User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ATTN: Tying Flex Points to Contracts as an Incentive or Condition
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by oldskool

It's a rule that has "the full backing of all Moderators and Admins" with a screenshot clearly showing an admin's dissenting opinion of it.


That screenshot was before this was agreed upon.

edit: actually, you can see the date was 3 days ago. This rule was just agreed on today.


I realize that I'm just saying that everybody (Thorn especially, sadly) should be on guard about that.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pontiacnutt
I dont use it to recruit, but I did last season buy flex for committed players, who were either coaches/gm's or as an award like season mvp or something like that. but I've never "advertised" it or used it as a means to recruit. In fact I didn't even post it in my team forum, but handled it via pm's privatly. If what I'm doing is wrong the ban me now.



Edit Clarification:
Only if it's tied to signing a contract or re-signing a contract. Our focus is stopping the practice as a recruiting tool.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 15:20:03
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by norsemanvike
Originally posted by pontiacnutt

I dont use it to recruit, but I did last season buy flex for committed players, who were either coaches/gm's or as an award like season mvp or something like that. but I've never "advertised" it or used it as a means to recruit. In fact I didn't even post it in my team forum, but handled it via pm's privatly. If what I'm doing is wrong the ban me now.



As long as it's not tied to signing a contract or re-signing a contract. Our focus is stopping the practice as a recruiting tool.


.....that doesn't even make sense. As long as I don't directly use it to get you to sign a contract it's fine?

How do you know if that guy is (re-)signing because he wants to be here or if he thinks he can lead the team in rushing and get FP out of it?
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v63/Creech/fpcontractsoklx7-1.jpg

Are we just posting stuff or did we actually come to a consensus.


It was a unanimous decision with the admins and mods.
 
usafdirtboyz
offline
Link
 
Umm, before I get in trouble I need to know if I did this the wrong way, I had offered to buy 500 FP for the 2 lowest rated players on my team, to get a little more depth, and make the team better as a whole, and asked if they would go into a 2 year deal with the team they are already on. Is that doing it the wrong way? No one has taken me up on the offer yet and if it is wrong then I need to take it down.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by TuNice

Its BS really. No matter what way you want to look at it, the people with money are always going to be ahead of those without it. So now you not only disallow players without money to succeed in the future but you dont allow a regulated way to transfer flex points between friends now you dont even allow it AT ALL. The argument is it will ruin the player market but in reality, if the owner really wanted too, he could use the FPs to make his own damn player and boost him. Which would be advantageous to him. Instead both people win. What players choose to do with THEIR OWN MONEY should be their own business. This rule is more un-ethical than that of the suspected owners.


"...as a condition of signing a contract with a team..."

Did you miss that part? You seem to be arguing that this hurts your ability to transfer FP between friends. This rule is aimed at people basically offering/asking for FP to play for a team.


How does one do this magical "transfer between friends"? Or is this just an instance where you can buy your friend xome flex points using his account or giving him money via paypal?

Can I give flex points to players already on my team?

Is this rule retroactive? Or will it only be enforced from here on out?
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by usafdirtboyz
Umm, before I get in trouble I need to know if I did this the wrong way, I had offered to buy 500 FP for the 2 lowest rated players on my team, to get a little more depth, and make the team better as a whole, and asked if they would go into a 2 year deal with the team they are already on. Is that doing it the wrong way? No one has taken me up on the offer yet and if it is wrong then I need to take it down.


This would be against the rules because you tied it to a 2 year extension.

Edit: Spelling
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 15:27:52
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
.....that doesn't even make sense. As long as I don't directly use it to get you to sign a contract it's fine?

How do you know if that guy is (re-)signing because he wants to be here or if he thinks he can lead the team in rushing and get FP out of it?


As with some of the rules on this site, we're not going to be able to 100% police it ourselves. We rely quite a bit on the community to help us out and that applies here as well.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk

"...as a condition of signing a contract with a team..."

Did you miss that part? You seem to be arguing that this hurts your ability to transfer FP between friends. This rule is aimed at people basically offering/asking for FP to play for a team.


How does one do this magical "transfer between friends"? Or is this just an instance where you can buy your friend xome flex points using his account or giving him money via paypal?

Can I give flex points to players already on my team?

Is this rule retroactive? Or will it only be enforced from here on out?

Q: Is this rule retroactive? Or will it only be enforced from here on out?
A: Moving forward it will be enforced.

Q: Can I give flex points to players already on my team?
A: As long as it's not tied to a condition of any contract; new, re-negotiated, or otherwise.

Q: How does one do this magical "transfer between friends"? Or is this just an instance where you can buy your friend xome flex points using his account or giving him money via paypal?
A: The second half or your question is your answer.
 
usafdirtboyz
offline
Link
 
OK then I will take it down.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
How does one do this magical "transfer between friends"? Or is this just an instance where you can buy your friend xome flex points using his account or giving him money via paypal?

Can I give flex points to players already on my team?

Is this rule retroactive? Or will it only be enforced from here on out?


That example (a b-day present or whatever) is when, if you log into a friends' account and buy him/her FP, it won't be against the rules (yet).

If it's a gift from one person to another and not even loosely tied to recruiting/keeping players, it'll be allowed (for now). If it's worded as a gift, but it's really like an NCAA player getting a gift from an agent with a and a "hope" that the player will sign with that agent when he goes pro, that's illegal. It'll be on a case-by-case basis.

I don't think it would be fair to do it retroactively, but I don't think that was discussed. Unless I missed that part and someone posts otherwise, consider that rule in effect from the time the first post in this thread was made.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by oldskool

.....that doesn't even make sense. As long as I don't directly use it to get you to sign a contract it's fine?

How do you know if that guy is (re-)signing because he wants to be here or if he thinks he can lead the team in rushing and get FP out of it?


As with some of the rules on this site, we're not going to be able to 100% police it ourselves. We rely quite a bit on the community to help us out and that applies here as well.


So we're back to the squeaky wheel gets the grease? It's only fitting that a rule implemented by a bunch of whining is policed & enforced by that same bunch of whiners.

I concede that avoiding turning GLB into CyberDunk is a good thing, but when you basically implement a rule "because somebody bitched", confirm you can't even enforce the rule on your own, and then admit to relying on the people who bitched to make decisions regarding the suspended/banned fate of other players...that's just a great precedent to set.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
I concede that avoiding turning GLB into CyberDunk is a good thing, but when you basically implement a rule "because somebody bitched", confirm you can't even enforce the rule on your own, and then admit to relying on the people who bitched to make decisions regarding the suspended/banned fate of other players...that's just a great precedent to set.


It was a rule made because we hadn't known it was much of an issue before. After it was brought to our attention about exactly how serious it is, a rule was put in place.

And having a penalty in place, even if we can't catch every single person who does it, will at least allow us to have some known consequences for those who are caught. And you'd be surprised how many people are caught breaking other rules due to the community's help. It's generally a very good group of people here and I think most are not only willing, but would very much like to help keep this game as clean as possible, and that means helping us police it.

I made this analogy before: it's like the war on drugs. If someone does drugs in his own house, alone, that he made/grew himself, and never leaves his house while high, that person will almost definitely not be caught. And other than knocking down people's doors at random to check, there's no way to change that. But we can have rules in place to make sure less drugs are done, make it at least tougher to do, and so on.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
I guess the rule is fine. Just seems largely pointless. No way to police AIM conversations or emails, that's for sure.
 
Norsemanvike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by Jed

Originally posted by oldskool


.....that doesn't even make sense. As long as I don't directly use it to get you to sign a contract it's fine?

How do you know if that guy is (re-)signing because he wants to be here or if he thinks he can lead the team in rushing and get FP out of it?


As with some of the rules on this site, we're not going to be able to 100% police it ourselves. We rely quite a bit on the community to help us out and that applies here as well.


So we're back to the squeaky wheel gets the grease? It's only fitting that a rule implemented by a bunch of whining is policed & enforced by that same bunch of whiners.

I concede that avoiding turning GLB into CyberDunk is a good thing, but when you basically implement a rule "because somebody bitched", confirm you can't even enforce the rule on your own, and then admit to relying on the people who bitched to make decisions regarding the suspended/banned fate of other players...that's just a great precedent to set.


It's not a reaction to a "squeaky wheel" or because "someone bitched." It's because we noticed, across the board, that after it was brought to our attention, we realized it was becoming a growing problem, affecting many regions, and many leagues levels. Can it be argued that the rules are placed in affect because of the practices of a few, sure. But allowing those unethical practices to go unchecked and allowed to spread, that's the what we're trying to prevent. Look at it this way. If you have a barrel of apples and you find 2 or 3 rotten apples in the barrel, do you want to leave the rotten apples there, continuing to rot and eventually cause the other apples to rot, and ultimately damaging the entire barrels of apples to go rotten? No. You would pull the 2 or 3 rotten apples out to save the rest of barrel. It's better to lose two or three than lose the entire lot.

Edit: Spelling
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 15:37:22
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.