I think looking at the Utopians and Bullets they are running quite a few backups on USA AAA. If we "require" many more by stamina it will begin to be a litte silly. I mean they both looked like they have nearly full sets of backups.
Forum > Suggestions > Teams with no backups have to be penalized
Kcirdor
offline
offline
The solution to the problem is to make fatigue factor into ability loss at a sharper curve. Every 10 percent you drop in energy you drop 10 percent of your abilities.
Also make the longer you stay in the game the faster your fatigue depletes.
Also make the longer you stay in the game the faster your fatigue depletes.
HootyHoo
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtisme
But "realistic" rosters will have at least 5 backup OL...most of whom will only play on FG team....or an extra TE on a goal line play. These teams will have a 3rd QB who holds a clip board 100% of the time. They will have 3 or 4 backup LB's and the last couple will only play in emergency or special teams. Same with a 3rd string HB...and bottom of every depth chart are special team only players.
Those types of players aren't going to be included in this game...and teams that do have them are going to use cpu players anyway.
Exactly.
But "realistic" rosters will have at least 5 backup OL...most of whom will only play on FG team....or an extra TE on a goal line play. These teams will have a 3rd QB who holds a clip board 100% of the time. They will have 3 or 4 backup LB's and the last couple will only play in emergency or special teams. Same with a 3rd string HB...and bottom of every depth chart are special team only players.
Those types of players aren't going to be included in this game...and teams that do have them are going to use cpu players anyway.
Exactly.
HootyHoo
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtisme
Well most NFL teams dont have a backup FB. Good TE's rarely come out unless the formation calls for it. I rarely see starting DB's subbed out of normal down situations...occasionally a poor cover safety is removed. But "good" players rarely sit on normal downs. And for OL....do you actually know a team that DOES sub offensive linemen on a regular basis??
You need more than 22+2 kickers anyway. But i think you're already convinced otherwise so im not going to argue that point.
Exactly again. You're on a roll.
Well most NFL teams dont have a backup FB. Good TE's rarely come out unless the formation calls for it. I rarely see starting DB's subbed out of normal down situations...occasionally a poor cover safety is removed. But "good" players rarely sit on normal downs. And for OL....do you actually know a team that DOES sub offensive linemen on a regular basis??
You need more than 22+2 kickers anyway. But i think you're already convinced otherwise so im not going to argue that point.
Exactly again. You're on a roll.
ohmybriguy
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtisme
In the USA pro...all of those teams are already beat out of the playoffs. All that reamain are teams with depth.
i dont see how you can say that... i just looked at the usa pro team, i think the western league and 3 out of the 4 teams remaining have minimum, mostly no backups. I'd say 3 outta 4 still shows no depth is better then depth.
In the USA pro...all of those teams are already beat out of the playoffs. All that reamain are teams with depth.
i dont see how you can say that... i just looked at the usa pro team, i think the western league and 3 out of the 4 teams remaining have minimum, mostly no backups. I'd say 3 outta 4 still shows no depth is better then depth.
the_old_days
offline
offline
I don't see why people, including mods and admin, try to defend this or brush it off. Having one player depth is unrealistic, it's a manipulation of the current game setup, and once it catches on in a broader spectrum and is trickled down to the lower leagues (which it inevitably will if the teams that do it continue winning) it will be next to impossible for new GLB players to find teams on which they can develop their players.
Not to mention that these teams save a bundle over teams who wish to play with depth.
I have eight players, two of which are back up players, and one who will be a back up next season. What happens when my team owners decide to release those players to compete? I spent good money on those players. Sure, I could get them picked up by another team, maybe, to fit the new roster minimun that is to be incorporated...but if the one man depth system is still working well, then that player faces the bench for 90% of the season. How is that player ever going to improve? Don't think it will happen? It's already happening everywhere as owners are restructuring their teams for next season, ohmybriguy being an example when he cut 60% of his roster.
I think this is a problem that is past speculation. You can't just assume that the system will wear itself out or will suddenly fail against teams with more depth. It's showing that not only does it work, but it will work better as the players on the one-depth teams continue to gain in level.
Not to mention that these teams save a bundle over teams who wish to play with depth.
I have eight players, two of which are back up players, and one who will be a back up next season. What happens when my team owners decide to release those players to compete? I spent good money on those players. Sure, I could get them picked up by another team, maybe, to fit the new roster minimun that is to be incorporated...but if the one man depth system is still working well, then that player faces the bench for 90% of the season. How is that player ever going to improve? Don't think it will happen? It's already happening everywhere as owners are restructuring their teams for next season, ohmybriguy being an example when he cut 60% of his roster.
I think this is a problem that is past speculation. You can't just assume that the system will wear itself out or will suddenly fail against teams with more depth. It's showing that not only does it work, but it will work better as the players on the one-depth teams continue to gain in level.
Last edited Apr 17, 2008 22:55:16
crise40g
offline
offline
Fix it please. How is a team with just 31 players kickin' arse? Real NFL teams have a hard time getting down to 53 players. Let's try and make this game as real as possible. I don't care who you are, if you play the whole game, your energy, attributes, and abilities, should take a big hit over the course of the game. And if you do put in injuries, staying in the game longer should make you more susceptible to injury. Only makes sense.
bigtisme
offline
offline
I had a couple of posts earlier in the thread that explain why we dont need 53 players to play a game of GLB.
ahnonamis
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtisme
I had a couple of posts earlier in the thread that explain why we dont need 53 players to play a game of GLB.
I think the bigger issue isn't that people are running bare bones, but that people are doing so with players at 14 or 15 stamina. If you're going to run with no backups for an extended period of time, you should get progressively lower on your pre-game energy over the course of the season/playoffs. No reason someone with two backups at their position and 30 stamina should come out of a game feeling the same as a guy with 16 and no backup whatsoever.
I had a couple of posts earlier in the thread that explain why we dont need 53 players to play a game of GLB.
I think the bigger issue isn't that people are running bare bones, but that people are doing so with players at 14 or 15 stamina. If you're going to run with no backups for an extended period of time, you should get progressively lower on your pre-game energy over the course of the season/playoffs. No reason someone with two backups at their position and 30 stamina should come out of a game feeling the same as a guy with 16 and no backup whatsoever.
bigtisme
offline
offline
Really?? 15 stamina
I haven't heard of people doing that (and winning). The USA pro teams have huge stamina's to go with their teams!!
I haven't heard of people doing that (and winning). The USA pro teams have huge stamina's to go with their teams!!ddingo
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtisme
Most positions in football CAN play an entire game and be fine. QB,FB,TE OL, LB, DB all typically do it for the entire game.
What?
Most OL play the entire game!? Are you kidding me?
The only position you've accurately listed is QB because it isn't generally a high-contact, high physical exertion position. A FB in a traditional I-Formation offense will rotate out of the game. Please find a real college or professional team that doesn't use at least 7+ DB's in a game.
Most positions in football CAN play an entire game and be fine. QB,FB,TE OL, LB, DB all typically do it for the entire game.
What?
Most OL play the entire game!? Are you kidding me?
The only position you've accurately listed is QB because it isn't generally a high-contact, high physical exertion position. A FB in a traditional I-Formation offense will rotate out of the game. Please find a real college or professional team that doesn't use at least 7+ DB's in a game.
ddingo
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtisme
Well most NFL teams dont have a backup FB. Good TE's rarely come out unless the formation calls for it. I rarely see starting DB's subbed out of normal down situations...occasionally a poor cover safety is removed. But "good" players rarely sit on normal downs. And for OL....do you actually know a team that DOES sub offensive linemen on a regular basis??
You need more than 22+2 kickers anyway. But i think you're already convinced otherwise so im not going to argue that point.
Funny.
Last season Kansas State had 23 players that made 10 or more tackles in the season.
http://web1.ncaa.org/d1mfb/2007/Internet/ranking_summary/2007000000327tackles.html
I guess that was the 11 starters and the 12 guys on special teams, right?
Virtually every team in the NCAA database from 2007 used 8 or more offensive linemen with regularity (defined as over half the games played).
Here's the link -- have a blast.
http://web1.ncaa.org/d1mfb/mainpage.jsp?year=2007
Well most NFL teams dont have a backup FB. Good TE's rarely come out unless the formation calls for it. I rarely see starting DB's subbed out of normal down situations...occasionally a poor cover safety is removed. But "good" players rarely sit on normal downs. And for OL....do you actually know a team that DOES sub offensive linemen on a regular basis??
You need more than 22+2 kickers anyway. But i think you're already convinced otherwise so im not going to argue that point.
Funny.
Last season Kansas State had 23 players that made 10 or more tackles in the season.
http://web1.ncaa.org/d1mfb/2007/Internet/ranking_summary/2007000000327tackles.html
I guess that was the 11 starters and the 12 guys on special teams, right?
Virtually every team in the NCAA database from 2007 used 8 or more offensive linemen with regularity (defined as over half the games played).
Here's the link -- have a blast.
http://web1.ncaa.org/d1mfb/mainpage.jsp?year=2007
Zickzack
offline
offline
Originally posted by bigtisme
Really?? 15 stamina
I haven't heard of people doing that (and winning). The USA pro teams have huge stamina's to go with their teams!!
What I am wondering is whether it is really such an advantage to be a level or two ahead of the competition if you need those levels to invest the points in stamina just to be able to stay on the field for the whole game to gain that experience. Time will tell I guess, but I am betting on teams with depth coming out ahead in the long run, even if right now players with more levels still might be at an advantage.
Really?? 15 stamina
I haven't heard of people doing that (and winning). The USA pro teams have huge stamina's to go with their teams!!What I am wondering is whether it is really such an advantage to be a level or two ahead of the competition if you need those levels to invest the points in stamina just to be able to stay on the field for the whole game to gain that experience. Time will tell I guess, but I am betting on teams with depth coming out ahead in the long run, even if right now players with more levels still might be at an advantage.
The chemistry addition will HELP the teams with no depth as they do not make that many moves to begin with. It will just make them even better.
Here are some facts (as opposed to assumptions) about stamina:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=78411
Basically, from what I read:
-Stamina depends on what the player is doing - making tackles, running deep routes, getting double-teamed or pancaked will all result in losing stamina faster than standing around, covering or running short routes, overmatching your opponent, etc.
-10% stamina does not equal 10% effectiveness. Players remain very effective even if their stamina is ridiculously low.
-No matter how far your stamina falls during the game, you will never lose more than 30 stamina after the game.
For all of you who assume that if a player's satmina falls to 25% in a game that means he will play badly, that simply isn't right. Also for those of you who assume that if a player's stamina falls to 25% in a game they will be at 25% energy after the game, this also isn't right. Even if your stamina fell to 0% in a game, you would still be at 70% after the game if you were at 100% to start with.
Here are some facts (as opposed to assumptions) about stamina:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=78411
Basically, from what I read:
-Stamina depends on what the player is doing - making tackles, running deep routes, getting double-teamed or pancaked will all result in losing stamina faster than standing around, covering or running short routes, overmatching your opponent, etc.
-10% stamina does not equal 10% effectiveness. Players remain very effective even if their stamina is ridiculously low.
-No matter how far your stamina falls during the game, you will never lose more than 30 stamina after the game.
For all of you who assume that if a player's satmina falls to 25% in a game that means he will play badly, that simply isn't right. Also for those of you who assume that if a player's stamina falls to 25% in a game they will be at 25% energy after the game, this also isn't right. Even if your stamina fell to 0% in a game, you would still be at 70% after the game if you were at 100% to start with.
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 03:26:05
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























