Looks like we take a big hit because of our "depth" at some positions that will never play at those positions...I think it's ridiculous to even consider those as part of the rankings. If they aren't on the depth chart, why should they be counted?
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #1 > Canada AAA#1 Western Conference Pre-Season Power Rankings
Jim Mora
offline
offline
Originally posted by blevstone
Looks like we take a big hit because of our "depth" at some positions that will never play at those positions...I think it's ridiculous to even consider those as part of the rankings. If they aren't on the depth chart, why should they be counted?
I figured some of it might be your WR depth at the time of the rankings, but it looks like you guys have signed another one. There's little to no chance I'd put the GSPs above the Kings at this point, numbers be damned. But I am looking forward to finding our first win against the Kings!
Looks like we take a big hit because of our "depth" at some positions that will never play at those positions...I think it's ridiculous to even consider those as part of the rankings. If they aren't on the depth chart, why should they be counted?
I figured some of it might be your WR depth at the time of the rankings, but it looks like you guys have signed another one. There's little to no chance I'd put the GSPs above the Kings at this point, numbers be damned. But I am looking forward to finding our first win against the Kings!
redeyes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Beefcake
Originally posted by djfivenine
How is this calculated...
It is based on sum of modified levels: Level * Depth Modifier, where the Depth Modifier for all starters is 1 and backups are reduced based on importance of depth at that position.
For example the modifier for:
starting C = 1, 2nd = .5 3rd and beyond = .1
starting G = 1, 2nd = 1, 3rd = .75, 4th = .5, 5th and beyond = .1
starting P = 1, 2nd and beyond = .1
BTW, this is depth on the roster not the actual depth chart.
It may not be perfect, but it does get a pretty good snapshot of the potential power of at team, builds and tactics aside (will build some of this in a-la Varmitcong for the in-season rankings)
It does not penalize for having a level 10 3rd string QB who might get 1 snap a game like an straight up average would, however it also rewards depth (especially quality depth) though where it is needed most.
The only thing it lacks (depending on how you look at it) is it doesn't differentiate between relative importance of any given position.
full chart of modifiers, if anyone is interested:
POS 1ST 2ND 3RD 4TH 5TH 6TH 7TH 8TH
QB 1.00 0.25
HB 1.00 0.75 0.25
FB 1.00 0.25
C 1.00 0.50
G 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.10
OT 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.10
TE 1.00 0.75 0.25 0.10
WR 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.25 0.10 0.10
DT 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.10
DE 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.75 0.25 0.10
LB 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.10
SS 1.00 0.50 0.25
FS 1.00 0.50 0.25
CB 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.25 0.10
P 1.00
K 1.00
Sorry to throw a wrinkle into things, but now that the 3-4 defense is available, the modifiers for the d-line and LBs doesn't necessairly apply to every team...it may be more important to have 4 quality LBs and only one DT (or NG in the 3-4)
Originally posted by djfivenine
How is this calculated...
It is based on sum of modified levels: Level * Depth Modifier, where the Depth Modifier for all starters is 1 and backups are reduced based on importance of depth at that position.
For example the modifier for:
starting C = 1, 2nd = .5 3rd and beyond = .1
starting G = 1, 2nd = 1, 3rd = .75, 4th = .5, 5th and beyond = .1
starting P = 1, 2nd and beyond = .1
BTW, this is depth on the roster not the actual depth chart.
It may not be perfect, but it does get a pretty good snapshot of the potential power of at team, builds and tactics aside (will build some of this in a-la Varmitcong for the in-season rankings)
It does not penalize for having a level 10 3rd string QB who might get 1 snap a game like an straight up average would, however it also rewards depth (especially quality depth) though where it is needed most.
The only thing it lacks (depending on how you look at it) is it doesn't differentiate between relative importance of any given position.
full chart of modifiers, if anyone is interested:
POS 1ST 2ND 3RD 4TH 5TH 6TH 7TH 8TH
QB 1.00 0.25
HB 1.00 0.75 0.25
FB 1.00 0.25
C 1.00 0.50
G 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.10
OT 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.10
TE 1.00 0.75 0.25 0.10
WR 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.25 0.10 0.10
DT 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.10
DE 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.75 0.25 0.10
LB 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.10
SS 1.00 0.50 0.25
FS 1.00 0.50 0.25
CB 1.00 1.00 0.75 0.75 0.50 0.25 0.25 0.10
P 1.00
K 1.00
Sorry to throw a wrinkle into things, but now that the 3-4 defense is available, the modifiers for the d-line and LBs doesn't necessairly apply to every team...it may be more important to have 4 quality LBs and only one DT (or NG in the 3-4)
redeyes
offline
offline
Originally posted by Beefcake
And now the Western Conference Power Rank as of 8am 7/24
Rank Score Team
1 809 Spokane Angry Pirates….ARRRGH
2 798 Pittsburgh Iron Men
3 796 South Dildo Demons
4 777 Montreal GSPs
5 774 Thunder bay Reapers
6 732 Kamloops Nittany Dodgers
6 732 Kensington Kings
8 725 Regina Renegades
9 709 Manitoba Manbeef
9 709 St. Catherines Storm
11 686 Vancouver Lions
12 683 Chilliwack Sabres
13 600 richmond bandits
14 598 Victoria Secret
15 570 Beefcake's Swords of Chaos
16 414 Pecker's Point Master Baiting Seaman
Edit: fixed tweaked formula a bit, see East thread for details.
The only reason that Pittsburgh is ranked below Spokane is because of depth. They have us pretty much out leveled at every position. We'll have to see how that works out during the season.
And now the Western Conference Power Rank as of 8am 7/24
Rank Score Team
1 809 Spokane Angry Pirates….ARRRGH
2 798 Pittsburgh Iron Men
3 796 South Dildo Demons
4 777 Montreal GSPs
5 774 Thunder bay Reapers
6 732 Kamloops Nittany Dodgers
6 732 Kensington Kings
8 725 Regina Renegades
9 709 Manitoba Manbeef
9 709 St. Catherines Storm
11 686 Vancouver Lions
12 683 Chilliwack Sabres
13 600 richmond bandits
14 598 Victoria Secret
15 570 Beefcake's Swords of Chaos
16 414 Pecker's Point Master Baiting Seaman
Edit: fixed tweaked formula a bit, see East thread for details.
The only reason that Pittsburgh is ranked below Spokane is because of depth. They have us pretty much out leveled at every position. We'll have to see how that works out during the season.
Beefcake
offline
offline
Originally posted by blevstone
Looks like we take a big hit because of our "depth" at some positions that will never play at those positions...I think it's ridiculous to even consider those as part of the rankings. If they aren't on the depth chart, why should they be counted?
Depth will never count against you. Lack of depth and/or quality will though... only 3 WRs 24, 18, and 17 isn't helping your case.
Originally posted by redeyes
Sorry to throw a wrinkle into things, but now that the 3-4 defense is available, the modifiers for the d-line and LBs doesn't necessairly apply to every team...it may be more important to have 4 quality LBs and only one DT (or NG in the 3-4)
That is why I made LB one of the deepest possible, and DT not so much. I don't think there will be a perfect analysis that is a catch all for everyone, but once the games start, things will begin to shake out more accurately.
Looks like we take a big hit because of our "depth" at some positions that will never play at those positions...I think it's ridiculous to even consider those as part of the rankings. If they aren't on the depth chart, why should they be counted?
Depth will never count against you. Lack of depth and/or quality will though... only 3 WRs 24, 18, and 17 isn't helping your case.
Originally posted by redeyes
Sorry to throw a wrinkle into things, but now that the 3-4 defense is available, the modifiers for the d-line and LBs doesn't necessairly apply to every team...it may be more important to have 4 quality LBs and only one DT (or NG in the 3-4)
That is why I made LB one of the deepest possible, and DT not so much. I don't think there will be a perfect analysis that is a catch all for everyone, but once the games start, things will begin to shake out more accurately.
blevstone
offline
offline
Originally posted by Beefcake
Originally posted by blevstone
Looks like we take a big hit because of our "depth" at some positions that will never play at those positions...I think it's ridiculous to even consider those as part of the rankings. If they aren't on the depth chart, why should they be counted?
Depth will never count against you. Lack of depth and/or quality will though... only 3 WRs 24, 18, and 17 isn't helping your case.
Originally posted by redeyes
Sorry to throw a wrinkle into things, but now that the 3-4 defense is available, the modifiers for the d-line and LBs doesn't necessairly apply to every team...it may be more important to have 4 quality LBs and only one DT (or NG in the 3-4)
That is why I made LB one of the deepest possible, and DT not so much. I don't think there will be a perfect analysis that is a catch all for everyone, but once the games start, things will begin to shake out more accurately.
Well...obviously that's not our final roster...why is this happening in the off season when many teams are still filling holes? Obviously there are going to be some "gaps" on alot of teams...
Originally posted by blevstone
Looks like we take a big hit because of our "depth" at some positions that will never play at those positions...I think it's ridiculous to even consider those as part of the rankings. If they aren't on the depth chart, why should they be counted?
Depth will never count against you. Lack of depth and/or quality will though... only 3 WRs 24, 18, and 17 isn't helping your case.
Originally posted by redeyes
Sorry to throw a wrinkle into things, but now that the 3-4 defense is available, the modifiers for the d-line and LBs doesn't necessairly apply to every team...it may be more important to have 4 quality LBs and only one DT (or NG in the 3-4)
That is why I made LB one of the deepest possible, and DT not so much. I don't think there will be a perfect analysis that is a catch all for everyone, but once the games start, things will begin to shake out more accurately.
Well...obviously that's not our final roster...why is this happening in the off season when many teams are still filling holes? Obviously there are going to be some "gaps" on alot of teams...
Beefcake
offline
offline
Originally posted by blevstone
Well...obviously that's not our final roster...why is this happening in the off season when many teams are still filling holes? Obviously there are going to be some "gaps" on alot of teams...
Because it's fun and has stirred up this forum a bit from it's usual boringness.
As I said, I'll update it again just before the first game for the final pre-season ranking, and throughout the season.
Well...obviously that's not our final roster...why is this happening in the off season when many teams are still filling holes? Obviously there are going to be some "gaps" on alot of teams...
Because it's fun and has stirred up this forum a bit from it's usual boringness.
As I said, I'll update it again just before the first game for the final pre-season ranking, and throughout the season.
Ace79603
offline
offline
our owner over here in the Regina Renegades is doing EVERYTHING possible to make us contenders this year. I don't think anyone could have done a better job than rnilo to bring this team back from the grave. Just giving my owner some props in the Public Fourms
douglasiv
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ace79603
our owner over here in the Regina Renegades is doing EVERYTHING possible to make us contenders this year. I don't think anyone could have done a better job than rnilo to bring this team back from the grave. Just giving my owner some props in the Public Fourms
I noticed this too, but wasn't going to say anything. I also am a big fan of the Victoria Secret rebuild.
our owner over here in the Regina Renegades is doing EVERYTHING possible to make us contenders this year. I don't think anyone could have done a better job than rnilo to bring this team back from the grave. Just giving my owner some props in the Public Fourms
I noticed this too, but wasn't going to say anything. I also am a big fan of the Victoria Secret rebuild.
cooljesture20
offline
offline
I'm excited about playing for Regina this year, last year was terrible for us, but we all stuck together!
Ace79603
offline
offline
Originally posted by cooljesture20
I'm excited about playing for Regina this year, last year was terrible for us, but we all stuck together!
yeah scouting will actually make a difference for us now instead of just of losing by 100 we lost by 92. LOL. IT will be fun. GL everyone
I'm excited about playing for Regina this year, last year was terrible for us, but we all stuck together!
yeah scouting will actually make a difference for us now instead of just of losing by 100 we lost by 92. LOL. IT will be fun. GL everyone
mitt31
offline
offline
I like playing for the leagues underdogs... Beafcake's swords of chaos
i'm hoping we play .500 this season and push for .600-.700 the next... will be difficult but fun.
i'm hoping we play .500 this season and push for .600-.700 the next... will be difficult but fun.
monts
offline
offline
Originally posted by douglasiv
Originally posted by Ace79603
our owner over here in the Regina Renegades is doing EVERYTHING possible to make us contenders this year. I don't think anyone could have done a better job than rnilo to bring this team back from the grave. Just giving my owner some props in the Public Fourms
I noticed this too, but wasn't going to say anything. I also am a big fan of the Victoria Secret rebuild.
We're trying to improve, just a matter of waiting for the season to start to see if it works
Originally posted by Ace79603
our owner over here in the Regina Renegades is doing EVERYTHING possible to make us contenders this year. I don't think anyone could have done a better job than rnilo to bring this team back from the grave. Just giving my owner some props in the Public Fourms
I noticed this too, but wasn't going to say anything. I also am a big fan of the Victoria Secret rebuild.
We're trying to improve, just a matter of waiting for the season to start to see if it works
Lax32
offline
offline
Originally posted by blevstone
Well...obviously that's not our final roster...why is this happening in the off season when many teams are still filling holes? Obviously there are going to be some "gaps" on alot of teams...
Thats how they do college and NFL rankings.
Well...obviously that's not our final roster...why is this happening in the off season when many teams are still filling holes? Obviously there are going to be some "gaps" on alot of teams...
Thats how they do college and NFL rankings.
djknick
offline
offline
Originally posted by blevstone
Looks like we take a big hit because of our "depth" at some positions that will never play at those positions...I think it's ridiculous to even consider those as part of the rankings. If they aren't on the depth chart, why should they be counted?
If they aren't on the depth chart...why are they on your team?
Looks like we take a big hit because of our "depth" at some positions that will never play at those positions...I think it's ridiculous to even consider those as part of the rankings. If they aren't on the depth chart, why should they be counted?
If they aren't on the depth chart...why are they on your team?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























