User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP For Defense: Bad D=Good XP
Page:
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Edited to add: Your level 15 FB is evidence of the problem right now. There are only 44 level 13 or higher players. In reality, level 12 should be the highest any player has reached by this point and that is with a boost.


Where did you come up with that number? Seems kind of arbitrary....

Originally posted by JDaniels127
Im a backup and i level every uhm....3 F#@W#%^ games. I mean that's ridiculous if your guy who is lower than a lvl 10 is leveling EVERY game. That's not fair...if we preach "the rich get richer" is what we want to avoid by not giving teams playoff EXP, we can't in good conscience keep screwing the back ups.


I don't know if it's so much unfair that the starter is getting so much exp, as much as it's unfair that the backup isn't getting enough. Same basic idea, just different idea on how to fix the issue.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Urrymonster
How on Earth are you still leveling so quick???? All my players have a higher stamina than what people recommend and yet they still get knackered and replaced. Generally though they are the highest snap players on my team (around the 50 mark).


I try to get everyone on my team around 80 plays/game each. That's how.
 
Urrymonster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by Urrymonster

How on Earth are you still leveling so quick???? All my players have a higher stamina than what people recommend and yet they still get knackered and replaced. Generally though they are the highest snap players on my team (around the 50 mark).


I try to get everyone on my team around 80 plays/game each. That's how.


Ah my bad I thought you had more than one player at each position on the depth chart. My bad!
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed


Where did you come up with that number? Seems kind of arbitrary....[/qoute]

Search. Show only human players. Minimum level 13. Max level 100. All Leagues
Sort by level.

LVL 15 - 1 player
LVL 14 - 17 players
LVL 13 - 51 players

I was wrong on 44. I thought it ended on page 2 instead of 3. I know there are 25 players per page.

There are 7 pages of players level 12 or higher so, there are roughly 131 level 12.

There are 14 pages of just level 11 players. So there are about 350 level 11 players.
 
Big_Sexxy_II
offline
Link
 
Keep in mind, Jed was also here before 99% of the individuals. He's one of the orginals, so he has a headstart on almost all of us.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Rage, I meant the part where you said no one should be over level 12 right now. That just seems like a strange statement and don't see much of a basis for it.
 
Apple Dapple
offline
Link
 
I've also argued about this. Our defense has spent a very low amount of plays on the field in a lot of games because we keep having the other team going 3 and out, and we suffer because of it. That's messed up.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Rage, I meant the part where you said no one should be over level 12 right now. That just seems like a strange statement and don't see much of a basis for it.



Because there are many, many teams that have played 16 games. To have such a low number of players that are level 13 and higher shows that the are coming from teams that don't play backups. All 14 and up come from 6 teams.

Of the players over level 12
12 are on the Pushovers
11 are on the Juggernauts
8 are on the Gangsters
8 are on the Dumptrucks
7 are on the Mustangs
6 are on the Nasty
5 are on the Mauraduers

2 teams have 3, 1 team has 2, and 4 teams have 1

With as many teams as have played a full season, if players should be above level 12 right now, they should be coming from a lot more teams than that.

12 is probably too high a number. It should probably be 11. Any level a fully bumped player couldn't reach playing 75% of the average number of snaps on 1 side of the ball is too high.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 15:34:45
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
There is a L11 defensive player on my team .. a "crappy" E. Europe team that is probably the 2nd best team talent wise in my league even though almost none of us started before March 24th.

L11 CB Day 10
L10 LB Day 8

Its possible to have higher level guys who werent even here the first day, you have to figure that each of these guys lost at least 2 levels if not 3 .. you just need to manage your snaps and LB is the hardest place to manage snaps because of CB/LB rotations.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
I looked. That level 11 CB was in for 63 of 68 plays in the last regular season game, and 62 of 67 plays the game before that.

This is what people are talking about. You shouldn't get more XP for having a guy in 90% of the plays on a defense that's on the field 1/2 the game.

What about teams with good defenses. Where the offense is on the field 80 plays and defense is on 45?

Should teams be penalized if they run a ball control offense that reduces the number of total plays in the game?

After 66% of average plays on one side of the ball then starters should only be in to win games not gain more XP.

You shouldn't punish teams for having good defenses, and you need incentives to put backup players in the games.
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
My team had 83 offensive snaps and 65 defensive snaps .. that is pretty skewed right there.

He was in 64/65 snaps that game

That is a good CB! Hes a starter so he should be in the entire game, he doesnt play any other position. Both of my starting CBs are over 90% of available snaps, that is GOOD.

The issue is that if you are a good defense, you are going to average 10-30 snaps MORE on offense than you are on defense, but if something isnt done about that imbalance the best thing you can do is ensure that your starters are out there as much as they can be.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
I've seen games where the defense was only on the field 38 plays.

Plus part of the argument here is teams aren't playing backups. There are many people playing this game who only own players. They are getting put on teams where they never see the field.

If you want to play your starter 90% of the time, then fine, you can do that to win the game. But you shouldn't get more XP than someone who doesn't see as many snaps or someone who actually plays their backups and tries to make the game fun for as many people as possible.

Part of the revenue for this is coming from people who don't own teams, but put money into their players. Why would anyone do that if no matter how much they tried to boost their players levels, he can never catch up because his players never get into a game.

 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Other than QB, RB, K, P i dont think there are alot of people who will struggle to find spots. Especially after they add all those teams.

I mean it was nearly impossible most of the season to find any DL!
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
But how much money will they put in, if they find spots, but their players never develop because they only get 5 to 10 plays a game, when they end up on a team where the owner has 20 players and wants them in 95% of the time so his players can level up faster?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
But how much money will they put in, if they find spots, but their players never develop because they only get 5 to 10 plays a game, when they end up on a team where the owner has 20 players and wants them in 95% of the time so his players can level up faster?


You have to pick your owners. I dont sign players who i can't play for 30 plays or more per game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.