User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > #1 CB lined up against #WR...and #2 CB lined up against #1 WR
Page:
 
kaygdanimal
offline
Link
 
Alright, let me see if I can give some good numbers indicating the problem: None of the issues you will see below are due to lack of stamina or my fatigue settings as majority of the times the CB playing out of position was early in the game, you know during the points where giving up any sort of point is crucial because once your team goes down early, they start FUDGING everything else up on offense.

A couple clarifications:

R1 = Receiver on right side, usually by himself
R2 = Receiver on left side
R3 = Slot Receiver

Black Sea Rebels Cornerbacks
Trent Kepler
Matt Brainard
Dan Paul Greg III
Chris Garrett

***On passes completed 10 yards or more***
***Numbers below are an indication of how many times that CB was covering that receiver on the field***

R1 Receiver
48 catches allowed
624.5 yards allowed
13.01 per catch
8 touchdowns total

R2 Receiver
22 catches allowed
260.5 yards allowed
11.84 per catch
3 touchdowns total

R3 Receiver
41 catches allowed
632.5 yards allowed
15.43 per catch
4 touchdowns total

Trent Kepler - #1 CB
Play %: 75%
R1: 9
R2: 3
R3: 1

Matt Brainard - #2 CB
Play %: 60%
R1: 11
R2: 8
R3: 5

Dan Paul Greg III - #3 CB
Play %: 61%
R1: 8
R2: 3
R3: 15

Chris Garrett - #4 CB
Play %: 53%
R1: 20
R2: 8
R3: 16

Now, looking over those numbers, yes the #1 should have the yards and catches but where did those yards and catches come from? Trent Kepler was on the field 75% of the time and yet only gave up 9 catches to the R1 receiver of 10 yards or greater. Chris Garrett saw 53% of those defensive plays and gave up 20 to the R1 receiver. The thing that pisses me off is that of those 733 defensive plays, why was he covering the #1 so many times We gave up a lot of those yards to the R1 because the engine had moved Trent Kepler to the R2 or R3 receiver letting our lowest level cornerback cover the R1. If Trent comes back on the field, I need him to stay on the R1 receiver because about 60 to 70% of all pass plays go to the right side and what point is there to having a Shutdown Cornerback if he's going to be shutting down the side of the field that sees less action?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kaygdanimal
There is a bug but people are not willing to accept that because this is their favorite little game in the whole world.

If I list a CB as #1 in my depth chart, he should stay on the right side of the field. By "right side", I am referring to when you are looking at the screen with the offense facing north and the defense facing south.

We get burned constantly on the right side of the field ... but alas it's never when our #1 CB is on the right side, it's always when he's on the left side for whatever reason there may be. I've specifically listed him at #1 for a freaking reason. I want him shutting down the RIGHT SIDE of the field and instead, this last game we get burned because the engine decided to move him to the LEFT SIDE and put our #3 on the RIGHT, resulting in two touchdowns that never would have happened if the #1 CB was on the RIGHT side of the field like I had freaking DICTATED in the DEPTH CHART.

I'm sorry guys, but this shit has been bugging me like hell and it's time that us PAYING customers actually get this shit fixed. I understand that this is BETA but it's been going on for so long and still nothing has been done. I'm just sick and tired of getting burned by our whoever lines up on the RIGHT side whenever the guy I listed as our #1 isn't where I listed him to be at.

Edit: To clarify even more, when you see that a QB completed a pass to the RIGHT side, that is the side I am clarifying. The RIGHT side is usually where you want your #1 CB to be covering as most teams pass to the right side more often.


Ahhh, I feel your pain brother. There has to be some middle of the road explainations to these legitimate bugs. This working as intended go fuck yourself attitude is getting old.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 09:46:51
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
I don't see why they can't just program it to say, "Position 1 plays against Position 1, 2 on 2, etc unless they are tired and out of the game." Leave the whole left side, right side out of it. And if someone wants to try and create a mismatch manually, then let them put their #1 WR at the #2 spot right before the game. Not a programmer, and I haven't worked for a software development company in years, but it seems very doable.
 
kaygdanimal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mocfam10
I don't see why they can't just program it to say, "Position 1 plays against Position 1, 2 on 2, etc unless they are tired and out of the game." Leave the whole left side, right side out of it. And if someone wants to try and create a mismatch manually, then let them put their #1 WR at the #2 spot right before the game. Not a programmer, and I haven't worked for a software development company in years, but it seems very doable.


It would not be feasible to program it that way because in the game engine, for whatever reason there may be, the QB tends to favor heavily towards throwing to the RIGHT side of the field, therefore the best tactic suggests putting your #1 CB to defend the RIGHT side of the field in an attempt to shut down that side and look to his lesser receiving targets.

In live football, you can totally move your WR anywhere on the line, left or right side, but it can be countered by the defense by placing whoever you want to cover him on him. A live QB can logically decide to look to his left first before anywhere else but in GLB, the QB tends to favor the right side of the field more than the left.

You could counteract that by your QB changing his Tactics to favor a particular receiver but then you must deal with your other receivers not receiving as many looks as you would like.
 
Link
 
Working as designed!
 
littlebengal
offline
Link
 
I believe this is how the formula kinda works. you go by energy then depth chart. so if you have your energy set to sub out at 65 and you have 4 CB #1 has 62 energy #2 has 61 energy #3 has 78 and #4 has 58 energy. this is the way the would line.

#3 in the first CB spot
#1 in the second CB spot
#2 in the third CB spot

My guess is this never happens early in the game only near half time and in the forth quarter. how many plays do your CB get and how many are on your team.
 
littlebengal
offline
Link
 
the new AI for offense and defense will change some of these.
 
HurricaneBear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by littlebengal
I believe this is how the formula kinda works. you go by energy then depth chart. so if you have your energy set to sub out at 65 and you have 4 CB #1 has 62 energy #2 has 61 energy #3 has 78 and #4 has 58 energy. this is the way the would line.

#3 in the first CB spot
#1 in the second CB spot
#2 in the third CB spot

My guess is this never happens early in the game only near half time and in the forth quarter. how many plays do your CB get and how many are on your team.


this is correct, it starts off 1 vs 1 2 vs 2 3 vs 3 etc, but as the game wears on, it depends on the WRs and CB's energy to determine which spot they are in
 
littlebengal
offline
Link
 
In real football where does the QB in a game normally go... He goes for the weakest defender almost all the time. So if there are say 30 passes to the right and the number 1 is there for 25 he may only give up 5 catches. if the the number 3 guy is there for the other 5 he may give up 5 catches for a lot of yards depending on the deference in levels.
 
littlebengal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kaygdanimal
Alright, let me see if I can give some good numbers indicating the problem: None of the issues you will see below are due to lack of stamina or my fatigue settings as majority of the times the CB playing out of position was early in the game, you know during the points where giving up any sort of point is crucial because once your team goes down early, they start FUDGING everything else up on offense.

A couple clarifications:

R1 = Receiver on right side, usually by himself
R2 = Receiver on left side
R3 = Slot Receiver

Black Sea Rebels Cornerbacks
Trent Kepler
Matt Brainard
Dan Paul Greg III
Chris Garrett

***On passes completed 10 yards or more***
***Numbers below are an indication of how many times that CB was covering that receiver on the field***

R1 Receiver
48 catches allowed
624.5 yards allowed
13.01 per catch
8 touchdowns total

R2 Receiver
22 catches allowed
260.5 yards allowed
11.84 per catch
3 touchdowns total

R3 Receiver
41 catches allowed
632.5 yards allowed
15.43 per catch
4 touchdowns total

Trent Kepler - #1 CB
Play %: 75%
R1: 9
R2: 3
R3: 1

Matt Brainard - #2 CB
Play %: 60%
R1: 11
R2: 8
R3: 5

Dan Paul Greg III - #3 CB
Play %: 61%
R1: 8
R2: 3
R3: 15

Chris Garrett - #4 CB
Play %: 53%
R1: 20
R2: 8
R3: 16

Now, looking over those numbers, yes the #1 should have the yards and catches but where did those yards and catches come from? Trent Kepler was on the field 75% of the time and yet only gave up 9 catches to the R1 receiver of 10 yards or greater. Chris Garrett saw 53% of those defensive plays and gave up 20 to the R1 receiver. The thing that pisses me off is that of those 733 defensive plays, why was he covering the #1 so many times We gave up a lot of those yards to the R1 because the engine had moved Trent Kepler to the R2 or R3 receiver letting our lowest level cornerback cover the R1. If Trent comes back on the field, I need him to stay on the R1 receiver because about 60 to 70% of all pass plays go to the right side and what point is there to having a Shutdown Cornerback if he's going to be shutting down the side of the field that sees less action?


Can you give the stamina on the 4 guys or at least who has the highest and by how much. We don't need actual numbers.
 
littlebengal
offline
Link
 
also do you know if the #1 WR was on the right or did that player move and that is why the CB moved.
 
littlebengal
offline
Link
 
In your last game the #1 WR had moved to the left side, that is why your CB moved to the left side.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10619322


This one is broke....

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=10618240


After watching most of these plays on this drive the field is setup in reverse on D the #1 is always on the left in the base 2 CB setup in the 3 CB defense, the #1 is on the Right usually in solo coverage. You could test this theory by moving your #1 guy to the #2 slot and see how many plays he plays on the right. my guess would be a lot more. The QB throws to the the right more as that is where the #1 WR is lined up most often.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 13:14:37
 
kaygdanimal
offline
Link
 
I have no qualms about showing stamina, especially so late in the season with our destiny already decided.

Our stamina range is 32-44, but that 44 is a good deal higher than our #1's. Our #1 never has stamina issues and as stated before, out of the 1374 defensive plays, our #1 played 75% of those snaps (1031), so it's not like he's getting wasted from fatigue and then being pushed over.
 
Jadin
offline
Link
 
Trent Kepler's stamina is 36
 
Concrete Dick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kaygdanimal
I have no qualms about showing stamina, especially so late in the season with our destiny already decided.

Our stamina range is 32-44, but that 44 is a good deal higher than our #1's. Our #1 never has stamina issues and as stated before, out of the 1374 defensive plays, our #1 played 75% of those snaps (1031), so it's not like he's getting wasted from fatigue and then being pushed over.


You got screwed, get over it! A bug pinned you down and fucked you up the ass! Raw head Rex style too! Without protection! Its part of the game. If you don't like it, find another hoppy where you have to pay money and you never see improvements! Like being married for instance. Its an investment that never pays off and always depreciates with time.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.