User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #5 > SA A5 All Star Team (Alpha vs Zeta)
Page:
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by redskinsfan1
Originally posted by valakar

Originally posted by redskinsfan1


only the owner can vote, only 1 vote for each position, closed ballot only

if anyone else remembers any, let him know


I did not read whole thread but why would you not allow a GM to vote? Not saying team gets multiple votes but could it not be an owner for team A that really knows and a GM on another team? Just trying to understand why it must be owner other then that is the easiest way to keep the vote in balance.


its because anybody can be a GM, not everybody can be an owner. i could hire everybody as a gm right now and they could all vote...it would be a big mess and it would be confusing on who voted already, so i think 16 owners, getting a lot of votes into the board. i think thats seems fair, but if people want to do gm's thats fine.


No I am not saying ALL GM's I am saying one representative per team elected by that teams owner. Most teams it will be the owner but some may want it to be a GM that is what I was saying.
 
KLKRTR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
Check out KLKRTR's "owner roll call" thread. Are you sure an owner only vote is gonna work? Half of the owners in this league haven't even looked at any of these teams.


1 vote per team is my guess. That way each team can get a post on their private forums and vote among themselves for who each they believe. Fair, no?
 
icefreeze57
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KLKRTR
Originally posted by stromstarhammer

Check out KLKRTR's "owner roll call" thread. Are you sure an owner only vote is gonna work? Half of the owners in this league haven't even looked at any of these teams.


1 vote per team is my guess. That way each team can get a post on their private forums and vote among themselves for who each they believe. Fair, no?


agreed
 
icefreeze57
offline
Link
 
Well you can't vote for ppl on your team so if gms vote then it wont really matter IMO plus i doubt that every gm will vote or even every owner
 
icefreeze57
offline
Link
 
as we get closer?
 
Bad Girl
offline
Link
 
I like one vote per team and let the owner choose who will represent their team

BG
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 18:49:48
 
E_The_Kid
offline
Link
 
Soo guys who are you voting for at OT? *wink* *wink*
 
Link
 
Originally posted by E_The_Kid
Soo guys who are you voting for at OT? *wink* *wink*


u got me
 
Lightw4re
offline
Link
 
Not you. You're not in this list 'nyway.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?league_id=141&conference_id=0&stat=other&playoffs=0
 
E_The_Kid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lightw4re
Not you. You're not in this list 'nyway.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?league_id=141&conference_id=0&stat=other&playoffs=0


With all due respect I don't think that Pancakes don't really mean much right now in Capped leagues.

And here's your list:

(RG) Randy "Macho Man" Savage LVL 21
W Team Opp Score Pan
-1 CAR ARG W40-10 40 (Up against a current level 12)
-2 CAR PER W3-49 15 (Up against a current level 10)
-3 CAR FIL W24-20 32 Lvl 13
-4 CAR PER W17-45 30 Lvl 17
-5 CAR SAN W41-13 27 Lvl 10
-6 CAR CEL L28-14 6 Lvl 18
-7 CAR SOU W48-7 49 Lvl 15
-8 CAR MED W27-21 26 Lvl 15
-9 CAR PAR L30-14 3 Lvl 15
-10 CAR COR W24-21 5 Lvl 17
-11 CAR FOR W20-45 11 Lvl 18
-12 CAR BOL L10-42 5 Lvl 20

Other than week 4 and 7 where Cartagena ran 49 and 52 times respectively I am not suprised by the totals.
____________________________________________________________________________________
(C) Tom NaIen Level 20
W Team Opp Score Pan
-1 CAR ARG W40-10 24 Lvl 14
-2 CAR PER W3-49 14 Lvl 10
-3 CAR FIL W24-20 28 Lvl 10
-4 CAR PER W17-45 21 Lvl 12
-5 CAR SAN W41-13 30 Lvl 14
-6 CAR CEL L28-14 11 Lvl 16
-7 CAR SOU W48-7 37 Lvl 18
-8 CAR MED W27-21 17 Lvl 16
-9 CAR PAR L30-14 7 Lvl 15
-10 CAR COR W24-21 4 Lvl 16
-11 CAR FOR W20-45 10 Lvl 14
-12 CAR BOL L10-42 8 Lvl 17

Since I already listed the levels for the NT above I listed the DT levels. Also I want to point out that Cartagena averages 43.2 rushes a game.

_____________________________________________________________________________________
(OT) Thomas Dawson Level 17
W Team Opp Score Pan
-1 PAR RIO W44-24 14 Starter at RT: Lvl 14
-2 PAR ARG W17-55 21 Lvl 13
-3 PAR PER W78-0 14 Lvl 10
-4 PAR FIL W7-62 15 Lvl 15
-5 PAR PER W42-7 17 Lvl 14
-6 PAR SAN W21-64 37 Lvl 7
-7 PAR CEL W31-28 1 Lvl 17
-8 PAR SOU W0-40 26 Lvl 15
-9 PAR CAR W30-14 5 Lvl 18
-10 PAR MED W52-3 8 Lvl 19
-11 PAR COR W17-20 2 Lvl 18
-12 PAR FOR W20-13 6 Lvl 14

What suprises me with Dawson is the fact that he plays LT and still gets these pancakes. I have a couple of theories. One is that Dawson is crazy strong and that he goes up against speed DEs who can't get overpowered by strong tackles. Another leading factor is that Paraguay runs alot.

| Things to keep in mind |
1) Build: Obviously, levels mean nothing without a good build. For all I know The Dlinemen have not-so-great builds or the players above have great builds.
2) Downfield blocking: I put up the levels of the starters the player would go up against on their respective teams first offensive play. So one must take in account the pancakes made on DBs and LBs.
3) Gameplanning: I included the average number of runs by a team per game to show the number of attempts to get downfield blocking and "attack" the defense.
4) Player Tactics: Each player's tactics are going to affect the outcome of a matchup I imagine that a Run Block vs. Evasive is going to help out the blocker.

If you want, I can go on in more detail. I could even go further down the list and see how much favorable the matchups go. But right now I need to gameplan for otherr teams. I would've talked about your players but I consider flaming people rude.

Everything above isn't meant to point out anything wrong with players mentioned. Only meant to prove a point. I'm sure there are a few mistakes so correct me if I'm wrong. And Cartagena and Paraguay if you don't want something above included PM me.
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 21:19:12
 
Lightw4re
offline
Link
 
Why you compare yourself with a guard and a center..

And i'm not saying that your build is weak. Just saying that you're not the only one who can make the team just because you're lvl 20.



Agree with one vote per team.
 
Link
 
ok, im confused now...were voting for only one person and you cant vote for one of your own players, or one vote per position and cant vote for any of your players or can you?
 
E_The_Kid
offline
Link
 
Not my point to compare with a G and C just wanted to show the players with the highest pancake number, I just want to say that pancakes are kind of overrated in this case. That's all. I didn't take it as saying my build is weak but just saying that pancakes are the only basis of a a good olineman is insane.

On another subject, I think the Oline should be counted as a whole. It's hard to give accalades to Olineman because to truly judge an olineman is to watch every single play and see what he does not just pancakes. So why not just vote for the best oline?
 
Link
 
I would vote for Thomas Dawson for the All Star team every day of the week. He keeps my QB's blind side covered, and he paves the way for our strong running game. He is a huge part of our team's success.
 
mavdaddy22
offline
Link
 
bottom line...

wait until last game

closed ballot for owners or 1 team representative only

cannot vote for your own players

each position has a starter and a backup

this way nobody can play "favorites"
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.