User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The solution!! For retiring players, teams playing 100+ plays per player/penalizing depth, and rewarding team with good defenses/quick scoring offenses
Page:
 
mpp
offline
Link
 
How's this idea.....(read parts of this here and there)

If salary minimums are set at 10%(just for talking purposes) a players level "normal training costs" and a player starts declining faster than he can train after 10yrs. He will eventually become to expensive to keep with his remaining skills. Also, as you stated here. Injuries and training facilities could influence the 10yr mark, forward or backward, by changing the effectiveness of training.

An additional take, as a player falls below 75% energy, their risk of injury should increase. Slightly at first and as you fall below 70% the risk should really go up.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly

i think there would have to be an "age limit" as well as a "wear and tear" limit that would work in conjunction together - i.e. the actual limit is a a variable based on a players wear and tear in conjunction with his age...


Even better is if players and owners don't know what the formula is. It could vary slightly by position. When player reached that point, there would be a red dot show up on their profile.


 
mikestiddy
offline
Link
 
Model it after real life... The average QB plays 10-12 years, RB 7-11, WR/TE 10-12, OL 10-14, DL 10-14, LB 8-12, DB 8-12, P/K 15-20 Once they reach the lower level of that amount of years, their production/health goes down and their talents start to dwindle. Also take into account how many injuries they have throughout their career. I would like to see it mimic the duration of careers for the NFL players
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by jearly


i think there would have to be an "age limit" as well as a "wear and tear" limit that would work in conjunction together - i.e. the actual limit is a a variable based on a players wear and tear in conjunction with his age...


Even better is if players and owners don't know what the formula is. It could vary slightly by position. When player reached that point, there would be a red dot show up on their profile.




I would agree.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikestiddy
Model it after real life... The average QB plays 10-12 years, RB 7-11, WR/TE 10-12, OL 10-14, DL 10-14, LB 8-12, DB 8-12, P/K 15-20 Once they reach the lower level of that amount of years, their production/health goes down and their talents start to dwindle. Also take into account how many injuries they have throughout their career. I would like to see it mimic the duration of careers for the NFL players


agree, but you would need the xp to increase quicker for the players with lower career expectancies to even up to the top players.. Also - RBS have the lowest career but cost the most to create? Doesn't make sense economically for the game (though I can see your point).
 
Graythreat
offline
Link
 
after all of the boneheaded ideas, I actually like this one...it will create parity......

If this is implemented though, we'll need a better way to reign in the amount of touches some players get (24 carries for #HB, 16 for #2 or something like that) rather than just rely on getting tired...but i want that control anyway
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Graythreat
after all of the boneheaded ideas, I actually like this one...it will create parity......

If this is implemented though, we'll need a better way to reign in the amount of touches some players get (24 carries for #HB, 16 for #2 or something like that) rather than just rely on getting tired...but i want that control anyway


absolutely. Personally, i would like to be able to specify carries per player for RBS and plays per QB. (WRs wouldn't make as much sense as you don't want the qb forcing a pass to one player if another is open).
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Graythreat
after all of the boneheaded ideas, I actually like this one...it will create parity......



the boneheaded ideas were just steps towards creating a good one
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Malachorn

90 is too high and I think that should be lowered.
The idea that you shorten your career for playing and everything else? I can't like that. This is a competition and I hate the idea that every player would get their turn as being one of the very best. Would completely diminish the value of going into the Hall of Fame or anything, in my opinion.


The first players to level up would definately have the advantage, because there would be less competition at the top levels.

After that, there would be more players to compete against at the top levels. Some would be at 7000 plays after 10 seasons, some after 8, some possibly after 6. The better built players would do better. Just because you have 3,000 level 40 players doesn't mean they are all going to excel.



Yeah, but at that point it is mostly JUST the system you were lucky enough to be a part of. When the best players retire they'll all be far too comparable too each other. Don't people want real bragging rights?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
What about this though.

I create a player...and have him sit...do nothing for say idk 5 seasons. So by now he's what level 20-25 maybe?? So then i start having him play in games. And he is way better than other players around him.

I mean you have your system designed to stop people from "playing the system" but honestly someone is going to "play" it somehow.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 23:07:36
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
What about this though.

I create a player...and have him sit...do nothing for say idk 5 seasons. So by now he's what level 20-25 maybe?? So then i start having him play in games. And he lasts way longer than other people around him.

I mean you have your system designed to stop people from "playing the system" but honestly someone is going to "play" it somehow.



You're right... there will always be players that are going to end up better through some way of taking advantage of the system. This way will just end up rewarding the different kind of power leveling (apathy leveling?).
 
Emanbears23
offline
Link
 
Guys, 10 seasons are a VERY long time away.Over a years away, do any of you who are so worried about this even know if you will still be so heavily into this game by then? Think about it, it's a long ways away.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
What about this though.

I create a player...and have him sit...do nothing for say idk 5 seasons. So by now he's what level 20-25 maybe?? So then i start having him play in games. And he lasts way longer than other people around him.

I mean you have your system designed to stop people from "playing the system" but honestly someone is going to "play" it somehow.



that's the reason for the "age limit" - i.e. other words a player's length of career would be defined by the "wear and tear" (number of plays) and "age" (seasons) in combination with eachother.

he formula would not be published so no-one really no-ones what it is
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
...that was actually my biggest problem with this though.
Seems to reward the players that aren't playing too much.

The guys in the Hall Of Fame all played backup for most of their careers? Seems odd.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Originally posted by Malachorn


90 is too high and I think that should be lowered.
The idea that you shorten your career for playing and everything else? I can't like that. This is a competition and I hate the idea that every player would get their turn as being one of the very best. Would completely diminish the value of going into the Hall of Fame or anything, in my opinion.


The first players to level up would definately have the advantage, because there would be less competition at the top levels.

After that, there would be more players to compete against at the top levels. Some would be at 7000 plays after 10 seasons, some after 8, some possibly after 6. The better built players would do better. Just because you have 3,000 level 40 players doesn't mean they are all going to excel.



Yeah, but at that point it is mostly JUST the system you were lucky enough to be a part of. When the best players retire they'll all be far too comparable too each other. Don't people want real bragging rights?


again - you can build players better, in addition adding in durability skill as well as team training facilities can take add the variety you are looking for.

Besides - if everyone just plays their starters at 100+ plays a game, then in 10 seasons everyone will be the same anyway, so I don't see your point...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.