User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bort here is my Report from the 7/31/08 early game sims
Page:
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by DLight03

My LB has 26 tackling, 26 strength. Most the LBs on my team have the same thing. We only missed two tackles (1 by a CB).

As long as your player is filled out in other important tackle-relative attributes, I don't think it's going to be a problem.


The idea of nerfing wrap up was to encourage the defense to get higher tackling numbers and making tackles less a given thing but more a probable thing.



The idea of nerfing wrap up was to punish highly excessive speed builds, most of which were stuffing the running game with few support skills.

If I have a LB with high agility/vision/confidence/jumping and adequately maintain strength and tackling, I should be tackling well just like I am.

If you just have a bunch of speed however and neglect vision, agility, or another key attribute while not pumping strength or tackling, then you should certainly miss tackles.

Tackling and Strength are not the only attributes that have to do with tackling. There are many other attributes involved in successfully making a tackle.

So to say it's wrong that a LB with sub-30 tackling and strength is making tackles, isn't really understanding just how much goes into making a tackle on any-given play imo...

It could have been that one game however, and maybe tackling/strength will need to be scaled up more. Obviously one game isn't a great sample size.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 11:36:50
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DLight03
The idea of nerfing wrap up was to punish highly excessive speed builds.

If I have a LB with high agility/vision/confidence/jumping and adequately maintain strength and tackling, I should be tackling well just like I am.

If you just have a bunch of speed however and neglect vision, agility, or another key attribute while not pumping strength or tackling, then you should certainly miss tackles.

Tackling and Strength are not the only attributes that have to do with tackling. There are many other attributes involved in successfully making a tackle.

So to say it's wrong that a LB with sub-30 tackling and strength is making tackles, isn't really understanding just how much goes into making a tackle on any-given play.


Now since my safeties rely on crushing into the ball carrier at high speed (to make up the lower tackling number) while taking the perfect angle (vision/agility) - I sure know.

But I like to question: Isn't that exactly how it shouldn't be?

Should a FS or CB at 15 strenght, 25 tackling be able to tackle a powerback of 70 strength, 50 carrying at decent speed?

I'd say no!

Even a well build run stopper should miss out a decent number of tackles on such a ball carrier - but a pass coverage LB should miss more and rarely stop the run.

I kind of like the idea of "can't have everything". So either you should sacrifice additional speed/agility/jumping (whatever...) to raise tackling to 40 - 50 OR you should miss out a decent number of tackles. It should be about what you gain and what you give.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 11:38:58
 
lawdog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MRIGUY


No bugs huh...What happened to the FS on this play. Did he see a cheerleader he was interested in?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=82436&pbp_id=414350


That's just really bad agility.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by itsme4

if FB's were half as effective in real life

as they are now on GLB

they would be the highest paid position in the game



SERIOUSLY CHANGE HOW EASY IT IS FOR POWER RUSHERS TO BREAK TACKLES...THAT SHIT IS NOT EVEN CLOSE TO REALISTIC


Keep it for now.

If defenses in real life had 30 tackling (= can hardly tackle at all), you'd see tons of broken tackles every play.

Seriously: do the tacklers provide serious strength/tackling/agility numbers - like 40+/40+/40+? If not... their tackles should be broken by power rushers a lot!

Changes need to be made to player builds; everyone knew at the end of season 3.


+1
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by DLight03

The idea of nerfing wrap up was to punish highly excessive speed builds.

If I have a LB with high agility/vision/confidence/jumping and adequately maintain strength and tackling, I should be tackling well just like I am.

If you just have a bunch of speed however and neglect vision, agility, or another key attribute while not pumping strength or tackling, then you should certainly miss tackles.

Tackling and Strength are not the only attributes that have to do with tackling. There are many other attributes involved in successfully making a tackle.

So to say it's wrong that a LB with sub-30 tackling and strength is making tackles, isn't really understanding just how much goes into making a tackle on any-given play.


Now since my safeties rely on crushing into the ball carrier at high speed (to make up the lower tackling number) while taking the perfect angle (vision/agility) - I sure know.

But I like to question: Isn't that exactly how it shouldn't be?

Should a FS or CB at 15 strenght, 25 tackling be able to tackle a powerback of 70 strength, 50 carrying at decent speed?

I'd say no!

Even a well build run stopper should miss out a decent number of tackles on such a ball carrier - but a pass coverage LB should miss more and rarely stop the run.

I kind of like the idea of "can't have everything". So either you should sacrifice additional speed/agility/jumping (whatever...) to raise tackling to 40 - 50 OR you should miss out a decent number of tackles. It should be about what you gain and what you give.


That trade-off already exists.

Pass coverage LB will miss more tackles against power backs than he will against elusive backs. A FS with 15 strength and 26 tackling will miss a LOT more tackles on a good power back than a good elusive back. You just don't notice it because the FS doesn't tackle power players very often. I can assure you if you put a FS with those stats at LB and made him tackle a power back, he'd lead the team in missed tackles easily. If Durant had to tackle a power back often, he would miss more tackles as well. It just so happens that I believe as an OLB, you are faced against weaker players in general (WRs, elusive backs which excel on the outside), so I don't consider it necessary unless there's a serious increase in the amount of power backs, particularly power backs that run to the outside.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 12:42:04
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
There are still some problems with types of builds in certain situations, we all know that.

But Todays sims were a lot better than the last few days, and they were better than all of last season.

Changes have happened and we need to adapt.

Well done on the fixes Bort.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB

I kind of like the idea of "can't have everything". So either you should sacrifice additional speed/agility/jumping (whatever...) to raise tackling to 40 - 50 OR you should miss out a decent number of tackles. It should be about what you gain and what you give.


+100,000!
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
There are still some problems with types of builds in certain situations, we all know that.

But Todays sims were a lot better than the last few days, and they were better than all of last season.

Changes have happened and we need to adapt.

Well done on the fixes Bort.



Well said.
 
lrunkle911
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
There are still some problems with types of builds in certain situations, we all know that.

But Todays sims were a lot better than the last few days, and they were better than all of last season.

Changes have happened and we need to adapt.

Well done on the fixes Bort.


looking forward to today and tomorrow (most my games are tomorow and 1 tonight).

way to go Bort and team on working so hard to get these new additions ready for the season. it is a lot of stuff added. (and I want more lol)

quite an undertaking. I now feel like i have really underachieved this week

 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.