User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Muraske
offline
Link
 
I think in regards the longevity of the game and fairness to everyone, you keep the rules as they are, promote the A league teams and demote the AA league teams.

You can't go changing the way you run the game just because some team who *intentionally* recruited all level 13's so they could *win the championship* doesn't want to get promoted, they all knew what they were getting into when it happened.

They gameplanned to win the championship in the A leagues, they know they get promoted, there shouldn't be any exceptions.
 
fixxxer101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Verde Verde Verde
First point of arguement, this thread was created for Canada AA players and owners, not all the A players and owners.

Second point, the top A teams that won championships should be able to compete come next season. I have seen some that have 7,500,000 plus to spend on stadium construction, which alot of AA teams could only dream of. With that kind of financial basis, they will be able to bring in some better players and at very least avoid the bottom two. In Canada AA#1 we had teams taken over midseason, they completely rebuilt and made the playoffs. AT the point they were taken, they were in 14yth out of 16. Tehjre is no reason a promoted team couldn't build a very competitive team. As levels get higher, the gap becomes less noticeable and more relies on gameplanning.


Well, my team is now considered AA if the promotions go through, so I feel my voice should be heard as well. I am not A or AA, I am Aa.

I pay my money like everyone else and just wish for the same opportunity to build a team good enough to stand a chance in the AA Group. It isn't just the cap or just the half season, it is the combination of the two. I think people are forgetting we only got 8 games this season to build on before the playoffs. Just compare the teams, it is insane. I saw an argument that someone made basically saying that it wouldn't matter if we wait one more season or not, the gap between the teams will still be the same. That couldn't be any more wrong. The lower level guys are gonna move up about 4 or 5 levels in the same time the higher level guys will move up 2 or 3. It would give us a huge chance to hold our own when we arrive in the AA.

And a little off subject, an idea I have been thinking of is to create a new league for team that people could buy that there is no promotion or demotion. Of course that would be a while from now, it is just an idea. This gives the chance to make rivalrys. And that would keep anyone from whining. That way they know what to plan and there couldn't be any issues taking place like this one. That would be HUGE to me. I love a good rivalry.
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 12:20:27
 
DaveTN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

If that is your argument, then we should go ahead with promotions, not suddenly change the plan and skip them.


Then make the definitive statement that promotions are going to occur.

It is the indecision which is hindering teams in their ability to make plans and changes for next season. I'm sure you can see that. The longer you debate about promotion/relegation the more handicap you've unintentionally given to all involved.

.

Last edited Jul 21, 2008 12:25:56
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaveTN
Originally posted by Bort


If that is your argument, then we should go ahead with promotions, not suddenly change the plan and skip them.


Then make the definitive statement that promotions are going to occur.

It is the indecision which is hindering teams in their ability to make plans and changes for next season.



The cap is being lifted. Your plans should be the same either way: recruit some players. Everyone else in your league is going to do it, no matter where you play.

In any case, I'll make an announcement tonight along with a state of the game thread.
 
DaveTN
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'll make an announcement tonight along with a state of the game thread.


Thank you!

 
jokerpac32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by DaveTN

Originally posted by Bort



If that is your argument, then we should go ahead with promotions, not suddenly change the plan and skip them.


Then make the definitive statement that promotions are going to occur.

It is the indecision which is hindering teams in their ability to make plans and changes for next season.



We love you Bort no doubt about it. No matter what you decide all teams will have to deal with it. But when you do compare those AA teams that would be demoted on paper they'll destroy the A teams and vice versa with the A's going to AA.

The cap is being lifted. Your plans should be the same either way: recruit some players. Everyone else in your league is going to do it, no matter where you play.

In any case, I'll make an announcement tonight along with a state of the game thread.


 
MrWiggly
offline
Link
 
I think better game planning and builds could win against higher levels any day. To a certain degree. Which an A level League Champion would have to have.

It could even bring more interest to the AA team that got demoted to win a few games and increase their players interest.

The A league teams I checked out were 3-5 lvls lower than the average of the AA teams. Given that some of the lower level AA teams are not as active or run well means that a well run A team that is 3-5 levels lower could still win games. Maybe not be a Championship contender their very first season in AA.

It also could mean that the A league team drops back down next season. Which would give them their extra year to level up and come back and kick all our AA butts the next season.

Just my 2 cents from an AA League team with an awefull OC
 
jokerpac32
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrWiggly
I think better game planning and builds could win against higher levels any day. To a certain degree. Which an A level League Champion would have to have.

It could even bring more interest to the AA team that got demoted to win a few games and increase their players interest.

The A league teams I checked out were 3-5 lvls lower than the average of the AA teams. Given that some of the lower level AA teams are not as active or run well means that a well run A team that is 3-5 levels lower could still win games. Maybe not be a Championship contender their very first season in AA.

It also could mean that the A league team drops back down next season. Which would give them their extra year to level up and come back and kick all our AA butts the next season.

Just my 2 cents from an AA League team with an awefull OC


Not a bad post, but remember the A teams only had 8 games. Sure there was some scrimmages and what not that made cash, but a human own team makes alot more. I think if the A teams that got promoted if they get promoted were given some extra cash it would be of help. Might be able to over pay a guy or two to even the playing field.
 
trauty
offline
Link
 
To compete in A next season, we probably need to recruit 8-10 guys at most (not saying we'll be able to keep up with all the teams that stack but at least their chemistry will be shot for half the season). To compete in AA, we will need to recruit 20-30 players. The thing I have a problem with is telling the guys on the team "Thanks for helping us win a championship. For your efforts, we are shipping you out of here because you aren't good enough to even backup." Most teams that get promoted in other leagues have a good enough roster to at least compete with the middle of the league they are going to -- they just need to make a few changes to be able to make a good showing in the league -- and almost none of them have to worry about demotion, Canada A at present teams might be able to compete with the 14th, 15th, or 16th teams. We are also screwed by chemistry hits if we overhaul our team.
 
Padre
offline
Link
 
If this is stupid then let it bet stupid but it was the best thought I could come up with. I wonder if there is a big difference between A and AA; if A teams coming up could receive extra money so they can afford higher level players or perhaps a free boost or two or three to the players already on the team.

I am one of the A teams and look forward to the challenge of being sent up. However I do also realize we only had 8 games to develop our team instead of 16. I really enjoy most of the Agents on my team and would hate to cut them loose because of the short season.

Either way I am just happy to be playing.

As a side note the Eagles championship game is tonight at 7:00 PM. Call your local cable provide for this once in a lifetime Pay-Per View Event.
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 16:22:44
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scarpenter23
So in other words they want to punish the team in AA that struggled because they had to change most of roster last year and make them stay where they get hammered again so they dont have to go through a bad season. All I know is if a team goes through a bad year and things dont get better.... Then players want to go and then you take chem. hits again and the cycle repeats... We got behind do to nonboosters... the chem hits and losses mounted and we never recovered... I dont think there is any right/wrong or fair way to do this... But, we gotta know so if we do have to stay we can at least try to get the highest level guys in we can to compete this season...



How is it punishing them when they weren't going to be relegated until half way through the season? Instead now those owners at the bottom get REWARDED for being crappy teams.
 
trauty
offline
Link
 
At minimum, the teams moving up from A need a chemistry grace period. If we stay at A, we will make around 10 moves which would equal about 20 chemistry points (since it's one for each addition and 1 for each subtraction)-- that's not a big deal. However, if we move up to AA, just to make it so we don't lose by 100 points a game, we will need to make around 30 moves or more which would annihilate our chemistry and make it so we have no chance at all anyway. Moving us up would eliminate being able to keep the core together. We will deal with whatever hand we are dealt, we refused to be one of the teams that deliberately lost the championship just to avoid promotion. I don't regret that for a minute. Just wish that such a grim fate didn't await us at AA.
 
daysend
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jokerpac32
Originally posted by MrWiggly

I think better game planning and builds could win against higher levels any day. To a certain degree. Which an A level League Champion would have to have.

It could even bring more interest to the AA team that got demoted to win a few games and increase their players interest.

The A league teams I checked out were 3-5 lvls lower than the average of the AA teams. Given that some of the lower level AA teams are not as active or run well means that a well run A team that is 3-5 levels lower could still win games. Maybe not be a Championship contender their very first season in AA.

It also could mean that the A league team drops back down next season. Which would give them their extra year to level up and come back and kick all our AA butts the next season.

Just my 2 cents from an AA League team with an awefull OC


Not a bad post, but remember the A teams only had 8 games. Sure there was some scrimmages and what not that made cash, but a human own team makes alot more. I think if the A teams that got promoted if they get promoted were given some extra cash it would be of help. Might be able to over pay a guy or two to even the playing field.


You have over $1M in the bank. Go sign some players before the rush is on. Your selling point is that you did so well that you are getting promoted.
 
trauty
offline
Link
 
How are you gonna sign players before the rush is on. We can't sign anybody over level 13 until the rollover. By then the rush will already be on. Most high level guys will be available then and a lot don't mind going to a rebuilding team but you gotta have at least a few pieces in place and we haven't been allowed to try to put those pieces in place.
Last edited Jul 21, 2008 18:58:56
 
EagleScream
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaveTN
A major part of the problem is this is now day 40 and Bort is still seeking opinions on this issue. If Bort had made a decision, right or wrong, and posted it a long time ago then teams would have had a decent amount of time to adjust accordingly.


Greetings,

I suspect Bort did have a decision that was already locked (A winner promoted, AA last place demoted) but he is just seeing if he made the right decision and if he gets enough details that he didn't he will reverse it else it stands

Cheers, Eagle Scream
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.