User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > What sense is it that the best teams only have 1 person on the depth chart.
Page:
 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
haha, i gotcha... yeah i felt bad today cause i cut half my team cause i didn't want to keep them on a roster and not play them... but there is also no teams to pick anyone up right now. Kinda sucks for them no matter what.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
It really looks like there's a 30 energy loss per game cap in place, I've never seen anyone drop below 71 energy after a game. The energy loss should be way, way bigger if you don't have a backup. You should be dropping 50+ energy if you play every snap and have your energy recovery rate take a hit if there's no qualified backup (no signing a bunch of 100FP creations, making a tackle your backup QB and getting around the penalty). It encourages owners to have and play their backups, it encourages players to have hope of getting in the game if they are a backup...

Then again, QBs play every snap unless they get hurt or are literally too exhausted to continue....so do a lot of positions.
 
Ballhair
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
It really looks like there's a 30 energy loss per game cap in place, I've never seen anyone drop below 71 energy after a game. The energy loss should be way, way bigger if you don't have a backup. You should be dropping 50+ energy if you play every snap and have your energy recovery rate take a hit if there's no qualified backup (no signing a bunch of 100FP creations, making a tackle your backup QB and getting around the penalty). It encourages owners to have and play their backups, it encourages players to have hope of getting in the game if they are a backup...

Then again, QBs play every snap unless they get hurt or are literally too exhausted to continue....so do a lot of positions.


I agree.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
I've been at < 70 energy from one game, I believe. I train on relaxed all the time too.

The teams with short benches will get creamed when playoff time comes. And next season, with trade deadlines, they can't add players right before playoff time.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
reduction in energy should be a formula (100 - stamina X 2.5)/100 per play. If a player has 20 stamina then 1 - 50/100 = .5. So every 10 plays they would lose 5 energy points. 60 plays would be 30 energy points. Also, players should lose 5% of total ability for every 10 points of energy loss. So using above scenario, a player with 20 stamina would lose 5% of playing ability after 20 plays. 10% after 40 plays. 15% after 60 plays.

you could have different formulas for different positions. For instance DT needs more stamina per play than a CB. But the variation shouldn't be that different.
 
Develop
offline
Link
 
^This man has the right idea.

Except how does a DT need more stamina than a CB?
 
MrEmerkin
offline
Link
 
I think a lot of owners will re-think limited rosters when the developers finally start to put in more formation options beside "I wanna run a lot outside" or something similar.



 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Develop
^This man has the right idea.

Except how does a DT need more stamina than a CB?


Agree, Rage is onto something. I like this and similar ideas

A DT is in a wrestling match with a 300 LB strength beast on every play. Not that CBs dont have ground to cover but the physical exertion / play is higher for a DT than a CB. Notice that DTs get rotated far more often than CBs in RL

 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CONN CHRIS



It can easily be solved by making a certain depth at each position mandatory for a line-up to be valid prior to game time.



I agree with this thread.

Seriously, injuries is not whats going to solve this. People should not be playing, let alone rewarded for playing just 1 HB or just 2 WR's in a game. Its simply unrealistic and those of us trying to play more realistically or suffering.

I like the suggestion of having a mandatory depth at each position for a lineup to be valid.

 
KGrob
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JeffHCross
Originally posted by ShamsTron

They must have to have their stamina jacked to be able to pull that off.
I don't think they have to. We played another team with few guys on the depth chart, and they seemed to actually get better as the game went on. It's almost like a low-energy but *better* player will still be better than a fully rested lower-level player.

Plus, the game has some really strange results from Depth Charts and Stamina.

Lvl 8 DT w/29 stamina. Two people on the depth chart. He plays 45 plays, and after the game has 71 energy.
Lvl 8 LB w/25 stamina. Only player at MLB on the depth chart. Plays 70 plays, and has 73 energy. And by far had the best stats on the defense.

That doesn't add up.



Good point.

I have a DT and he does seem to advance slowly compared to some of the others on our team.
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
They are going to implement a mandatory roster size eventually. From what I could tell, it was in the 40s. A lot of teams are using various workarounds this season that won't exist next season. Which is fine, the game is in a beta. If they lose because of it, they'll learn and move on (hopefully). I'm all for mandatory depth, I have several players on my roster who I could release and not really notice. That's what backups are for.In the odd chance in game where I need one, there one is...skilled and everything.
 
Peregrine
offline
Link
 
In my opinion they need to implement a real injury system, one that can result in lost games - this is the major need for depth in real pro football and it's the same here. It's frankly ridiculous for this game to be living in a dreamworld where no one gets hurt, and it leads to the kinds of gaming the system we have seen so far.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
I agree with your ideas on the obligation to have big roster.

Plus the idea of Rage Kinard

Originally posted by

reduction in energy should be a formula (100 - stamina X 2.5)/100 per play. If a player has 20 stamina then 1 - 50/100 = .5. So every 10 plays they would lose 5 energy points. 60 plays would be 30 energy points. Also, players should lose 5% of total ability for every 10 points of energy loss. So using above scenario, a player with 20 stamina would lose 5% of playing ability after 20 plays. 10% after 40 plays. 15% after 60 plays.


60 for 30 energy it's what we can see... i say 60 play cost 60 energy! because who in real football play 60 play?

There's something i want to add... this about the back ups. Actually it's very frustating to play 2 or 3 string (and a lot disadvantage) . Finding a team is a pain in the ass, and quiting a team either.

If it continue we will lack of new players quite fast...

Ok the news league will solve partially the problem but how long?

edit: Plus i agree with the injury lacking of power effects. We need some injury which make a player out of condition for minimum 1 match
Last edited Apr 14, 2008 07:15:51
 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by


reduction in energy should be a formula (100 - stamina X 2.5)/100 per play. If a player has 20 stamina then 1 - 50/100 = .5. So every 10 plays they would lose 5 energy points. 60 plays would be 30 energy points. Also, players should lose 5% of total ability for every 10 points of energy loss. So using above scenario, a player with 20 stamina would lose 5% of playing ability after 20 plays. 10% after 40 plays. 15% after 60 plays.


60 for 30 energy it's what we can see... i say 60 play cost 60 energy! because who in real football play 60 play?



I like your point, how about something like this though... Every play costs 3 or 4 energy points... and every play on the bench gets you 1 point back. That way players come out of the game, rest up, and can go back in.

 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
I like it too just about choice
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.