User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Something is broken with GLB's autoadjust - ISSUE RESOLVED
Page:
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Originally posted by PING72

I agree with you mostly, but not as definitive. Let's say I dial up a SB slant pass and the other team messed up their AI and did not cover the wr3 at all. The first time I call it the guy drops the wide open pass. The second time is a 'bad throw' due to a blitz. I WANT the AI to keep calling this play b/c it's open.

The problem is reading if the play didn't work (incompletions b/c of a great defense), or incompletions b/c of dropped passes, bad throws, sacks, etc.


Auto adjust will never be able to account for that. That's up to the coordinators to find the likely successes and give them a high enough base % that they can keep getting called even if they fail a couple of times at the start.

But yeah, it seems to me that a 0 yard gain should be a small downward adjustment. I'm not sure if I believe an incompletion should matter. (Is a 0 yard pass any worse than a 0 yard run?) Ideally, a 2 yard loss should be a bigger downward adjustment than an incompletion, a 6 yard loss should be a bigger downward adjustment than a 2 yard loss, and a 3.5 yard gain should be better than a 0.5 yard gain. I'm not sure if any of those are the case right now.

Exhibit #498 why I don't like to use Auto-Adjust. Thanks!
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
nvm tautology linked it
Edited by Catch22 on Sep 16, 2011 11:47:36
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
That said, the play got called more and more each quarter. First quarter: 5. Second quarter: 9. Third quarter: 14. Fourth quarter: 16

Here is an observation.

Start of the game...
WR Clear Out - 0 yards
WR Clear Out - 6 yards
ignore, 3rd down Shallow Cross - 7 yards
TE Cross Slant - 0 yards
Shotgun Smash - 20.5 yds (1d)
I Pitch Weak - 0.5 yd loss
TE Cross Slant - 4 yd loss
ignore, 3rd downWeak Flag Deep Post - 6.5 yd loss
Shotgun Smash - 14 yds (1d)
Shotgun Smash - 7.5 yds
HB Blast - 10 yds (1d)
HB Blast - 2 yds
Shotgun Smash - 16 yds (1d)

So early on I can see why it would be adjusted up. Run 4 times for 3 big positive results plus another positive result. Of the other 8 plays, 1 was a big positive result, 2 others were positive results, and 3 were losses. That means roughly you have 7 of 12 plays adjusted it up and only 3 of 12 plays adjusted it down.

What I wonder is if plays don't adjust down quickly once they've gone up. Or if other plays can't catch up. Here are the next few plays:

Shotgun Smash - 0 yds
WR Screen Strong - 2 yds
ignore, 3rd down HB Clear - 9 yds (touchdown)
HB Counter Weak - 4 yds
HB Counter Strong - 4 yds
ignore, 3rd down Weak I HB Slam - 1 yd (no first)
Shotgun Smash - 0 yds
Shotgun Smash - 0 yds
ignore, 3rd down Weak I Flag Deep Post - 12 yds (1d)
Shotgun Smash - 0 yds
WR Screen Strong - 42 yds (1d)
HB Counter Strong - 4 yds
WR Screen Strong - 3 yds
ignore, 3rd down Weak I HB Slam - 2 yds (no first)
ignore, 3rd down Weak I HB Slam - 1 yd (touchdown)
Shotgun Smash - 0 yds
HB Counter Weak - 61.5 yds (1d)
FB Slam - 0.5 yds
HB Dive Weak - 2 yds
ignore, 3rd down Weak I HB Slam - 0 yds (touchdown)

(some of these are goal line plays, not sure if that matters)

If I remember correctly, 0 yards doesn't adjust you down. But 5 other plays that got run resulted in first downs or touchdowns, with no losses, so that should have adjusted it down somewhat.

Shotgun Smash - 0 yds
Shotgun Smash - 8 yds
ignore, 3rd down WR Clear Out - 7 yds (1d)
HB Counter Strong - 2.5 yds
Shotgun Smash - 0 yds
ignore, 3rd down Middle Overload - 4.5 yd loss
Shotgun Smash - 0 yds
Shotgun Smash - 0 yds
ignore, 3rd down WR Hook - 0 yds
TE Cross Slant - 0 yds
HB Blast - 10 yds
Shotgun Smash - 20 yds (1d)
Shotgun Smash - 18 yds (1d)
Shotgun Smash - 9 yds

So here is a theory:
-Early big plays from Shotgun Smash pushed it up to the top (no surprise there)
-Early negatives from other plays maybe adjusted Smash up more than it adjusted other plays up, since it was a higher base % at the time?
-The 0 yds (incompletions), especially in the second group where the play was not really successful) didn't adjust it down
-Another loss from another play in the third group, and then a few more big plays from Smash to start the 3rd quarter (end of the 3rd group above) just pushed it way up again.
-Out of the 44 times it was run, Smash lost yards only once (the 25th time it was run)... so the theory is the incompletions didn't hurt the auto adjust value and the losses from other plays and the gains from Smash just pushed it way up


This is pretty much the only possible explanation, but nonetheless I don't believe this is the way in which "adjust slowly" should possibly work. And to have an incomplete pass not count as a negative is silly. Hell, a 1-2 yard gain should count as a negative. Bort does get how football works right. We have to move the ball forward as an offense, not stay still. I also think it appears to be too dumbed down. I have the feeling that a 10 yard gain gets the same auto-adjust bump as a 60 yard gain, which is just silly.

The way I see it roughly:

Run:
loss of 2 or more= major negative
loss of 1.5-gain of 1.5=negative (unless said run resulted in a first down on 3rd/4th down)
gain of 2-4 yards=no net change
gain of 4.5-8 yards=positive
gain of 8.5-20 yards=Major positive
gain of 20+ yards=Super positive

Pass:
Sack, INT=major negative
TFL, Inc, or less than 2 yard gain-negative
gain of 2.5-5 yards-no net change (unless results in a 1st down on 3rd/4th down)
gain of 5.5-15 yards=Positive
gain of 15.5-30 yards=Major Positive
gain of 30+ yards=Super positive

Something along those lines. I'm curious to what it really is.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Can I interject?

I'm guilty of this too, but I think we're drifting away from the original purpose of this thread: to determine whether or not Auto-Adjust is working AS INTENDED.

It could very-well-be that Bort's intention with Auto-Adjust makes little-to-no-sense. But even if that's the case, if Bort intended for Auto-Adjust to be neutral on incomplete passes, and if Auto-Adjust is being neutral on incomplete passes, then technically that's not a "bug." It's something that should be changed, sure, but that would need to be covered in the Suggestions forum.

I just don't want this legitimate-and-important thread to get locked because it's gotten off-track, so my suggestion would be to carry the conversation about how Auto-Adjust SHOULD work to either Suggestions or GLB Main, and leave this thread for answering the question of whether or not it's working as intended or not.

Sound good, guys?

/breathlessly awaits Bort's answer in the Q&A thread on this question.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
I also think it appears to be too dumbed down. I have the feeling that a 10 yard gain gets the same auto-adjust bump as a 60 yard gain, which is just silly.


Just a quick note about this... from Q&A here's a Bort quote which kinda talks about this http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4675729&page=6#42983647 Originally posted by Bort
Depends on your strength setting. A full (100) setting will adjust for a very good play bias by 6 - 10%. There's actually some variation depending on situation (and opponent's defense in casual) so that it doesn't push up run/pass too high just because you got a first down on 1 yards to go, or converted a long 4th down with a pass, for example.

A touchdown will add another 6%, a first down an extra 2.
I am asking for some additional clarification in the current Q&A:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4731373&page=6#43531296
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4731373&page=5#43515174

I actually think Bort took more things into consideration than you give him credit for, but I do think there are probably some obvious holes.
Edited by TrevJo on Sep 16, 2011 12:20:52
Edited by TrevJo on Sep 16, 2011 12:17:51
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Can I interject?

I'm guilty of this too, but I think we're drifting away from the original purpose of this thread: to determine whether or not Auto-Adjust is working AS INTENDED.


Never fear, Catch is here. I'm sure that's his primary goal as he looks into this.
 
Link
 
Game link http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1803889
AI link http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_offense_ai.pl?team_id=399&id=196033

Look at 1st and 10. By my count I had 31 1st and 10's in this game. There are 4 possible packages that can be called.

30% WR Pass
10% 5WR
40% Sweep/Pitch
20% Off Tkl

The 5WR set was called 10 (32%) times. WR Pass 11 (35%) times, Sweep/Pitch 6 (19%) times and Off Tkl 4 (13%) times. Auto-Adjust for this Input is set to Medium.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Even if I had auto-adjust on very quickly, I would not expect the results that we got. It's not like Shotgun Smash was going for huge TDs or something. There were some nice gains in there, but nothing that great. Nothing to justify it being called 30 out of 39 times in the 2nd half including like 90% of that packages plays in the 4th quarter. Basically, the % went from 10 to 90 because of 6 good gains (10-20 yards), and 5 moderate gains (5-10 yards) while having 2 sacks and 14 incompletions. And it's not like we're talking about no other plays working ever. We had a 60 yard PS counter, and a 40 yard WI WR screen in there. Hell, HB Blast picked up 10 or more yards 3 times, and was a 2 yard gain the other time it was called.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I am asking for some additional clarification in the current Q&A:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4731373&page=6#43531296
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4731373&page=5#43515174

I actually think Bort took more things into consideration than you give him credit for, but I do think there are probably some obvious holes.


I guess the big question is that % additive or multiplicative. In other words, if we start at 10%, get a 1st down completion valued at +10%, would that move it to 20% or 11%. That's a major difference and completely changes how someone might want to set up their AI. Basically, if we put each % as 100% rather than 10%, we wouldn't get such a severe reaction.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Even if I had auto-adjust on very quickly, I would not expect the results that we got. It's not like Shotgun Smash was going for huge TDs or something. There were some nice gains in there, but nothing that great. Nothing to justify it being called 30 out of 39 times in the 2nd half including like 90% of that packages plays in the 4th quarter. Basically, the % went from 10 to 90 because of 6 good gains (10-20 yards), and 5 moderate gains (5-10 yards) while having 2 sacks and 14 incompletions. And it's not like we're talking about no other plays working ever. We had a 60 yard PS counter, and a 40 yard WI WR screen in there. Hell, HB Blast picked up 10 or more yards 3 times, and was a 2 yard gain the other time it was called.


Just counting the plays you mentioned in that post, Smash still had more good gains (6) than all the other plays combined (5), not to mention the 5 moderate gains from Smash as well.

As far as the 2 sacks, Smash gained 7.5 or more yards 8 times before the first time it lost yards. It really comes down to what AA considers to be a moderate gain vs a big gain, and whether incompletions are a factor at all, imo.
Edited by TrevJo on Sep 16, 2011 12:30:41
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Just counting the plays you mentioned in that post, Smash still had more good gains than all the other plays combined, not to mention the moderate gains as well.

As far as the 2 sacks, Smash gained 7.5 or more yards 8 times before the first time it lost yards. It really comes down to what AA considers to be a moderate gain vs a big gain, and whether incompletions are a factor at all, imo.


well yes, if you have a play getting called over and over again while the other plays don't then of course it is going to get more gains.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
well yes, if you have a play getting called over and over again while the other plays don't then of course it is going to get more gains.


Which would naturally result in that play getting adjusted up more than all the other plays combined.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Which would naturally result in that play getting adjusted up more than all the other plays combined.


But I see what you're saying. Whether it should really go up more should depend on whether all big plays are created equal
And how much more also depends on whether adjustments are multiplicative or additive like you mentioned. Does it go up 10% to 13% to 16% to 19% maybe (additive)? Or does it go up something like 10% to 13% to 18% to 26% (multiplicative) perhaps?
Edited by TrevJo on Sep 16, 2011 12:36:54
Edited by TrevJo on Sep 16, 2011 12:36:33
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
But I see what you're saying. How much more it should go up depends on whether all big plays are created equal, and also depends on whether adjustments are multiplicative or added. Does it go up 10% to 13% to 16% to 19% maybe (additive)? Or does it go up 10% to 13% to 18% to 25% (multiplicative) perhaps?


I mean multiplicative like a play gets a +10% boost so it get 10%*1.10=11%. In this way, multiplicative actually increases slower than additive. This is the way that would make sense because it wouldn't matter if you had 10 outputs all at 100% or 10 outputs all at 1%. It also would prevent a play from going completely to zero.

Either way, auto adjust definitely seems to be the culprit, and incompletions need to be minor negatives. Hell, to me, an incompletion followed by a 15 yard pass should be a net zero. Two incompletions should equal a 25 yard pass. three incompletions a big gain 30+.
Edited by GMathiasf on Sep 16, 2011 12:41:52
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
This is the way that would make sense because it wouldn't matter if you had 10 outputs all at 100% or 10 outputs all at 1%. It also would prevent a play from going completely to zero.


Well the way I think it works (based on vague recollection of Bort answers) is that if you only have 10 plays at 1% then when the sim begins it will fix them all to 10% each at the start so it's 100% total. In which case it wouldn't matter if you had 10 plays starting at 10% or 10 plays starting at 1%.

I agree with your point about multiplicative being good for avoiding zero though. I also think multiplicative is necessary so that if you have an output at 0%, it can stay at 0%. (Although it's possibly coded just to remove that output all together at the start of the sim if it's set to 0%.) tbh I have always figured it was multiplicative...

Lots of mysteries!
Edited by TrevJo on Sep 16, 2011 12:45:29
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.