User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Pass defenders still have too quick reflexes...Bort was going to fix?
Page:
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
not fixed yet
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 13:19:07
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by markhehe
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by Greenday4537


What's wrong with the way it is? ALL WRs drop passes. This is a fact of life. If a team only has 3 dropped passes on one game, so what? That's not bad. If a team is all low levels, they should have a bunch of drops.

As for DBs reacting too quick, what else should they do? I've never just seen a DB just stand there while a WR runs past them. Fine, maybe decrease the chances for a dropped ball or a deflection, but make it so sometimes the QB passes are just completely off, so this way completion %s don't go sky high.


They were superhumanly quick.

I'm not against the drops. I (and others) are saying that just as receivers make mistakes and drop the ball, defenders should make mistakes and not recognize passes as quickly every time.

That's how football works. The inherent advantage in offense is that they know what they plan to do and the defense doesn't have any idea. That's why most first downs are converted in real life.

The running game has been brought up to realistic levels; the passing game needs to, as well.


the running game has NOT been brought up to realistic levels!!! its worse, if anything. when a back with 73 speed and 50 agility cant get outside, there is a problem. you cant get caught by a LB with 50 or 60 speed. the numbers have to mean something!!! if you have 73 speed(and enough agility to support that)then you should be able to beat everyone to the corner. if the CB makes the tackle, so be it. but, no-one should stop him from getting to the outside.


A team I watched and help with offense has a speed RB who got around the corner extremely well last game.

The problem you refer to (and even a little of the passing problems) has to do, though, with too-fast LB's because tackling was too easy, so they could just go for speed.

As they're forced to build tackling to stop power runners, they'll be weaker against speedy outside runners.
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by markhehe

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by Greenday4537



What's wrong with the way it is? ALL WRs drop passes. This is a fact of life. If a team only has 3 dropped passes on one game, so what? That's not bad. If a team is all low levels, they should have a bunch of drops.

As for DBs reacting too quick, what else should they do? I've never just seen a DB just stand there while a WR runs past them. Fine, maybe decrease the chances for a dropped ball or a deflection, but make it so sometimes the QB passes are just completely off, so this way completion %s don't go sky high.


They were superhumanly quick.

I'm not against the drops. I (and others) are saying that just as receivers make mistakes and drop the ball, defenders should make mistakes and not recognize passes as quickly every time.

That's how football works. The inherent advantage in offense is that they know what they plan to do and the defense doesn't have any idea. That's why most first downs are converted in real life.

The running game has been brought up to realistic levels; the passing game needs to, as well.


the running game has NOT been brought up to realistic levels!!! its worse, if anything. when a back with 73 speed and 50 agility cant get outside, there is a problem. you cant get caught by a LB with 50 or 60 speed. the numbers have to mean something!!! if you have 73 speed(and enough agility to support that)then you should be able to beat everyone to the corner. if the CB makes the tackle, so be it. but, no-one should stop him from getting to the outside.


A team I watched and help with offense has a speed RB who got around the corner extremely well last game.

The problem you refer to (and even a little of the passing problems) has to do, though, with too-fast LB's because tackling was too easy, so they could just go for speed.

As they're forced to build tackling to stop power runners, they'll be weaker against speedy outside runners.


but when? thought that was already in effect. ill open my guy's build for a while, if you wanna see it. its frustrating to have a level 25 that you have spent a ton of bucks on, constantly get caught in the backfield. we have a great O-Line, so i dont get it. my back should at least beat everyone to the sideline. i wouldnt even care if he just ran out of bounds, but he should beat everyone else to the sideline. he's not just a speed freak either. i built up his agility and vision before the season because of the rumors of the speed nerf, but still nothing.
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by markhehe
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by markhehe


Originally posted by Ken1



Originally posted by Greenday4537




What's wrong with the way it is? ALL WRs drop passes. This is a fact of life. If a team only has 3 dropped passes on one game, so what? That's not bad. If a team is all low levels, they should have a bunch of drops.

As for DBs reacting too quick, what else should they do? I've never just seen a DB just stand there while a WR runs past them. Fine, maybe decrease the chances for a dropped ball or a deflection, but make it so sometimes the QB passes are just completely off, so this way completion %s don't go sky high.


They were superhumanly quick.

I'm not against the drops. I (and others) are saying that just as receivers make mistakes and drop the ball, defenders should make mistakes and not recognize passes as quickly every time.

That's how football works. The inherent advantage in offense is that they know what they plan to do and the defense doesn't have any idea. That's why most first downs are converted in real life.

The running game has been brought up to realistic levels; the passing game needs to, as well.


the running game has NOT been brought up to realistic levels!!! its worse, if anything. when a back with 73 speed and 50 agility cant get outside, there is a problem. you cant get caught by a LB with 50 or 60 speed. the numbers have to mean something!!! if you have 73 speed(and enough agility to support that)then you should be able to beat everyone to the corner. if the CB makes the tackle, so be it. but, no-one should stop him from getting to the outside.


A team I watched and help with offense has a speed RB who got around the corner extremely well last game.

The problem you refer to (and even a little of the passing problems) has to do, though, with too-fast LB's because tackling was too easy, so they could just go for speed.

As they're forced to build tackling to stop power runners, they'll be weaker against speedy outside runners.


but when? thought that was already in effect. ill open my guy's build for a while, if you wanna see it. its frustrating to have a level 25 that you have spent a ton of bucks on, constantly get caught in the backfield. we have a great O-Line, so i dont get it. my back should at least beat everyone to the sideline. i wouldnt even care if he just ran out of bounds, but he should beat everyone else to the sideline. he's not just a speed freak either. i built up his agility and vision before the season because of the rumors of the speed nerf, but still nothing.



Here's your running back in action, doing exactly what you say the game isn't allowing:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78727&pbp_id=51144

Translation: My players and strategy are being dominated by other players and another strategy, therefor the game is broken.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Things I'm sick of: "My sims were okay. I'm smarter than you. You must have bad builds or bad play settings." We've provided a ton of evidence that it's not just a few games, but entire leagues with completion percentages in the 50% range.

That means something Bort changed had adversely affected the passing game. And from what most of us have seen who actually look at the game it appears like DB's are breaking on passes the instant the QB throws the ball and getting deflection after deflection.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 20:45:17
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Things I'm sick of: "My sims were okay. I'm smarter than you. You must have bad builds or bad play settings." We've provided a ton of evidence that it's not just a few games, but entire leagues with completion percentages in the 50% range.

That means something Bort changed had adversely affected the passing game. And from what most of us have seen who actually look at the game it appears like DB's are breaking on passes the instant the QB throws the ball and getting deflection after deflection.


is it that they are breaking on the ball quicker or is it that they are already so close to the wr that they dont have that far to go when then they break, i think it more noticeable when teams are playing tight coverage, the teams that are going vs zone or loose man coverage and say , everything is fine, works grat blah blah blah arent seeing the issue

sure u are going to get a catch here and there vs tight coverage but a db with 40 speed and 35 agil should not be able to cover a wr with 75 speed 65 agil in tight coverage thats the problem the wr should own him 7-10 times depending on the play call, and its not happening

and 76 65 is not a one dimensional build
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
The problem right now is that defenses can run tight coverage and limit the defense to 50% completions or less. One way or another the offense should be able to complete around 65% of their passes in an average game. If a team plays deep and lots of zone it'll be lots of underneath stuff, and if they play tight man then even if the percentages are low, then the offense should be burning them deep a few times.
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Things I'm sick of: "My sims were okay. I'm smarter than you. You must have bad builds or bad play settings." We've provided a ton of evidence that it's not just a few games, but entire leagues with completion percentages in the 50% range.

That means something Bort changed had adversely affected the passing game. And from what most of us have seen who actually look at the game it appears like DB's are breaking on passes the instant the QB throws the ball and getting deflection after deflection.


DBs broke instantly last season too. Bort's already changed the way passes are deflected back to they way it was last season.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Something else is still going on, but based on his comments Bort is working on it so I'm happy.
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
The problem right now is that defenses can run tight coverage and limit the defense to 50% completions or less. One way or another the offense should be able to complete around 65% of their passes in an average game. If a team plays deep and lots of zone it'll be lots of underneath stuff, and if they play tight man then even if the percentages are low, then the offense should be burning them deep a few times.



i agree, unless its a missed tackle, blown coverage or a jump ball where the wr comes back to the ball there are very few plays where the db gets beat deep while in tight coverage, regardless of lvl, or skill... which shouldn’t be the case

 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GenoBong
Originally posted by markhehe

Originally posted by Ken1


Originally posted by markhehe



Originally posted by Ken1




Originally posted by Greenday4537





What's wrong with the way it is? ALL WRs drop passes. This is a fact of life. If a team only has 3 dropped passes on one game, so what? That's not bad. If a team is all low levels, they should have a bunch of drops.

As for DBs reacting too quick, what else should they do? I've never just seen a DB just stand there while a WR runs past them. Fine, maybe decrease the chances for a dropped ball or a deflection, but make it so sometimes the QB passes are just completely off, so this way completion %s don't go sky high.


They were superhumanly quick.

I'm not against the drops. I (and others) are saying that just as receivers make mistakes and drop the ball, defenders should make mistakes and not recognize passes as quickly every time.

That's how football works. The inherent advantage in offense is that they know what they plan to do and the defense doesn't have any idea. That's why most first downs are converted in real life.

The running game has been brought up to realistic levels; the passing game needs to, as well.


the running game has NOT been brought up to realistic levels!!! its worse, if anything. when a back with 73 speed and 50 agility cant get outside, there is a problem. you cant get caught by a LB with 50 or 60 speed. the numbers have to mean something!!! if you have 73 speed(and enough agility to support that)then you should be able to beat everyone to the corner. if the CB makes the tackle, so be it. but, no-one should stop him from getting to the outside.


A team I watched and help with offense has a speed RB who got around the corner extremely well last game.

The problem you refer to (and even a little of the passing problems) has to do, though, with too-fast LB's because tackling was too easy, so they could just go for speed.

As they're forced to build tackling to stop power runners, they'll be weaker against speedy outside runners.


but when? thought that was already in effect. ill open my guy's build for a while, if you wanna see it. its frustrating to have a level 25 that you have spent a ton of bucks on, constantly get caught in the backfield. we have a great O-Line, so i dont get it. my back should at least beat everyone to the sideline. i wouldnt even care if he just ran out of bounds, but he should beat everyone else to the sideline. he's not just a speed freak either. i built up his agility and vision before the season because of the rumors of the speed nerf, but still nothing.



Here's your running back in action, doing exactly what you say the game isn't allowing:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78727&pbp_id=51144

Translation: My players and strategy are being dominated by other players and another strategy, therefor the game is broken.


not my HB DA. thats the power back thats the backup
 
Sledge
offline
Link
 



Last edited Aug 1, 2008 21:43:47
 
cptafw163
offline
Link
 
Well all our QBs are between levels 20-25 out of 100...so we all suck. All the defenders need to do is be in front
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.