User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy
This thread should prove to be entertaining.

I personally like it the way it is, and I have beaten teams with a higher avg level of starters. I look at it this way, if I, as an owner am trying to tell the QB to throw deep into triple coverage, or the coach to call a running play on 3rd and 15. Then in hindsight I would want my people to ignore my ass and do what they need to do to try and pull it off. As it stands the game 'tries' to be fairly idiot proof. As improvements come down the line, the base game will still be fairly idiot proof, and as you dive deeper into the settings you can better dictate the play calls.

There is some variety in the game, and it is built that way purposefully. If you want 100% control then a console game is right up yer alley. Anyway, ADV AI will help curb some of the issues people are facing and if they want an entirely predictable and static offense then so be it.

So this thread, is an incessant repition of an issue that is being addressed already.

And level isn't all, builds, tactics and depth can trump level.


I agree that the OP doesn't understand the realistic and necessary situational adjustments (throw the ball when behind or 3rd and long, run it when ahead, and the like), but I think the "purposeful variety" sucks.

There are real life teams that never run the FB, in any situation. So if I set in my settings that 100% of runs should be HB runs, then every run should be a HB run.

There probably aren't teams that never call a pass the backfield, because they work better in real life than they do here. But, it still will, even if all my passes are set to go either to WR's or TE's. It's harder to tell there, as it could be a QB decision making issue (and if it is, the AI updates won't fix it), but it should never call a designed play to pass to a back if I have those at zero.

It really should situationally adjust more like the way it auto-adjusts. It should use plays that you've authorized proportionately more by situation (instead of adjusting those based on how well the play works, it could adjust based on situational appropriateness).

So, on 3rd and 15 if I have pass on 50%, it might become 100%. And if I have long as length on 25%, that might double to 50% or even triple to 75%. But if I decided in a given game I never wanted to throw deep against a given team, ever, then even on 3rd and 15 it should be throwing medium in hopes of breaking a tackle-- because maybe I believed that we couldn't throw deep against a given team-- in which case I might prefer to throw medium and hope to get YAC.

And anything at 0% should mean zero, ever.

I understand this is moot because the idea is that advanced AI is coming so we'll finally be able to control these things, but some of the automatic play calling is BS. Other parts aren't, as it should situationally adjust, but it should always situationally adjust by multiplier, so that 0% means 0%.
 
big_cheese
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy

This thread should prove to be entertaining.

I personally like it the way it is, and I have beaten teams with a higher avg level of starters. I look at it this way, if I, as an owner am trying to tell the QB to throw deep into triple coverage, or the coach to call a running play on 3rd and 15. Then in hindsight I would want my people to ignore my ass and do what they need to do to try and pull it off. As it stands the game 'tries' to be fairly idiot proof. As improvements come down the line, the base game will still be fairly idiot proof, and as you dive deeper into the settings you can better dictate the play calls.

There is some variety in the game, and it is built that way purposefully. If you want 100% control then a console game is right up yer alley. Anyway, ADV AI will help curb some of the issues people are facing and if they want an entirely predictable and static offense then so be it.

So this thread, is an incessant repition of an issue that is being addressed already.

And level isn't all, builds, tactics and depth can trump level.


I agree that the OP doesn't understand the realistic and necessary situational adjustments (throw the ball when behind or 3rd and long, run it when ahead, and the like), but I think the "purposeful variety" sucks.

There are real life teams that never run the FB, in any situation. So if I set in my settings that 100% of runs should be HB runs, then every run should be a HB run.

There probably aren't teams that never call a pass the backfield, because they work better in real life than they do here. But, it still will, even if all my passes are set to go either to WR's or TE's. It's harder to tell there, as it could be a QB decision making issue (and if it is, the AI updates won't fix it), but it should never call a designed play to pass to a back if I have those at zero.

It really should situationally adjust more like the way it auto-adjusts. It should use plays that you've authorized proportionately more by situation (instead of adjusting those based on how well the play works, it could adjust based on situational appropriateness).

So, on 3rd and 15 if I have pass on 50%, it might become 100%. And if I have long as length on 25%, that might double to 50% or even triple to 75%. But if I decided in a given game I never wanted to throw deep against a given team, ever, then even on 3rd and 15 it should be throwing medium in hopes of breaking a tackle-- because maybe I believed that we couldn't throw deep against a given team-- in which case I might prefer to throw medium and hope to get YAC.

And anything at 0% should mean zero, ever.

I understand this is moot because the idea is that advanced AI is coming so we'll finally be able to control these things, but some of the automatic play calling is BS. Other parts aren't, as it should situationally adjust, but it should always situationally adjust by multiplier, so that 0% means 0%.


There is a God! Thank you
 
dleeg5199
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy

This thread should prove to be entertaining.

I personally like it the way it is, and I have beaten teams with a higher avg level of starters. I look at it this way, if I, as an owner am trying to tell the QB to throw deep into triple coverage, or the coach to call a running play on 3rd and 15. Then in hindsight I would want my people to ignore my ass and do what they need to do to try and pull it off. As it stands the game 'tries' to be fairly idiot proof. As improvements come down the line, the base game will still be fairly idiot proof, and as you dive deeper into the settings you can better dictate the play calls.

There is some variety in the game, and it is built that way purposefully. If you want 100% control then a console game is right up yer alley. Anyway, ADV AI will help curb some of the issues people are facing and if they want an entirely predictable and static offense then so be it.

So this thread, is an incessant repition of an issue that is being addressed already.

And level isn't all, builds, tactics and depth can trump level.


I agree that the OP doesn't understand the realistic and necessary situational adjustments (throw the ball when behind or 3rd and long, run it when ahead, and the like), but I think the "purposeful variety" sucks.

There are real life teams that never run the FB, in any situation. So if I set in my settings that 100% of runs should be HB runs, then every run should be a HB run.

There probably aren't teams that never call a pass the backfield, because they work better in real life than they do here. But, it still will, even if all my passes are set to go either to WR's or TE's. It's harder to tell there, as it could be a QB decision making issue (and if it is, the AI updates won't fix it), but it should never call a designed play to pass to a back if I have those at zero.

It really should situationally adjust more like the way it auto-adjusts. It should use plays that you've authorized proportionately more by situation (instead of adjusting those based on how well the play works, it could adjust based on situational appropriateness).

So, on 3rd and 15 if I have pass on 50%, it might become 100%. And if I have long as length on 25%, that might double to 50% or even triple to 75%. But if I decided in a given game I never wanted to throw deep against a given team, ever, then even on 3rd and 15 it should be throwing medium in hopes of breaking a tackle-- because maybe I believed that we couldn't throw deep against a given team-- in which case I might prefer to throw medium and hope to get YAC.

And anything at 0% should mean zero, ever.

I understand this is moot because the idea is that advanced AI is coming so we'll finally be able to control these things, but some of the automatic play calling is BS. Other parts aren't, as it should situationally adjust, but it should always situationally adjust by multiplier, so that 0% means 0%.


Finally, someone that understands what 0 means.
 
Sigmaforce
offline
Link
 
Would you be upset if your WR burnt a CB and had an easy line to the endzone but your QB didn't pass to him because you had your long pass percentage at 0?

Would you be annoyed if your QB threw to the TE who was covered by a CB, SS and LB because you had it set to 90% TE passing and it got intercepted, even though your HB was open to gain a few yards?

I do agree on some points: 100% HB running should mean the FB gets no carries, for example. But the passing game needs to be adaptive in my opinion. If there's no reasonable receiver option available within your current settings, the QB shouldn't be locked in to throwing into double or triple coverage when they've got a HB in the flats who can pick up a few yards. No coaches say Don't, under any circumstance, pass to the HB, you got me? Throw it to the other team before you do!

 
big_cheese
offline
Link
 
0=0 OFF=OFF! If I choose to turn off auto-adjust I don't care if I get burned! At least I had a choice. If I wanna run up the gut 100% of the time and lose by 1000 points I'm fine with that.
Last edited Jul 9, 2008 12:35:11
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sigmaforce
Would you be upset if your WR burnt a CB and had an easy line to the endzone but your QB didn't pass to him because you had your long pass percentage at 0?

Would you be annoyed if your QB threw to the TE who was covered by a CB, SS and LB because you had it set to 90% TE passing and it got intercepted, even though your HB was open to gain a few yards?

I do agree on some points: 100% HB running should mean the FB gets no carries, for example. But the passing game needs to be adaptive in my opinion. If there's no reasonable receiver option available within your current settings, the QB shouldn't be locked in to throwing into double or triple coverage when they've got a HB in the flats who can pick up a few yards. No coaches say Don't, under any circumstance, pass to the HB, you got me? Throw it to the other team before you do!



I definitely want the QB to check off.

I'm saying HB passes at 0% should mean 0% of plays *designed* to go to the HB, and I admitted we can't know whether or not it's followed; but I bet it isn't, given the other additions that are for "variety" rather than situational adjustments.

I'd also, personally, want to be able to tell the QB never to throw to the HB (it'd be fine if those plays worked as well as in real life, but they don't), that it's better to throw it away than to the HB-- although that should probably be an individual player tactic. But there should be some way.
 
big_cheese
offline
Link
 
Lets forget about game planning and scouting teams and stick our thumbs up our collective asses and set the auto-adjust to 100% Enjoy the ride!!! The fucked up thing is that would probably be more consistent and at least you would know that you were getting fucked going into the game rather than after the game.
Last edited Jul 9, 2008 12:52:16
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
I agree that the OP doesn't understand the realistic and necessary situational adjustments (throw the ball when behind or 3rd and long, run it when ahead, and the like), but I think the "purposeful variety" sucks.

There are real life teams that never run the FB, in any situation. So if I set in my settings that 100% of runs should be HB runs, then every run should be a HB run.

There probably aren't teams that never call a pass the backfield, because they work better in real life than they do here. But, it still will, even if all my passes are set to go either to WR's or TE's. It's harder to tell there, as it could be a QB decision making issue (and if it is, the AI updates won't fix it), but it should never call a designed play to pass to a back if I have those at zero.

It really should situationally adjust more like the way it auto-adjusts. It should use plays that you've authorized proportionately more by situation (instead of adjusting those based on how well the play works, it could adjust based on situational appropriateness).

So, on 3rd and 15 if I have pass on 50%, it might become 100%. And if I have long as length on 25%, that might double to 50% or even triple to 75%. But if I decided in a given game I never wanted to throw deep against a given team, ever, then even on 3rd and 15 it should be throwing medium in hopes of breaking a tackle-- because maybe I believed that we couldn't throw deep against a given team-- in which case I might prefer to throw medium and hope to get YAC.

And anything at 0% should mean zero, ever.

I understand this is moot because the idea is that advanced AI is coming so we'll finally be able to control these things, but some of the automatic play calling is BS. Other parts aren't, as it should situationally adjust, but it should always situationally adjust by multiplier, so that 0% means 0%.


This post is a good one.

Another point that isn't considered often when it comes to auto-adjust but is moot because of the upcoming advanced tactics: sometimes there are other considerations that are influencing your tactics settings beyond winning that particular game. For example, I'm the OC of a team that has been playing above its level all season. There are games that we all knew we weren't going to win without significant divine intervention. Those games tended to tire out the defense, for obvious reasons. In order to keep our energy up for winnable games, I'd order a lot of run plays to wind the clock down and shorten the game. In these situations I'd prefer if the sim followed my orders the entire game - they're there for a reason, even if the reason has nothing to do with winning that game.
 
Nik Aitken
offline
Link
 
We lost its a bug.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
When the game was designed Bort knew the settings weren't very advanced. He had two choices then. Make them 100% locked in or build in some automatic changes. If you look at the game as a whole, making them 100% locked in would be horrible. He had to go with the lowest common denomiator if you will. This includes adjustments you didn't set.

The same people complaining about this would be the same people comlaining about running the ball on third and long and the same people complaining about running the ball when you are way behind at the end of the game. I honestly believe you would see a thousand times more threads if there were no changes than what you see now.

I am not trying to say the way things work now are good, just that it was the lesser of two evils. The only auto adjust that doesn't make sense to me is running the FB when you have FB carries set to zero. That one just seems wrong.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Not a bug.
 
big_cheese
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
When the game was designed Bort knew the settings weren't very advanced. He had two choices then. Make them 100% locked in or build in some automatic changes. If you look at the game as a whole, making them 100% locked in would be horrible. He had to go with the lowest common denomiator if you will. This includes adjustments you didn't set.

The same people complaining about this would be the same people comlaining about running the ball on third and long and the same people complaining about running the ball when you are way behind at the end of the game. I honestly believe you would see a thousand times more threads if there were no changes than what you see now.

I am not trying to say the way things work now are good, just that it was the lesser of two evils. The only auto adjust that doesn't make sense to me is running the FB when you have FB carries set to zero. That one just seems wrong.


I see you are finally siding on the voice of reason. Job well done.
Zero should mean zero 100% of the time. There is no Grey area when it comes to numbers. We are not complaining about how the auto-adjust works when it is on, but when it is set to off or percentages are set to zero thats when you run into issues.
Last edited Jul 10, 2008 07:35:52
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Fortunately, zero does mean zero.

Auto-adjust does different things than the built-in play weights.

The play weights look at certain situations (you can tell which, because the offense AI screen has a default input for each of them) and weights the called plays slightly towards what would be most effective in the majority of circumstances.

The auto-adjust looks at each play individually as it's run and assigns a success rating to it. Plays/defenses that get higher success ratings get called more often based on the auto-adjust percentage.

They're two different systems used for two different purposes. Play with auto-adjust on 100% if you really think there's no difference.
 
big_cheese
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Fortunately, zero does mean zero.

Auto-adjust does different things than the built-in play weights.

The play weights look at certain situations (you can tell which, because the offense AI screen has a default input for each of them) and weights the called plays slightly towards what would be most effective in the majority of circumstances.

The auto-adjust looks at each play individually as it's run and assigns a success rating to it. Plays/defenses that get higher success ratings get called more often based on the auto-adjust percentage.

They're two different systems used for two different purposes. Play with auto-adjust on 100% if you really think there's no difference.


All I am saying for the 1000th time is when I turn auto-adjust off it should not deviate under no circumstances. I don't give a rat's ass how you think it works when it is on. I want to stick to my game plan 100% of the time. Fuck the auto-adjust, fuck Gasper Gomez, and fuck the Diaz Brothers, Fuckem all!! I bury those coackaroaches.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by big_cheese
Originally posted by wombat killer

When the game was designed Bort knew the settings weren't very advanced. He had two choices then. Make them 100% locked in or build in some automatic changes. If you look at the game as a whole, making them 100% locked in would be horrible. He had to go with the lowest common denomiator if you will. This includes adjustments you didn't set.

The same people complaining about this would be the same people comlaining about running the ball on third and long and the same people complaining about running the ball when you are way behind at the end of the game. I honestly believe you would see a thousand times more threads if there were no changes than what you see now.

I am not trying to say the way things work now are good, just that it was the lesser of two evils. The only auto adjust that doesn't make sense to me is running the FB when you have FB carries set to zero. That one just seems wrong.


I see you are finally siding on the voice of reason. Job well done.
Zero should mean zero 100% of the time. There is no Grey area when it comes to numbers. We are not complaining about how the auto-adjust works when it is on, but when it is set to off or percentages are set to zero thats when you run into issues.


Nope. I guess you really didn't understand what I was saying. You still don't understand what the purpose of auto adjust is.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.