Also of note, when injuries are implimented, that will help, albeit slightly, in the fight against farm teams.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Does GLB almost necessitate farm teams (discussion)?
Originally posted by ewinter43
Originally posted by thehazyone
. Of course people will still think 3 teams and 40+ players is "cheating" but I don't really care... it's my money and I can spend it how I want to.
yes you can argue that. it is your money- a ridiculous amount, but yours nonetheless. i liken that response to a kid on the playground screaming, "im taking my ball and going home!". just a little childish.
It's not that ridiculous. I've spent less than $200. I go off on weekend trips that cost much more than that. It's not childish, I'm just tired of people complaining about owners/players like me as if we are ruining the game. What sense does it make to limit how much a person can spend in their enjoyment of a game? Everyone has their own perspective... let people do as they want and quit trying to force rules and limitations down people's throats.
I'm all for fair play and doing things the right way (and I think all of the players on my teams will tell you I go above and beyond what they would expect from an owner) but really all the threads here at GLB mount to whines about what so and so is getting or not getting. The few constructive suggestions and critiques that are posted get buried in the drama.
Maybe I'll just go back in my corner now, but none of my teams made the playoffs (it took me a while to figure this game out) so I'm killing time reading these forums now.
Originally posted by thehazyone
. Of course people will still think 3 teams and 40+ players is "cheating" but I don't really care... it's my money and I can spend it how I want to.
yes you can argue that. it is your money- a ridiculous amount, but yours nonetheless. i liken that response to a kid on the playground screaming, "im taking my ball and going home!". just a little childish.
It's not that ridiculous. I've spent less than $200. I go off on weekend trips that cost much more than that. It's not childish, I'm just tired of people complaining about owners/players like me as if we are ruining the game. What sense does it make to limit how much a person can spend in their enjoyment of a game? Everyone has their own perspective... let people do as they want and quit trying to force rules and limitations down people's throats.
I'm all for fair play and doing things the right way (and I think all of the players on my teams will tell you I go above and beyond what they would expect from an owner) but really all the threads here at GLB mount to whines about what so and so is getting or not getting. The few constructive suggestions and critiques that are posted get buried in the drama.
Maybe I'll just go back in my corner now, but none of my teams made the playoffs (it took me a while to figure this game out) so I'm killing time reading these forums now.
drkbgrk
offline
offline
farm teams (colluding) are cheating and will be result in bans, just to frame this debate in here.
"If you perform a series of trades with the express purpose of depleting one team to build up another, your team could be fined or taken away."
and
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=30182&page=7
This thread asked a slightly different question.
No, was the answer.
"If you perform a series of trades with the express purpose of depleting one team to build up another, your team could be fined or taken away."
and
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=30182&page=7
This thread asked a slightly different question.
No, was the answer.
cajik
offline
offline
Originally posted by drkbgrk
Originally posted by cajik
What if a farm team is a legitimate team that is trying to win and develop players for a higher level team at the same time?
This is not the type of farm team where every player plays 2-way and 90+ snaps a game, but a legitimate, realistic, feeder team.
All of GLB performs the needed functions of a real world farm system in that the larger number of lower leagues develop players faster than the USA pro league could without them. Player experience is, after all, a limited commodity.
There is, however, no need to have "farm teams" collude with another team.
The lower leagues in GLB are not owned by a corporate association for the purpose of producing a marketable, televisable product like MLB or D-league NBA.
The lower leagues are their own marketable product. Independent owners of lower teams are participating in leagues just as competitively as independent owners in the higher leagues.
The sifting of two teams up and down each season will produce the hierarchy which gives competitive substance to the league ranking structure.
The term "farm team" as used in this debate is really referring to collusion between two teams which should be independent competitive agents in their respective leagues.
Instead of having players on teams competing to win championships and get promoted to the next league, or even having players trying to stand out and get bigger contracts in better programs, we have leagues of half-teams playing for maximum PT instead of playing to win.
Those teams are then gutted, destroying any identity they had within their own conference. Regular season stats, awards, championships, season records, ratings, standings, competition, fun, etc... The all become devalued.
The more collusive teams there are, the worse the problems become.
The less collusion there is, the better GLB will play.
No collusion would be the best.
Yes there is an endless supply for higher level teams to pick up promising players from the lower league teams. But it would be beneficial for a big team to have a direct link to a well-run feeder team that is a hotbed for developing talent.
In baseball, the minor league system is funded by the major league teams. The hot prospects are paid by the affiliated major league team, and they have control of what team they play for. They would want the player to develop with a lower league team and slowly move their way up to one day earn a spot on the big league team.
A similar concept exists in European soccer. A lot of big teams have ties to smaller feeder clubs where they have loaner agreements, first options, etc. Young players can be sent to the feeder team to gain valuable experience while remaining under control of the big team. Also if the feeder team signs a player on its own and receives a trade offer and accepts it from another team, the first option would allow the parent club to offer the same deal which must be accepted. It is then up to the player to choose where he wants to go.
I think in a few seasons, it will be difficult for new teams to move their way up without having some help from some of the big teams. They can develop their players, but if the team doesn't get all the breaks and wins promotion year after year, I think a lot of those players will eventually look to move to a higher tiered team. Especially if the feature where game XP may also be based on the quality of your opponent. If they could loan backup players from their parent club, they would have an easier time of growing the team.
Originally posted by cajik
What if a farm team is a legitimate team that is trying to win and develop players for a higher level team at the same time?
This is not the type of farm team where every player plays 2-way and 90+ snaps a game, but a legitimate, realistic, feeder team.
All of GLB performs the needed functions of a real world farm system in that the larger number of lower leagues develop players faster than the USA pro league could without them. Player experience is, after all, a limited commodity.
There is, however, no need to have "farm teams" collude with another team.
The lower leagues in GLB are not owned by a corporate association for the purpose of producing a marketable, televisable product like MLB or D-league NBA.
The lower leagues are their own marketable product. Independent owners of lower teams are participating in leagues just as competitively as independent owners in the higher leagues.
The sifting of two teams up and down each season will produce the hierarchy which gives competitive substance to the league ranking structure.
The term "farm team" as used in this debate is really referring to collusion between two teams which should be independent competitive agents in their respective leagues.
Instead of having players on teams competing to win championships and get promoted to the next league, or even having players trying to stand out and get bigger contracts in better programs, we have leagues of half-teams playing for maximum PT instead of playing to win.
Those teams are then gutted, destroying any identity they had within their own conference. Regular season stats, awards, championships, season records, ratings, standings, competition, fun, etc... The all become devalued.
The more collusive teams there are, the worse the problems become.
The less collusion there is, the better GLB will play.
No collusion would be the best.
Yes there is an endless supply for higher level teams to pick up promising players from the lower league teams. But it would be beneficial for a big team to have a direct link to a well-run feeder team that is a hotbed for developing talent.
In baseball, the minor league system is funded by the major league teams. The hot prospects are paid by the affiliated major league team, and they have control of what team they play for. They would want the player to develop with a lower league team and slowly move their way up to one day earn a spot on the big league team.
A similar concept exists in European soccer. A lot of big teams have ties to smaller feeder clubs where they have loaner agreements, first options, etc. Young players can be sent to the feeder team to gain valuable experience while remaining under control of the big team. Also if the feeder team signs a player on its own and receives a trade offer and accepts it from another team, the first option would allow the parent club to offer the same deal which must be accepted. It is then up to the player to choose where he wants to go.
I think in a few seasons, it will be difficult for new teams to move their way up without having some help from some of the big teams. They can develop their players, but if the team doesn't get all the breaks and wins promotion year after year, I think a lot of those players will eventually look to move to a higher tiered team. Especially if the feature where game XP may also be based on the quality of your opponent. If they could loan backup players from their parent club, they would have an easier time of growing the team.
Malachorn
offline
offline
Originally posted by PinTBC
Just because you choose to not give your backups any playing time, why would you suddenly change that method of operating during the playoffs? There are no injuries, and players will play for 10 seasons before topping out, so why would a team that only plays its starters ever need more players?
Because your team actually will play better if your guys are allowed to rest during a game. The benefit getting rest during a game might be outweighed during the regular season, but in the playoffs you just need to win. That means a team with decent depth is going to have an advantage.
...It's all about the advantage.
Just because you choose to not give your backups any playing time, why would you suddenly change that method of operating during the playoffs? There are no injuries, and players will play for 10 seasons before topping out, so why would a team that only plays its starters ever need more players?
Because your team actually will play better if your guys are allowed to rest during a game. The benefit getting rest during a game might be outweighed during the regular season, but in the playoffs you just need to win. That means a team with decent depth is going to have an advantage.
...It's all about the advantage.
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
thehazyone,
Originally posted by
What sense does it make to limit how much a person can spend in their enjoyment of a game?
As covered in my other post, it makes perfect sense. This isn't a single player game, it's an MMO, so balance trumps individuals.
Originally posted by
What sense does it make to limit how much a person can spend in their enjoyment of a game?
As covered in my other post, it makes perfect sense. This isn't a single player game, it's an MMO, so balance trumps individuals.
I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.
Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).
Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.
Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.
Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).
Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.
Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by
I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.
Wow, this will be great.
Originally posted by
Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).
Again great.
Great fixes here Devs, this should def. help break up the "farm system".
I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.
Wow, this will be great.
Originally posted by
Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).
Again great.
Great fixes here Devs, this should def. help break up the "farm system".
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by
maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure
I assume this means that you'll be doing a total pyramid thing? Damn
maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure
I assume this means that you'll be doing a total pyramid thing? Damn
I've played other MMO's and it's always been a time/money investment thing in those too. I fail to see the difference here.
That being said, I'm not opposed to team/player limitations as long as they are realistic and don't completely curtail my ability to do things within the game that I want to do (i.e. test things out with new builds without having to retire 5 players to do so).
I could live with a no more than 5-10 of your own players on a team limitation. As it is, I pretty much do that now. Almost all of my starters are players that are not my own.
I understand the smaller player's perspective either. If I was someone who didn't have $200 to throw into the game, I would be frustrated by someone like me. That's why I could understand and agree to realistic and fair limitations. I'm not trying to be a bully, I'm just having fun right now and doing what they let me do. If they change it, I'll change with it. I'm not going anywhere, this game is much too fun and the people I've met are much too fun.
That being said, I'm not opposed to team/player limitations as long as they are realistic and don't completely curtail my ability to do things within the game that I want to do (i.e. test things out with new builds without having to retire 5 players to do so).
I could live with a no more than 5-10 of your own players on a team limitation. As it is, I pretty much do that now. Almost all of my starters are players that are not my own.
I understand the smaller player's perspective either. If I was someone who didn't have $200 to throw into the game, I would be frustrated by someone like me. That's why I could understand and agree to realistic and fair limitations. I'm not trying to be a bully, I'm just having fun right now and doing what they let me do. If they change it, I'll change with it. I'm not going anywhere, this game is much too fun and the people I've met are much too fun.
Originally posted by Bort
I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.
Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).
Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.
Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.
LOVE the team chemistry idea, but Bort... what's to stop someone from having 22 of their own players sticking together and building the highest possible chemistry rating?
I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.
Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).
Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.
Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.
LOVE the team chemistry idea, but Bort... what's to stop someone from having 22 of their own players sticking together and building the highest possible chemistry rating?
Vanilla Thunder
offline
offline
Originally posted by
I've played other MMO's and it's always been a time/money investment thing in those too. I fail to see the difference here.
This game is zero-sum, that means that when you win, someone must lose. Other MMOs (warcraft, etc) are not zero-sum, and therefor are more open.
You (meaning the Admins) must carefully maintain balance, as helping you to hurt the majority of the players kills the game.
I've played other MMO's and it's always been a time/money investment thing in those too. I fail to see the difference here.
This game is zero-sum, that means that when you win, someone must lose. Other MMOs (warcraft, etc) are not zero-sum, and therefor are more open.
You (meaning the Admins) must carefully maintain balance, as helping you to hurt the majority of the players kills the game.
Originally posted by thehazyone
Originally posted by Bort
I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.
Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).
Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.
Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.
LOVE the team chemistry idea, but Bort... what's to stop someone from having 22 of their own players sticking together and building the highest possible chemistry rating?
Nothing is stopping them I guess, unless we decide on a max players on your own team rule or something, which I'm not a huge fan of.
Originally posted by Bort
I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.
Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).
Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.
Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.
LOVE the team chemistry idea, but Bort... what's to stop someone from having 22 of their own players sticking together and building the highest possible chemistry rating?
Nothing is stopping them I guess, unless we decide on a max players on your own team rule or something, which I'm not a huge fan of.
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by
maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure
I assume this means that you'll be doing a total pyramid thing? Damn
Pyramids per region. Yes, it's official (minus the announcement).
We have an idea for a short world tourney, too, to help tie everyone together. We'll announce that after we figure it out more. But those are both off-topic for this thread.
Originally posted by
maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure
I assume this means that you'll be doing a total pyramid thing? Damn
Pyramids per region. Yes, it's official (minus the announcement).
We have an idea for a short world tourney, too, to help tie everyone together. We'll announce that after we figure it out more. But those are both off-topic for this thread.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thehazyone
Originally posted by Bort
I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.
Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).
Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.
Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.
LOVE the team chemistry idea, but Bort... what's to stop someone from having 22 of their own players sticking together and building the highest possible chemistry rating?
Nothing is stopping them I guess, unless we decide on a max players on your own team rule or something, which I'm not a huge fan of.
Nor am I, but you know it's going to happen and people are going to complain about it.
Originally posted by thehazyone
Originally posted by Bort
I think the addition of salary caps and TEAM CHEMISTRY will help quite a bit with collusion, along with an earlier trade deadline, etc.
Salary caps will mean you can't stack your team with too many high level players (especially since there are minimum salaries based on level).
Team chemistry will mean that you have to keep a squad together for a while to keep them competitive. If you bring in too much new blood all at once, you'll hurt your team chemistry and your team will suck.
Also, we're discussing the idea of maybe having a designated "farm league" where the teams would not promote/relegate (maybe the 16-league level of the pyramid structure?). That on its own wouldn't keep two teams owned by two players from combining forces in an "unfair" way, however. Maybe the other stuff would cover that.
LOVE the team chemistry idea, but Bort... what's to stop someone from having 22 of their own players sticking together and building the highest possible chemistry rating?
Nothing is stopping them I guess, unless we decide on a max players on your own team rule or something, which I'm not a huge fan of.
Nor am I, but you know it's going to happen and people are going to complain about it.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























