User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Passing needs to be fixed in this game, very long post with a ton of research, don't discard as another whine post
Page:
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Another NFL example, the most lopsided rushing team in the history on modern NFL. 2006 Atlanta Falcons with Michael Vick 2682 passing yards 2939 rushing yards. They also went 7-9. That was a weird team on many levels, but that is going to be below normal if this sim goes live as is.

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
for someone who asked earlier about total yards.

4,067.5 passing take in account 1 team did have 0 yards passing
3,810 rushing take in account 3 teams had negative rushing yards.

About even, but in football passing is not even. There is a reason why the NFL career record for passing yards in THREE TIMES higher than career rushing yards. There is a reason why so few players rush for 2,000 yards, but there is always a couple of 4,000 yard passers in a season. In a normal game, passing earns twice as many yards as rushing. This game should be the same way.


Well, Bort had the right solution, which was to slow defenders' unbelievably good reaction times to passes, thus cutting down on deflections. I'm hoping he's still planning to do that. That's the big problem right now; defenders defend the pass unbelievably well.

But some people see this sort of thing and jump all over it and say passing is too easy, even if the stats don't fit their statement. They irritate the crap out of me, but they may have been successful in stopping Bort from implementing the great idea he had.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Fix the defenders mugging the WR's problem or implement PI penalties. Nerfing back defender vision wouldn't hurt either, but I thought the passing game worked pretty well last season. CB's playing tight man coverage got burnt deep occasionally, and QB's averaged 60-70% completion percentage in a close game.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TDmaker99
instead of trying to nerf multiple attributes on multiple positions, it would great if we could just go back to last season and let the wr's use their speed, the reason db's got burnt so bad last year is because 99% of teams had their db's set to play like glue " if u can " which means tight coverage and from time to time u will get beat in tight coverage, the seed nerf has screwed up the game imo

with the adv tactics u can now choose to play tight coverage and go to a cover 2 d where u have help over the top, that way the qb only has a small window to ht the wr before the s gets there

and no my player builds were not all based on speed, bit its obvious that the nerf has screwed up the wr's big time, at the very least dial the nerf back a bit and tell us and we'll all be ok


Screw that! No one dimensional players!

Last year's sim was horrible, yards per pass attempt were lower than this year's, and rushing was non-existent in close games.

And CB's were one dimensional speedsters, too. Even LBers were.

In fact, it's possible that much of the problem is that defenders are still built for last season and are super-fast and don't have good tackling, leading to them being better at defending passes than rushes.
 
Alex44
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TDmaker99
instead of trying to nerf multiple attributes on multiple positions, it would great if we could just go back to last season and let the wr's use their speed, the reason db's got burnt so bad last year is because 99% of teams had their db's set to play like glue " if u can " which means tight coverage and from time to time u will get beat in tight coverage, the seed nerf has screwed up the game imo

with the adv tactics u can now choose to play tight coverage and go to a cover 2 d where u have help over the top, that way the qb only has a small window to ht the wr before the s gets there

and no my player builds were not all based on speed, bit its obvious that the nerf has screwed up the wr's big time, at the very least dial the nerf back a bit and tell us and we'll all be ok


If it were the nerf it would have the same effect on the defensive players which would balance it anyway.


 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Fix the defenders mugging the WR's problem or implement PI penalties. Nerfing back defender vision wouldn't hurt either, but I thought the passing game worked pretty well last season. CB's playing tight man coverage got burnt deep occasionally, and QB's averaged 60-70% completion percentage in a close game.


Yards per pass attempt last season were about 2 yards below real life.

It's about the same this season, except I actually think that more teams are passing more realistically (i.e. better) in this sim than last season's.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
...
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 21:44:44
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Ken, all I know is that most of the teams I play on are among the best in their divisions, and we're seeing really low completion percentages suddenly this year. I understand emphasizing catching for WR's, agility for one-dimensional builds, and tackling for the defense, but the result so far as I see it is that most QB's are completing an abnormally low percentage of passes. And while Bort made an appearance in this thread, I've yet to see him show any concern about it. Surely he can run a database query and pull the overall completion percentages by leagues, and I'm sure what we'd see is that they're down quite a bit.

And I know that on my team at least the only WR we have that's close to one-dimensional is our slot WR who has 80spd/45agl. Otherwise my other WR have softcapped their agility and have 40+ catching. In a 62-0 blowout I had WR with 70spd/50agl/55catch being shut down by a lvl 13 SS out of position playing CB. Something is wrong there.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 21:52:51
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Alex44
Originally posted by TDmaker99

instead of trying to nerf multiple attributes on multiple positions, it would great if we could just go back to last season and let the wr's use their speed, the reason db's got burnt so bad last year is because 99% of teams had their db's set to play like glue " if u can " which means tight coverage and from time to time u will get beat in tight coverage, the seed nerf has screwed up the game imo

with the adv tactics u can now choose to play tight coverage and go to a cover 2 d where u have help over the top, that way the qb only has a small window to ht the wr before the s gets there

and no my player builds were not all based on speed, bit its obvious that the nerf has screwed up the wr's big time, at the very least dial the nerf back a bit and tell us and we'll all be ok


If it were the nerf it would have the same effect on the defensive players which would balance it anyway.




d players do not have as much speed as o do so they get nerfed less right, i mean no one said that db is too damn fast we need to nerf db's , you dont see many 80 speed 40 agil db's, atleast i dont

also im pretty sure that what the nerf did was cut down the acceleration hence the wr's cant get open = catching in trafic = more drops = more passes to the TE, which is what everyone is complaining about, it may not have been perfect but its better than what we have now, seriously where does this nerfing end, right now it has killed wr's so they will have to nerf db's next qb's ????

 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
There is no way you say the upgrade works. Another NFL example, two of the most successful rushing heavy teams ever, both super bowl champions, 2005 Steelers. 3104 passing yards, 2223 rushing yards 2000 Ravens 3102 passing yards 2,199 rushing yards.

No winning team in modern football has ever out rushed their passing game. It's not normal. Yes there was something wrong with cookie cutter builds, but having the game like it is is not football. Maybe high school football, but even the better high school teams I've seen are passing teams. The new sim is fubared

 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Ken, all I know is that most of the teams I play on are among the best in their divisions, and we're seeing really low completion percentages suddenly this year. I understand emphasizing catching for WR's, agility for one-dimensional builds, and tackling for the defense, but the result so far as I see it is that most QB's are completing an abnormally low percentage of passes. And while Bort made an appearance in this thread, I've yet to see him show any concern about it. Surely he can run a database query and pull the overall completion percentages by leagues, and I'm sure what we'd see is that they're down quite a bit.

And I know that on my team at least the only WR we have that's close to one-dimensional is our slot WR who has 80spd/45agl. Otherwise my other WR have softcapped their agility and have 40+ catching. In a 62-0 blowout I had WR with 70spd/50agl/55catch being shut down by a lvl 13 SS out of position playing CB. Something is wrong there.


correct when the db's can play tight coverage all game long and the qb has time, those db's should get beat a couple times deep, the nerf has screwed up passing like it or not

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Ken, all I know is that most of the teams I play on are among the best in their divisions, and we're seeing really low completion percentages suddenly this year. I understand emphasizing catching for WR's, agility for one-dimensional builds, and tackling for the defense, but the result so far as I see it is that most QB's are completing an abnormally low percentage of passes. And while Bort made an appearance in this thread, I've yet to see him show any concern about it. Surely he can run a database query and pull the overall completion percentages by leagues, and I'm sure what we'd see is that they're down quite a bit.

And I know that on my team at least the only WR we have that's close to one-dimensional is our slot WR who has 80spd/45agl. Otherwise my other WR have softcapped their agility and have 40+ catching. In a 62-0 blowout I had WR with 70spd/50agl/55catch being shut down by a lvl 13 SS out of position playing CB. Something is wrong there.


I'm not saying everything's perfect with passing. I'm just saying that it's no worse than last season, and probably a little better from the box scores I look at.

Last season, it was hard to get more than 5 yards per pass attempt, either. So if someone suggests going back to anything from the execrable Season 3, I'll yell and scream until I get a sore throat.

Again, Bort had the solution: a bit of a nerf to pass coverage. I thought it was going to happen, and maybe I'll post about it again, but it does have to be done in a measured way, and hopefully it would add a yard or so per pass attempt, the other yard or so that might be needed to mirror real life coming eventually as defenders have to improve their tackling, instead of spending all their points on pass coverage skills.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ilok
There is no way you say the upgrade works. Another NFL example, two of the most successful rushing heavy teams ever, both super bowl champions, 2005 Steelers. 3104 passing yards, 2223 rushing yards 2000 Ravens 3102 passing yards 2,199 rushing yards.

No winning team in modern football has ever out rushed their passing game. It's not normal. Yes there was something wrong with cookie cutter builds, but having the game like it is is not football. Maybe high school football, but even the better high school teams I've seen are passing teams. The new sim is fubared



Last season's sim wasn't football, either, to a much worse degree. It was purely defense-dominated.

Passing is about the same strength as last season, but rushing has improved. You're looking at rushing vs. passing and saying it's not working due to that. I'm concerned first with offense vs. defense, and last year defenses ruled and passing was no better. It's just that rushing was worse than now.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 22:06:50
 
Juan Fiddy
offline
Link
 
Copying this over here cuz it seems like a good place for it. Based on the OP, the comparison of avg yards is likely heavily skewed due to dump offs. My initial question was based on the check downs a QB makes through the receivers and if on TE intended plays the QB calls a check on the WRs before dumping off into the flats.

Basic Tactics call a 30% TE pass, which carries over into the Med Pass AI calls. This is not all of the HB dumps in this one game, there were 12 dump passes in the first half alone.

Originally posted by

1)
9:31 2nd & G OPP 6.5 Stoff el Ito pass to Tully Mars over the middle (incomplete)
40% TE Med, 20% WR Med, 40% Long
Short HB pass to the flats, Can't call this one, questionable no pressue...distance is to goal, applicable outputs are for 2nd >4 If 2& >4 does not apply blanket would be
20% FB Inside Run, 30% TE Med, 20% WR Short, 30% WR Med:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=80322&pbp_id=441764

2)
3:27 2nd & 9 OPP 46.5 Stoff el Ito pass to Tully Mars over the middle (3.5 yd gain) [tackle: Victor McGregor]
40% TE Med, 20% WR Med, 40% Long
HB Short pass flats, TE doubled up:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=80322&pbp_id=442367

3)
1:09 2nd & 9.5 OPP 36 Stoff el Ito pass to Premier Halfback up the right side (dropped - incomplete)
40% TE Med, 20% WR Med, 40% Long
HB pass in flats, Check down, TE has x2LB in range during check?:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=80322&pbp_id=442445

-----
12:38 2nd & 10 OWN 44.5 Throwin Deepbombs pass to Tully Mars over the middle (5.5 yd gain) [tackle: Brock Raum]
30% FB Short, 20% HB Short, 10% WR Short, 40% Med
HB short pass, (poss check down), WRs did not complete patterns:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=80322&pbp_id=442731

10:12 2nd & 6.5 OPP 40.5 Throwin Deepbombs pass to Premier Halfback up the left side (dropped - incomplete)
30% FB Short, 20% HB Short, 10% WR Short, 40% Med
HB pass flats left inc (poss check down):
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=80322&pbp_id=442983

5:50 2nd & 5.5 OWN 14 Throwin Deepbombs pass to Premier Halfback over the middle [missed tackle: Jane Skinner] (1 yd gain) [tackle: Stella Artois]
30% FB Short, 20% HB Short, 10% WR Short, 40% Med
HB short, quick release (I beleive this was intended):
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=80322&pbp_id=443436

2:00 2nd & 2.5 OWN 48.5 Stoff el Ito pass to Tully Mars up the left side (no gain) [tackle: Jerry Jiglo]
30% FB Short, 20% HB Short, 10% WR Short, 40% Med
HB Flats left, can't call this one cover is close:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=80322&pbp_id=443768

*****now thats 4 HB passes on consecutive 2nd downs, actual play is a 20% call*****

Alot of the coverage is very tight, esp on the TE. Some of these plays have valid WR targets though. The notes are just internal forum stuff but apply to a degree so I'm leaving em in.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=80322
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
No way passing is the same strength as last season. All of the numbers I posted say it's down. Completion percentage needs to go up and yac needs to go up a little and we'll be much more realistic compared to NFL type numbers. The problem last year with the passing game was you'd pass for 250 yards and 230 of them would be actual in the air passing yards and 20 yards would be yac. WR's caught the ball and were immediately tackled.

This year they're not completing passes at all. Some teams are seeing some long TD runs when a CB misses a tackle, but overall I'm just seeing CB's own WR's. And if you trust the dots a lot of that seems to be illegal contact.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.