User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Solution to the teams who move up being out leveled
Page:
 
RyguyRB
offline
Link
 
As much as I'd love for my level 11 CB to be higher than my lvl 22 CB in 2 seasons, that doesnt seem very fair, does it?
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
Originally posted by marauder22

Originally posted by Aperture


So each of your team's players gets to automatically be better than 50% of the higher league's? Sounds like a great deal for the newcomers and a very poor deal for the ones already there.


So you think by only keeping ppl that were here early happy will help the game in the long run? People don't wanna wait forever to be competitive because people like you don't want to have competition, but an edge. Their will always be 3 or 4 cupcakes if you leave the system the way it is. New teams and teams with later season players that move up will be the cupcakes to the upper leagues.I'm sure you love these games. http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=87960 Was their any glory in beating this team that you outlevel in some areas by up to 13 levels? Unless you think you won because of better gameplanning. LMAO
what a dumb example. it was the team that promoted that won 92-0.


His team has been around since season 1. Not a team that just came into the league. Look at the season 3 AA#2 winner. That team will have a disadvantage. The argument I was making in that post. Was this is what I think he wants the games to be like. If the teams that start later have to compete with the teams that have been around longer. Being outleveled by 13 levels is really bad for the game.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RyguyRB
As much as I'd love for my level 11 CB to be higher than my lvl 22 CB in 2 seasons, that doesnt seem very fair, does it?


How about deducting seasons from your player for every 3 boost he uses past what he can use for the season. So if your player boosted to level 22. He'd lose 2 2/3 seasons. Seeing as how your CB would boost to level 14. Now if he could boost another 8 to be at the median he'd lose 2 2/3 seasons.
 
Aperture
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by marauder22

The argument I was making in that post. Was this is what I think he wants the games to be like. If the teams that start later have to compete with the teams that have been around longer.


For the record, it's not what I want the games to be like. There goes your argument in that post. However, please don't propose the obvious false dichotomy that superficially appears to follow from this. It's not valid.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Aperture
Originally posted by marauder22


The argument I was making in that post. Was this is what I think he wants the games to be like. If the teams that start later have to compete with the teams that have been around longer.


For the record, it's not what I want the games to be like. There goes your argument in that post. However, please don't propose the obvious false dichotomy that superficially appears to follow from this. It's not valid.


I will ask you this then. Do you think their should be teams outleveled by 13 levels?
 
Aperture
offline
Link
 
I will ask in response how that question is relevant, because the issue at hand is teams that promote, not teams that are newer than other teams.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
btw where is this 13-level difference you speak of? generally i see no more than 4 or 5. that example of the oceania AA#1 winner, most of them are about 5 levels off from the top team in the league. it sort of makes sense too, considering that AAA happened one year before AA and the general # of levels gained from year 3 to 4 is 5 levels.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Aperture
I will ask in response how that question is relevant, because the issue at hand is teams that promote, not teams that are newer than other teams.


The teams that will have to get to the median level are teams that are new. So the question is when they win their league will they compete if their 13 levels below the other teams highest players? This thread is to help new teams that are being promoted. Not teams that have been around since season 1 who are already at the median level of the next league they will be moving up to.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SyedAshrafulla
btw where is this 13-level difference you speak of? generally i see no more than 4 or 5. that example of the oceania AA#1 winner, most of them are about 5 levels off from the top team in the league. it sort of makes sense too, considering that AAA happened one year before AA and the general # of levels gained from year 3 to 4 is 5 levels.


You don't see it yet. you only see 4-6 level advantages. Next season you will see a bigger number. When the capped teams move up. Take this team for example http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=230. Now put a top cap level team against them that will be moving up to face this team.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 02:53:23
 
fakesanta
offline
Link
 
-50

why not nerf the xp's of teams getting relegated. no shit ...
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fakesanta
-50

why not nerf the xp's of teams getting relegated. no shit ...


Why is it only ppl that are way ahead in levels that hate these ideas? Edges are pretty weak to have. I play poker for a living. What would my edge be if I could view 1 of my opponents cards every hand? Would that help my game in any way?
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 03:12:56
 
RyguyRB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by marauder22
Originally posted by RyguyRB

As much as I'd love for my level 11 CB to be higher than my lvl 22 CB in 2 seasons, that doesnt seem very fair, does it?


How about deducting seasons from your player for every 3 boost he uses past what he can use for the season. So if your player boosted to level 22. He'd lose 2 2/3 seasons. Seeing as how your CB would boost to level 14. Now if he could boost another 8 to be at the median he'd lose 2 2/3 seasons.



I kinda like that idea, could give the people that showed up late a chance to catch up without a huge advantage, as long as its taken perfectly proportionally. Not sure how you'd decide that, either... does it proportion to a player that boosts at the beginning of the season, in the playoffs, offseason? What about training, do they get free training points, do they lose those? Why not allow restro boosting than? Too many questions, and problems with it, although I do like it if it were planned out properly to where it would give those players no advantage whatsoever.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RyguyRB
Originally posted by marauder22

Originally posted by RyguyRB


As much as I'd love for my level 11 CB to be higher than my lvl 22 CB in 2 seasons, that doesnt seem very fair, does it?


How about deducting seasons from your player for every 3 boost he uses past what he can use for the season. So if your player boosted to level 22. He'd lose 2 2/3 seasons. Seeing as how your CB would boost to level 14. Now if he could boost another 8 to be at the median he'd lose 2 2/3 seasons.



I kinda like that idea, could give the people that showed up late a chance to catch up without a huge advantage, as long as its taken perfectly proportionally. Not sure how you'd decide that, either... does it proportion to a player that boosts at the beginning of the season, in the playoffs, offseason? What about training, do they get free training points, do they lose those? Why not allow restro boosting than? Too many questions, and problems with it, although I do like it if it were planned out properly to where it would give those players no advantage whatsoever.


They could only allow the players that moved up with the team to boost to the median levels. Not recruits they get in the offseason.
 
Aperture
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by marauder22


Why is it only ppl that are way ahead in levels that hate these ideas?


Hold it!

If you're going to accuse people, accuse people. Don't insinuate.

Originally posted by marauder22
Edges are pretty weak to have. I play poker for a living. What would my edge be if I could view 1 of my opponents cards every hand? Would that help my game in any way?


False analogy. Furthermore, the logical consequence of it is not to allow any sort of extra boosting to achieve level parity, it's making everybody's numbers exactly the same. After all, wouldn't that completely eliminate edges?
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Aperture
Originally posted by marauder22



Why is it only ppl that are way ahead in levels that hate these ideas?


Hold it!

If you're going to accuse people, accuse people. Don't insinuate.

Originally posted by marauder22

Edges are pretty weak to have. I play poker for a living. What would my edge be if I could view 1 of my opponents cards every hand? Would that help my game in any way?


False analogy. Furthermore, the logical consequence of it is not to allow any sort of extra boosting to achieve level parity, it's making everybody's numbers exactly the same. After all, wouldn't that completely eliminate edges?


Like I said why do teams need edges? Do you think you need an edge to win?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.