User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Problem with Stamina/Substitution/Depth?
Page:
 
NOVASaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

That used to be the case also, but once again it was a complain fest...everyone wants to see a nice big 100 all the time. I wanted it to be more of a "wear you down over the course of the season" bar.


I like whichever way seems more realistic. Right now I don't feel like I can carry depth anymore but I would like to. More people could have an active role on the teams if we were forced to carry more depth. But I know the amount of bitching would be nigh unbelievable from the powergamers..
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 22:22:20
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by bulletbait

Also, I really enjoy this game, and want to keep playing. That is the reason I'm so passionate about this. I don't want to see the game resimmed or any of that crap. What happened, happened. I'm just trying to bring attention to something that seems fundamentally wrong.


I don't get it...

Maybe he had better sub settings than you, and his depth chart is a lot better than yours... from a structure standpoint.


How is it better? He's got virtually no depth. He doesn't have a realistic depth chart. And what is "better" in terms of sub settings? Is it realistic to have your players playing until they are at 10%? Doesn't seem like it.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by oldskool

Not to hijack the thread, but doesn't it seem odd that the energy levels never dip below 70, which happens to be the exact maximum they could drop while still being able to regenerate back to 100 before the next game? Seems that removing this cap would help remedy the situation, as teams that play the same guys throughout the game wouldn't be at 100% for the next one...


That used to be the case also, but once again it was a complain fest...everyone wants to see a nice big 100 all the time. I wanted it to be more of a "wear you down over the course of the season" bar.

Sounds like you were right all along, Borty my good man.
 
Link
 
Stamina should play more of a role IMHO. Those complainers need to grow up.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by oldskool

Not to hijack the thread, but doesn't it seem odd that the energy levels never dip below 70, which happens to be the exact maximum they could drop while still being able to regenerate back to 100 before the next game? Seems that removing this cap would help remedy the situation, as teams that play the same guys throughout the game wouldn't be at 100% for the next one...


That used to be the case also, but once again it was a complain fest...everyone wants to see a nice big 100 all the time. I wanted it to be more of a "wear you down over the course of the season" bar.


That is how it needs to be, We don't need injuries we need this feature. This plus the salary caps will help STOP over spending by all the rookie owners(guilty). We also need a hand book for all the newb owners that are about to swarm all over the new teams. Force them to review it as soon as they buy their team, and agree to terms of use after passing a short 5 question test. No one will be able to waste a thousand dollars to train on intense anymore. No one will be demanding to be paid to train on intense daily. The loan thing can be removed after the economy corrects itself.

Well I kinda got carried on but yes please make fatigue matter. Make the minimum post game fatigue like 60. You can also make it where the more plays you play in a game the lower your minimum fatigue will be. And the in game over use can also amount to slower regen during the game and faster depletion of energy.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
PS it will also slow down the "xp grinders"
 
Link
 
Agreed, injuries is kind of lame, to penalize a player's attributes that we work so hard for and pour money into? Work injuries into an element of the game that becomes strategy, not dumb luck. Sure you have dumb luck in the NFL, but this is a different type of game as we have already established, so no reason to penalize us for bad luck injuries.

It reminds me of those lame battles in Final Fantasy and other RPGs where you get some screwball boss to fight and all he does is turn all of your guys confused and paralyzed and poisoned and status hell like crazy, and it's just kind of silly and it's more of a nuisance than anything to deal with.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 22:31:41
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Consider this, as well:

Flames54's team (Galaxy Aces) runs this short depthchart strategy.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=673

Consider this matchup:

Kona Gold vs Galaxy Aces

http://goallineblitz.com/game/compare_teams.pl?team1=673&team2=671

Fairly even teams, right? Sure, the Aces are a little better, but not blowout better.

Apparently not.

Final score? 66-6 Aces over Gold.

Does that seem right to you guys? Check his whole season, he won huge blowouts.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 22:34:39
 
NOVASaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Strategy Expert
Agreed, injuries is kind of lame, to penalize a players attributes that we work so hard for and pour money into? Work injuries into an element of the game that becomes strategy not dumb luck. Sure you have dumb luck in the NFL, but this is a different type of game as we have already established, so no reason to penalize us for bad luck injuries.


Injuries would NOT be lame. They would be a pain in the ass for a lot of people, but not lame. There are no good football sims that don't include injuries PRECISELY because the injuries force you to plan ahead and make alterations on the fly, which are two things that make the game harder.

Originally posted by The Strategy Expert

It reminds me of those lame battles in Final Fantasy and what not where you get some screwball boss to fight and all he does is turn all of your guys confused and paralyzed and poisoned and status hell like crazy, and it's just kind of silly and it's more of a nuisance than anything to deal with.


I'm afraid you lost me there..

Last edited Apr 17, 2008 22:34:25
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Injuries: Why not have them just be an energy deduction? You CAN play through most injuries, but you'll be less effective and more likely to want/need to be subbed out than if you were at 100%.
 
NOVASaint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Injuries: Why not have them just be an energy deduction? You CAN play through most injuries, but you'll be less effective and more likely to want/need to be subbed out than if you were at 100%.


I think that's the obvious way to go.
 
Tim Harper
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
No, they'd still complain. I tried to explain it that way to them, but "power gamers" don't care. They want MAX NUMBERS!!!!11!!!


Hey don't be talking smack about me, I never once stuck my nose into that whole stamina chat we had in alpha. Then again my memory is a bit fuzzy and don't remember a whole lot these days.

I don't mind stamina having a bigger role in the game, I will just pump stamina to counter it. So bring it on chump!

 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tank Basterson
Originally posted by oldskool

Injuries: Why not have them just be an energy deduction? You CAN play through most injuries, but you'll be less effective and more likely to want/need to be subbed out than if you were at 100%.


I think that's the obvious way to go.


"injuries" should only occur in this game from overuse. Kickers Punters shouldn't get penalized for overuse other than fatigue, in game.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Tank Basterson


Injuries would NOT be lame. They would be a pain in the ass for a lot of people, but not lame. There are no good football sims that don't include injuries PRECISELY because the injuries force you to plan ahead and make alterations on the fly, which are two things that make the game harder.



I dont have a problem with the concept of injuries, i like the other suggestions of how they are manifested as mentioned in this thread.
 
stevegamer
offline
Link
 
This is frankly, a major problem - for all practical purposes in this game, stamina doesn't matter. All you need to do is make sure your energy is at 100 going into the game, and you're mostly good.

The utter lack of coverage of how this works (and other things as well) in the FAQ, led most new players to make reasonable guesses about things. This isn't the first beta game I've seen with a horrible FAQ - most of them are that way, actually.

Realism is not happening the way things are, and it's VERY counter-intuitive - you don't want to have any depth. As we all know, pro players don't play every snap anymore - If this was Chuck Bednarik's Goal Line Blitz, I might expect this kind of strategy being good.

The real problem is that you've let power gamers who want MAX numbers dictate what makes sense, and the game is screwed up in such a way that it is so unlike modern (post-1960) football, that you really should call it something else - it is NOT a football simulation at all.

When you see teams with no depth in real life, you punish them by forcing them to continuously play players until they are tired.

I'd really like to find out what other bass-ackwards things the alpha testers know about that all of us new players don't. I don't want hings handed to me, I can figure most things out just fine - but when you're dealing with things that are this screwed up, it's a problem.

You've got my money for this upcoming season, and my attention. Let's see if you can keep it by fixing the product.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.