User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Pump Fakes need to be re-examined. They cause a 'stun' essentially and the separation allowed in the stun is far to great and becomes near unrecoverable. Just like CB's aren;t supposed to be perfect neither are WR's and QB's. A few extra yards or even a nice break out is fair, but high pump fakes = much more than that.

If I were in charge:

C snaps ball to QB.
QB watches play develop.
QB makes 'pump fake' check, this causes a check against vision/super vision for Defensive Secondary. If fail - they bite and move in direction of play pump fake would send them, if Succeed they continue in current coverage.
QB makes determination who is open, throws ball. Secondary that bit on Pump fake may have made a receiver open, but instead of standing their drooling, they can still react. If they have adequate speed and agility they can course correct and if not make the play, limit the size of the gain.

Presently the 'frozen' CB/Secondary from a pump fake is just far too much.


See, I don't know if this is quite broken.

Perhaps we're just noticing all the hits, and not all the misses. Does anyone have replays of where a pump fake juked, say, the third receiving option on the play, and the QB went to another receiver?

Perhaps this issue is toned down, or resolved more realistically, if the QB doesn't automatically notice the pump fake worked somewhere, and he throws there immediately. That seems to be the biggest issue, I think.

I'd be willing to wager the code works out to something like the frame before you actually pass, you try to pump fake in the area of the wide receiver you're about to throw to. If it works, it looks like someone sniper shot the defender the second before the pass goes off.

It'd be more realistic if the entire field was affected by the play's pump fake, as opposed to a particular passing target's defender right before the pass is thrown. For example, dlinemen might slow their rush a bit as they attempt to break up the pass, or a safety might bite on an underneath route, while the qb, a few frames later decides to go over the top.

Last edited Aug 14, 2008 00:09:03
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
The point I am making is that its a 'freeze' the CB doesn't bite on a fake pass but then recover but in the process give the receiver more room to get open. Instead what happens is the DB freezes completely, and this allows far more separation AND holds the DB in place for an amount of time before they can recover and in the timescale of the simulation this allows receivers to get far more yardage/separation then they actually do.

Also, it happens Multiple times in a single game, if you watch games, true pump fakes do not occur as often as they are occurring in GLB. If a QB pump fakes too much, the DB compensates and knows to be looking for it. Its rare you get the same DB multiple times with pump fakes.

In all, the implementation is wrong. The DB should not be frozen, instead they should be made to 'bite' on the expected route of a pump faked pass, move in that direction for a very few ime slices and then they can return to their coverage but based on their speed and agility they may take a little time to get back into coverage allowing the receiver to remain open and gain extra yardage. all that ime the DB would still be moving and reacting. There would not be a period of time where they just stand there drooling doing nothing at all.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
The point I am making is that its a 'freeze' the CB doesn't bite on a fake pass but then recover but in the process give the receiver more room to get open. Instead what happens is the DB freezes completely, and this allows far more separation AND holds the DB in place for an amount of time before they can recover and in the timescale of the simulation this allows receivers to get far more yardage/separation then they actually do.

Also, it happens Multiple times in a single game, if you watch games, true pump fakes do not occur as often as they are occurring in GLB. If a QB pump fakes too much, the DB compensates and knows to be looking for it. Its rare you get the same DB multiple times with pump fakes.

In all, the implementation is wrong. The DB should not be frozen, instead they should be made to 'bite' on the expected route of a pump faked pass, move in that direction for a very few ime slices and then they can return to their coverage but based on their speed and agility they may take a little time to get back into coverage allowing the receiver to remain open and gain extra yardage. all that ime the DB would still be moving and reacting. There would not be a period of time where they just stand there drooling doing nothing at all.


That would add another level of reality to the SIM.

Really good suggestion!
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.