User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This new "dancing" that is prevalent since the update.
Page:
 
Judan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool

OK, so you have two options.

Either open your cakehole and reveal this master build that has the elusive run style working, or keep it closed and watch their capabilities go by the boards because you want to have an advantage between now and when Bort makes the run style change.


It is no use. He'll just respond with another condescending paragraph about his super secret squirrel players...

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
It seems like the paths it's generating are good, it just takes too long to generate them and it gets confused too easily.

If you don't want to outright scrap it, maybe set it so that when it picks an "optimum" path, it goes that direction for some arbitrary length of time before re-checking its path, so that instead of dancing around going nowhere they'll be gaining positive yards?


It generates a new path every tick, so yeah maybe that's contributing to the problem.
I can certainly try something like that - I'm just worried we'll never be able to see Barry Sanders type moves if that's the way it goes.
 
Link
 
Doubt it will make much of a difference. If he cuts down on the stutter stepping, won't hurt me since my guy doesn't do it. I'm just saying that when something doesn't work the way you expect it to, it doesn't mean it's a bug. I will say this. The team my HB is on has a fantastic line. That certainly helps. And people forget that the dots are not 100% accurate. Sometimes, the little freeze action is the HB trying to be "elusive" and make a tackler who's got him dead to rights miss. Happens all the time in the NFL (see Cadillac Williams), where the guy starts dancing and gets flattened. I really don't see the issue.
 
Judan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


It generates a new path every tick, so yeah maybe that's contributing to the problem.
I can certainly try something like that - I'm just worried we'll never be able to see Barry Sanders type moves if that's the way it goes.


What's the tick count?

Perhaps raising that would be beneficial, although that would effect the entire game...

 
Link
 
And Doc I apologize if I came off sounding condescending. It's 12:45 AM here so my political sensor is off. LOL
 
NSchmidt10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eric the Great of Antarctica
Doubt it will make much of a difference. If he cuts down on the stutter stepping, won't hurt me since my guy doesn't do it. I'm just saying that when something doesn't work the way you expect it to, it doesn't mean it's a bug. I will say this. The team my HB is on has a fantastic line. That certainly helps. And people forget that the dots are not 100% accurate. Sometimes, the little freeze action is the HB trying to be "elusive" and make a tackler who's got him dead to rights miss. Happens all the time in the NFL (see Cadillac Williams), where the guy starts dancing and gets flattened. I really don't see the issue.


I guess I don't know why I stutter step so much.... 70 speed 50 agility 30 confidence and 42 vision. I don't know what I need more of to just pick a hole and get 3 yards rather then getting 1 or 2 most of the time but getting that 60 yard run every 100 plays.
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
My 66 speed/55 agility back did the same thing.


 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by oldskool
It seems like the paths it's generating are good, it just takes too long to generate them and it gets confused too easily.

If you don't want to outright scrap it, maybe set it so that when it picks an "optimum" path, it goes that direction for some arbitrary length of time before re-checking its path, so that instead of dancing around going nowhere they'll be gaining positive yards?


It generates a new path every tick, so yeah maybe that's contributing to the problem.
I can certainly try something like that - I'm just worried we'll never be able to see Barry Sanders type moves if that's the way it goes.


Technically you could still have Sanders-like moves. You would be moving forward for a bit, and then if the best path was off at a really weird angle only a Sandersesque cut would keep you from being tackled.
 
neverdodge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eric the Great of Antarctica
Doubt it will make much of a difference. If he cuts down on the stutter stepping, won't hurt me since my guy doesn't do it. I'm just saying that when something doesn't work the way you expect it to, it doesn't mean it's a bug. I will say this


That's precisely the point. Here is what i already posted elsewhere :
At least i would like to know what is considered a bug, and what is considered working as intended. If i'm told that the actual sim is working as intended when you got a back focused either on speed or agility, then i know mine is doing something wrong, or got a bad build or a bad line or whatever.
Now if that's the case, the sim engine shouldn't be changed in that area and so we can try to experiment and finally figure out.

Else, if it's not working as intended and if it's keep being changed, how can we figure it ?
Of course your answer will be that there are elusive or speed backs that do well actually. I'll just throw at you the same thing that has been told to people having those min/max build then : maybe your guy is doing well, but maybe he's not build the way Bort mean elusive or speed back should be, so your abusing a part of the sim that's broken ...

 
pumph
offline
Link
 
The problem isn't that elusive doesn't work. The problem is that it works too well.

Not even Barry Sanders, who we could probably agree was the most elusive back of all time, juked and stuttered every play for every defender that approached him. That's the issue now. It's as if someone set to elusive is afraid to get hit at all.

In my opinion, the styles need to somehow just be set so that it only affects open-field running. Power = try to run him over. Elusive = try to make him miss. Combo = just get what yards you can.

In between the tackles, the runner can hesitate a little bit, but eventually, he just needs to pick a hole and go with it.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 23:13:07
 
HERO
offline
Link
 
My elusive backs are stutter stepping a lot more these first scrimmage games than they ever have and not much has changed since then. I have no problem with them trying to juke a defender or wait for a hole to open. It's when there isn't anyone in front of them that bothers me. Or even if the guy is 20 yards away. Just run straight!

Knowing that the elusive backs were having quite the problem this season I went for the combo running style and my guys still did their fair sharing of dancing. Unfortunately in one game we played a gutted team for one reason or another and I racked up 300+ yards but it could have been a lot more if I was running north and south instead of making sure I stepped on every blade of grass on the way to the end zone.

I also still say go back and look at that fluky kick off where everyone ran past the ball except the KR. He had three blockers in front of him and the kicker and the reason he didn't score was because he was giving the crowd his best John Travolta impersonation. I can see needing vision and confidence but seriously, how much vision do you need to see an open field?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by oldskool

It seems like the paths it's generating are good, it just takes too long to generate them and it gets confused too easily.

If you don't want to outright scrap it, maybe set it so that when it picks an "optimum" path, it goes that direction for some arbitrary length of time before re-checking its path, so that instead of dancing around going nowhere they'll be gaining positive yards?


It generates a new path every tick, so yeah maybe that's contributing to the problem.
I can certainly try something like that - I'm just worried we'll never be able to see Barry Sanders type moves if that's the way it goes.


Thats the same thing I thought when I read that. If we have them run a short distance with out redirecting we will never get a Sanders in this game.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Hopefully this will get worked out.

I'm seeing Elusive RBs of ALL BUILDS have this same kind of trouble..

Hopefully we will hear something before the seaons starts.

I really don't want to have to set my high speed/high agility back to Power.
 
Shagrat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eric the Great of Antarctica
There are plenty of elusive backs that are successful. You're just pissed because we won't share with you. I am telling you that elusive backs work FINE. Its just the standard elusive back build that is problematic and apparently has been since season 1. Hmmmmmm. Perhaps people post bad advice to stay at the top of their game? Wouldn't surprise me one bit. While I am willing to agree that the ACCEPTED elusive back build doesn't work, I refuse to say that elusive backs as a whole don't work. There are just too many guys MAKING it work.


Um which one of your HBs are you talking about? The lvl 15 playing in the A leagues?
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Its really simple to me: Elusive Backs worked great last year, we need to just go back to that.

What would be wrong with just coding elusive backs, just like last season?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.