User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I am just going to make some updates to just make the defenders play closer in general, and skip any special risk calculations.


This is something I also noticed in the last game for all corners, but primarily our CB2. When he lined up on one side of the field he was a shutdown. On the other side he gave up 10 yards every pass and got nowhere near his man. A lot of the time there seemed to be an artificial distance between the two dots which wasn't there last season.

I think the agility factor has possibly had the duplicitous effect of basically making even fast WR into 'slow' WR. We were also up against a weaker team, which made it even more unusual because there seemed to be no rhyme or reason why a team with 3 of the best CB's in the division should each suffer the same issue against the same WR on different downs and drives (each player with varying degrees of attributes - but almost all with 50+ vision).

Considering we also play tight and aggressive it seems wierd.
 
mpowell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I am just going to make some updates to just make the defenders play closer in general, and skip any special risk calculations.


The quicker the fix, the better, imop. But just to echo others, I really appreciate your attention to these issues since I know you're loaded down with work.

Ultimately, some kind of adaptive CB coverage would be appropriate. If WR is repeatedly catching passes underneath, the CB should play closer and closer coverage, especially if the coverage is already set to be 'tight'. But obviously I don't know the actual code mechanism that causes the CB to drop back in these circumstances. Maybe the CB somehow thinks he is playing tight due to a peculiarity in the code.
 
Otega
12th MIManITW
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mpowell
Originally posted by Bort

I think I am just going to make some updates to just make the defenders play closer in general, and skip any special risk calculations.


The quicker the fix, the better, imop. But just to echo others, I really appreciate your attention to these issues since I know you're loaded down with work.

Ultimately, some kind of adaptive CB coverage would be appropriate. If WR is repeatedly catching passes underneath, the CB should play closer and closer coverage, especially if the coverage is already set to be 'tight'. But obviously I don't know the actual code mechanism that causes the CB to drop back in these circumstances. Maybe the CB somehow thinks he is playing tight due to a peculiarity in the code.


Ya, I agree with this. UNTIL a CB gets burned over the top (because he was playing too tight), the adjustment/risk factor on underneath throws should be moving the CB closer to the WR on coverage, not giving cushion. So, in essence, if you decide to put it back in at some point, it should work opposite the way it does now.

Or, even further, if a CB gets burnt a couple times on good routes, maybe he should automatically get subbed out for a couple plays, then go back in.

Just some random thoughts.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I am just going to make some updates to just make the defenders play closer in general, and skip any special risk calculations.


Hmm... this worries me.

Right now, CBs are shutting down WRs anyway. The only time that doesn't happen is when this current bug kicks into place. If the defenders play even closer, won't this kill the passing game? Maybe not... maybe CBs won't be able to keep up as much since WRs make the first move theoretically?

As far as the risk calculations, isn't that just the calculation a QB makes to see who the most open WR is? Or was the special calculation you're referring to the one where the QB keeps going back to what's working? If so, I think that's an excellent thing to remove. The QB should analyze the entire field every play, and not revert to one WR, or TE, or HB. That may even be why we see so many quick passes that make no sense, or dump offs, or TE fixations. This could benefit QBs with higher vision, which would be a boon.
 
mpowell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by Bort

I think I am just going to make some updates to just make the defenders play closer in general, and skip any special risk calculations.


Hmm... this worries me.

Right now, CBs are shutting down WRs anyway. The only time that doesn't happen is when this current bug kicks into place. If the defenders play even closer, won't this kill the passing game? Maybe not... maybe CBs won't be able to keep up as much since WRs make the first move theoretically?

As far as the risk calculations, isn't that just the calculation a QB makes to see who the most open WR is? Or was the special calculation you're referring to the one where the QB keeps going back to what's working? If so, I think that's an excellent thing to remove. The QB should analyze the entire field every play, and not revert to one WR, or TE, or HB. That may even be why we see so many quick passes that make no sense, or dump offs, or TE fixations. This could benefit QBs with higher vision, which would be a boon.


No, he's talking about calculations the CB makes. The original arrangement was apparently for the CB to elevate the risk posed by the WR every time the WR caught the ball. But this was broken because the result was the CB giving him more cushion, even if that was just making it worse. My opinion is that this has become more of a problem over time b/c as QBs and WRs have been getting better, it is more and more likely that the WR will catch most of these open passes and the QB will repeatedly find the open WR on every play, exacerbating the feedback effect where the CB plays more and more off.

Fact is, the AI is going to be a little crappy initially and get better over time as the game improves. And that's okay. But if something creates a huge exploit, it really needs to be fixed, even if it's just a little hacky, or it's going to ruin people's seasons, which just isn't cool.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Ahh... that risk assessment. Thanks for clearing that up
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
Now watch the sims for WR's beating CB's deep. If that starts happening, the fix worked and we'll have to reevaluate how close you want to play.


GG Bort
 
mpowell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bug03
Now watch the sims for WR's beating CB's deep. If that starts happening, the fix worked and we'll have to reevaluate how close you want to play.


GG Bort


That would be fine. Slower CBs will just have to play slightly more relaxed coverage. But theoretically they should have better agi, jumping, whatever, to get in there and do a better job knocking down passes headed their way.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
CB's getting beat would only make me more right. I keep seeing teams playing Cover 0 and cover 1 and I personally can't wait to see what this fix does to their D.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Why not just reset the passing game mechanics to exactly what they were last season?

The system is so flawed right now, that the only teams that are going to win games are the Run-based teams. What we have right now, are WRs on one side who cannot get open, because Cornerbacks are playing too tight and reacting too quickly, while on the other side of the field, the same Cornerbacks are giving up catch after catch, because they're inexplicably giving up larger cushions.

Half the people are complaining about their WRs not being able to get open at all, while the other half of the people are complaining about their CBs not being able to cover at all.

This is crippling the passing game, and for teams that were built for the passing offense, there is no way to survive against rushing teams, who dont have to worry about how buggy the system is, and who dont have to worry about constant changes in the sim while trying to fix the passing game. Next game, WRs might never get open, but the game after that, they might be torching defenders for 37 catches, like we've seen.

Last season, the pass game was balanced for both CBs and WRs. If you had good personnel and a good gameplan, you would be successful passing or defending the pass. Now it's just a damn crapshoot.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
If you want to see it at work just watch my CB's last game -- every play, every reciever, he's set on close but he's playing like he's set on "far" - deliberately leaving a 5 plus yard buffer.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Why not just reset the passing game mechanics to exactly what they were last season?.


They are the same as they were last season. That's the whole problem of why this is confusing and I'm trying to sort it out.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
I just went thru one of my games and its the CB2 that always gives the huge cushion. This is so frustrating to have a good build and good tactics and to have the WR you are supposed to be guarding catch ball after ball because you are 5-10 back.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I think I am just going to make some updates to just make the defenders play closer in general, and skip any special risk calculations.


I endorse this move completely. I've been struggling with CBs, CB2 mostly, playing loose no matter how he's set or how our defensive settings were (cover short, med, deep) since Season 2.


Bort's working the forums hard tonight. Must be our lucky day.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 19:30:20
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by glb.center
I just went thru one of my games and its the CB2 that always gives the huge cushion. This is so frustrating to have a good build and good tactics and to have the WR you are supposed to be guarding catch ball after ball because you are 5-10 back.


My CB gave the huge cushion regardless of which CB position he lined up in.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.