I should have held off on the voting lol.
pink_panther
offline
offline
Originally posted by Majpain
I should have held off on the voting lol.
I would think that you would be able to change your vote until at least the regular season is over.
I should have held off on the voting lol.
I would think that you would be able to change your vote until at least the regular season is over.
GridIronKing34
offline
offline
Originally posted by Majpain
I should have held off on the voting lol.
Here's how I think you shuold do Pro Bowl Voting...
1. Have Nominations thread where players can nominate players.
2. Put together a ballot, while going through team leaders for each team to see if anyone was snubbed for the list.
3. Send out the ballot to ONLY COACHES, let them vote for their teams players. The best player will win regardless.
4. When you get back all ballots, or as many as possible, tally up the results and bam, you got yourself a Pro Bowl team. It'd probably be better to have one guy handle Eastern and the other Western... This worked very well for USA AAA #1.
I should have held off on the voting lol.
Here's how I think you shuold do Pro Bowl Voting...
1. Have Nominations thread where players can nominate players.
2. Put together a ballot, while going through team leaders for each team to see if anyone was snubbed for the list.
3. Send out the ballot to ONLY COACHES, let them vote for their teams players. The best player will win regardless.
4. When you get back all ballots, or as many as possible, tally up the results and bam, you got yourself a Pro Bowl team. It'd probably be better to have one guy handle Eastern and the other Western... This worked very well for USA AAA #1.
Last edited Jul 8, 2008 19:20:53
redwolfe11
offline
offline
You cant limit the voting to only coaches. There are some inactive coaches on the forums, and some very active player owners.
Pariah
offline
offline
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
UMBF
offline
offline
Originally posted by Pariah
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
What I did for all-pro teams in EE AAA #1 last season was have every team submit a ballot, which let them choose how they wanted to do it - whether they wanted to vote on it in their forums, or just choose someone to fill out the ballot for the team.
It also lets you vote for your own team members, because if there is any bias, it basically gets cancelled out as it is one of 32 (probably fewer, but we got 28 in EE AAA #1) ballots. The problem with voting for people on your own team in a format like this is if every individual person is allowed to vote, teams can try to flood the ballot box with lots of members of their team, and it isn't really fair to teams with only a few agents, as opposed to teams made up of many agents.
It also lets you vote for your own team members, because if there is any bias, it basically gets cancelled out as it is one of 32 (probably fewer, but we got 28 in EE AAA #1) ballots. The problem with voting for people on your own team in a format like this is if every individual person is allowed to vote, teams can try to flood the ballot box with lots of members of their team, and it isn't really fair to teams with only a few agents, as opposed to teams made up of many agents.
Dannyg28
offline
offline
Originally posted by Pariah
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
don't you remember last season when the millens voted for practically only millens. thats what i am trying to avoid.
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
don't you remember last season when the millens voted for practically only millens. thats what i am trying to avoid.
SteelAngel2001
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dannyg28
Originally posted by Pariah
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
don't you remember last season when the millens voted for practically only millens. thats what i am trying to avoid.
it's not our fault all our players were pro bowlers :V
Originally posted by Pariah
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
don't you remember last season when the millens voted for practically only millens. thats what i am trying to avoid.
it's not our fault all our players were pro bowlers :V
Majpain
offline
offline
Originally posted by SteelAngel2001
Originally posted by Dannyg28
Originally posted by Pariah
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
don't you remember last season when the millens voted for practically only millens. thats what i am trying to avoid.
it's not our fault all our players were pro bowlers :V
Maybe a couple.
Originally posted by Dannyg28
Originally posted by Pariah
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
don't you remember last season when the millens voted for practically only millens. thats what i am trying to avoid.
it's not our fault all our players were pro bowlers :V
Maybe a couple.
pink_panther
offline
offline
It really only messes up the Western conference whatever the Millens decide to do so this basic concept should be fine.
cwcapper
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dannyg28
Originally posted by Pariah
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
don't you remember last season when the millens voted for practically only millens. thats what i am trying to avoid.
They would never do that. I can't believe that the millens guys all voted for themselves. Weird.
Originally posted by Pariah
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
don't you remember last season when the millens voted for practically only millens. thats what i am trying to avoid.
They would never do that. I can't believe that the millens guys all voted for themselves. Weird.
SteelAngel2001
offline
offline
Originally posted by cwcapper
Originally posted by Dannyg28
Originally posted by Pariah
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
don't you remember last season when the millens voted for practically only millens. thats what i am trying to avoid.
They would never do that. I can't believe that the millens guys all voted for themselves. Weird.
We were balanced out by everyone else in the conference voting mostly Aces.
Originally posted by Dannyg28
Originally posted by Pariah
I think team members should be able to vote for team members, but not for themselves. I think its a waste to vote for someone on another team if the player on your own team deserves to make it.
don't you remember last season when the millens voted for practically only millens. thats what i am trying to avoid.
They would never do that. I can't believe that the millens guys all voted for themselves. Weird.
We were balanced out by everyone else in the conference voting mostly Aces.
RazorStar
offline
offline
I think a few wildcats deserve spots, but I left them blank, because putting someone else there didn't seem fair, and I can't actually put them there.
Coriantumr
offline
offline
Defensive numbers are misleading, if you go off of tackles then you are pretty much clueless on how the game works. If a guy has the largest amount of tackles that doesn't mean he is the better player it just means his offense sux and the D is always on the field. Defense is hard to judge in this game because all you see is a little circle running around and not everyone watches every play of every game. You could go off of player build but then not all players want to share their build with the rest of the world, so D is the hardest to pick for Pro Bowl I think. If there were a way to put up numbers per play or averaged like that then that would be a more accurate way to show the D. Say 10 tackles in 30 plays is better than 20 tackles in 100 plays. Also because a LB doesn't get many tackles doesn't mean he sux it just means that his D line is too good. Too many factors in Defense to make a good choice but you guys can have fun with that. My lonely SS doesn't put up great numbers and to me that is a good thing, becuase if you have an SS with too many tackles that means the rest of your D isn't doing their job very well.
Last edited Jul 9, 2008 07:16:00
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























