User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP Bonuses for Impact Plays made on the field - a must add
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
How to you give an XP bonus for good stats to a CB who never gets thrown to, because he locks his man down? He wouldn't have any ints, pd's, or tackles, but he performed really well. What about the FB who makes great blocks for his HB but never gets a pancake? He's got no stats to give him an XP boost.

I understand that you want to feel like you are being rewarded in some way for a good performance on the field, but we are not going to give extra XP for it. End of season trophies, better contracts, cash bonuses, a morale boost, etc are all rewards for doing well. We even have some ideas for your player gaining a reputation for being a stud, and causing morale effects on the other team, etc.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Peyton's successes? Like the 28 INTs he threw his first year?

You made a point, but it was the one counter to your own


Manning threw 28 Ints vs 26 Touchdowns for passer rating of 71.2. Leaf? 2 touchdowns vs. 15 interceptions for a passer rating 39.0. Don't forget, I'm proposing two systems for XP Bonuses and Penalties based on player performance as they'd balance each other out. If those systems were implemented in GBL, Manning would progress faster than Leaf....not at the same rate.

Also, If DD and Bort added some sort of XP Bonus/Penalty systems along with the X-Factor/Potential feature ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=40965 ), I think an insane amount of depth and realism could be added to GBL.
 
methomps
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
How to you give an XP bonus for good stats to a CB who never gets thrown to, because he locks his man down? He wouldn't have any ints, pd's, or tackles, but he performed really well. What about the FB who makes great blocks for his HB but never gets a pancake? He's got no stats to give him an XP boost.

I understand that you want to feel like you are being rewarded in some way for a good performance on the field, but we are not going to give extra XP for it. End of season trophies, better contracts, cash bonuses, a morale boost, etc are all rewards for doing well. We even have some ideas for your player gaining a reputation for being a stud, and causing morale effects on the other team, etc.


Bingo. The tie between stats and good performance is just too remote for this to work.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I understand that you want to feel like you are being rewarded in some way for a good performance on the field, but we are not going to give extra XP for it. End of season trophies, better contracts, cash bonuses, a morale boost, etc are all rewards for doing well. We even have some ideas for your player gaining a reputation for being a stud, and causing morale effects on the other team, etc.


Ah well, I tried. Thanks for the feedback.
 
gtbice
offline
Link
 
I think they should add the "impact plays" 3 or 4 seasons down the road, when bad teams moved down leagues and good ones move up, there is to much of a mix up of really good and really bad teams in one conferance right now.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
How to you give an XP bonus for good stats to a CB who never gets thrown to, because he locks his man down? He wouldn't have any ints, pd's, or tackles, but he performed really well.


But how did that CB get to the point of being labeled a shutdown CB? At some point in his career -- likely very early -- he must have been getting those ints and returning some of them for tds, breaking up passes, making tackles and tackles for loss vs. the run, etc. So he'd have had to progress to the point where he's feared.

With things the way they are now in GBL, two identical CB's would progress at the same rate no matter how many or how few plays they make. That's not realistic.

Originally posted by Bort

What about the FB who makes great blocks for his HB but never gets a pancake? He's got no stats to give him an XP boost.


Yeah, but you guys don't even keep pancake block stats for fullbacks right now. I figure a "great block" would register as a pancake for FB's if you guys decided to add it as a trackable stat for that position.


 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SAGA45
Yeah, but you guys don't even keep pancake block stats for fullbacks right now. I figure a "great block" would register as a pancake for FB's if you guys decided to add it as a trackable stat for that position.



Pancakes aren't even a very good stat for offensive linemen.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by SAGA45

Yeah, but you guys don't even keep pancake block stats for fullbacks right now. I figure a "great block" would register as a pancake for FB's if you guys decided to add it as a trackable stat for that position.



Pancakes aren't even a very good stat for offensive linemen.


But you have to track big blocks in the running game somehow and right now, pancakes offer the best way to do it. I know Stats Inc. tracks Sacks Allowed, Sack Yards, False Starts, Holds, and Penalty Yards for O-line guys which is good. But penalties have yet to be added to GBL. However, I did read it was a high priority to get them in which is a good sign.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 17:55:57
 
boomer82
offline
Link
 
This is a good idea in theory, but how do you reward the ones who do their job so well they don't get noticed?

Like Bort said, how do you reward the CB who has 10 passes thrown at him ALL YEAR (random example)? He's clearly the best but will have very few stats.

OLs with pancakes aren't necessarily the best ones. I'd rather have an OL with 0 pancakes and 0 sacks allowed than 10 pancakes and 1 sack allowed.

The reputation idea will be fun to mess with and see how it impacts the game.
 
stregone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by boomer82
This is a good idea in theory, but how do you reward the ones who do their job so well they don't get noticed?

Like Bort said, how do you reward the CB who has 10 passes thrown at him ALL YEAR (random example)? He's clearly the best but will have very few stats.

OLs with pancakes aren't necessarily the best ones. I'd rather have an OL with 0 pancakes and 0 sacks allowed than 10 pancakes and 1 sack allowed.

The reputation idea will be fun to mess with and see how it impacts the game.


Just give the bonus to all players on the field.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
How to you give an XP bonus for good stats to a CB who never gets thrown to, because he locks his man down? He wouldn't have any ints, pd's, or tackles, but he performed really well. What about the FB who makes great blocks for his HB but never gets a pancake? He's got no stats to give him an XP boost.
We have to stop confusing things here.

What SAGA45 and I see is the fact that players such as the lockdown corner who plays an entire game and the weak, low level players who fail are rewarded with an increased amount of experience regardless of their performance. Meanwhile, players who perform well fall through a crack of no rewards.

What we are trying to do is account for things the current XP system lacks. The XP system doesn't lack in providing for any of the players you mention. The only player we see not being rewarded are the ones who actually perform.

We don't see a need for a bonus for these other kinds of players, because in a way, the XP system already assures they get a bonus... because the lockdown corner will start and take an overwhelming majority of snaps (and hence more XP) and the weaker players get more XP per snap and per day.

As SAGA45 said, in the current system what we'll have are two players in every position (one who makes plays and another who doesn't) who will both progress to superstar status... a concept that is not correct.

Originally posted by Bort
I understand that you want to feel like you are being rewarded in some way for a good performance on the field, but we are not going to give extra XP for it. End of season trophies, better contracts, cash bonuses, a morale boost, etc are all rewards for doing well. We even have some ideas for your player gaining a reputation for being a stud, and causing morale effects on the other team, etc.
Like I said, the only concern here is the fact that stats are relegated to an aesthetic in the game.

As we've all shown both for or against, there are a lot of ways in which skill is raised. People getting stats is one such way of skill improvement. Obviously if there are other ways to reward stats as a skill increasing phenomenon without having to delve into XP, I'm not against that. But the game has to find a way to reward stats.
Last edited Apr 13, 2008 21:24:14
 
boomer82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kinglehr
Like I said, the only concern here is the fact that stats are relegated to an aesthetic in the game.

As we've all shown both for or against, there are a lot of ways in which skill is raised. Obviously if there are other ways to reward stats as a skill increasing phenomenon without having to delve into XP, I'm not against that. But the game has to find a way to reward stats.


Reward stats? How about the fact if you're good, better teams will want to sign you and you can move up to "better" leagues? Or the team you're on has that much of a better chance of winning?

Rewards don't have to be all about the individual.
 
SAGA45
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by boomer82
Reward stats?


Yes, in the form of increased player progress. Right now, in-game performance, other than the amount snaps played, appears to have absolutely no bearing on the player's progression rate. As mentioned many times before, that's highly unrealistic considering two identical players, who get an equal amount of playing time, would progress at the same rate regardless of how either of them performs on the field. That shouldn't be the case.

As kinglehr stated, there needs to be a reward for in-game performance that goes toward increasing that player's rate of progression. Right now, other than Boosting, it's through gaining XP that a player levels up and skill points are awarded. Unless the devs would rather award skill points directly (which I doubt they would), XP should be one of the means by which in-game performance is rewarded.
 
kinglehr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by boomer82
Originally posted by kinglehr

Like I said, the only concern here is the fact that stats are relegated to an aesthetic in the game.

As we've all shown both for or against, there are a lot of ways in which skill is raised. Obviously if there are other ways to reward stats as a skill increasing phenomenon without having to delve into XP, I'm not against that. But the game has to find a way to reward stats.


Reward stats? How about the fact if you're good, better teams will want to sign you and you can move up to "better" leagues? Or the team you're on has that much of a better chance of winning?

Rewards don't have to be all about the individual.
You're on the wrong forum for this argument. The argument is about stats as a skill increasing phenomenon, not some kind of self-gratification.
 
Link
 
What if, instead of getting an XP bonus, the bonus goes directly to the stat in question.

If a CB makes a nice INT, give him a X bonus to his catch attribute. If a DE makes a big hit, give a bonus to his tackle ability, etc.
OR
Give a temporary boost for the rest of Quarter/Half/Game. Sort of an "In the Zone" thing.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.