Originally posted by morty
O. k., I`ll start with my first choice - the Quarterback.
Important for my nomination was the following: Completition rating, INTs, QB rating TDs and YA.
I didnīt take into account how many times the QB has been sacked, since I believe this is being part of the weakness of the O-line ( or strength of the opponentīs defense ) -nevertheless, this could be argued
I appreciate you taking the initiative to get a positive discussion moving forward. And I think you've made a good start. But at the same time, it seems a little disingenuous to factor in the weakness/strength of the O-line when evaluating sacks, yet at the same time you have NOT factored in the weakness/strength of the overall offensive talent around the QB's when looking at other stats.
So the net result is you have come up with the two QB's with the most overall talent around them. These are both good QB's, but are they really the best when you take into account what other QB's had to work with comparably? So I think your methodology could be improved. Please take this only as constructive suggestions - I appreciate that you stepped forward and made an attempt and admire your effort while I do see areas for potential improvement.
Another area for improvement I can think of - since these are nominations - is to nominate the top 5 players and the arguments for each, and don't at this point try to reach a conclusion. You are calling these nominations but really you're giving conclusions and your reasoning.
I think it's ok if you only want to nominate from your conference - representatives from the other conference can do the same, and then with this information everyone can evaluate easier.
So my suggestion is to go back and NOMINATE the top 5 players at each position, giving all relevant information you can think of, and the arguments for each. Then the next step would be for everyone to comment and reach a conclusion.
O. k., I`ll start with my first choice - the Quarterback.
Important for my nomination was the following: Completition rating, INTs, QB rating TDs and YA.
I didnīt take into account how many times the QB has been sacked, since I believe this is being part of the weakness of the O-line ( or strength of the opponentīs defense ) -nevertheless, this could be argued
I appreciate you taking the initiative to get a positive discussion moving forward. And I think you've made a good start. But at the same time, it seems a little disingenuous to factor in the weakness/strength of the O-line when evaluating sacks, yet at the same time you have NOT factored in the weakness/strength of the overall offensive talent around the QB's when looking at other stats.
So the net result is you have come up with the two QB's with the most overall talent around them. These are both good QB's, but are they really the best when you take into account what other QB's had to work with comparably? So I think your methodology could be improved. Please take this only as constructive suggestions - I appreciate that you stepped forward and made an attempt and admire your effort while I do see areas for potential improvement.
Another area for improvement I can think of - since these are nominations - is to nominate the top 5 players and the arguments for each, and don't at this point try to reach a conclusion. You are calling these nominations but really you're giving conclusions and your reasoning.
I think it's ok if you only want to nominate from your conference - representatives from the other conference can do the same, and then with this information everyone can evaluate easier.
So my suggestion is to go back and NOMINATE the top 5 players at each position, giving all relevant information you can think of, and the arguments for each. Then the next step would be for everyone to comment and reach a conclusion.






























