Originally posted by Juan Fiddy
This thread should prove to be entertaining.
I personally like it the way it is, and I have beaten teams with a higher avg level of starters. I look at it this way, if I, as an owner am trying to tell the QB to throw deep into triple coverage, or the coach to call a running play on 3rd and 15. Then in hindsight I would want my people to ignore my ass and do what they need to do to try and pull it off. As it stands the game 'tries' to be fairly idiot proof. As improvements come down the line, the base game will still be fairly idiot proof, and as you dive deeper into the settings you can better dictate the play calls.
There is some variety in the game, and it is built that way purposefully. If you want 100% control then a console game is right up yer alley. Anyway, ADV AI will help curb some of the issues people are facing and if they want an entirely predictable and static offense then so be it.
So this thread, is an incessant repition of an issue that is being addressed already.
And level isn't all, builds, tactics and depth can trump level.
I agree that the OP doesn't understand the realistic and necessary situational adjustments (throw the ball when behind or 3rd and long, run it when ahead, and the like), but I think the "purposeful variety" sucks.
There are real life teams that never run the FB, in any situation. So if I set in my settings that 100% of runs should be HB runs, then every run should be a HB run.
There probably aren't teams that never call a pass the backfield, because they work better in real life than they do here. But, it still will, even if all my passes are set to go either to WR's or TE's. It's harder to tell there, as it could be a QB decision making issue (and if it is, the AI updates won't fix it), but it should never call a designed play to pass to a back if I have those at zero.
It really should situationally adjust more like the way it auto-adjusts. It should use plays that you've authorized proportionately more by situation (instead of adjusting those based on how well the play works, it could adjust based on situational appropriateness).
So, on 3rd and 15 if I have pass on 50%, it might become 100%. And if I have long as length on 25%, that might double to 50% or even triple to 75%. But if I decided in a given game I never wanted to throw deep against a given team, ever, then even on 3rd and 15 it should be throwing medium in hopes of breaking a tackle-- because maybe I believed that we couldn't throw deep against a given team-- in which case I might prefer to throw medium and hope to get YAC.
And anything at 0% should mean zero, ever.
I understand this is moot because the idea is that advanced AI is coming so we'll finally be able to control these things, but some of the automatic play calling is BS. Other parts aren't, as it should situationally adjust, but it should always situationally adjust by multiplier, so that 0% means 0%.
This thread should prove to be entertaining.
I personally like it the way it is, and I have beaten teams with a higher avg level of starters. I look at it this way, if I, as an owner am trying to tell the QB to throw deep into triple coverage, or the coach to call a running play on 3rd and 15. Then in hindsight I would want my people to ignore my ass and do what they need to do to try and pull it off. As it stands the game 'tries' to be fairly idiot proof. As improvements come down the line, the base game will still be fairly idiot proof, and as you dive deeper into the settings you can better dictate the play calls.
There is some variety in the game, and it is built that way purposefully. If you want 100% control then a console game is right up yer alley. Anyway, ADV AI will help curb some of the issues people are facing and if they want an entirely predictable and static offense then so be it.
So this thread, is an incessant repition of an issue that is being addressed already.
And level isn't all, builds, tactics and depth can trump level.
I agree that the OP doesn't understand the realistic and necessary situational adjustments (throw the ball when behind or 3rd and long, run it when ahead, and the like), but I think the "purposeful variety" sucks.
There are real life teams that never run the FB, in any situation. So if I set in my settings that 100% of runs should be HB runs, then every run should be a HB run.
There probably aren't teams that never call a pass the backfield, because they work better in real life than they do here. But, it still will, even if all my passes are set to go either to WR's or TE's. It's harder to tell there, as it could be a QB decision making issue (and if it is, the AI updates won't fix it), but it should never call a designed play to pass to a back if I have those at zero.
It really should situationally adjust more like the way it auto-adjusts. It should use plays that you've authorized proportionately more by situation (instead of adjusting those based on how well the play works, it could adjust based on situational appropriateness).
So, on 3rd and 15 if I have pass on 50%, it might become 100%. And if I have long as length on 25%, that might double to 50% or even triple to 75%. But if I decided in a given game I never wanted to throw deep against a given team, ever, then even on 3rd and 15 it should be throwing medium in hopes of breaking a tackle-- because maybe I believed that we couldn't throw deep against a given team-- in which case I might prefer to throw medium and hope to get YAC.
And anything at 0% should mean zero, ever.
I understand this is moot because the idea is that advanced AI is coming so we'll finally be able to control these things, but some of the automatic play calling is BS. Other parts aren't, as it should situationally adjust, but it should always situationally adjust by multiplier, so that 0% means 0%.






























