User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morty
O. k., I`ll start with my first choice - the Quarterback.
Important for my nomination was the following: Completition rating, INTs, QB rating TDs and YA.
I didnīt take into account how many times the QB has been sacked, since I believe this is being part of the weakness of the O-line ( or strength of the opponentīs defense ) -nevertheless, this could be argued


I appreciate you taking the initiative to get a positive discussion moving forward. And I think you've made a good start. But at the same time, it seems a little disingenuous to factor in the weakness/strength of the O-line when evaluating sacks, yet at the same time you have NOT factored in the weakness/strength of the overall offensive talent around the QB's when looking at other stats.

So the net result is you have come up with the two QB's with the most overall talent around them. These are both good QB's, but are they really the best when you take into account what other QB's had to work with comparably? So I think your methodology could be improved. Please take this only as constructive suggestions - I appreciate that you stepped forward and made an attempt and admire your effort while I do see areas for potential improvement.

Another area for improvement I can think of - since these are nominations - is to nominate the top 5 players and the arguments for each, and don't at this point try to reach a conclusion. You are calling these nominations but really you're giving conclusions and your reasoning.

I think it's ok if you only want to nominate from your conference - representatives from the other conference can do the same, and then with this information everyone can evaluate easier.

So my suggestion is to go back and NOMINATE the top 5 players at each position, giving all relevant information you can think of, and the arguments for each. Then the next step would be for everyone to comment and reach a conclusion.
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Joebarber
Originally posted by kalkmanc

Originally posted by dadeboy


I'll do the running backs
What went in to my nomination was yards, ypc, tds, the amount of times they were tackled for a loss, and fumbles.
I accounted for how many times they were tackled in the backfield, because the true test of a back is his ability to at least grind out a yard or two.
I didnt take in to account fumbles lost, because the backs have no control over this.
My vote goes to: Graig Cooper- Rivals Mainboard Pimps (No bias)
Backup: Jack Razorback- Vienna Fortress

Cooper averages 4.7 yards a carry, while toting the rock for 20 tds and 1425 yards and 7 fumbles going into the last game of the season while being taken down in the backfield only 12 times. He is third in yards, and tied for first in tds.
Razorback has the same average and number of tds, while amassing 1296.5 yards and 6 fumbles going into the last game of the season and being taken down behind the line of scrimmage 35 times. He is fourth in yards, and is tied for first in tds.

I really wanted to give Hokie the backup spot here, but with the lack of tds and him leading the three in fumbles I just was not able to do it, although the yards he put up is impressive. I must say though, it really is amazing the numbers these two backs put up splitting time in the backfield. 3051.5 yards and 35 tds combined ? Thats obscene.

Again, I dont want yall to think Im biased nominating Coop for the top spot, I just felt like he is the best right now. I would appreciate any criticism or comments, and if yall feel like someone else should rate the backs, I understand.

(I am gonna go ahead and put Lawrence's name on the best DE spot though... 63 tackles, 14 sacks, 2 ff, 7 tfl's, a pick and 36 hurries with only 1 missed tackle ? INSANE)


How dare you not put our combo together.haha..good job joe, Im sure Hokie is pisssseeed


Huh? I didn't do anything


lol...oops, read the OP name wrong.
 
Joebarber
offline
Link
 
Haha either way LOL at the guy who thinks we should be punished because we have too much talent around us.
 
Tiny Tom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sly
Originally posted by morty

O. k., I`ll start with my first choice - the Quarterback.
Important for my nomination was the following: Completition rating, INTs, QB rating TDs and YA.
I didnīt take into account how many times the QB has been sacked, since I believe this is being part of the weakness of the O-line ( or strength of the opponentīs defense ) -nevertheless, this could be argued


I appreciate you taking the initiative to get a positive discussion moving forward. And I think you've made a good start. But at the same time, it seems a little disingenuous to factor in the weakness/strength of the O-line when evaluating sacks, yet at the same time you have NOT factored in the weakness/strength of the overall offensive talent around the QB's when looking at other stats.

So the net result is you have come up with the two QB's with the most overall talent around them. These are both good QB's, but are they really the best when you take into account what other QB's had to work with comparably? So I think your methodology could be improved. Please take this only as constructive suggestions - I appreciate that you stepped forward and made an attempt and admire your effort while I do see areas for potential improvement.

Another area for improvement I can think of - since these are nominations - is to nominate the top 5 players and the arguments for each, and don't at this point try to reach a conclusion. You are calling these nominations but really you're giving conclusions and your reasoning.

I think it's ok if you only want to nominate from your conference - representatives from the other conference can do the same, and then with this information everyone can evaluate easier.

So my suggestion is to go back and NOMINATE the top 5 players at each position, giving all relevant information you can think of, and the arguments for each. Then the next step would be for everyone to comment and reach a conclusion.


Or you can go ahead and nominate some players you think are better than them? Or is it easier to say "you're wrong nyah nyah" than actually figure out who should be on the all conference team.
 
Gambit
offline
Link
 
The WR nominations are done:

Jimmy Tea and Mike Smith III just outshone everyone else this season.

Honorable mentions to Gather Moss and Hiram Post for outstanding seasons as well, and to Ocho Zinco for the best yards per catch and TD to drops ratio among receivers with over 1000 yards.

These are the top 5 from Zeta Conference, and also who I think are the top 2. Glanced at Alpha and Warren Doom, Jason T. Walker and John Hennessey deserve honorable mentions if I were to include Alpha, but Jimmy Tea and Mike Smith III still the best overall.
 
Gambit
offline
Link
 
QB - lots of ways of looking at QB's so let's see who stands out in different categories.

1st, productivity - VERY important.
1) Peabody 4025 yards
2) Amaya 3970 yards
3) Young II 3960 yards
4) Washim 3910 yards

2nd, % completion - not so important, as it can depend on style of offense, but generally an all-conference QB needs to have a good rating. I noticed the best QB's with 3000+ passing yards were in the 60%-65% range, so then I checked which of the above were in that range:

1) Peabody 61.1%
2) Young 61%
3) Amaya 60.8%

to me that elimated Washim, although he had 59.4% (close)

I pretty much ignored Yds/att or Yds/com as these relate to what kind of offense the team runs.

I then looked at TDs vs INTs and I saw that the best QB's had 25+ TD's but 3 had 30 or more (33, 30, 30) TD's. One of these with 30 TD's was Peabody. He also had a very respectful ratio of 14 INT's against these 30 TD's. Of the two remaining QB's, Amaya had 26 TD's against 20 INT's and Young II had 18 TD's against 26 INT's.

So my conclusion is that the best QB from Zeta is Peabody. Honorably mention to Amaya. Pohl also deserves an honorable mention for the best QB without top end passing numbers, but he can't really be considered All-Conference when you compare him to Peabody because Peabody was much more productive with 4025 yards passing and had comparably high completion percentage and TD's and TD to INT ratio.
Last edited Jul 13, 2008 18:09:41
 
Gambit
offline
Link
 
HB's

The 5 most productive HB's were

1) Hokiepride (1740)
2) William Stone (1573)
3) Graig Cooper (1535)
4) Rick Fastley (1448)
5) Ram SteelHead (1426)

All these running backs had 4 point something yards per carry except one, Ram SteelHead, with an AMAZING 6.2 yards per carry!!! SteelHead also had the least number of fumbles (4) and tied for the least number of fumbles lost (2).

Rick Fastley had 18 fumbles with 6 lost so fumbles definitely elimated him. Hokiepride (11) and William Stone (13) also had a lot of fumbles.

All the running backs had 13-15 TD's except Graig Cooper with 20. 20 TD's is an impressive feat no doubt! However, it's not as impressive as 6.2 yards per carry!! Also, while Cooper had 55% more TD's than SteelHead, he also had 75% more fumbles and 100% more fumbles lost!

The CLEAR choice for best HB in Zeta Conference is Ram SteelHead.

I think the honorable mention is best deserved by Hokiepride for being the yardage leader and having the 2nd best ypc (4.9)
 
Joebarber
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gambit
HB's

The 5 most productive HB's were

1) Hokiepride (1740)
2) William Stone (1573)
3) Graig Cooper (1535)
4) Rick Fastley (1448)
5) Ram SteelHead (1426)

All these running backs had 4 point something yards per carry except one, Ram SteelHead, with an AMAZING 6.2 yards per carry!!! SteelHead also had the least number of fumbles (4) and tied for the least number of fumbles lost (2).

Rick Fastley had 18 fumbles with 6 lost so fumbles definitely elimated him. Hokiepride (11) and William Stone (13) also had a lot of fumbles.

All the running backs had 13-15 TD's except Graig Cooper with 20. 20 TD's is an impressive feat no doubt! However, it's not as impressive as 6.2 yards per carry!! Also, while Cooper had 55% more TD's than SteelHead, he also had 75% more fumbles and 100% more fumbles lost!

The CLEAR choice for best HB in Zeta Conference is Ram SteelHead.

I think the honorable mention is best deserved by Hokiepride for being the yardage leader and having the 2nd best ypc (4.9)


Umm no...
In your opinion the choice is Ram SteelHead. IMO 20 TDs is a hell of a lot more impressive than a 6.2 YPC, especially when he is splitting carries with the most productive back in the conference.
 
Sly
offline
Link
 
That's because it's your player. It's impressive that the Pimps scored 70 TD's as a team, and their RB's got 37 of those TD's and your player by luck of the substitution happened to be the one in the game on 20 of those TD's. So what the team did IS impressive, but you trying to ride that team achievement to claim your individual player is something more than he is is just, well, exactly what I'd expect from a Shrimps player. You have a decent player but nothing more, and he's far from the best HB in the league.
 
Joebarber
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sly
That's because it's your player. It's impressive that the Pimps scored 70 TD's as a team, and their RB's got 37 of those TD's and your player by luck of the substitution happened to be the one in the game on 20 of those TD's. So what the team did IS impressive, but you trying to ride that team achievement to claim your individual player is something more than he is is just, well, exactly what I'd expect from a Shrimps player. You have a decent player but nothing more, and he's far from the best HB in the league.


Actually it's not my player...I've got 2 lineman...
 
hokeez
offline
Link
 
How can you honestly look at fumbles and count those more than fumbles lost? if your own team recovers, it doesnt really hurt the offense. In most cases the running back is past the line of scrimmage when he fumbles so he still gains some yards.

Yes Hokie has 11 fumbles but he only lost 2 of those. Thats a huge difference rather than if he had lost all 11 of those.

What I would consider in addition to overall yards is number of first downs.

Cooper is 3rd(?) in yards and tied for first in td's. He also has 30 more first downs than my running back. That stat is important because it shows that it was his effort that moved the chains and kept the drive going.

My choice for 1st team HB is Cooper. He had a good balance of yardage, touchdowns, few fumbles, and first downs. I think he has shown that he is one of the more complete running backs in the league
 
Gambit
offline
Link
 
I don't see any stats that I can use to compare Cooper's 1st downs to Ram SteelHead's 1st downs, so unless you can point me to where I can find that easily, I'm afraid it's a dead-end as a suggestion. In any case, I'm not sure what it means, except one HB happened to be subbed in more often on 1st down and another more often on 3rd down. Without situational data it's hard to evaluate. How many 3rd and 1 opportunities did each back have? How many 3rd and 2? etc. Unless the situations are comparable the number of 1st downs resulting from those situations isn't relevant.

I did go back and look to see if there was anything else relevant I should be taking into account. First, the issue has been raised that Cooper was splitting time. However, Ram SteelHead was also splitting time with William Stone, the #2 most prolific back, so Cooper's splitting time doesn't make him special in this comparison.

None of the backs seem to have any receiving stats worth mentioning, so that's not a way to find more insight.

However, I did find this: Ram SteelHead has 84!! broken tackles compared to Cooper's 44. Hokiepride has 28.

So this is the only other stat that's relevant that I missed, and once again it points to Ram SteelHead as the CLEAR choice of best HB in the conference!
Last edited Jul 13, 2008 21:56:02
 
Joebarber
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gambit
I don't see any stats that I can use to compare Cooper's 1st downs to Ram SteelHead's 1st downs, so unless you can point me to where I can find that easily, I'm afraid it's a dead-end as a suggestion. In any case, I'm not sure what it means, except one HB happened to be subbed in more often on 1st down and another more often on 3rd down. Without situational data it's hard to evaluate. How many 3rd and 1 opportunities did each back have? How many 3rd and 2? etc. Unless the situations are comparable the number of 1st downs resulting from those situations isn't relevant.

I did go back and look to see if there was anything else relevant I should be taking into account. First, the issue has been raised that Cooper was splitting time. However, Ram SteelHead was also splitting time with William Stone, the #2 most prolific back, so Cooper's splitting time doesn't make him special in this comparison.

None of the backs seem to have any receiving stats worth mentioning, so that's not a way to find more insight.

However, I did find this: Ram SteelHead has 84!! broken tackles compared to Cooper's 44. Hokiepride has 28.

So this is the only other stat that's relevant that I missed, and once again it points to Ram SteelHead as the CLEAR choice of best HB in the conference!


Unless you want to go back and count how many times cooper and hokie juked someone that stat is a non-issue as well. Cooper and Hokie aren't power backs, so they don't break tackles. Steelhead isn't an elusive back, so he won't have jukes.
 
hokeez
offline
Link
 
ugh this pisses me off i saw it the other day, it was in a stat column like the other regular statistics but i cant remember where i saw it now. ill let ya know if i find it
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gambit
The WR nominations are done:

Jimmy Tea and Mike Smith III just outshone everyone else this season.

Honorable mentions to Gather Moss and Hiram Post for outstanding seasons as well, and to Ocho Zinco for the best yards per catch and TD to drops ratio among receivers with over 1000 yards.

These are the top 5 from Zeta Conference, and also who I think are the top 2. Glanced at Alpha and Warren Doom, Jason T. Walker and John Hennessey deserve honorable mentions if I were to include Alpha, but Jimmy Tea and Mike Smith III still the best overall.


I don't see how you can nominate WR's and not include someone that is third in yards, tied for first in TD's, with fewer drops, a higher YPC average and a higher YAC. That would be Preston Parker. Not only that you didn't even give him honorable mention.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.