User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
aharden2
offline
Link
 
In response to aprjem:

"There are three kinds of lies: lies, damned lies, and statistics." The semi-ironic statement refers to the persuasive power of numbers, and succinctly describes how even accurate statistics can be used to bolster inaccurate arguments.

(quote made famous by Mark Twain)
 
Lefty Wall
offline
Link
 
I've taken a real interest today in whose stronger Alpha or Zeta and I have to say currently the crown belongs to Alpha as they are the raining champions this being said I would have to give the vegas odds to Zeta for this season as Belo/Monkeys look to be extremely strong contenders. Then again in the playoffs anything can happen if not what would be the point of playing the games.
 
aharden2
offline
Link
 
For instance, why do we need to include the top 8 teams? Why not just the teams that have homefield advantage? After all, when was the last time someone in the bottom 4 took home a league championship? The top 4 are the real contenders, so they should be the only ones we care about.

Current top 4 in Alpha:
San Juan Ridgerunners - 39
Rio Revolucion - 39
Arsenal - 36
Peru Deacons - 39

Total = 153
Avg = 38.25


Current top 4 in Zeta:
Belo Horizonte Miners - 39
Krazy Monkeys - 42
Manus Thunder - 39
Brazil Cubs - 39

Total = 159
Avg. = 39.75


The average contender in the Zeta conference will be 1.5 levels better than the average contender in the Alpha conference.

Perhaps you don't like including just the teams with homefield advantage, and would rather add in the 5 and the 6 seeds, teams who are likely to just barely miss homefield advantage in the first round but are very capable of winning a couple of playoff games. That will look something like this:


Current top 6 in Alpha:
San Juan Ridgerunners - 39
Rio Revolucion - 39
Arsenal - 36
Peru Deacons - 39
Camelot Knights - 39
Macchu Picchu Bulldogs - 36


Total = 228
Avg = 38

Current top 6 in Zeta:
Belo Horizonte Miners - 39
Krazy Monkeys - 42
Manus Thunder - 39
Brazil Cubs - 39
Cleveland Dawgpound - 39
USAORG Cartel - 39


Total = 237
Avg. = 39.5


So, if you are basing things off of the top 6 teams in each league, the average contender in the Zeta conference is still ahead by 1.5 levels! I think I have very clearly shown that the power shifts to the Zeta when you view the top 4 and the top 6 teams from each conference.

Last edited Jul 7, 2008 17:20:35
 
aharden2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aprjem


In an averaging of all the top 8 teams overall ratings, Zeta leads the Alpha conference by the slim margin of 38.625 to 37.825. That is mostly skewed by the fact that the Krazy Monkeys, one of the best rated teams in GLB, have a rating of 42.


Are you sure it's not "mostly skewed" by the 8th place team in the Zeta conference having a 33 rating? I mean, if we are scratching off the Monkeys because they are 3-point outliers on the positive side, shouldn't we scratch off the Roughnecks because they are 6-point outliers on the negative side? I find it interesting that a team with a 42 rating is "mostly" skewing an average of 38.62, but the team with the 33 rating is not even mentioned. Perhaps you have an underlying agenda???
Last edited Jul 7, 2008 17:26:43
 
ShamsTron
offline
Link
 
I don't think that is 1.5 "levels". Also I am not a fan of the overall ranking. For one is goes by 3 so that is a wide margin of error. Also the stats are not made that well, for example I remember seeing somewhere that the WR's rushing skill is put into question when involving the rushing bar.
 
aharden2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ShamsTron
I don't think that is 1.5 "levels". Also I am not a fan of the overall ranking. For one is goes by 3 so that is a wide margin of error. Also the stats are not made that well, for example I remember seeing somewhere that the WR's rushing skill is put into question when involving the rushing bar.


I agree, I'm just using the guidelines that one of your fellow Alpha conference proponents created. Based off of ratings, the averages point directly in favor of the Zeta conference.
 
aprjem
offline
Link
 
Sorry man... I appreciate your appology. I just enjoy a heated debate!
 
aprjem
offline
Link
 
I agree they are in favor... but NOT BY ENOUGH TO SAY ONE WAY OR THE OTHER. I used top 8 because those are the ones in the playoffs, thats all.
 
mwitter
offline
Link
 
Current top 4 in Alpha:
San Juan Ridgerunners - 39
Rio Revolucion - 39
Arsenal - 36
Peru Deacons - 39



How you found this 36? Score and lvl starter?
 
jkocurek
offline
Link
 
I just wish we had a playoff to determine who the best team was.
 
bacchuspoet
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ksychic
Sorry aprjem, "asses" was not the best word, and I apologize. I just feel Belo and Krazy should be the top 2 teams in the ranking. I didn't use the best wording. Some say Rio and San Juan should be 1 and 2. Anyway, we are all entitled to our opinions. Sorry for using the wrong wording, and don't get me wrong, I respect ALL Alpha teams .

Once again, my apologies to who took it offensively.


ksychic, that is the most sincere apology I think I've ever seen on a GLB forum. Thanks for being a man and giving respect instead of being an a-hole and trying to start a bunch of crap. You're a class act.
As far as your opinion goes? I respect it, just don't agree with it!
 
aharden2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jkocurek
I just wish we had a playoff to determine who the best team was.



Ya, the media poll is really going to hurt a bunch of teams this year. And don't get me started on that damn coach's poll. What a bunch of morons!
 
tyrant91101
offline
Link
 
Wait are you guys seriously ranking this based on the matchup screens? Jesus christ.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/compare_teams.pl?team1=373&team2=528

Which team is the best?
 
ksychic
offline
Link
 
Alright, I guess I'll agree with my owner Lefty Wall who I have tremendous respect for. At the current moment, Alpha is the better conference. The champion came from the Alpha conference and until a team from Zeta wins, Alpha should be thought of as better.

However, with that being said, with the addition of a few great teams in our conference this year, I feel Zeta is stronger overall.

We will know who is better the day the championship is played. We don't know how it will shape up after some Alpha teams boost, so I guess for me to instantly assume Krazy and Belo would win is also wrong.

Good luck to all teams in the Playoffs .
 
Korak
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by aharden2
Originally posted by jkocurek

I just wish we had a playoff to determine who the best team was.



Ya, the media poll is really going to hurt a bunch of teams this year. And don't get me started on that damn coach's poll. What a bunch of morons!



Maybe we should have a committee to select match-ups to be played as one game playoffs. This should stop all of the complaints.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.