User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Controlling a Player's Weight (Diet)
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
It's a waste of time and it ruins player individuality. Why, if I get a strength bonus for being fat, would I not want my offensive line & defensive tackles to be the absolute fattest they can be?

Now there's variety in weights, but if you have a semblance of control over it and if it relates to training 'advantages' everyone will be the same. The players that need strength the most need speed the least; all this would do is make every offensive lineman & defensive tackle the same weight, thus nullifying player weight individuality (everybody's going to be the same weight, and if they choose to be different they'll be frowned upon as 'wasteful') as well as the strength bonus (if everyone gets the same bonus, then nobody gets a bonus), and as a result nothing changes.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
It's a waste of time and it ruins player individuality. Why, if I get a strength bonus for being fat, would I not want my offensive line & defensive tackles to be the absolute fattest they can be?

Now there's variety in weights, but if you have a semblance of control over it and if it relates to training 'advantages' everyone will be the same. The players that need strength the most need speed the least; all this would do is make every offensive lineman & defensive tackle the same weight, thus nullifying player weight individuality (everybody's going to be the same weight, and if they choose to be different they'll be frowned upon as 'wasteful') as well as the strength bonus (if everyone gets the same bonus, then nobody gets a bonus), and as a result nothing changes.


The DL and OL would all be large human beings. This is how it is in the NFL. However, the LB, CB, WR, and even QB positions would have some variety. Do you want to be a Brandon Marshall or a Steve Smith? Flutie or McNabb?

As a LB, do you want to be quick to the ball, a hard hitter, or have some sort of balance? Yes, this is already a possibility. This simply adds depth to your build.

Size is too closely correlated to strength (a little less to speed) that it should not be a side-note on player creation and development.
 
Kayoh
offline
Link
 
I actually really like this idea. QBs, WRs, HBs, and CBs all start out WAYYY too skinny. Peyton Manning is 6'5" 230 lbs. I've never seen a QB weigh more than 224 on GLB.

JaMarcus Russell is 6'6" and around 265 lbs. That's big, but look at Joe Flacco, Ben Roethlisberger, and Derek Anderson.

Then the receivers. The heaviest I've ever seen a WR was 203 lbs. Some receivers in the NFL that aren't even considered "big" receivers are bigger than that. Roy Williams weighs 211 lbs. Andre Johnson is 6'3" 222 lbs. Then, when we talk about bigger receivers...holy crap. Brandon Marshall is 6'4" 230 lbs, as is Marques Colston. Vincent Jackson for San Diego is 6'5" 240 lbs.

Then the HBs. Shaun Alexander is 5'11" 225 lbs. LT is 5'10" 221 lbs. Larry Johnson is 6'1" 230 lbs. Steven Jackson is 6'2" 231. To get those sizes, you'd need to make a FB.

CB sizes aren't that extreme, just the idea of a 6'4" 170 lb CB is ridiculous.
Last edited Jul 10, 2008 19:46:28
 
bigtony2tone
offline
Link
 
When making CBs or HBs, I don't know how many times during my rerolling that I saw 6'3" and 6'4" at both spots. Huh? Yet 5'11" is the shortest at both spots.

As far as being able to "train" weight, you would HAVE to make a max/min for all positions, have a max loss/gain of 10lbs per year, and have advantages/disadvantages for both. The higher the level of competition you get, the more physically imposing the players become. GLB should try to simulate real life in this way as well.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio

Seems like a waste of time.


Really? This is an MMORPG. Adding depth to player creation and development is a waste of time? Thanks for your input, but I disagree.

I would agree if you said:

-"there are more pressing issues right now"
-"this would be too massive an overhall of the existing system to be feasible"
-"I choose not to elaborate, but I am against this idea"

Again, size matters in football. Genetics play the majority of the role, but diets are very important to professional athletes. It just seems to be a pretty big issue that was skipped over.


"Waste of time" and "added depth to player creation" are terms I'd use interchangeably. It has nothing to do with the developers wasting time, it just sounds like an unnecessary, cumbersome upkeep that we could do without. What is gained by having weight variations? Who really is going to respond to that with "wow, what great realism!" when they've got 20 players to spend even more time checking up on every single day? I think if GLB were more like a game where every user was a single player, then yes these minute details could be made more realistic, like in a first person RPG, but right now things are perfectly fine as they are and I'm just not seeing enough of a reason for this change to happen. Operating as we are now, under the premise that our bits of data we call players are unable to jump out of the server and grab an extra bite to eat at Wendy's, is how I'd like to see it remain.
 
bigtony2tone
offline
Link
 
Well that's you. If you don't care, no one's making you do anything. If this little game takes too much time out of your day, you don't have to continue playing it. It would be just like any other options you have. You don't have to change your tactics or training if you don't want to. It's obvious things are NOT "perfectly fine as they are" because the game is constantly in a state of change.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio

"Waste of time" and "added depth to player creation" are terms I'd use interchangeably. It has nothing to do with the developers wasting time, it just sounds like an unnecessary, cumbersome upkeep that we could do without. What is gained by having weight variations? Who really is going to respond to that with "wow, what great realism!" when they've got 20 players to spend even more time checking up on every single day? I think if GLB were more like a game where every user was a single player, then yes these minute details could be made more realistic, like in a first person RPG, but right now things are perfectly fine as they are and I'm just not seeing enough of a reason for this change to happen. Operating as we are now, under the premise that our bits of data we call players are unable to jump out of the server and grab an extra bite to eat at Wendy's, is how I'd like to see it remain.


I disagree. It has everything to do with developers spending time. An idea that is a quick fix and would add more depth to player development is good on both ends. Unfortunately, this idea is not a quick fix.

And consider it as population control. There will always be a problem balancing the amount of teams and players. If you cannot spend the time to check in on your players every day or two, you probably should not have that many players.

I, personally, would like to play aroud with player size. Having a light DE that has to fill out as he levels vs. a heavier DE that is stronger, but has to work twice as hard to get his speed up to par.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Your height could go up by an inch or 2 in the first couple of seasons. Most likely, it would stay the same. This adds variability aside from what happens on the day of player creation. I have recently signed on to re-rollers anonymous to address this issue.

Weight, however, would basically be controlled by the user and the tactics he/she selects. If you are training strength on intense, you should be eating on intense as well. If you do not, you will see a hit in strength gains...but lose weight and get that slight boost to the effects of speed (and future training in speed).

Aside from implementation difficulties, I do not see why this idea is not even entertained by most. It has potential to be a better discussion than the one million all-star game ideas out there that all follow the same format and get the same responses.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtony2tone
Well that's you. If you don't care, no one's making you do anything. If this little game takes too much time out of your day, you don't have to continue playing it. It would be just like any other options you have. You don't have to change your tactics or training if you don't want to. It's obvious things are NOT "perfectly fine as they are" because the game is constantly in a state of change.


By the same token, if you don't like my personal slant on things, you could just not respond. No one's making you read it. Better yet, quit the game entirely so you don't have to deal with my posts if you can't handle them. That's your logic at work, bigtony2tone. "Well that's you."? Yes, this is me, I'm just another user posting his opinion in the thread. I don't even have to justify it, much less to some kid who doesn't matter. But I'm humoring kretchfoop because at least he is making an effort.

I'm not seeing how this idea would globally benefit GLB. As it stands, it seems like a feature that comes down to individual preference. Some people will like the new feature and attempt to take advantage of it, and some won't because they'll get pissed off that one aspect of their player has to change because of their training style. It'll be very difficult for people to balance energy-returning and weight gain/loss if training intensity is a factor in both. I know I'd always be choosing the training that returned the most energy to my player (plus intense is just plain not affordable), and -I PERSONALLY- would not want to see my player's weight shift in either direction from what I rolled to begin with.

To each his own.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 12:06:26
 
bigtony2tone
offline
Link
 
First off, the idea here is to give your opinion. But if you're making suggestions as to the betterment of this game, not just your personal slant on things. The idea behind gaining/losing weight is that it adds another dimension to the game, giving you something else the do with your players. It would NOT be required to utilize. The thing is, weight is such a large part of football. If the goal of GLB is to be a simulation, weight should be a significant factor here as well. In your case, you would just maintain your player's weight. End of discussion. Though I don't need to explain myself to some kid who doesn't matter.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtony2tone
First off, the idea here is to give your opinion. But if you're making suggestions as to the betterment of this game, not just your personal slant on things. The idea behind gaining/losing weight is that it adds another dimension to the game, giving you something else the do with your players. It would NOT be required to utilize. The thing is, weight is such a large part of football. If the goal of GLB is to be a simulation, weight should be a significant factor here as well. In your case, you would just maintain your player's weight. End of discussion. Though I don't need to explain myself to some kid who doesn't matter.


+1

(pulling out the defibrillator)

I will not let this idea die.
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
THIS IS A GOOD IDEA.. but we needed to be able o pick height, my HB is 5'11" and 180 lbs o.o
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 22:53:58
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
and he is a POWER BACK lol
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
It would be nice to reroll for both height and weight and be able to put stat points into height (to the max). This would result in more "cookie-cutter builds" as far as size goes, but result in different overall builds based on stats. A 6'6", 330 pound OT that has the potential to be as fast as a 5'11", 180 pound HB is laughable. And the opposite, for strength, is also silly as hell.
Last edited Jul 11, 2008 23:00:39
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
my HB is slower than most NTs :'( just he is capping on str >.> at lvl 6
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.