User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > LOL Only one more scrimmage game left?
Page:
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
I love how people try to act like there are no problems. This game is in beta and there will be problems after they work on it. If anything the admins want us to tell problems so they can fix them. There is no possible way this guy would get blown out, look at my profile, one team was blown out with only 31 yards and we were even with them in everything. My team's got shut down to 3 points and 130 yards and I know they have good builds. The only team that one of my teams or gm'd teams beat was a gutted team and they still shut us down to only 300 yards and 30 points.
 
Vagabond
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yarmond1
This whole thing just reeks of inconsistencies on so many levels. Some had good luck and some had bad luck.

*And I would surely think that we needed more then 2 scrimmages to get used to how things are working now.


Hey - I follow the official guide to build my players.
Season 2 went well and in season 3 I was rewarded with lots of fumbles of my HBs even though they had strength and high carrying !
Our running game were destroyed by the changes Bort made at the beginning of season 3 and which he has corrected now. But we didnt cry out on all forums like so many others do now - instead we made the best out if it and went undefeated in the regular season.

You´re problem is that you take season 3 as the baseline for your success but season 3 was a failure if you ask me.
Tackling was nerfed and speed was totally overrated while really important stats were totally faded out.
How can a HB with 40 carrying fumble 4 times in a game ( and not only in one ) ???
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
bort is tweaking things constantly - so even through the day - he is making adjustments..

the people who played early yesterday morning had a ton of WR drops...as they day went on...those decreased...

so - by your next preseason game - things will probably be quite different
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
I think the tackling changes were too dramatic. If tackling was going to be as much of an attribute as it currently is, perhaps these changes should be made incrementally over the course of 1-2 seasons. Season 4 you see more missed tackles, but surely not to the level that we are at today (immobile QBs running 60 yard for TDs, HBs on STs destroying everybody, etc). By season 5, players will have had a season to start training / developing tackling, but the missed tackle "bar" could be raised again, so that those who ignored it start to see big warning signs.

The reality is that most players with good builds largely ignored tackling because it wasn't necessary due to wrap-up. Lots of players will come on and say "you should have made a good build LOL". Why would anybody with a successful build invest so heavily in tackling when it was not necessary? Now that it is necessary, we will gladly develop tackling. The problem is that this change was too dramatic and now we're seeing silly results because such a large number of players built players based on the way the game has been for 3 seasons.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 06:52:40
 
yarmond1
offline
Link
 
I actually think you are on the right track for sure Vagabond. But I honestly believe we just need more then 2 scrimmage games to be certain. Actually, of the top 3 tacklers in that game 2 were my LB and DT (as in those are my players). I know they have great builds and last year they didn't do much of anything at all and had the same thought as you with your rb. After one game they pretty much dominated on the defense, granted they were on the field a whole of a lot due to our offense sucking, but you get the point.

But the difference is really huge and to know for sure what needs to be done to players builds (differently or not) I think we need atleast one more scrimmage maybe 2. And I know for sure the QBs build doesn't suck bad enough to have a game like that. It's my cousins QB and I helped build him.

*Besides a few brain deads, great discussion all. Thanks!
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 06:54:16
 
Vagabond
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barnsie
I think the tackling changes were too dramatic. If tackling was going to be as much of an attribute as it currently is, perhaps these changes should be made incrementally over the course of 1-2 seasons. Season 4 you see more missed tackles, but surely not to the level that we are at today (immobile QBs running 60 yard for TDs, HBs on STs destroying everybody, etc). By season 5, players will have had a season to start training / developing tackling, but the missed tackle "bar" could be raised again, so that those who ignored it start to see big warning signs.

The reality is that most players with good builds largely ignored tackling because it wasn't necessary due to wrap-up. Lots of players will come on and say "you should have made a good build LOL". Why would anybody with a successful build invest so heavily in tackling when it was not necessary? Now that it is necessary, we will gladly develop tackling. The problem is that this change was too dramatic and now we're seeing silly results.


Having a D player with low tackling is NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOT a good build !!!!!!!!!
How many times do I need to say this ?
A D players has to be able to tackle - if he cant he´s just a wannabe trackstar.

And to use an anology:
What you are saying is that the school grades should have lower standards just because 70% of the students got an F - this way you only punish the ones who did their homework AGAIN !
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barnsie
I think the tackling changes were too dramatic. If tackling was going to be as much of an attribute as it currently is, perhaps these changes should be made incrementally over the course of 1-2 seasons. Season 4 you see more missed tackles, but surely not to the level that we are at today (immobile QBs running 60 yard for TDs, HBs on STs destroying everybody, etc). By season 5, players will have had a season to start training / developing tackling, but the missed tackle "bar" could be raised again, so that those who ignored it start to see big warning signs.

The reality is that most players with good builds largely ignored tackling because it wasn't necessary due to wrap-up. Lots of players will come on and say "you should have made a good build LOL". Why would anybody with a successful build invest so heavily in tackling when it was not necessary? Now that it is necessary, we will gladly develop tackling. The problem is that this change was too dramatic and now we're seeing silly results because such a large number of players built players based on the way the game has been for 3 seasons.


halfway through season 3 they said tackling would need to be higher in season 4, you should have started fixing it in season 3. Now its your problem not everyone else's




There are some issues with the sim and I'm sure they will be fixed. I doubt Bort will need more time but if he does then that's fine but we shouldn't delay the season for people who have 25 tackling and are crying about missing tackles
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
It makes it hard to find the real issues with the sims when you have people pointing out that they have crappy tackling skills or low stamina, and saying there is something broken in the sim
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
Originally posted by Barnsie

I think the tackling changes were too dramatic. If tackling was going to be as much of an attribute as it currently is, perhaps these changes should be made incrementally over the course of 1-2 seasons. Season 4 you see more missed tackles, but surely not to the level that we are at today (immobile QBs running 60 yard for TDs, HBs on STs destroying everybody, etc). By season 5, players will have had a season to start training / developing tackling, but the missed tackle "bar" could be raised again, so that those who ignored it start to see big warning signs.

The reality is that most players with good builds largely ignored tackling because it wasn't necessary due to wrap-up. Lots of players will come on and say "you should have made a good build LOL". Why would anybody with a successful build invest so heavily in tackling when it was not necessary? Now that it is necessary, we will gladly develop tackling. The problem is that this change was too dramatic and now we're seeing silly results because such a large number of players built players based on the way the game has been for 3 seasons.


halfway through season 3 they said tackling would need to be higher in season 4, you should have started fixing it in season 3. Now its your problem not everyone else's




There are some issues with the sim and I'm sure they will be fixed. I doubt Bort will need more time but if he does then that's fine but we shouldn't delay the season for people who have 25 tackling and are crying about missing tackles


QFE, even if you missed it all the way through season three you could have read the update page and put in more tackling when you boosted, that is what all my linebackers did
 
Vagabond
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
Originally posted by Barnsie

I think the tackling changes were too dramatic. If tackling was going to be as much of an attribute as it currently is, perhaps these changes should be made incrementally over the course of 1-2 seasons. Season 4 you see more missed tackles, but surely not to the level that we are at today (immobile QBs running 60 yard for TDs, HBs on STs destroying everybody, etc). By season 5, players will have had a season to start training / developing tackling, but the missed tackle "bar" could be raised again, so that those who ignored it start to see big warning signs.

The reality is that most players with good builds largely ignored tackling because it wasn't necessary due to wrap-up. Lots of players will come on and say "you should have made a good build LOL". Why would anybody with a successful build invest so heavily in tackling when it was not necessary? Now that it is necessary, we will gladly develop tackling. The problem is that this change was too dramatic and now we're seeing silly results because such a large number of players built players based on the way the game has been for 3 seasons.


halfway through season 3 they said tackling would need to be higher in season 4, you should have started fixing it in season 3. Now its your problem not everyone else's




There are some issues with the sim and I'm sure they will be fixed. I doubt Bort will need more time but if he does then that's fine but we shouldn't delay the season for people who have 25 tackling and are crying about missing tackles


and much less we should bent over to the guys who didnt develop tackling ...
pure logic should tell you that 25 tackling is not enough for level 17+
 
Blutoski
offline
Link
 
I think everybody is right here. There are still some sim issues. I'm seeing a lot with how the depth chart is reacting differently this year. There are too many sacks right now and too many drops. There are also too many missed tackles. However, I think all those things are going to increase. Bort has said as much and I think its a good thing. I think some of these settings still just need a little tweaking.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
the depth chart is screwed up, mostly the new WR and CB sections

sacks - I haven't seen much on


catching - this has been said already, catching was going to have to be higher this season. That was announced a few weeks ago with the tackling and agility changes
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShakeNBake
Originally posted by Barnsie

I think the tackling changes were too dramatic. If tackling was going to be as much of an attribute as it currently is, perhaps these changes should be made incrementally over the course of 1-2 seasons. Season 4 you see more missed tackles, but surely not to the level that we are at today (immobile QBs running 60 yard for TDs, HBs on STs destroying everybody, etc). By season 5, players will have had a season to start training / developing tackling, but the missed tackle "bar" could be raised again, so that those who ignored it start to see big warning signs.

The reality is that most players with good builds largely ignored tackling because it wasn't necessary due to wrap-up. Lots of players will come on and say "you should have made a good build LOL". Why would anybody with a successful build invest so heavily in tackling when it was not necessary? Now that it is necessary, we will gladly develop tackling. The problem is that this change was too dramatic and now we're seeing silly results because such a large number of players built players based on the way the game has been for 3 seasons.


halfway through season 3 they said tackling would need to be higher in season 4, you should have started fixing it in season 3. Now its your problem not everyone else's




There are some issues with the sim and I'm sure they will be fixed. I doubt Bort will need more time but if he does then that's fine but we shouldn't delay the season for people who have 25 tackling and are crying about missing tackles


I'm not going to really argue back and forth, but the reason I commented is because it is everybody's problem, not just my problem. If it was just my players that had the missed tackles, I'd say, OK, I didn't develop tackling, it worked for a few seasons, but now I have to really focus on it. The reality, however, is that it is the majority of players, not just my players. Go look at box scores. That said, I plan to develop tackling, I have no problem doing so. I can tell you that quite a few players with 40+ tackling are missing more than I think is probably normal.

So you're guys aren't having any problems here?
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
we missed 8 tackles, but I expected it

only 2 of them that missed tackles had tackling above 40

I think 45-50 will be the target #


Also power is going to be huge, given the QB scramble needs fixed but power backs will be breaking tackles, i don't want to get much into my players builds but power backs with good strength will be knocking LB's and CB's with low strength and tackling all season long
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 07:50:44
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
Also I think there are a lot of players playing on power tackling and they are the ones missing tackles then the owners think it's a sim problem when actually its low tackling, low energy, and power tackling problems

oh and my power back ran over 12 players by his-self so the team we played are probably saying the sim is broken when actually my HB is stronger then they are so it only makes since for him to put them on their ass
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 07:56:40
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.