User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > sack fumble bug. no credit for the sack
Page:
 
Link
 
Do you know that he even tackled him though? He could have just stripped it out of his hands, from what I saw he didn't even touch the QB, so it might have just been stripped.
 
AnthonyE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lionsalltheway
Do you know that he even tackled him though? He could have just stripped it out of his hands, from what I saw he didn't even touch the QB, so it might have just been stripped.


It's still recorded as a sack. Watching David Carr at quarterback for 5 years, I know this particular rule. lol.
 
vexxet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lionsalltheway
Do you know that he even tackled him though? He could have just stripped it out of his hands, from what I saw he didn't even touch the QB, so it might have just been stripped.


ive though of that, but then why was he credited with the forced fumble? if he touches the QB in any shape way or form and the ball comes out it IS a sack fumble.
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vexxet
Originally posted by lionsalltheway

Do you know that he even tackled him though? He could have just stripped it out of his hands, from what I saw he didn't even touch the QB, so it might have just been stripped.


ive though of that, but then why was he credited with the forced fumble? if he touches the QB in any shape way or form and the ball comes out it IS a sack fumble.


No it's not. If he just strips it out of the QB hands it's just a FF..not a sack. If he knocks the player down and on the way down he fumbles...then yes it's a sack. Strahan of the NYG was really good at sticking his hands out and causing fumbles. He would get a FF for that, but not the sack unless the QB went down too.

EDIT: For example, Strahan runs along the backside of Favre, knocks the ball out of his hands while being pushed by an RB. The ball pops free and is recovered by Strahan. He gets a FF and a FR..not a sack. However, if he actually "tackles" favre and on the way down the ball comes out...it's a sack, FF, FR.

Get it?
Last edited Apr 12, 2008 23:16:32
 
partylwc
offline
Link
 
so what if its a designed draw play but the QB gets stuffed behind the line of scrimmage.. i mean technically teh QB could still have thrown the ball so why is this not a sack? and why is TFL not on the stat sheet? its just tackles sacks and ints pretty much.. I mean my players got a FR and a TFL but as far as anyone else knows hes just got 6 tackles; that kinda blows
 
DiMo28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by partylwc
so what if its a designed draw play but the QB gets stuffed behind the line of scrimmage.. i mean technically teh QB could still have thrown the ball so why is this not a sack? and why is TFL not on the stat sheet? its just tackles sacks and ints pretty much.. I mean my players got a FR and a TFL but as far as anyone else knows hes just got 6 tackles; that kinda blows


I don't care what others are saying. I know for a fact that if you cause the QB to fumble on a pass play, it's a sack (and a forced fumble). It doesn't matter if you get all ball and don't even graze the QB's jersey. It's a sack.

If it is a designed QB draw, then it would not be a sack.
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
I'm pretty sure if the ball is knocked out on an intended pass play, whether the QB is tackled or not, it's a sack and a forced fumble.
 
DiMo28
offline
Link
 
Here is a definition of a team sack and it supports my stance:

"Team sacks come from when a QB either runs out of bounds untouched (behind the line of scrimmage) or fumbles the ball while attempting to pass."
 
vexxet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
Originally posted by vexxet

Originally posted by lionsalltheway


Do you know that he even tackled him though? He could have just stripped it out of his hands, from what I saw he didn't even touch the QB, so it might have just been stripped.


ive though of that, but then why was he credited with the forced fumble? if he touches the QB in any shape way or form and the ball comes out it IS a sack fumble.


No it's not. If he just strips it out of the QB hands it's just a FF..not a sack. If he knocks the player down and on the way down he fumbles...then yes it's a sack. Strahan of the NYG was really good at sticking his hands out and causing fumbles. He would get a FF for that, but not the sack unless the QB went down too.

EDIT: For example, Strahan runs along the backside of Favre, knocks the ball out of his hands while being pushed by an RB. The ball pops free and is recovered by Strahan. He gets a FF and a FR..not a sack. However, if he actually "tackles" favre and on the way down the ball comes out...it's a sack, FF, FR.

Get it?


no i dont get it. what you said is wrong. thats a sack fumble.
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
Originally posted by vexxet

Originally posted by lionsalltheway


Do you know that he even tackled him though? He could have just stripped it out of his hands, from what I saw he didn't even touch the QB, so it might have just been stripped.


ive though of that, but then why was he credited with the forced fumble? if he touches the QB in any shape way or form and the ball comes out it IS a sack fumble.


No it's not. If he just strips it out of the QB hands it's just a FF..not a sack. If he knocks the player down and on the way down he fumbles...then yes it's a sack. Strahan of the NYG was really good at sticking his hands out and causing fumbles. He would get a FF for that, but not the sack unless the QB went down too.

EDIT: For example, Strahan runs along the backside of Favre, knocks the ball out of his hands while being pushed by an RB. The ball pops free and is recovered by Strahan. He gets a FF and a FR..not a sack. However, if he actually "tackles" favre and on the way down the ball comes out...it's a sack, FF, FR.

Get it?


Nope, you are wrong. The QB does NOT have to go down for it to be a sack. This is true for college and the NFL.

There are instances where a QB will scramble out on a passing play and run out of bounds and lose yardage. Typically, if a defender was chasing him, they will credit this defender with a sack, even though he did not actually tackle the QB.

The same thing applies in this case. Though the QB is not falling down, he is fumbling the football, on a pass play, because of a defender. So the defender who got to him gets credited for a sack and a forced fumble. The QB falling down has nothing to do with it.

Look here:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=DoEtX_pAoFQ

First play on that video is the exact example of what I'm talking about.
 
VikesRule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by partylwc
so what if its a designed draw play but the QB gets stuffed behind the line of scrimmage.. i mean technically teh QB could still have thrown the ball so why is this not a sack? and why is TFL not on the stat sheet? its just tackles sacks and ints pretty much.. I mean my players got a FR and a TFL but as far as anyone else knows hes just got 6 tackles; that kinda blows

This is something I don't agree with, but that's how it is. A QB draw, or any play that the QB is supposed to run on without passing, does not allow "sacks" to happen, rather the QB is treated simply as a runningback and any tackle behind the LOS results in a TFL.

I disagree and think that whomever is the first person to receive the snap from center, if they are tackled behind the LOS, it should be a sack, in my opinion. But that is not how the NFL works, only on a pass play will they credit a defender with a sack. How they determine what is and isn't a pass play is up to the stat guys.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.