User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Free for All > When it's all said and done best RB ever
Page:
 
Shane Falco
offline
Link
 
Personally I have to plug Walter Payton and even though he prolly doesn't deserve to be on the list you have to admit watching Larry Zonka just plow over people w/ a bloody face was whole lotta fun to watch

 
stat2883
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Shane Falco
Personally I have to plug Walter Payton and even though he prolly doesn't deserve to be on the list you have to admit watching Larry Zonka just plow over people w/ a bloody face was whole lotta fun to watch



Back when football was football. You could piledrive QBs into the ground, man-handle WRs in their routes, and gouge people's eyes out. Nice throwback with the Csonka reference. That was a hell of a RB trio they had in Miami. Granted you could almost lump Kiick in as a WR.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 16:07:34
 
cyclone42088
offline
Link
 
if adrian peterson can stay healthy and run the way he did in his rookie season he is going to be a force to reckon with and will be talked about in the best backs ever
 
rusdom
offline
Link
 
Me, and it wont even be close
 
pootytang
offline
Link
 
Adrian Peterson shouldnt even be mentioned till at least 3 or 4 more years, kids a pheanom thats for sure but he had durability issues in college so we can only wait and see if it carries over to the pros.
 
JoSCh
offline
Link
 
Not one mention of Bears great Bryan Johnson... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bryan_Johnson_(American_football)

Tomlinson will be among the greats, and he arguably has the best all around game. Better runner than Faulk, better receiver than Brown, carried his team throughout where neither Payton nor E Smith had to, and will likely leave the game better than Sanders and with less lost yardage .
 
FarEastBeast
offline
Link
 
My vote goes to Tomlinson.

No weakness in his game, can even throw and catch touchdowns. Must like Payton i.e. do everything ... can play with power or play with elusiveness.

Barry Sanders I think was the most talented, but he had a LOT of runs for losses - of course his OL was terrible was a large part of the reason, so without his talent it would have been worse.


I cannot comment on Bryan Johnson or Jim Brown .... I never saw them play. A Peterson ..... again have not seen enough of him.

Certainly a key component of being "the best ever" must be longevity. One season does not a career make.
 
HoggLife
offline
Link
 
In my lifetime the best I have ever seen is hands down Barry Sanders. The guy never had a great O-Line and no one on offense that was a threat besides Herman Moore and no one could stop B. Sanders! Best ever hands down!
 
stat2883
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FarEastBeast
I cannot comment on Bryan Johnson

If you've watched the skins at all since 2000, you've probably seen Bryan Johnson

...yes....THAT Bryan Johnson.
 
WEglAudacity
offline
Link
 
Not even an honorable mention for Bo Jackson? Get that man a new hip and he could probably still score touchdowns.
 
stat2883
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WEglAudacity
Not even an honorable mention for Bo Jackson? Get that man a new hip and he could probably still score touchdowns.


he stiffed me for an autograph after a Royals/Twins game....so no!
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stat2883
even worse is trying to do it for WRs

--at least there the general consensus is Jerry Rice, but after that it gets cloudy real fast. Even Rice may not be a stone cold lock.


Don Hutson FTW
 
PRUETER
offline
Link
 
I think Bo Jackson would've had the rushing record if he never got hurt.He had power and amazing speed.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
And I'd say Jim Brown SHOULD win easy.

But he was a douche that wouldn't even block for his quarterback and didn't care about his team. Walter Payton gets the nod from me for best ever RB, even though Jim Brown was the most dominant.
 
favre466
offline
Link
 
Ahman Green, he had a couple good years, that has to make him good, just throwing it out there.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.