User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Page:
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
The problem with just having a team be reset after it's sold is the lack of continuity. There's no way to continue a franchise unless you want to own it for the entire period of time. Allow for owner-to-player transfers of teams to GM's that have been there for at least a season.

If you want to move up teams then you do it by record/tiebreaker as normal. I wouldn't recommend moving a team immediately down however for obvious reasons (lopsided / bloated conferences).

Allow for teams to be processed to bottom rung in the offseason. Owners who sell midseason are refunded the appropriate FP and the team becomes CPU owned. The top 3 longest running GM's of the team are given full GM powers for the remainder of the season. If the team had no GM's, then it is either CPU run or offered to be GM'd to a random person chosen from the waiting list (Trial GM period).
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
There's no way to continue a franchise unless you want to own it for the entire period of time.


Owning a team isn't a part time luxury anyone can afford with the demand for teams so high. Anyway, it sounds like your ideas fit pretty closely with a few of mine. I think this idea can work.
 
YardRat
offline
Link
 
1. The next highest rated teams should move up to fill the new void, based on the playoff brackets and then w/l record as the first tie-breaker, conference standing for regular season as the next, etc.

2. Interim ownership via another GM or player currently on the team to finish out the season with the option to remain owner at season's end, or continue with the sale.

3. No cpu players on any roster allowed, except for teams in the bottom tier of their league.

4. Is there an option to buy (accept/deny) for new owners currently when offered a team with no penalty (dropping down/off the list)? If not, there should be. If a new owner wants to field a team with his players in the 20's, then he should be allowed to A)Refuse ownership of a team that is going to restrict his capability to create such a team without losing the opportunity to own or B)Accept the team with full knowledge that the lvl 20's in a lower rated league is going to suffer sportsmanship penalties.

5. See the interim ownership comment in #2.
 
cheese4ead
offline
Link
 
The problem with this is that the owner is not the be all and end all of the team. Guys are putting the effort and the cash to make their teams the best they can be. If an owner decides to go awol how is this the fault of the rest of the team. Worse still if the owner goes from Dr Jekyl to Mr Hyde and logs in once in 16 days then on the 16th day post a message to say "I've sold the team, have a nice day" how is that the teams fault. The current rules aren't dealing with this type of thing and this has happened twice to us. The GM's and players of the team I am on took ownership of this team by the amount of work put into it and earned the right to elect a new owner within the ranks. These situations aren't black and white and need individual assessment.
 
manic
offline
Link
 
Not every problem can be solved, and not all of them need to be.. Some things need to work themselves out, and will over time given the chance.

I think this is a bad idea that will cause more problems than it solves, if it even solves any. Someone who gets a previously owned team is likely to be outmatched, thats just the way it is, the playing fields can't always be equal. It may be alot worse if the previous owner had a "fire sale" or something. If fire sales are a problem then address them, don't start limiting when teams can be bought and sold and reverting every team to a brand new team to try and make things fair for everyone.
Last edited Jun 29, 2008 05:00:03
 
coboney
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, I've seen this idea floated around several times in several threads, and I do kinda like the idea of everyone starting with the same clean slate, bottom rung, when you get a team. There are some issues with the idea, though, so I'm just sort of collecting the various versions of this idea in one spot for discussion.

Basically the idea I've seen is:

When a team is sold back to the game, all the players are released and it gets moved to the bottom tier, gets stadium and fan support reset, and appropriate teams get moved up the ladder at promotion time (end of the season).

Now, help me figure out solutions to the problems that haven't been worked out with the idea, to see if it's even feasible:

1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

Thanks all...feel free to add to the ideas and problems list.


1. The way to do it is to have it bump. So if a Team in PRO drops to AA - then the top ranked team in AA not getting promoted promotes then the top ranked team in AAA not getting promoted gets bumped up too. This way all the leagues are the same size still.

2. Maybe when a team is sold the GMs and Players have a 48 hour window to buy it regardless if they are on the wait list. This also deals with #5 as if there's someone on the team who wants to take it over they can.

3. If no GM or Player buys the team - maybe make it like the Dleagues as it was suggested where they can be offered contracts still. This way they don't screwed of EXP at a bad time of sale.

4. I don't think there's much you an do here that I can think of.

5. Addressed in #2 - if no one though is willing to buy - 3. happens
 
Beefcake Jack
offline
Link
 
I'm not entirely sure how to solve the problem, but I know it sucks to be in the position I found myself in. I was excited to see that I finally bought a team, but the excitement quickly faded when I received a AAA team that was basically inactive. I've done my best to get players and field a competitive team, but what it is going to amount to is a waste of flex points as it is going to take the initial ownership period to right the ship. Maybe an option to let the top X in the waiting list have an option to see what is available before purchase and perhaps work with an exiting owner to make transition not so bad.
Last edited Jun 29, 2008 07:26:11
 
Willis66
offline
Link
 
I like this idea, and youre right on the money with number 2 dont do that. Also how long do account merges usually take to be completed?
 
Warhawk
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Because of issues 4 and 5, my suggestion would be to automatically relegate teams that are sold that season in the normal relegation process, regardless of their record, and not release all players. The biggest problem I've seen with gutted teams is that a lot of them are sold mid-season with a couple wins under their belt, and then they hang around in the league, while other teams who are probably better than them get relegated. That way they would move down a league, as they ought to, but probably wouldn't cause problems for the new owner from a sportsmanship or level cap perspective, and if the team is still a competitive team, the new owner can easily move back up, instead of having to wait several seasons to get back to where the team was before.

I think releasing all the players will probably hurt teams recruiting in the long run. Moving teams to the bottom rung would help them if the league they're moving into has been around for only a season or so, but an all-CPU team in USA BBB right now is still going to get whipped. Dumping all of the players makes the team less attractive to free agents than if the new owner, say, inherited a level 20 QB to build the team around.

Rather than trying to completely rework the process, I think the best idea is just to expedite the normal relegation of gutted teams.

Maybe allow new owners unlimited cuts during the chemistry grace period?
Last edited Jun 29, 2008 07:39:40
 
fins88
offline
Link
 
i do not think moving teams to bottom lvl in the middle of the season is right at all.

To me it leaves the team promoting mid season at a disadvantage. They are in the playoffs at there league now and if they promote they can be fighting for a spot in the next league. Money they would have made in the playoffs are now gone.

would have to agree more on cobony's point number 2. Let a GM have first crack at it only if they do not own a team now.And this is where is becomes tricky to do that Cause you may have a GM that owns a team make a deal with another that is on the team to turn one into a farm team.Hope that made sense cause it sounded right when i was typing it.

 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Ok apparently lot of users have not understand that answering a bit do not help.

1: That's the best question i think. Who's move up?

It's very complicated not really what the most users think...

First step: little final or losing final for each team losing the conf final. So you have 2 teams who move up and a reserve of 2 teams with a rank (3 and 4) for possible gutt relegation.

Ok but that's one league! There's another league who deserve the right to be promoted!

Example AAA1 and AAA2. Each league have the #3 and #4 teams in reserve.

So if we have 2 teams gutted that will be all #3 who are promoted. But if we have only one???? I think, like someone told, we must choose the best team and it's the best standing in regular season. Same rule as regular season to pick one team from same standing.

Now we must think about something: it's a pyramidal system so if you relegate one team from top to bottom, that will have consequencies into ALL leagues.

So with (example) 1 more team in AAA1 who move up. There's a need in AA1 and AA2 to a promotion! Same rule as above.

Etc... etc...

IS there a weakness? In AAA league we have a reserve of 4 teams waiting for promotion. I don't think there will have more than 4 teams over 32 that will be gutted same season.

That's the same structure for the level below with 4 teams over 32. 4 teams in AA1 and AA2, 4 teams in AA3 and AA4 etc... For A level, 4 teams in A1 and A2 etc...

That's plenty of teams available to promotion.

But i see 1 problem: How make this system automatic with some coding? i'm not a coder i don't know. Perhaps that will need an admin hand and that's a lot of work...




2: If we like the 1: idea, we can't move a team down in a middle of a season. So we need to maintain balance if we can in the league. I think we must not allow gutting in the middle of the season. That's not at 100% fair because a team without tactic can't compete. So what? I think you must use the GM rule to replace the owner. If you don't have a GM, you ask the team to elect a temporary "GM" who will drive the team for the rest of season and then the team is gutted and sold. This temporary GM can't buy the team (because we have a waiting list...)

The worse case will be a temporary GM who try for few match and become inactive but the end of season will be near. Players will get their XP and must be patient. Solution: we can do again the elect thing.



3: Don't need to answer with 2)
A cupcake team is always bad because there is teams will be disadvantaged.


4: Owning a team is not playing his own player...If we choose to make temporary caps and sportmanship that's because we don't want unbalance! So lvl 20s players in a low level team is unbalance!!!

5: Cf the 2) But no need of disbanding a team if the GM take ownership of the team!



I hope that will be a good solution for lot of people.

Last edited Jun 29, 2008 08:10:12
 
GSUFan513
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


When a team is sold back to the game, all the players are released and it gets moved to the bottom tier, gets stadium and fan support reset, and appropriate teams get moved up the ladder at promotion time (end of the season).

Now, help me figure out solutions to the problems that haven't been worked out with the idea, to see if it's even feasible:

1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

Thanks all...feel free to add to the ideas and problems list.


My only concern with THIS idea is how to implement it. You can't, unless you wait til the offseason...thats why the need is there for a GUT LEAGUE. You can still move them to bottom rung come the offseason....okay, hear me out (Bort I pmed you with this once...):

1. Team gets Gutted. New owner takes over. (he pays 1000 XP for the NEXT 2 seasons, so there is an incentive to getting a gutted team.)

2. Gut League sends up a similarly leveled CPU owned team to finish out the Gutted Teams games. Just to allow for XP and stuff in those games.

3. Gut League is in place with OTHER gutted teams and a few CPU teams (just enough that each team has someone to play). They play each other until the end of the season, at which time they are replaced in a BBB league. You don't have to change how teams are moved up that way, they are automatically one of the teams that moves down.

4. Everyones Happy. Gut Team Owner, has a chance to win while building his team, Other teams get a chance to still gain XP. Nobody has to move up mid-season (which would sorta suck).

 
awesome
offline
Link
 
I think if the team is abandoned/gutted, it should be completely removed from wherever it is and put in the bottom division of its league. Then just move up the best available team to replace it. I don't think new owners should be able to get higher tier teams from the start. Everyone should have to start at the bottom of a league.

If all the players from the pre-gutted/abandoned team still want to stay together, they should have that option with the new owner at the time he/she acquires the team. If this happens, and enough players decide to stay, then the team could stay in its current division. Some formula would need to be created to determine the level of retention required in order to stay in the division, though. For example, if the roster has 40 people on it and 35 stay, it is probably still in good shape to stay in the division. On the other hand if only 10 stay, it should be demoted. Whatever the exact number is could be figured out ahead of time. As long as everyone knows exactly what that number is, then they can plan accordingly.

^--- note here, that it is the players' collective decision that determines whether the team is eligible to stay in the division. The owner is taking over a group of people who have been together for quite some time. They are the ones that got the team where it is. If they don't want to be a part of it anymore, the team gets demoted. New owners should have no expectation of taking over a high level team. They should all be expecting to have to start as a new owner should: at the bottom with a mostly clean slate.

It is just patently ridiculous that a brand new owner can step in and take over a USA Pro team that has few players left that were the reason that the team got to the Pro division in the first place. These types of teams should be knocked all the way down to BBB so they can rebuild properly. Otherwise it will be several seasons before they are able to compete due to the painfully slow relegation/promotion process.
Last edited Jun 29, 2008 08:54:20
 
uncle_wilf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
When a team is sold back to the game, all the players are released and it gets moved to the bottom tier, gets stadium and fan support reset, and appropriate teams get moved up the ladder at promotion time (end of the season).

As I understand it, people on the waiting list have a choice between starting with a new team or taking over an extant one. Am I correct? If that is the case, then this idea would seem to remove some of that choice.

I have a player on Mozilla Firefox, a team in USA Pro, that was "gutted" and sold back to the league last season. I joined shortly after that, to take part in the challenge of rebuilding that team and helping it stay in USA Pro. We are fighting tooth and nail this season to maintain our status. It's one heck of a challenge to become competitive in that league, but if we succeed it will be worthwhile.

On the other hand, some new owners of re-sold teams may want to start again in the bottom tier. I don't have any objection to that, though I'd have some problems with stadium reset as many teams in the lower tiers have well developed stadia already. I don't think that fan support should be reset beyond that which happens for teams with low support at the season change.

Originally posted by Bort
1. Who moves up? I.E, which team is selected to move up? They'd have to be in the same conference as the team that moves to the bottom.

This is probably the easiest to solve. Teams sold that elect to move down would be labelled by the system. During the processing of relegation and promotion, you can perform extra switches to move these teams down, in some cases, a number of times. Devising a system of tie-breakers to decide which teams move up is the only problem here, but that shouldn't be insurmountable. e.g:

1. Furthest progress in the play-offs
2. Head to head record (if applicable)
3. Regular season record
4. Most Points scored
5. Fewest Points conceded
6. "Strength of team"
7. Random drawing of lots

I also don't think teams who are sold should have players released automatically. Some agents may not want their players to be released.
Last edited Jun 29, 2008 10:38:14
 
Virtue76
offline
Link
 
I think the original idea from Bort is great.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.