User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Owner Bashing Threads, Name Calling, Hate-Speech
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jorge
I'm all about being respectful to others and dealing with things in a civil manner. I highly doubt I would ever be in the situation where I would feel the need to "call someone out" publicly. However, if I did get to that point then the conversations I have had to include responses I had recieved along with conversations directed at me do not hold any sort of "protection". They happened, they are real, if someone doesn't want to be quoted then they need to be more careful about "thinking before they speak".

I find it extremely disturbing that this thread is telling me that if I ever got to the point that I felt I needed to take an issue publicly then all conversations in private forums and private messages can not be included. Seriously, what sort of made up law is this?

I'm sorry but this is the internet and while you might silence people here(I can't even believe I read that you want to...still blows my mind) you can't keep people from expressing themselves.



This is my first real forum post outside of private team forums but I want to agree with jorge on this issue. If you tell an owner they can make whatever promises they want to make in team forums or via private massage and the player is prohibited from being able to hold these owners publicly accountable for their words and deeds then you are doing a disservice to players of the game (especially those who pay money to you for extra flex points.)

In real life, a player who has been lied to by an owner would present it to the media if they had written proof of it. Yes, they also have a grievance process through the Union but that doesn't stop them from going public with the matter.

I understand what you are wanting to do in limiting the public conflict in the game. However, if owners know that they can be held publicly accountable for the things they tell someone privately it will cause them to be a little more responsible for the things they say and do. They won't be able to lie to someone just to get them on their team.

An owner rating might not tell the real story of an owner. If a guy can't seem to put together a winning game plan he would be rated low. If an owner wins but puts the screws to players in the process he could have a moderate rating that doesn't tell the real story.

I am always against private messages being sent when private issues are discussed. When it's germane to the game play of this league, then I'm not as inclined to say it has to be completely secret if it pertains directly to unfulfilled promises to a player.

Please reconsider your blanket protection of owners and players that would allow them to lie to each other with complete immunity. In the end, it would reflect badly on this game and be a deterrent to having people join and participate.
 
KGrob
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by daleandelisdad
Originally posted by jorge

I'm all about being respectful to others and dealing with things in a civil manner. I highly doubt I would ever be in the situation where I would feel the need to "call someone out" publicly. However, if I did get to that point then the conversations I have had to include responses I had recieved along with conversations directed at me do not hold any sort of "protection". They happened, they are real, if someone doesn't want to be quoted then they need to be more careful about "thinking before they speak".

I find it extremely disturbing that this thread is telling me that if I ever got to the point that I felt I needed to take an issue publicly then all conversations in private forums and private messages can not be included. Seriously, what sort of made up law is this?

I'm sorry but this is the internet and while you might silence people here(I can't even believe I read that you want to...still blows my mind) you can't keep people from expressing themselves.



This is my first real forum post outside of private team forums but I want to agree with jorge on this issue. If you tell an owner they can make whatever promises they want to make in team forums or via private massage and the player is prohibited from being able to hold these owners publicly accountable for their words and deeds then you are doing a disservice to players of the game (especially those who pay money to you for extra flex points.)

In real life, a player who has been lied to by an owner would present it to the media if they had written proof of it. Yes, they also have a grievance process through the Union but that doesn't stop them from going public with the matter.

I understand what you are wanting to do in limiting the public conflict in the game. However, if owners know that they can be held publicly accountable for the things they tell someone privately it will cause them to be a little more responsible for the things they say and do. They won't be able to lie to someone just to get them on their team.

An owner rating might not tell the real story of an owner. If a guy can't seem to put together a winning game plan he would be rated low. If an owner wins but puts the screws to players in the process he could have a moderate rating that doesn't tell the real story.

I am always against private messages being sent when private issues are discussed. When it's germane to the game play of this league, then I'm not as inclined to say it has to be completely secret if it pertains directly to unfulfilled promises to a player.

Please reconsider your blanket protection of owners and players that would allow them to lie to each other with complete immunity. In the end, it would reflect badly on this game and be a deterrent to having people join and participate.


Nice post. Good points.

 
pnewtonjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KGrob
Originally posted by daleandelisdad

Originally posted by jorge


I'm all about being respectful to others and dealing with things in a civil manner. I highly doubt I would ever be in the situation where I would feel the need to "call someone out" publicly. However, if I did get to that point then the conversations I have had to include responses I had recieved along with conversations directed at me do not hold any sort of "protection". They happened, they are real, if someone doesn't want to be quoted then they need to be more careful about "thinking before they speak".

I find it extremely disturbing that this thread is telling me that if I ever got to the point that I felt I needed to take an issue publicly then all conversations in private forums and private messages can not be included. Seriously, what sort of made up law is this?

I'm sorry but this is the internet and while you might silence people here(I can't even believe I read that you want to...still blows my mind) you can't keep people from expressing themselves.



This is my first real forum post outside of private team forums but I want to agree with jorge on this issue. If you tell an owner they can make whatever promises they want to make in team forums or via private massage and the player is prohibited from being able to hold these owners publicly accountable for their words and deeds then you are doing a disservice to players of the game (especially those who pay money to you for extra flex points.)

In real life, a player who has been lied to by an owner would present it to the media if they had written proof of it. Yes, they also have a grievance process through the Union but that doesn't stop them from going public with the matter.

I understand what you are wanting to do in limiting the public conflict in the game. However, if owners know that they can be held publicly accountable for the things they tell someone privately it will cause them to be a little more responsible for the things they say and do. They won't be able to lie to someone just to get them on their team.

An owner rating might not tell the real story of an owner. If a guy can't seem to put together a winning game plan he would be rated low. If an owner wins but puts the screws to players in the process he could have a moderate rating that doesn't tell the real story.

I am always against private messages being sent when private issues are discussed. When it's germane to the game play of this league, then I'm not as inclined to say it has to be completely secret if it pertains directly to unfulfilled promises to a player.

Please reconsider your blanket protection of owners and players that would allow them to lie to each other with complete immunity. In the end, it would reflect badly on this game and be a deterrent to having people join and participate.


Nice post. Good points.



Agree fully. A blanket protection of owners and players will kill the game in the end.


 
pnewtonjr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by panther17
So will owners with 10+ players on their own team going to be able to vote 10+ times saying that the owner is great even when he could be totally neglecting the other players on his team not controlled by him?




And this is rather an important point. I don't want it to get buried.
 
Greg B
offline
Link
 
I dont have any mean comments to say about the team owner Im playing for, he seems like a nice guy just not very active. Gets frustrating losing 98-8
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pnewtonjr
Originally posted by panther17

So will owners with 10+ players on their own team going to be able to vote 10+ times saying that the owner is great even when he could be totally neglecting the other players on his team not controlled by him?




And this is rather an important point. I don't want it to get buried.


They wouldn't be able to vote towards their own rating.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Will owners get to retort, i.e. Player went inactive regularly? Player didn't update training to be ready for next game?

Or what about previous owners? Or will it just be relegated to the team you are currently on?

I may be in the "doghouse" for going public with my issue. Although I have apologized, I can't take it back now.
Last edited Apr 12, 2008 01:59:35
 
Link
 
ok this is kinda contradicting isnt it

u say u dont want any bashing or anything yet u have a forum inviting it in yes i kno i dont have to read and i dont but still u guys kinda should choose one way or another cuz the trash talking does filter into users inboxes other forums etc so i really do think u should allow it everywhere or no where at all just making that point if its already been made here sorry
 
hud
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wolffangmaster1
ok this is kinda contradicting isnt it

u have a forum inviting it in



what? The Trash Talk forum is for game talk and call outs of characters and teams. It is not for bashing, or complaining, or calling the users out.

THere is nothing wrong with that forum... there is nothing contradictory.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
Originally posted by wolffangmaster1

ok this is kinda contradicting isnt it

u have a forum inviting it in



what? The Trash Talk forum is for game talk and call outs of characters and teams. It is not for bashing, or complaining, or calling the users out.

THere is nothing wrong with that forum... there is nothing contradictory.



so whats the difference if someone says "dude u suck shit" in here or in any other forum besides the trash talk one i'm just saying u shouldnt be saying none of that stuff when u still can do it i see that as contradicting if going by what Bort said is he doesnt want to see that stuff anywhere when there is a forum to do it i wouldnt have a problem if it would STAY in the forum but it wont stay there as it can be seen in one of the sticky posts and a guy saying he gets stuff in his inbox about it
 
hud
offline
Link
 
THAT FORUM IS TO TALK ABOUT THE IMAGINARY PLAYERS AND TEAMS. B&D dont want people to trash talk the people who play the game. There is a big difference. It is wrong for me to call say "wolffangmaster1 is a piece of crap player who will f you if you deal with him." It doesnt matter if i say it in GLB forum or the trash talk forum. They dont want it. According to the set up, I could say that you have made some bad choices and people should beware of you. People PMing that dude is a little imature.

But in the spirit of the trash talk forum i could say in a new thread "John Slaughter (LB) is a piece of crap who doesnt belong in the USA BB. But as long he is on the suck ass LV Gamblers, we will let him stay."

BIG DIFFERENCE
 
Link
 
i didnt think of it that way but yeah that makes sense i just saw it as a place to bash ppl directly to them but yeah i cant really say anything against ppl bashing computer generated characters
 
hud
offline
Link
 
glad i could help. But you are right, the trash talk forum had alot of user bashing going on. The new Mods have been trying to moniter it though and are doing a good job.

We have to be talk about other users, but there also has to be a line. Bort and DD are trying to draw that line with this thread and through enforcing consequences.
 
Link
 
yep and for only being 2 main ppl doin this they r doing one hell of a job
 
D30weasel
offline
Link
 
We could do it like EBAY does. I'm not sure what it would take to implement the idea, but every EBAY user has their own rating. With individual comments, and grades.

For example, an owner has a tendancy to lie to players to get them to sign. After awhile, his rating gets low, and players who are considering signing with him can view his ratings, from every player that has chosen to contribute to his rating, and see that several players have bee duped by the owner.

But, on the other side of the coin, that owner can leave negative scores, and remarks, about those players.

Then, the smart player can look at the owners negative remarks, and go find out if those individual players have a history, or if it is trend for that owner to mistreat his players.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.