User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
But NIMBY is a valid argument in this case. It's not like we're discriminating against the team because of their race or religion. What we're saying is, "No, kindergarten age children don't belong in a high school honors class trying to read Machiavelli. They're a distraction and a nuisance and will hold the rest of the students back."
What happens if the Miners wind up with a #3 seed in the playoffs, have disgustingly low energy levels for their first round matchup with what is bound to be an extremely tough 6 seed (Zeta is a tight conference. Not a whole lot traditionally separates 1-8), and lose that game because their collective energy levels blow? Do they not then have a right to be upset? I certainly would be if I were them. And I understand that's a somewhat unrealistic possibility, but it could viably happen. What do we say to ULLA? "Sorry about your playoff loss. Better luck next year?" That's just messed up. Especially for a guy like ULLA, who has GOT to be one of the top guys in terms of dollars spent in GLB (looking at it from a pure revenue stream point of view). Life isn't fair, but that's one of the reasons we love sports. It's supposed to be.

EDIT: And as for the A levels with level 19 stocked teams? That is still where teams like the Lions are supposed to be. There's still a competitive difference between that league and ours. Granted, they wouldn't be much more competitive in that league, but they would still be MORE competitive than they are here, and pose an energy level danger to a team that CAN'T go anywhere but up. That was supposed to be the reason for the different classes of leagues in the first place, wasn't it? To provide specific niches for different level teams?
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 15:48:30
 
orcinus
offline
Link
 
You're missing the point of my argument, though.

Whether that team belongs in another league isn't the issue.

With over 4,000 teams in 127 leagues, this situation isn't unique. While it's unlikely, we could have a dozen AAA owners throw in the towel tonight, trade/release their players and sell their teams back.

Whether they like it or not, tomorrow's twelve new owners are going to be faced with the task of rebuilding and probably all wish they were in an "easier" league.

Do you move them all down tomorrow?

What about the four more that sell back Saturday afternoon and get replaced with CPU rosters?

While the example is extreme in nature, it illustrates my point.

Setting precedent with TPat's team is a bad idea.

If he signed a team full of LVL16 players because that's all the market would bear, and then went 0-16, would you still complain?

The only difference is how he chooses to run the team. Until there is a league mandate that states TPat MUST field a competitive team, this is a non-issue in my eyes.

It's an easy win for anyone lucky enough to draw TPat's team, for sure, and should spark all sorts of whining from everyone that doesn't, but it's a non-issue from an administrative sense.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I think the issue was people were abusing the move up move down system. Owner A who had a good team but in a tough league would get together with owner B who had a bad team in a bad league and switch and trade all the good players onto owner A's team, which would then dominate in the lower league. People were moving to Africa AA with level 24 players when everyone else had level 13s and 14s. Thus Bort just put a stop to it altogether. If I had moved probably an equal number of people would be complaining that an exception had been made for a mod when other people weren't allowed to move. I can almost promise you this would have happened. Ideally we would have enough people to thoroughly investigate each scenario and decide on a case by case basis, but we can't and also people in season 2 were pretty craftily decieving Bort by signing low level players, moving down, then they had a whole roster lined up that was much higher leveled than their current league.

I guess it sucks to have a team with low level players although everyone in the division will play us so no one gets an easy win that everyone else didn't get, and the same goes for racking up stats. Everyone gets the same shot at it. Stamina should not be too much of an issue wither because Bort changed the sim to make it so that when you play a team like mine you don't get nearly as tired as in past seasons.

If you PM another mod maybe they can convince Bort to swap my teams. It makes no difference to me what league we are in since I am not expecting to compete for another 2 seasons. But by the time we hit season 7 or 8 I think we can compete for a title and cetainly be a powerhouse as other teams start to decline. People tend to see teams like this and think farm team, but you can see from all the players who have theme names that that is not the case and that I am looking down the road and not just in it for this season.
Last edited Jul 31, 2008 16:30:20
 
orcinus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bacchuspoet

What happens if the Miners wind up with a #3 seed in the playoffs, have disgustingly low energy levels for their first round matchup with what is bound to be an extremely tough 6 seed (Zeta is a tight conference. Not a whole lot traditionally separates 1-8), and lose that game because their collective energy levels blow?


If that happens, they'd only have themselves to blame for poor game-planning and would deserve their fate. There are workarounds to avoid high-energy losses during blowouts ... all of which managed with tactic, substitution and depth chart adjustments.

 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
I'm not suggesting farm team. Like I said, I think your motives are fine. I don't have a problem with that.
I'll concede the debate. Not because I think this is the best way to handle the issue, but because I don't see another way to deal with it unless we had a bunch of mods policing just this issue and that's not anything even resembling efficient. They have other things to do, like deal with whiny-ass posters like myself. lol
And you're right tpat, people absolutely would start complaining about the situation specifically because you're a mod.
It's just that there has got to be a better way of handling this. Oh well, I'll let wiser minds than mine try and sort it out.
 
Dlux67
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chevyman
Originally posted by dlux67

Originally posted by tpaterniti


Originally posted by morbid



Originally posted by tpaterniti




I asked to move down and was told no. I should be able to start whoever I want on my team. It is a themed team and I have a 10 season plan for it. I am sorry it messes up your stats. I cleared it with Bort a long time ago.


Only problem is your hurting a team that is actually trying to improve and needs to move down next season to be competitive. Instead they will be stuck in AAA again and make it even harder for them in offseason to recruit players. Im not worried about the stat part but the fair play part. Your a Moderator and should not be doing this, you guys are supposed to be looking out for others and not yourselves first IMO.


I don't know what to tell you man. I told Bort I would be starting level 1s and asked him if the team could move down for those very reasons and he said no. The reason I made the team the way it is is because I am a Star Trek fan and wanted a Star Trek themed team. It wasn't to cheat the system. I pay for my team/s (will be only 2 after this season down from 6 last season) like every one else and I think that if I want to make a themed team and start a new roster I should be able to do that.


I think its cute that you have a themed team - although I am not sure if I saw a Jordi LaForge in the starting line-up, which is a disgrace.
The beef is with allowing your team to play in AAA ball. I am confused as to why Bort has an issue with your team moving down - did he provide any specifics?



Look at thier kicker.


Oh, I should have clarified...I was speaking about real football players only.

 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Well I suggested a move up wait list and a system where gutted teams automatically got bumped down to the lowest level with stadium and money reset, but since I didn't resell my team it wouldn't really fall under that either.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
it is definitely an imperfect system - but what can you do...

don't really see that it is tpaterniti's fault in any case....

 
und666
offline
Link
 
its not his fault ...im sure given the choice he would be in a 13 capped league but it doesnt make it suck any less

...i will probably win the rushing trophys again this year now but zeta has lost most of its cupcake teams and we have gained another one so it wont mean anything ...atleast last year both conferences had 250 point games

its alot more lopsided now ...for everyone one in zeta besides miners that is
 
MR. ULLA
offline
Link
 
Bump to discuss lameass name-change.

Starfleet Academy ?!! Seeerioulsy?

Damn Trekkies!

-U

ETA Somebody make a Tackle Tribble and see if they get picked up.




Last edited Aug 4, 2008 14:39:40
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.