User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Hagetaka
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fmxda
Is it too much to ask that 1000 or 2000 test games are simulated with players of various skills, stats, and level before implementing potential changes?


It's just the two guys running this, but it would be nice if they had a friend OCD enough to just sim and read pbp to tweak the AI
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hagetaka
Originally posted by fmxda

Is it too much to ask that 1000 or 2000 test games are simulated with players of various skills, stats, and level before implementing potential changes?


It's just the two guys running this, but it would be nice if they had a friend OCD enough to just sim and read pbp to tweak the AI


Bort already sims on another server before he implements things
 
fmxda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hagetaka
Originally posted by fmxda

Is it too much to ask that 1000 or 2000 test games are simulated with players of various skills, stats, and level before implementing potential changes?


It's just the two guys running this, but it would be nice if they had a friend OCD enough to just sim and read pbp to tweak the AI

"A friend OCD enough" is easily replaced by a script which could parse pay by plays and show basic stats like frequencies of sacks by DTs and how 4+ per game against fair competition is not remotely close to normal.

I know that someone will or has said that it's beta but you're still taking our money, and I just had two teams I play on lose by 1 point in the 4th quarter due to a super obvious bug that simply adequate private testing would have caught many times over. This really gives me no faith that other signficant, but less obvious bugs are not slipping through the cracks.
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 21:09:07
 
orcinus
offline
Link
 
This happened once in the playoffs to our team, and while the circumstances were a bit peculiar, I don't think it was a bug.

After giving up zero sacks in the regular season, a level five NT mowed our C for seven sacks. He ran over him a couple times, a few looked like the C was moving over to double the DT, and a couple took place in the midst of a blitz.

A bug was our first thought, of course, but I'm more inclined to think this happened as a result of a gross build mismatch somewhere along the line between the two players. The only bad thing was I've not been able to get the NT to open up his build.

Sucks, but I don't think it's a bug. Might be something that could be tweaked to sim a bit better, but it's not a bug.
 
hoyaboy1
offline
Link
 
While "bug" might not be the right word (although the fact that it kept happening on hash marks is troublesome), it is at the least a coding problem. On passing plays o-lineman should be backing up, not charging forward or sideways. There should also never be a situation where the NT is left completely unblocked.

It also seems like this has only been happening in the playoffs, but I'm not sure what explains that since Bort said he didn't adjust the C or G code.
 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
it looks like the center is expecting the FB to pick up the blitz, not sure if the FB's vision is low cause he never goes after the NT (not that thats how blocking assignments go in the NFL, i cant imagine anyone expects a FB to pick up a NT). Maybe its just a case of making sure the C always blocks the NT instead of thinking someone else (RB, FB) is supposed to pick up the block.
 
Link
 
If D-Line stunts were in the game, I could see this being realistic, but these plays are just a DT running forward while the C and RG say "Oh you're looking for the QB, yeah he's back there".

Something's fairly obviously wrong here, but I'm sure as the game matures, it'll be worked out.
 
drkbgrk
offline
Link
 
our level 5 back up NT gets his first two career sacks on the left hashmark! Level 9 O linemen parted like the red sea.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1127405

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1127562

Is this what the Break Through skill looks like?
Last edited Apr 19, 2008 12:40:30
 
Link
 
Even if this was not a bug, it is a serious coding problem. It just doesn't make too much sense. No matter what caused C and G to give a free path to NT, it doesn't happen this frequently in real footbal games.
 
sethypooh21
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I can see the point re: "not picking up the blitz" if its a LB or DB coming, but it's the dude right in front of him, who is presumably trying to get into the backfield on EVERY single play...
 
lump7502
offline
Link
 
i dont get the whole biggest threat thing in real life its a simple rule you work from the inside out period i think it would be a failure on the guard more than the center the nt is lined up gaped the guard would move down and leave the tackle one on one with the end in this situation.could possibly be a lack of the line general skill
 
saiyun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ohmybriguy
it looks like the center is expecting the FB to pick up the blitz, not sure if the FB's vision is low cause he never goes after the NT (not that thats how blocking assignments go in the NFL, i cant imagine anyone expects a FB to pick up a NT). Maybe its just a case of making sure the C always blocks the NT instead of thinking someone else (RB, FB) is supposed to pick up the block.


FB never pick up DT on blitz..there is at least a 100 lb difference

the FB will retire after the 1st season if he is relied to pick up a DT
 
hoyaboy1
offline
Link
 
I'd really like to see this addressed - it'll be ridiculous if NTs are still racking up 5+ sacks a game when season 2 starts.
 
FBGProfessor
offline
Link
 
The question is: what was the Center's vision at the time of the play? You can't block what you can't see.

Originally posted by drkbgrk
our level 5 back up NT gets his first two career sacks on the left hashmark! Level 9 O linemen parted like the red sea.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1127405

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1127562

Is this what the Break Through skill looks like?


 
hoyaboy1
offline
Link
 
Sigh. Its the exact same thing happening to tons of centers and RGs, but only late in the season and on hashmarks. It is obviously a bug, and vision shouldn't have anything to do with knowing a blocking assignment.
Last edited Apr 23, 2008 13:07:25
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.