User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
why am i happy with the game and you arent? why are ur builds trashed? when i boosted, i added agility to all my speed players, tackling to all my DBs and LBs, vision to all my linemen, carrying to my HB. i just dont understand how 15 points cant "fix" your builds. did you not know this off-season that the nerfs were coming? quit the F-ing crying.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Speed trumping all was a bug.

The whiners are extremely lucky Bort's nice enough to look past their obvious exploitation of that bug and merely changed the code so it is no longer trump instead of just outright banning them, and they don't even realize it.
 
Rexxor
offline
Link
 
Just making suggestions - not "crying" and trying to remain constructive, so drop the attitude.

Oh..and a forums search function would be nice too lol...not original but figured while we were discussing things...
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by markhehe
why am i happy with the game and you arent? why are ur builds trashed? when i boosted, i added agility to all my speed players, tackling to all my DBs and LBs, vision to all my linemen, carrying to my HB. i just dont understand how 15 points cant "fix" your builds. did you not know this off-season that the nerfs were coming? quit the F-ing crying.


Thank you!
+1
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 14:51:35
 
Link
 
I agree with the speed issue, and when I heard it was going to be fixed I was happy that my CB would be on a better playing field with the WRs who had nothing but speed.

Then CBs got two more "penalties" leveled against them with the cushion and delayed reaction time.

I have no issue being beat by a WR that is better than me, but talk about a silver platter.

Maybe we can further handicap CBs by making them partially retarded.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
It doesn't look like you were following the whole passing game issue, because it was buggy. Extremely so.

Yes, you mention other bugs that need to be looked into, but the passing game issue took precedence because it was a huge situation. Half of every team's offense, in fact.

And please explain what type of build was "rendered into garbage"? I can't think of any type of player that is now useless, or even significantly changed.

Again, specifics.


I used me and my team as an example of the cost involved in this BETA, but to our knowledge, we don't have any players with borked builds. But we likely would have if we didn't fork over $200 last week to boost everyone and adapt to the changes. My complaint there is that if players see that speed kills, and develop their players within that rule system for 3 seasons - and Bort decides that speed shouldn't kill unless you have 7 other stats up to acceptable levels - then what Bort should do is make the change - but provide a reasonable way for players to adjust to the new rules.

The other bugs aren't things that need to be looked into. They are things that should have stopped this season from starting. On almost every running play, the LBs run the other direction. On every punt return, the gunners are allowed a free release to the returner.

Because of the cost involved, people are treating this like a real game. The creators are treating it like a BETA. In every way except that BETA testing never costs $200 every 45 days, ever. All I'm saying is that the fact that money is being charged - A LOT OF MONEY - that changes the expectations on how things have to be. Changing the rules? Allow your testers to respec to the new rules. Charging ridiculous amounts of money to be competitive? You have to provide some stability to the sim engine.

The Season 3 sim engine wasn't perfect - but my team actually blocked on punt returns, my CBs covered the way they were setup to cover, and my LBs didn't drop back into deep zones on almost every running play.

These things need to get worked out BEFORE they make it into the code base that people are paying for.

 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Speed trumping all was a bug.

The whiners are extremely lucky Bort's nice enough to look past their obvious exploitation of that bug and merely changed the code so it is no longer trump instead of just outright banning them, and they don't even realize it.


you usually have good points, but banning someone for putting their points into speed because it worked? Give me a fucking break.

Anyways, change happens, you deal with it. You build your players to fit the changes, even if it takes some time. Unless you were so far towards an outlier, you can make things work with the new changes. You can still be the "fast" team if that's what you want, you just need to round things out to a more realistic level.
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by j10er

It doesn't look like you were following the whole passing game issue, because it was buggy. Extremely so.

Yes, you mention other bugs that need to be looked into, but the passing game issue took precedence because it was a huge situation. Half of every team's offense, in fact.

And please explain what type of build was "rendered into garbage"? I can't think of any type of player that is now useless, or even significantly changed.

Again, specifics.


I used me and my team as an example of the cost involved in this BETA, but to our knowledge, we don't have any players with borked builds. But we likely would have if we didn't fork over $200 last week to boost everyone and adapt to the changes. My complaint there is that if players see that speed kills, and develop their players within that rule system for 3 seasons - and Bort decides that speed shouldn't kill unless you have 7 other stats up to acceptable levels - then what Bort should do is make the change - but provide a reasonable way for players to adjust to the new rules.

The other bugs aren't things that need to be looked into. They are things that should have stopped this season from starting. On almost every running play, the LBs run the other direction. On every punt return, the gunners are allowed a free release to the returner.

Because of the cost involved, people are treating this like a real game. The creators are treating it like a BETA. In every way except that BETA testing never costs $200 every 45 days, ever. All I'm saying is that the fact that money is being charged - A LOT OF MONEY - that changes the expectations on how things have to be. Changing the rules? Allow your testers to respec to the new rules. Charging ridiculous amounts of money to be competitive? You have to provide some stability to the sim engine.

The Season 3 sim engine wasn't perfect - but my team actually blocked on punt returns, my CBs covered the way they were setup to cover, and my LBs didn't drop back into deep zones on almost every running play.

These things need to get worked out BEFORE they make it into the code base that people are paying for.



no....im paying for a beta version and im treating it as such. i realize its gonna have bugs, but i still have a blast playing it. play for free if you dont think its worth the cost.
 
DirtyDawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Johnny_Johnson
I agree with the speed issue, and when I heard it was going to be fixed I was happy that my CB would be on a better playing field with the WRs who had nothing but speed.

Then CBs got two more "penalties" leveled against them with the cushion and delayed reaction time.

I have no issue being beat by a WR that is better than me, but talk about a silver platter.

Maybe we can further handicap CBs by making them partially retarded.
lmao.... I think with all these changes every one should be able to atleast move there SA's 1 time every season!

 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
What gets me is that some people are complaining about their player's build when they had the same opportunity as everybody else to build their player the way they wanted. Nobody had any advantage over anybody else. Everybody gets the same number of SPs per level, same number of exp for training, etc... I had to build the same type of guys, with the same number of points, with the same knowledge about the game as everybody else. You don't see me complaining. I'm very happy with my player's build.

Bottom line is those who are complaining are scared of change or cannot adapt to a changing environment. I have to change the way I build my players just like everybody else that is bitching and whining. Sack up and quit being little bitches, make the necessary changes and thank Bort for making such a great game in such a short amount of time with so limited resources.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by markhehe
why am i happy with the game and you arent? why are ur builds trashed? when i boosted, i added agility to all my speed players, tackling to all my DBs and LBs, vision to all my linemen, carrying to my HB. i just dont understand how 15 points cant "fix" your builds. did you not know this off-season that the nerfs were coming? quit the F-ing crying.


We did the same thing. If the rules of the sim change, it shouldn't cost us $200 to fix our players to allow them to beta test the new changes. Should it?

Why has every other MMO figured out that those things require free respecs to keep their customer base, but the suggestion is so unacceptable here? A free respec doesn't even cost Bort money. We're still going to have to keep boosting to remain competitive.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Johnny_Johnson
I agree with the speed issue, and when I heard it was going to be fixed I was happy that my CB would be on a better playing field with the WRs who had nothing but speed.

Then CBs got two more "penalties" leveled against them with the cushion and delayed reaction time.

I have no issue being beat by a WR that is better than me, but talk about a silver platter.

Maybe we can further handicap CBs by making them partially retarded.


Its only delayed if you don't have solid vision and then agility/speed to make it work, otherwise the change was minimal. CB's with high vision were reacting too fast, it was a necessary change.
 
Minnsooner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Minnsooner

I have 2 seasons of player builds going to waste.

Originally posted by What Minnsooner means

I spent 2 seasons of player builds exploiting the previous breaks & glitches in the sim and I am now upset that said exploits are closed and now my players are not uber-players.




Wrong dipshit. My players are very well rounded, maybe to well. Pick any player and I will give you his build. I will put my WR, CB, SS, FB, HB, QB, well any player I own, and then you tell me what could be better. I lost 2 games in the last 2 years, because of better builds, not exploits.

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by j10er

It doesn't look like you were following the whole passing game issue, because it was buggy. Extremely so.

Yes, you mention other bugs that need to be looked into, but the passing game issue took precedence because it was a huge situation. Half of every team's offense, in fact.

And please explain what type of build was "rendered into garbage"? I can't think of any type of player that is now useless, or even significantly changed.

Again, specifics.


I used me and my team as an example of the cost involved in this BETA, but to our knowledge, we don't have any players with borked builds. But we likely would have if we didn't fork over $200 last week to boost everyone and adapt to the changes. My complaint there is that if players see that speed kills, and develop their players within that rule system for 3 seasons - and Bort decides that speed shouldn't kill unless you have 7 other stats up to acceptable levels - then what Bort should do is make the change - but provide a reasonable way for players to adjust to the new rules.

The other bugs aren't things that need to be looked into. They are things that should have stopped this season from starting. On almost every running play, the LBs run the other direction. On every punt return, the gunners are allowed a free release to the returner.

Because of the cost involved, people are treating this like a real game. The creators are treating it like a BETA. In every way except that BETA testing never costs $200 every 45 days, ever. All I'm saying is that the fact that money is being charged - A LOT OF MONEY - that changes the expectations on how things have to be. Changing the rules? Allow your testers to respec to the new rules. Charging ridiculous amounts of money to be competitive? You have to provide some stability to the sim engine.

The Season 3 sim engine wasn't perfect - but my team actually blocked on punt returns, my CBs covered the way they were setup to cover, and my LBs didn't drop back into deep zones on almost every running play.

These things need to get worked out BEFORE they make it into the code base that people are paying for.



First of all, the LB's stopped dropping into deep zones a few days ago, if yours are still doing it, check your defensive AI.

Second of all, Like I had said in a previous thread, if you really thought that all your WR needed was speed to be succesful, and you didn't consider that buggy, that says a helluva lot in and of itself. Bort said during season 3, that SPEED WOULD BE CHANGED, apparently you didn't believe him.

Third, you have a point with the CB, and Bort is just ignoring it, wait, what, he is looking into it? Oh I see, so somebody reports something to a programmer, and there is a magic button somewhere in the code that says turn me on and all is fixed? Damn, missed that.

Charging ridiculous amounts of money??? Granted, I haven't looked at your account, you could have 30 players, you could have 1, but I just dropped $60 bucks, renewed my ownership until season 10, and boosted my players, the ones I wanted to for the time being, and I still have a shitload of FP left, And I think my higher level players are competitive, and wait, I still have a CHOICE if I wanted to spend that money or not.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Personally, I think Bort does a great job and he'll continue to get my hard earned money.

This game is still a work in progress and I think many people forget that. They see something working so well (too well) and they start to mimic it. Part of Bort's job is to find a balance that makes everything realistic. It's not an easy one and I don't know how he does what he does because as he said he's damned if he does, damned if he doesn't. He'll never make every one happy but I'm sure as long as he continues down the path he is going that in 3-4 seasons, the complaints will be few and far between (at least in regards to the sim).

I know it's hard to be patient when people are paying money, so my solution is don't pay money if you don't like the product. No one is making you continue to pay money and if you don't like it, let your wallet do your talking for you.

Me... I'll continue to pay because I believe in the product and enjoy it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.