Originally posted by TrevJo
Originally posted by PING72
I agree with you mostly, but not as definitive. Let's say I dial up a SB slant pass and the other team messed up their AI and did not cover the wr3 at all. The first time I call it the guy drops the wide open pass. The second time is a 'bad throw' due to a blitz. I WANT the AI to keep calling this play b/c it's open.
The problem is reading if the play didn't work (incompletions b/c of a great defense), or incompletions b/c of dropped passes, bad throws, sacks, etc.
Auto adjust will never be able to account for that. That's up to the coordinators to find the likely successes and give them a high enough base % that they can keep getting called even if they fail a couple of times at the start.
But yeah, it seems to me that a 0 yard gain should be a small downward adjustment. I'm not sure if I believe an incompletion should matter. (Is a 0 yard pass any worse than a 0 yard run?) Ideally, a 2 yard loss should be a bigger downward adjustment than an incompletion, a 6 yard loss should be a bigger downward adjustment than a 2 yard loss, and a 3.5 yard gain should be better than a 0.5 yard gain. I'm not sure if any of those are the case right now.
Exhibit #498 why I don't like to use Auto-Adjust. Thanks!
Originally posted by PING72
I agree with you mostly, but not as definitive. Let's say I dial up a SB slant pass and the other team messed up their AI and did not cover the wr3 at all. The first time I call it the guy drops the wide open pass. The second time is a 'bad throw' due to a blitz. I WANT the AI to keep calling this play b/c it's open.
The problem is reading if the play didn't work (incompletions b/c of a great defense), or incompletions b/c of dropped passes, bad throws, sacks, etc.
Auto adjust will never be able to account for that. That's up to the coordinators to find the likely successes and give them a high enough base % that they can keep getting called even if they fail a couple of times at the start.
But yeah, it seems to me that a 0 yard gain should be a small downward adjustment. I'm not sure if I believe an incompletion should matter. (Is a 0 yard pass any worse than a 0 yard run?) Ideally, a 2 yard loss should be a bigger downward adjustment than an incompletion, a 6 yard loss should be a bigger downward adjustment than a 2 yard loss, and a 3.5 yard gain should be better than a 0.5 yard gain. I'm not sure if any of those are the case right now.
Exhibit #498 why I don't like to use Auto-Adjust. Thanks!





I'm sure that's his primary goal as he looks into this.























