was said was that there wouldnt be a minimum (or there would be after a while, once some players are like, level 50 or something), but a maximum for certain leagues, so that there won't be level 15 players playing against level 8s or so. and the fact is its not really like nfl rookie ranked, they're different leagues. the pro leagues are w/ pros, so obviously they'll have higher levels. if you make a new character, you might want to put him on your team, but wouldnt it be better to put him onto a smaller team or league where you would actually get playing time and xp? its like in other mmorpgs, you cant expect to be able to be with the level 30s if you're just level 5 or something. the gap is gigantic. you'd be playing w/ other level 5s to be able to catch up w/ the level 30s. people who start before tend to have a headstart. that's just how things are.
Good points. But think about...trading and team ownership. There shouldnt be trading constraints or creation constraints on team owners. A pro-league team should be able to trade their level 20 3rd string back-up to a YYYY league team where he could be starter or help that team be better. Or, a team owner in Pro-League could trade for a level 5 from WWWW league to be a back-up on their team. Or just simply that I as pro-league team owner could create a new level 1 player that I'm willing to spend $10 a year on to make MY team better. Especially if I want to tailor-make a WR a certain way or to have certain abilities that I cant rely on others in my team willing to create. Shouldn't be forbidden by rules from having him on my pro-league team that I own.
If I want to create 50 players and boost them all per year, GLB wouldnt be against that. But if I create them all specifically for the team I own then you shouldn't be penalized either as a pro-league owner or a ZZZZZ owner if there's some rule on levels allowed in certain leagues.
No constraints would also mean the difference between levels then is not absurd like a 21 pancake per game thing -- which is just level 11 OL vs level 6 DL. Five levels! Not 21 pancakes.
pretty sure what was said was that there wouldnt be a minimum (or there would be after a while, once some players are like, level 50 or something), but a maximum for certain leagues, so that there won't be level 15 players playing against level 8s or so. and the fact is its not really like nfl rookie ranked, they're different leagues. the pro leagues are w/ pros, so obviously they'll have higher levels. if you make a new character, you might want to put him on your team, but wouldnt it be better to put him onto a smaller team or league where you would actually get playing time and xp? its like in other mmorpgs, you cant expect to be able to be with the level 30s if you're just level 5 or something. the gap is gigantic. you'd be playing w/ other level 5s to be able to catch up w/ the level 30s. people who start before tend to have a headstart. that's just how things are.
Good points. But think about...trading and team ownership. There shouldnt be trading constraints or creation constraints on team owners. A pro-league team should be able to trade their level 20 3rd string back-up to a YYYY league team where he could be starter or help that team be better. Or, a team owner in Pro-League could trade for a level 5 from WWWW league to be a back-up on their team. Or just simply that I as pro-league team owner could create a new level 1 player that I'm willing to spend $10 a year on to make MY team better. Especially if I want to tailor-make a WR a certain way or to have certain abilities that I cant rely on others in my team willing to create. Shouldn't be forbidden by rules from having him on my pro-league team that I own.
If I want to create 50 players and boost them all per year, GLB wouldnt be against that. But if I create them all specifically for the team I own then you shouldn't be penalized either as a pro-league owner or a ZZZZZ owner if there's some rule on levels allowed in certain leagues.
No constraints would also mean the difference between levels then is not absurd like a 21 pancake per game thing -- which is just level 11 OL vs level 6 DL. Five levels! Not 21 pancakes.
Last edited Apr 20, 2008 21:57:39
fore772
offline
offline
Well, for now, it's still early. I'll just say 'Let the seasons play out for a bit' and we'll see. Wait at least another season or two, see how things settle in then bring the topic back up
Certainly 21 pancakes is way too many, but maybe there were just odd circumstances, glitchiness, who knows. All I'm saying, we're still in the public beta and not everything is perfect or balanced yet. And the team thing.. I'm guessing that's why people would buy teams in different leagues. One farm team or w/e, and one main team, or in nicer terms, a lower leveled team, and a higher leveled team. So once the players get good enough or too good for the lower league, they can be moved up to the other team, and the owner can sign lower leveled players for his other team. Just let it play out.
Certainly 21 pancakes is way too many, but maybe there were just odd circumstances, glitchiness, who knows. All I'm saying, we're still in the public beta and not everything is perfect or balanced yet. And the team thing.. I'm guessing that's why people would buy teams in different leagues. One farm team or w/e, and one main team, or in nicer terms, a lower leveled team, and a higher leveled team. So once the players get good enough or too good for the lower league, they can be moved up to the other team, and the owner can sign lower leveled players for his other team. Just let it play out.You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























