Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
Guppy, Inc
offline
offline
I cant beleive how many people cant understand how important game planning is. Every OC on my losing teams complained but they simply got outcoached.
Warlock, we already took this discussion in the BBB #14 forum yesterday and like I said, the NFL record for sacks in a game is 7, and if I remember correctly Umenyiora had 6 against the Eagles as late as last season. So it is not totally unrealistic. It is an extremely impressive performance on the boundaries of what should be possible, but you are talking about the unanimous defensive MVP of the league.
We have beaten you 30-9 and 22-6 this season, and you somehow complain that it is because the sim is broken?
You have a very good team, but I think that the Golfers also deserves some respect and it is not totally unrealistic that we beat you when we have higher-level starters and back-ups with what I think is very good builds.
We have beaten you 30-9 and 22-6 this season, and you somehow complain that it is because the sim is broken?
You have a very good team, but I think that the Golfers also deserves some respect and it is not totally unrealistic that we beat you when we have higher-level starters and back-ups with what I think is very good builds.
Originally posted by CaptainAmerica
Originally posted by Warlock
Explain to me how we gave up as many sacks in this last game, as we did for the entire season combined (all 17 games)... we even played the same team earlier in the season, yet somehow they managed 4 times the number of sacks this time around.
Maybe they boosted before the playoffs.
Dee leveled up 3 times before the playoffs, yes.
Originally posted by Warlock
Explain to me how we gave up as many sacks in this last game, as we did for the entire season combined (all 17 games)... we even played the same team earlier in the season, yet somehow they managed 4 times the number of sacks this time around.
Maybe they boosted before the playoffs.
Dee leveled up 3 times before the playoffs, yes.
ryan20662
offline
offline
Just as long as you don't expect him to do the same thing against the Assassins cavalier.
Warlock
offline
offline
glb.center,
Yes, because they added setting for specific DL play, right? Game-planning is very simplistic atm, it has very little to do with a DE having an 11 tackle, 6 sack, 5 hurry performance... build on the other hand does, but is his build worthy of that type of performance? Possibly, but based on other data concerning the player and previous opponents, I'd say no it wasn't. That's my point, this game is borked, if the sim has that much weight in how a game unfolds. A couple of plays shouldn't set the tone of an entire game, especially when those plays are heavily influenced by the sim. We can debate whether or not the sim was responsible for the missed assignments or if it was in-fact build-related, but my opinion is that it snowballed after the sim screwed us on the first few plays. Hence the sims fault.
Cavalier,
I never put down your team, I only want to know the logic behind such results. I'm sorry if you take that as a slight against your team, but it's not the case. I also never said it was unrealistic that we lost, merely that a player had such a dominating performance (one that was only matched against some of the worst teams in the league). Where in my posts do I say anything, remotely negative about your team... if you take my questioning the sim as disrespect, I honestly don't know what to tell you.
Yes, because they added setting for specific DL play, right? Game-planning is very simplistic atm, it has very little to do with a DE having an 11 tackle, 6 sack, 5 hurry performance... build on the other hand does, but is his build worthy of that type of performance? Possibly, but based on other data concerning the player and previous opponents, I'd say no it wasn't. That's my point, this game is borked, if the sim has that much weight in how a game unfolds. A couple of plays shouldn't set the tone of an entire game, especially when those plays are heavily influenced by the sim. We can debate whether or not the sim was responsible for the missed assignments or if it was in-fact build-related, but my opinion is that it snowballed after the sim screwed us on the first few plays. Hence the sims fault.
Cavalier,
I never put down your team, I only want to know the logic behind such results. I'm sorry if you take that as a slight against your team, but it's not the case. I also never said it was unrealistic that we lost, merely that a player had such a dominating performance (one that was only matched against some of the worst teams in the league). Where in my posts do I say anything, remotely negative about your team... if you take my questioning the sim as disrespect, I honestly don't know what to tell you.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Well you're either:
A - suggesting the sim screwed you because his player isn't as good as his single game performance dictated.
or
B - suggesting his player isn't as good as it is because.
Either which way you're choosing to criticise the sim based on the performance of players, which in turn is a slight upon those players.
In his first game against you the DE had a good performance. 5 levels later - he murdered you. I think that speaks volumes.
A - suggesting the sim screwed you because his player isn't as good as his single game performance dictated.
or
B - suggesting his player isn't as good as it is because.
Either which way you're choosing to criticise the sim based on the performance of players, which in turn is a slight upon those players.
In his first game against you the DE had a good performance. 5 levels later - he murdered you. I think that speaks volumes.
Warlock
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
Well you're either:
A - suggesting the sim screwed you because his player isn't as good as his single game performance dictated.
or
B - suggesting his player isn't as good as it is because.
Either which way you're choosing to criticise the sim based on the performance of players, which in turn is a slight upon those players.
In his first game against you the DE had a good performance. 5 levels later - he murdered you. I think that speaks volumes.
C - take what was said for what it's worth. Unlike many others, I say what I mean. If I intended to criticize his player or team, I'd have come right out and said so. We could interpret everything multiple ways... unfortunately, people are constantly looking for something that probably isn't there.
You know like the whole political correctness thing. For example, if I call someone a loser, why would that be offensive? Either they are a loser, making the statement indeed accurate (so why would it be offensive?) or they're not a loser and the statement is inaccurate (yet again, why would it be offensive?). Instead, we'd end up calling the person "success challenged", which is the same thing, just a nicer way of saying it. It still doesn't change the facts of the matter though.
It's all good though, obviously, poor sportsmanship only goes one way... not like I wouldn't be happy if I won a game through questionable circumstances, right? Fair play is only that thing losers whine about, because they didn't win...
If you do not think that some of the things in this sim aren't questionable (taking into account all the known factors), that's your choice, I personally would like to understand why this anomaly happened. I took the "tough shit" response last season when the sim clearly ignored the team's game-plan, I'm a bit tired of it at this point... I don't feel that an explanation is completely out of line. If the developers feel that I'm wrong in wanting an explanation, so be it, but every action has a consequence. I won't continue to support a company that approaches things this way. I'm only one person, but with that business philosophy, I'm sure that I won't be the last.
Well you're either:
A - suggesting the sim screwed you because his player isn't as good as his single game performance dictated.
or
B - suggesting his player isn't as good as it is because.
Either which way you're choosing to criticise the sim based on the performance of players, which in turn is a slight upon those players.
In his first game against you the DE had a good performance. 5 levels later - he murdered you. I think that speaks volumes.
C - take what was said for what it's worth. Unlike many others, I say what I mean. If I intended to criticize his player or team, I'd have come right out and said so. We could interpret everything multiple ways... unfortunately, people are constantly looking for something that probably isn't there.
You know like the whole political correctness thing. For example, if I call someone a loser, why would that be offensive? Either they are a loser, making the statement indeed accurate (so why would it be offensive?) or they're not a loser and the statement is inaccurate (yet again, why would it be offensive?). Instead, we'd end up calling the person "success challenged", which is the same thing, just a nicer way of saying it. It still doesn't change the facts of the matter though.
It's all good though, obviously, poor sportsmanship only goes one way... not like I wouldn't be happy if I won a game through questionable circumstances, right? Fair play is only that thing losers whine about, because they didn't win...
If you do not think that some of the things in this sim aren't questionable (taking into account all the known factors), that's your choice, I personally would like to understand why this anomaly happened. I took the "tough shit" response last season when the sim clearly ignored the team's game-plan, I'm a bit tired of it at this point... I don't feel that an explanation is completely out of line. If the developers feel that I'm wrong in wanting an explanation, so be it, but every action has a consequence. I won't continue to support a company that approaches things this way. I'm only one person, but with that business philosophy, I'm sure that I won't be the last.
driftinggrifter
offline
offline
1 Get a better coordinator
2 Get better players
3 Boost before the playoffs not during the season.
Other than that I really don't know what to tell ya.
Oh yeah, never overlook confidence, its a very fragile thing.
2 Get better players
3 Boost before the playoffs not during the season.
Other than that I really don't know what to tell ya.
Oh yeah, never overlook confidence, its a very fragile thing.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by Warlock
If you do not think that some of the things in this sim aren't questionable (taking into account all the known factors), that's your choice, I personally would like to understand why this anomaly happened. I took the "tough shit" response last season when the sim clearly ignored the team's game-plan, I'm a bit tired of it at this point... I don't feel that an explanation is completely out of line. If the developers feel that I'm wrong in wanting an explanation, so be it, but every action has a consequence. I won't continue to support a company that approaches things this way. I'm only one person, but with that business philosophy, I'm sure that I won't be the last.
I think plenty in the sim is questionable. Or at least there are dozens of variables that can influence it long after you've finished tweaking percentages. For instance my own team just ran 200 yards on a team we should never run 200 yards on...but we got momentum going and kept on moving. I suspect that they tried to 'cope' with our passing game seeing it as our major threat...only to have our pretty good running game come back and bite them in the ass.
It all depends on if you class it as an anomaly. Or just something that happens in football.
Your approach seemed to be "we were going to get beat anyway, but I don't like how we got beat". Which is fine. But if you knew or felt you were going to get beat, you must have had an inkling as to 'why'? Maybe it was the fact that in one game already your QB had his arse handed to him by their pass rush?
I still feel you're looking for an excuse in the sim, rather than thinking "hmm, what could he have changed in 5 levels of player enhancement since we played them at the beginning of the year". Or "maybe his build is that superior now that he has his 3 extra boosts stacked".
If you do not think that some of the things in this sim aren't questionable (taking into account all the known factors), that's your choice, I personally would like to understand why this anomaly happened. I took the "tough shit" response last season when the sim clearly ignored the team's game-plan, I'm a bit tired of it at this point... I don't feel that an explanation is completely out of line. If the developers feel that I'm wrong in wanting an explanation, so be it, but every action has a consequence. I won't continue to support a company that approaches things this way. I'm only one person, but with that business philosophy, I'm sure that I won't be the last.
I think plenty in the sim is questionable. Or at least there are dozens of variables that can influence it long after you've finished tweaking percentages. For instance my own team just ran 200 yards on a team we should never run 200 yards on...but we got momentum going and kept on moving. I suspect that they tried to 'cope' with our passing game seeing it as our major threat...only to have our pretty good running game come back and bite them in the ass.
It all depends on if you class it as an anomaly. Or just something that happens in football.
Your approach seemed to be "we were going to get beat anyway, but I don't like how we got beat". Which is fine. But if you knew or felt you were going to get beat, you must have had an inkling as to 'why'? Maybe it was the fact that in one game already your QB had his arse handed to him by their pass rush?
I still feel you're looking for an excuse in the sim, rather than thinking "hmm, what could he have changed in 5 levels of player enhancement since we played them at the beginning of the year". Or "maybe his build is that superior now that he has his 3 extra boosts stacked".
Last edited Jul 19, 2008 07:15:15
Warlock
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Warlock
If you do not think that some of the things in this sim aren't questionable (taking into account all the known factors), that's your choice, I personally would like to understand why this anomaly happened. I took the "tough shit" response last season when the sim clearly ignored the team's game-plan, I'm a bit tired of it at this point... I don't feel that an explanation is completely out of line. If the developers feel that I'm wrong in wanting an explanation, so be it, but every action has a consequence. I won't continue to support a company that approaches things this way. I'm only one person, but with that business philosophy, I'm sure that I won't be the last.
I think plenty in the sim is questionable. Or at least there are dozens of variables that can influence it long after you've finished tweaking percentages. For instance my own team just ran 200 yards on a team we should never run 200 yards on...but we got momentum going and kept on moving. I suspect that they tried to 'cope' with our passing game seeing it as our major threat...only to have our pretty good running game come back and bite them in the ass.
It all depends on if you class it as an anomaly. Or just something that happens in football.
Your approach seemed to be "we were going to get beat anyway, but I don't like how we got beat". Which is fine. But if you knew or felt you were going to get beat, you must have had an inkling as to 'why'? Maybe it was the fact that in one game already your QB had his arse handed to him by their pass rush?
I still feel you're looking for an excuse in the sim, rather than thinking "hmm, what could he have changed in 5 levels of player enhancement since we played them at the beginning of the year". Or "maybe his build is that superior now that he has his 3 extra boosts stacked".
I'm not looking for an excuse, but if you don't ask questions, issues won't be found (and hopefully adjusted). It's how we as "beta-testers" help make the game better. Unfortunately, the developers seem to be content keeping us in the dark with vague answers or "tough shit" responses. That doesn't bode well for the game.
This is a simulation, to me, this means that they're aiming to make it accurate and/or realistic. I played competitive football at high levels, I can give you plenty of reasons why a 6 sack performance is neither accurate or realistic in this particular game...
A - This was against a top play-off team that has a very high chemistry, mistakes that were displayed in the sim (such as botched blocking assignments), wouldn't have happened as frequently. At the very least, to the starters. Otherwise, what's the point of having chemistry?
B - In the real world, when a player is completely over-matched, the team adjusts to help that player with their assignments. When I played DE in college and used to beat the LT, after a couple times, I had a HB/FB in my face every play and/or they took advantage of my penetration by running inside the tackle (effectively taking me out of the play or forcing me to play the run more). There's no option to do this in game-planning and the sim obviously doesn't do it for us. I played LT in semi-pro, so I understand both positions, extremely well. This is also the reason why 6+ sacks single player performances are so rare in the NFL, but 6+ sack games aren't as uncommon... by focusing on a stopping a great player, it gives other players more opportunities to make the play instead.
C - It takes more than a bad series or two, before a player's confidence is totally destroyed. My game was intimidation when I played, so I know all about confidence. It usually took at least two or three series before I'd totally demoralize an opponent, to the point where they started to make mental mistakes.
D - While the DE is a very good player, based on the first play-off game (in which he was already boosted and had a pretty good game), his numbers went through the roof proportionally. You can compare the starting LTs for both games and you can argue build and level (1 level difference between them), but is it such a vast difference that it meant a 300% increase in performance? I'd say no and if certain factors within the sim caused this dramatic increase in a player's performance (such as confidence and luck)... I'd say that it's an issue that needs to be adjusted, not chalked up as an excuse... because it's pretty unrealistic/inaccurate/random/etc... at least in the extent to which it effects things.
Now, this only matters if the developers are trying to make the sim accurate and/or realistic. If that's not the case, a simple answer is all I need to know, I'd rather not be a part of this game.
Originally posted by Warlock
If you do not think that some of the things in this sim aren't questionable (taking into account all the known factors), that's your choice, I personally would like to understand why this anomaly happened. I took the "tough shit" response last season when the sim clearly ignored the team's game-plan, I'm a bit tired of it at this point... I don't feel that an explanation is completely out of line. If the developers feel that I'm wrong in wanting an explanation, so be it, but every action has a consequence. I won't continue to support a company that approaches things this way. I'm only one person, but with that business philosophy, I'm sure that I won't be the last.
I think plenty in the sim is questionable. Or at least there are dozens of variables that can influence it long after you've finished tweaking percentages. For instance my own team just ran 200 yards on a team we should never run 200 yards on...but we got momentum going and kept on moving. I suspect that they tried to 'cope' with our passing game seeing it as our major threat...only to have our pretty good running game come back and bite them in the ass.
It all depends on if you class it as an anomaly. Or just something that happens in football.
Your approach seemed to be "we were going to get beat anyway, but I don't like how we got beat". Which is fine. But if you knew or felt you were going to get beat, you must have had an inkling as to 'why'? Maybe it was the fact that in one game already your QB had his arse handed to him by their pass rush?
I still feel you're looking for an excuse in the sim, rather than thinking "hmm, what could he have changed in 5 levels of player enhancement since we played them at the beginning of the year". Or "maybe his build is that superior now that he has his 3 extra boosts stacked".
I'm not looking for an excuse, but if you don't ask questions, issues won't be found (and hopefully adjusted). It's how we as "beta-testers" help make the game better. Unfortunately, the developers seem to be content keeping us in the dark with vague answers or "tough shit" responses. That doesn't bode well for the game.
This is a simulation, to me, this means that they're aiming to make it accurate and/or realistic. I played competitive football at high levels, I can give you plenty of reasons why a 6 sack performance is neither accurate or realistic in this particular game...
A - This was against a top play-off team that has a very high chemistry, mistakes that were displayed in the sim (such as botched blocking assignments), wouldn't have happened as frequently. At the very least, to the starters. Otherwise, what's the point of having chemistry?
B - In the real world, when a player is completely over-matched, the team adjusts to help that player with their assignments. When I played DE in college and used to beat the LT, after a couple times, I had a HB/FB in my face every play and/or they took advantage of my penetration by running inside the tackle (effectively taking me out of the play or forcing me to play the run more). There's no option to do this in game-planning and the sim obviously doesn't do it for us. I played LT in semi-pro, so I understand both positions, extremely well. This is also the reason why 6+ sacks single player performances are so rare in the NFL, but 6+ sack games aren't as uncommon... by focusing on a stopping a great player, it gives other players more opportunities to make the play instead.
C - It takes more than a bad series or two, before a player's confidence is totally destroyed. My game was intimidation when I played, so I know all about confidence. It usually took at least two or three series before I'd totally demoralize an opponent, to the point where they started to make mental mistakes.
D - While the DE is a very good player, based on the first play-off game (in which he was already boosted and had a pretty good game), his numbers went through the roof proportionally. You can compare the starting LTs for both games and you can argue build and level (1 level difference between them), but is it such a vast difference that it meant a 300% increase in performance? I'd say no and if certain factors within the sim caused this dramatic increase in a player's performance (such as confidence and luck)... I'd say that it's an issue that needs to be adjusted, not chalked up as an excuse... because it's pretty unrealistic/inaccurate/random/etc... at least in the extent to which it effects things.
Now, this only matters if the developers are trying to make the sim accurate and/or realistic. If that's not the case, a simple answer is all I need to know, I'd rather not be a part of this game.
Koncorde
offline
offline
See, as soon as you bring numbers of % into it, you're really asking to be owned on several levels.
Adrian Peterson on October 28th against Philadelphia ran for 70 yards on 20 carries, for a 3.5 avg.
Adrian Peterson on November 4th against San Diego Chargers ran for 296 yards on 30 carries, for a 9.9 yard average.
That's a 400% increase. And he didn't even boost for that game.
So much for realism?
Adrian Peterson on October 28th against Philadelphia ran for 70 yards on 20 carries, for a 3.5 avg.
Adrian Peterson on November 4th against San Diego Chargers ran for 296 yards on 30 carries, for a 9.9 yard average.
That's a 400% increase. And he didn't even boost for that game.
So much for realism?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























