Originally posted by Juan Fiddy
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy
I'm trying not to come across as an ass here, but the whole point of matchups is to exploit a weakness. If you have a weakness, then you need to do something about it.
But that's not the issue. Find a mismatch? Go ahead and have your QB attack it, but having a design "flaw" that allows teams to wait until near gametime and pick WR charts, while the defense is left no time to react is obviously an issue.
In the NFL they had a similar issue with the Colts and changed the rules to fix this because it's obviously not fair.
That's the only complaint that holds weight, but even that lends to shoring up your secondary so that it is capable enough to cover most of the threats, most of the time. If you only have one or two good coverage guys, then your secondary is just going to get beat.
I did however say that to avoid ping ponging up untill game time, it wouldn't be unreasonable to ask that there is a lock on the DCs for a certain period prior to the game being played. BUT in the context of the original post that wouldn't matter because the DC will get adjusted up to the lock, and even if the D has additional time to adjust past that it would still be considered by the OP as an exploit.
My position though is that you can't call something an exploit if it is well within the scope of the gameplay. As it stands, it is working as intended. Doesn't mean that it couldn't be adjusted, does mean that calling it an exploit is stretching it.
I get what you're saying, but anything can be an "exploit", whether or not it's working as intended. If, through something technically allowed by the game engine, a player is able to do something altering the balance of the game in such a way that he violates the intent of the rule or mechanism itself, then I'd say that's an exploit.
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy
I'm trying not to come across as an ass here, but the whole point of matchups is to exploit a weakness. If you have a weakness, then you need to do something about it.
But that's not the issue. Find a mismatch? Go ahead and have your QB attack it, but having a design "flaw" that allows teams to wait until near gametime and pick WR charts, while the defense is left no time to react is obviously an issue.
In the NFL they had a similar issue with the Colts and changed the rules to fix this because it's obviously not fair.
That's the only complaint that holds weight, but even that lends to shoring up your secondary so that it is capable enough to cover most of the threats, most of the time. If you only have one or two good coverage guys, then your secondary is just going to get beat.
I did however say that to avoid ping ponging up untill game time, it wouldn't be unreasonable to ask that there is a lock on the DCs for a certain period prior to the game being played. BUT in the context of the original post that wouldn't matter because the DC will get adjusted up to the lock, and even if the D has additional time to adjust past that it would still be considered by the OP as an exploit.
My position though is that you can't call something an exploit if it is well within the scope of the gameplay. As it stands, it is working as intended. Doesn't mean that it couldn't be adjusted, does mean that calling it an exploit is stretching it.
I get what you're saying, but anything can be an "exploit", whether or not it's working as intended. If, through something technically allowed by the game engine, a player is able to do something altering the balance of the game in such a way that he violates the intent of the rule or mechanism itself, then I'd say that's an exploit.






























