:o
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by The Duff Man
phthalatemagic was actually threatening to join DDL...that is how bad it has gotten
All right, fine...I'll take Big Shirl & phthalatemagic's OT, but I don't know if I can take any more of your players Duff. Pls, I can only do so much. Tell you what, make me a temp GM of the OFGs, I'll look over all the rest's builds and see if I could take a few more, but I'm ONLY doing this because I think you're a decent guy!
phthalatemagic was actually threatening to join DDL...that is how bad it has gotten
All right, fine...I'll take Big Shirl & phthalatemagic's OT, but I don't know if I can take any more of your players Duff. Pls, I can only do so much. Tell you what, make me a temp GM of the OFGs, I'll look over all the rest's builds and see if I could take a few more, but I'm ONLY doing this because I think you're a decent guy!
Yellow
offline
offline
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by The Duff Man
phthalatemagic was actually threatening to join DDL...that is how bad it has gotten
All right, fine...I'll take Big Shirl & phthalatemagic's OT, but I don't know if I can take any more of your players Duff. Pls, I can only do so much. Tell you what, make me a temp GM of the OFGs, I'll look over all the rest's builds and see if I could take a few more, but I'm ONLY doing this because I think you're a decent guy!
PP, you are a stand-up guy!
Originally posted by The Duff Man
phthalatemagic was actually threatening to join DDL...that is how bad it has gotten
All right, fine...I'll take Big Shirl & phthalatemagic's OT, but I don't know if I can take any more of your players Duff. Pls, I can only do so much. Tell you what, make me a temp GM of the OFGs, I'll look over all the rest's builds and see if I could take a few more, but I'm ONLY doing this because I think you're a decent guy!
PP, you are a stand-up guy!
The Duff Man
offline
offline
I am sure you don't want to get into this much detail, but one thing dragging down the ranking of the ***O*** could be a lot of guys who are on the team but not on the depth chart.
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by Adderfist
You know, the yell players could make good backups for SFM.
;D
Come on Adderfist! you know darn well that they aren't good enough to be backups for even a USA BBB squad. Stop being so mean and teasing them like that! It reminds me of the hot girls that flirted with the boys in Special Ed back in Jr High, just because they thought it was funny. You're better than that!
You know, the yell players could make good backups for SFM.
;D
Come on Adderfist! you know darn well that they aren't good enough to be backups for even a USA BBB squad. Stop being so mean and teasing them like that! It reminds me of the hot girls that flirted with the boys in Special Ed back in Jr High, just because they thought it was funny. You're better than that!
zero
offline
offline
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by Adderfist
You know, the yell players could make good backups for SFM.
;D
Come on Adderfist! you know darn well that they aren't good enough to be backups for even a USA BBB squad. Stop being so mean and teasing them like that! It reminds me of the hot girls that flirted with the boys in Special Ed back in Jr High, just because they thought it was funny. You're better than that!
HAHAHAHAHA
i just graduated from HS and i know EXACTLY WHAT YOU MEAN. MAN I WAS JEALOUS OF THE SPED KIDS
Originally posted by Adderfist
You know, the yell players could make good backups for SFM.
;D
Come on Adderfist! you know darn well that they aren't good enough to be backups for even a USA BBB squad. Stop being so mean and teasing them like that! It reminds me of the hot girls that flirted with the boys in Special Ed back in Jr High, just because they thought it was funny. You're better than that!
HAHAHAHAHA
i just graduated from HS and i know EXACTLY WHAT YOU MEAN. MAN I WAS JEALOUS OF THE SPED KIDS
Yeremiah
offline
offline
Originally posted by zero
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by Adderfist
You know, the yell players could make good backups for SFM.
;D
Come on Adderfist! you know darn well that they aren't good enough to be backups for even a USA BBB squad. Stop being so mean and teasing them like that! It reminds me of the hot girls that flirted with the boys in Special Ed back in Jr High, just because they thought it was funny. You're better than that!
HAHAHAHAHA
i just graduated from HS and i know EXACTLY WHAT YOU MEAN. MAN I WAS JEALOUS OF THE SPED KIDS
Helmets are just a lady magnet.
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by Adderfist
You know, the yell players could make good backups for SFM.
;D
Come on Adderfist! you know darn well that they aren't good enough to be backups for even a USA BBB squad. Stop being so mean and teasing them like that! It reminds me of the hot girls that flirted with the boys in Special Ed back in Jr High, just because they thought it was funny. You're better than that!
HAHAHAHAHA
i just graduated from HS and i know EXACTLY WHAT YOU MEAN. MAN I WAS JEALOUS OF THE SPED KIDS
Helmets are just a lady magnet.
JTD
offline
offline
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Originally posted by nathbear
Kinda confused as to how the Vaqueros ranking could go down despite beating the team ranked directly above us, but still good to get the lists out there...
Thanks for the good work!
I'm going to use this comment as an excuse to give a practical demonstration of how the rankings are calculated.
Here is how the Vaqueros offense ranked in the week 1 ratings:
First, I calculated the average level at each position.
QB: 28.0 (level 28 starter)
HB: 27.7 (a 28 and a 27, weighted 70-30)
FB: 25.0 (a 25)
WR: 26.1 (28, 27, 23, 21, weighted 37.5-35-20-7.5)
TE: 23.4 (24, 21, weighted 80-20)
OT: 25.4 (28, 24, 23, weighted 40-40-20)
OG: 25.8 (28, 26, 21, weighted 40-40-20)
C: 26.3 (27, 22, weighted 85-15)
Next, I did the same calculation for every other team in the league, and found the highest rating at each position, which was:
QB: 29.0 (2 teams)
HB: 27.7 (Vaqueros)
FB: 29.0 (***O***)
WR: 26.5 (NJ Generals)
TE: 27.2 (Grand Junction)
OT: 27.6 (Richmond)
OG: 27.2 (NJ Generals)
C: 28.3 (Las Vegas Aces)
Then I compared the Vaqueros ratings to those league maximums and converted the Vaqueros position ratings to a 100 point scale:
QB: 96.6 (28/29*100)
HB: 100
FB: 86.2
WR: 98.5
TE: 86.0
OT: 92.0
OG: 94.9
C: 92.9
Finally, I averaged these numbers together, with weights of 16.25% QB, 22.5% HB, 7.5% FB, 11.25% WR, 5% TE, 15% OT, 15% OG, 7.5% C. My logic for those numbers is that when passing, the QB and the collective receiving corps matter equally, so QB = WR+TE, whereas while when running, it's mostly the HB, less the FB. Overall, I give 37.5% credit to the O-Line, which is important on every play, 32.5% credit to the passing game skill players, and 30% credit to the running game skill players. Eventually, once I have enough data, I will run some multivariable regression analysis on rankings vs. results, and see if I'm overrating/underrating certain positions. Off the top of my head, HB should probably be worth less, and the O-Line probably worth more, but I'm not ready yet to mess with that portion of these rankings. Next season, perhaps. Anyway, averaging the numbers together with those weights, I calculated a rating of 95.0 for the Vaqueros offense.
Doing the same basic thing on defense, I got a rating of 94.7, and on special teams (kicker + punter) I got 84.4. Weighting THESE numbers together, 45-45-10, I got a team rating of 93.8, but this received a 1% penalty because of 90 chemistry (I penalize 1% for each 10 points of chem below 100, so a team with 10 chem takes a 9% hit) so the final rating came out as 92.9 for week one.
Then they played a game against the New Jersey Generals, who were rated 93.6, so the Vaqueros were rated 0.7 lower, and thus were 2 point underdogs (actually 2.1282). They won by 3, so that means they overperformed their ranking by 5, which earned an adjustment of +0.26.
Now then, their week 2 rankings:
The only changes in level are that the backup TE went from 21 to 22, a DT went from 26 to 27, a LB went from 22 to 23, a CB went from 25 to 27, and the K went from 26 to 27. This did increase the weighted average level at those positions, but other teams also improved. Specifically, the best WR corps in the league jumped from 26.5 to 27.3, TE went from 27.2 to 27.8, and OT and OG went up as well, along of course with some increases to the defensive maximums.
In other words, the "league best" went up more than the Vaqueros did, therefore the Vaqueros rating dropped a bit in comparison, to an offense rating of 94.3, a defense rating of 93.0, and 86.2 on special teams. These, and a 91 chemistry, average together to 92.1, a drop from the 92.9 the were beforehand. The adjustment bonus for their upset win raises it to 92.3, but it's still lower than it was beforehand.
Is that a long enough answer to a short question?
Thank you for explaining everything in detail BJJ, I was wondering how you were calculating everything. Perhaps you should try to factor chemistry into the mix as well as a 5-10% component of overall rating.
Originally posted by nathbear
Kinda confused as to how the Vaqueros ranking could go down despite beating the team ranked directly above us, but still good to get the lists out there...
Thanks for the good work!
I'm going to use this comment as an excuse to give a practical demonstration of how the rankings are calculated.
Here is how the Vaqueros offense ranked in the week 1 ratings:
First, I calculated the average level at each position.
QB: 28.0 (level 28 starter)
HB: 27.7 (a 28 and a 27, weighted 70-30)
FB: 25.0 (a 25)
WR: 26.1 (28, 27, 23, 21, weighted 37.5-35-20-7.5)
TE: 23.4 (24, 21, weighted 80-20)
OT: 25.4 (28, 24, 23, weighted 40-40-20)
OG: 25.8 (28, 26, 21, weighted 40-40-20)
C: 26.3 (27, 22, weighted 85-15)
Next, I did the same calculation for every other team in the league, and found the highest rating at each position, which was:
QB: 29.0 (2 teams)
HB: 27.7 (Vaqueros)
FB: 29.0 (***O***)
WR: 26.5 (NJ Generals)
TE: 27.2 (Grand Junction)
OT: 27.6 (Richmond)
OG: 27.2 (NJ Generals)
C: 28.3 (Las Vegas Aces)
Then I compared the Vaqueros ratings to those league maximums and converted the Vaqueros position ratings to a 100 point scale:
QB: 96.6 (28/29*100)
HB: 100
FB: 86.2
WR: 98.5
TE: 86.0
OT: 92.0
OG: 94.9
C: 92.9
Finally, I averaged these numbers together, with weights of 16.25% QB, 22.5% HB, 7.5% FB, 11.25% WR, 5% TE, 15% OT, 15% OG, 7.5% C. My logic for those numbers is that when passing, the QB and the collective receiving corps matter equally, so QB = WR+TE, whereas while when running, it's mostly the HB, less the FB. Overall, I give 37.5% credit to the O-Line, which is important on every play, 32.5% credit to the passing game skill players, and 30% credit to the running game skill players. Eventually, once I have enough data, I will run some multivariable regression analysis on rankings vs. results, and see if I'm overrating/underrating certain positions. Off the top of my head, HB should probably be worth less, and the O-Line probably worth more, but I'm not ready yet to mess with that portion of these rankings. Next season, perhaps. Anyway, averaging the numbers together with those weights, I calculated a rating of 95.0 for the Vaqueros offense.
Doing the same basic thing on defense, I got a rating of 94.7, and on special teams (kicker + punter) I got 84.4. Weighting THESE numbers together, 45-45-10, I got a team rating of 93.8, but this received a 1% penalty because of 90 chemistry (I penalize 1% for each 10 points of chem below 100, so a team with 10 chem takes a 9% hit) so the final rating came out as 92.9 for week one.
Then they played a game against the New Jersey Generals, who were rated 93.6, so the Vaqueros were rated 0.7 lower, and thus were 2 point underdogs (actually 2.1282). They won by 3, so that means they overperformed their ranking by 5, which earned an adjustment of +0.26.
Now then, their week 2 rankings:
The only changes in level are that the backup TE went from 21 to 22, a DT went from 26 to 27, a LB went from 22 to 23, a CB went from 25 to 27, and the K went from 26 to 27. This did increase the weighted average level at those positions, but other teams also improved. Specifically, the best WR corps in the league jumped from 26.5 to 27.3, TE went from 27.2 to 27.8, and OT and OG went up as well, along of course with some increases to the defensive maximums.
In other words, the "league best" went up more than the Vaqueros did, therefore the Vaqueros rating dropped a bit in comparison, to an offense rating of 94.3, a defense rating of 93.0, and 86.2 on special teams. These, and a 91 chemistry, average together to 92.1, a drop from the 92.9 the were beforehand. The adjustment bonus for their upset win raises it to 92.3, but it's still lower than it was beforehand.
Is that a long enough answer to a short question?
Thank you for explaining everything in detail BJJ, I was wondering how you were calculating everything. Perhaps you should try to factor chemistry into the mix as well as a 5-10% component of overall rating.
palmer_garnett_95
offline
offline
Originally posted by JTD
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Weighting THESE numbers together, 45-45-10, I got a team rating of 93.8, but this received a 1% penalty because of 90 chemistry (I penalize 1% for each 10 points of chem below 100, so a team with 10 chem takes a 9% hit) so the final rating came out as 92.9 for week one.
Thank you for explaining everything in detail BJJ, I was wondering how you were calculating everything. Perhaps you should try to factor chemistry into the mix as well as a 5-10% component of overall rating.
He already does, just not that much unless you have really bad chemistry.
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Weighting THESE numbers together, 45-45-10, I got a team rating of 93.8, but this received a 1% penalty because of 90 chemistry (I penalize 1% for each 10 points of chem below 100, so a team with 10 chem takes a 9% hit) so the final rating came out as 92.9 for week one.
Thank you for explaining everything in detail BJJ, I was wondering how you were calculating everything. Perhaps you should try to factor chemistry into the mix as well as a 5-10% component of overall rating.
He already does, just not that much unless you have really bad chemistry.
Last edited Aug 5, 2008 10:42:23
Maik Jeaunz
offline
offline
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
I think he should factor in how much we can bench press
XPLODE!!!11
I think he should factor in how much we can bench press
XPLODE!!!11
BobJoeJim
offline
offline
Originally posted by The Duff Man
I am sure you don't want to get into this much detail, but one thing dragging down the ranking of the ***O*** could be a lot of guys who are on the team but not on the depth chart.
My calculations are based on rosters, not depth charts. Your "#1 WR" is the highest level WR you have, regardless of where he is on the depth chart. Otherwise I'd have ALL KINDS of headaches with the formula.
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
I think he should factor in how much we can bench press
If we can get every single player in the league to make their build open to everyone, I gladly would
I am sure you don't want to get into this much detail, but one thing dragging down the ranking of the ***O*** could be a lot of guys who are on the team but not on the depth chart.
My calculations are based on rosters, not depth charts. Your "#1 WR" is the highest level WR you have, regardless of where he is on the depth chart. Otherwise I'd have ALL KINDS of headaches with the formula.
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
I think he should factor in how much we can bench press
If we can get every single player in the league to make their build open to everyone, I gladly would

You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























