I really, really disagree with this change. I don't want my run stopping LOLB on the field in nickel sets! The ROLB should be a pass coverage guy, and now he is riding the pine on passing plays! How is this logical?
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > LOLB still playing in Nickel Back formations
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rayn21
I really, really disagree with this change. I don't want my run stopping LOLB on the field in nickel sets! The ROLB should be a pass coverage guy, and now he is riding the pine on passing plays! How is this logical?
Well, truth is, the LOLB should be good in coverage. Even more so then run stopping, it could be argued.
I think the best solution is letting the choice be made on each play.
Like I mentioned before, the biggest drawback to this change is the fact no one will want to play ROLB anymore. There's exactly zero benefit to it, especially in a 4-3 defense.
I really, really disagree with this change. I don't want my run stopping LOLB on the field in nickel sets! The ROLB should be a pass coverage guy, and now he is riding the pine on passing plays! How is this logical?
Well, truth is, the LOLB should be good in coverage. Even more so then run stopping, it could be argued.
I think the best solution is letting the choice be made on each play.
Like I mentioned before, the biggest drawback to this change is the fact no one will want to play ROLB anymore. There's exactly zero benefit to it, especially in a 4-3 defense.
slipknottin
offline
offline
Originally posted by DLight03
ROLB is generally your best blitzing linebacker.
LOLB is generally your best coverage linebacker (because he has to deal with the TE).
You have it backwards. The LOLB (strong side LB) is generally the best pass rusher, and the biggest strongest guy. He has to shed blocks from the TE/FB to get to the HB, and generally is good at jamming the TE and not letting him off the line. The weakside backer (rolb) is smaller and quicker, his job is to chase down running plays away from him, and cover the HB/FB when they go out into pass coverage.
In the NFL just about every team pulls the LOLB off the field when they go to nickel or dime. Bears for instance take Hillenmeyer off the field, Packers take Poppinga off the field. The weakside backer is almost always better in coverage.
ROLB is generally your best blitzing linebacker.
LOLB is generally your best coverage linebacker (because he has to deal with the TE).
You have it backwards. The LOLB (strong side LB) is generally the best pass rusher, and the biggest strongest guy. He has to shed blocks from the TE/FB to get to the HB, and generally is good at jamming the TE and not letting him off the line. The weakside backer (rolb) is smaller and quicker, his job is to chase down running plays away from him, and cover the HB/FB when they go out into pass coverage.
In the NFL just about every team pulls the LOLB off the field when they go to nickel or dime. Bears for instance take Hillenmeyer off the field, Packers take Poppinga off the field. The weakside backer is almost always better in coverage.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 10:25:24
slipknottin
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
Well, truth is, the LOLB should be good in coverage. Even more so then run stopping, it could be argued.
Not in the NFL. The primary job of every SLB in the NFL is to stop the run.
Well, truth is, the LOLB should be good in coverage. Even more so then run stopping, it could be argued.
Not in the NFL. The primary job of every SLB in the NFL is to stop the run.
DLight03
offline
offline
Originally posted by slipknottin
Originally posted by DLight03
ROLB is generally your best blitzing linebacker.
LOLB is generally your best coverage linebacker (because he has to deal with the TE).
You have it backwards. The LOLB (strong side LB) is generally the best pass rusher, and the biggest strongest guy. He has to shed blocks from the TE/FB to get to the HB, and generally is good at jamming the TE and not letting him off the line. The weakside backer (rolb) is smaller and quicker, his job is to chase down running plays away from him, and cover the HB/FB when they go out into pass coverage.
In the NFL just about every team pulls the LOLB off the field when they go to nickel or dime. Bears for instance take Hillenmeyer off the field, Packers take Poppinga off the field. The weakside backer is almost always better in coverage.
Your best pass rusher would be the player on the weakside (in this game, ROLB). This is because 1. You can attack the QBs blindside and 2, you don't have to deal with the TE.
There is no legitimate strongside and weakside linebacker in this game, because they do not follow the TE. Instead, ROLB lines up on the right, LOLB on the left. ROLB has an easier time getting to the QB, because he deals with less people, and it's the QBs blindside. What you're saying is right about LOLB going off the field, but LBs don't play weakside and strongside here, they simply play left and right, they don't line up in accordance to the TE, like traditionally strongside linebackers would do. I think if you wanted to argue that ROLB is a better at coverage than LOLB, you can, but ROLB is really the blitzing linebacker, not LOLB.
Originally posted by DLight03
ROLB is generally your best blitzing linebacker.
LOLB is generally your best coverage linebacker (because he has to deal with the TE).
You have it backwards. The LOLB (strong side LB) is generally the best pass rusher, and the biggest strongest guy. He has to shed blocks from the TE/FB to get to the HB, and generally is good at jamming the TE and not letting him off the line. The weakside backer (rolb) is smaller and quicker, his job is to chase down running plays away from him, and cover the HB/FB when they go out into pass coverage.
In the NFL just about every team pulls the LOLB off the field when they go to nickel or dime. Bears for instance take Hillenmeyer off the field, Packers take Poppinga off the field. The weakside backer is almost always better in coverage.
Your best pass rusher would be the player on the weakside (in this game, ROLB). This is because 1. You can attack the QBs blindside and 2, you don't have to deal with the TE.
There is no legitimate strongside and weakside linebacker in this game, because they do not follow the TE. Instead, ROLB lines up on the right, LOLB on the left. ROLB has an easier time getting to the QB, because he deals with less people, and it's the QBs blindside. What you're saying is right about LOLB going off the field, but LBs don't play weakside and strongside here, they simply play left and right, they don't line up in accordance to the TE, like traditionally strongside linebackers would do. I think if you wanted to argue that ROLB is a better at coverage than LOLB, you can, but ROLB is really the blitzing linebacker, not LOLB.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 10:35:19
slipknottin
offline
offline
Originally posted by DLight03
Your best pass rusher would be the player on the weakside (in this game, ROLB). This is because 1. You can attack the QBs blindside and 2, you don't have to deal with the TE.
In a 3-4. Not true in a 4-3. The difference is in a 3-4 you have an additional ILB to cover the TE/back. That weakside backer can be more of a pass rusher and less of a cover guy. In a 4-3 its completely different.
Originally posted by
There is no legitimate strongside and weakside linebacker in this game, because they do not follow the TE.
Right and theres no such thing as FS or SS either. Lots of coaches still refer to them as strong and weak backers.
Your best pass rusher would be the player on the weakside (in this game, ROLB). This is because 1. You can attack the QBs blindside and 2, you don't have to deal with the TE.
In a 3-4. Not true in a 4-3. The difference is in a 3-4 you have an additional ILB to cover the TE/back. That weakside backer can be more of a pass rusher and less of a cover guy. In a 4-3 its completely different.
Originally posted by
There is no legitimate strongside and weakside linebacker in this game, because they do not follow the TE.
Right and theres no such thing as FS or SS either. Lots of coaches still refer to them as strong and weak backers.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 10:35:09
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by slipknottin
Originally posted by DLight03
ROLB is generally your best blitzing linebacker.
LOLB is generally your best coverage linebacker (because he has to deal with the TE).
You have it backwards. The LOLB (strong side LB) is generally the best pass rusher, and the biggest strongest guy. He has to shed blocks from the TE/FB to get to the HB, and generally is good at jamming the TE and not letting him off the line. The weakside backer (rolb) is smaller and quicker, his job is to chase down running plays away from him, and cover the HB/FB when they go out into pass coverage.
Dude, you couldn't be more wrong about this. You should know better. Lawrence Taylor, the best pass rushing LB of all time, was a WILL.
edit: I just noticed your last post. The Giants did use a 3-4, so this reconciles your other post.
Originally posted by DLight03
ROLB is generally your best blitzing linebacker.
LOLB is generally your best coverage linebacker (because he has to deal with the TE).
You have it backwards. The LOLB (strong side LB) is generally the best pass rusher, and the biggest strongest guy. He has to shed blocks from the TE/FB to get to the HB, and generally is good at jamming the TE and not letting him off the line. The weakside backer (rolb) is smaller and quicker, his job is to chase down running plays away from him, and cover the HB/FB when they go out into pass coverage.
Dude, you couldn't be more wrong about this. You should know better. Lawrence Taylor, the best pass rushing LB of all time, was a WILL.
edit: I just noticed your last post. The Giants did use a 3-4, so this reconciles your other post.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 10:44:33
slipknottin
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
Dude, you couldn't be more wrong about this. You should know better. Lawrence Taylor, the best pass rushing LB of all time, was a WILL.
In a 3-4. Nickel/dime formations dont use a 3-4. In those situations you move the LB up to play DE like Dallas does with Ware.
Dude, you couldn't be more wrong about this. You should know better. Lawrence Taylor, the best pass rushing LB of all time, was a WILL.
In a 3-4. Nickel/dime formations dont use a 3-4. In those situations you move the LB up to play DE like Dallas does with Ware.
Rayn21
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
Like I mentioned before, the biggest drawback to this change is the fact no one will want to play ROLB anymore. There's exactly zero benefit to it, especially in a 4-3 defense.No joke, now you are on the side of the field with barely any action AND you get to sit out half the game..... What is the point?
Like I mentioned before, the biggest drawback to this change is the fact no one will want to play ROLB anymore. There's exactly zero benefit to it, especially in a 4-3 defense.No joke, now you are on the side of the field with barely any action AND you get to sit out half the game..... What is the point?
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by slipknottin
Originally posted by islander1
Dude, you couldn't be more wrong about this. You should know better. Lawrence Taylor, the best pass rushing LB of all time, was a WILL.
In a 3-4. Nickel/dime formations dont use a 3-4. In those situations you move the LB up to play DE like Dallas does with Ware.
In the dime, perhaps.
Nickel 3-4 uses 3 linebackers though.
Originally posted by islander1
Dude, you couldn't be more wrong about this. You should know better. Lawrence Taylor, the best pass rushing LB of all time, was a WILL.
In a 3-4. Nickel/dime formations dont use a 3-4. In those situations you move the LB up to play DE like Dallas does with Ware.
In the dime, perhaps.
Nickel 3-4 uses 3 linebackers though.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rayn21
Originally posted by islander1
Like I mentioned before, the biggest drawback to this change is the fact no one will want to play ROLB anymore. There's exactly zero benefit to it, especially in a 4-3 defense.No joke, now you are on the side of the field with barely any action AND you get to sit out half the game..... What is the point?
it's a shame the offensive AI doesn't allow teams to choose a weak side play versus a strong side play specifically.
I don't know how that was ever left out of the interface. A simple additional dropdown - strong side/weak side would have sufficed.
Originally posted by islander1
Like I mentioned before, the biggest drawback to this change is the fact no one will want to play ROLB anymore. There's exactly zero benefit to it, especially in a 4-3 defense.No joke, now you are on the side of the field with barely any action AND you get to sit out half the game..... What is the point?
it's a shame the offensive AI doesn't allow teams to choose a weak side play versus a strong side play specifically.
I don't know how that was ever left out of the interface. A simple additional dropdown - strong side/weak side would have sufficed.
slipknottin
offline
offline
Originally posted by islander1
Nickel 3-4 uses 3 linebackers though.
It really depends on your personel and how you want to use them. Patriots move there LBs and DEs around, Seymour goes to DT, Thomas goes to DE.
This entire issue could be fixed if we had a substitution option for different formations. Then that ROLB if hes a great pass rusher can just move to DE.
Nickel 3-4 uses 3 linebackers though.
It really depends on your personel and how you want to use them. Patriots move there LBs and DEs around, Seymour goes to DT, Thomas goes to DE.
This entire issue could be fixed if we had a substitution option for different formations. Then that ROLB if hes a great pass rusher can just move to DE.
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by slipknottin
Originally posted by islander1
Nickel 3-4 uses 3 linebackers though.
It really depends on your personel and how you want to use them. Patriots move there LBs and DEs around, Seymour goes to DT, Thomas goes to DE.
This entire issue could be fixed if we had a substitution option for different formations. Then that ROLB if hes a great pass rusher can just move to DE.
completely agree. Right now though, I'd be happy with the simple option of choosing who to sub out in the nickel and dime formations.

Originally posted by islander1
Nickel 3-4 uses 3 linebackers though.
It really depends on your personel and how you want to use them. Patriots move there LBs and DEs around, Seymour goes to DT, Thomas goes to DE.
This entire issue could be fixed if we had a substitution option for different formations. Then that ROLB if hes a great pass rusher can just move to DE.
completely agree. Right now though, I'd be happy with the simple option of choosing who to sub out in the nickel and dime formations.

Randy03Texags
offline
offline
Yes, I would be really happy the way NCAA and Madden have it, where you can assign who is at what position in "Formation Subs" somehow.
Because right now our MLB is on the field in dime and I dont want that. I also dont want my LOLB as MLB somehow in sets .. there was a play the last sim game where the LOLB was lined up as the MLB and the MLB was lined up as LOLB and over the TE in a clear passing situation. I hate that!
That didnt happen last season.
Because right now our MLB is on the field in dime and I dont want that. I also dont want my LOLB as MLB somehow in sets .. there was a play the last sim game where the LOLB was lined up as the MLB and the MLB was lined up as LOLB and over the TE in a clear passing situation. I hate that!
That didnt happen last season.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























