User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > HB Counter Strong RB goes too far downfield - FILED BUG #759
Page:
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by .spider.
I wont share build, but I can assure you it shouldnt be re-current vision checks failed. 67+ vision.


What makes you say this? Why do you think vision of 67 isn't failing vision checks on a fairly regular basis? Given the speed of the play, all it takes is one failed check and you are off to the races.

Also, why do you think this play has to do with failed vision checks? It sseems more likely that it is a vision check being passed, given that the HB seems to depart from the script a bit.

 
tonnyrat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
What makes you say this? Why do you think vision of 67 isn't failing vision checks on a fairly regular basis? Given the speed of the play, all it takes is one failed check and you are off to the races.

Also, why do you think this play has to do with failed vision checks? It sseems more likely that it is a vision check being passed, given that the HB seems to depart from the script a bit.



it probably isn't vision because dots with 48 or 72 vision and 140 speed don't do this. dots with 48 or 72 vision and 150 speed do it all the time no matter what agility/quick cut is at.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tonnyrat
it probably isn't vision because dots with 48 or 72 vision and 140 speed don't do this. dots with 48 or 72 vision and 150 speed do it all the time no matter what agility/quick cut is at.


Just to be clear, the 150+ and even 155+ guys don't do it EVERY time. So something is causing them to do this occasionally.

It seems to me that it is a pathing choice, not something that is "broken" about the play. (I'm not passing judgement on whther or not it's desirable, just noting the difference).


I suppose it doesn't hurt to ask...are all the HB's suffering from this running on Super Elusive, or no?




Edited by tautology on Sep 13, 2011 17:50:48
Edited by tautology on Sep 13, 2011 17:49:25
 
tonnyrat
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1813313&pbp_id=4034438Originally posted by tautology
Just to be clear, they don't do it EVERY time. So something is causing them to do this occasionally.

It seems to me that it is a pathing choice.


I suppose it doesn't hurt to ask...are all the HB's suffering from this running on Super Elusive, or no?






99 elusive also results in this behavior.
 
gbororats
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
remember back in the day when everyone took speed, and no one took agility like S1-5, and then they changed it to make agility more important since no one trained it, I agree it looks bugged and like crap, but unless bort hard codes sharp cuts that's all that is happening, too much speed causing rounded turns. Its like trying to take a Lamborghini around a hair-pin turn at top speed... its not going to happen.

The pathing needs to be changed and that's the only way to fix it, waypoints need to be added so that the HB takes 5 steps to the weak side, and hard code a cut that takes you off to the next waypoint on the strong side which means a cookie cutter play with no variation. I'd personally take 4 yards a carry every time if it was guaranteed. the existence of counters damaged the sim in the first place
 
tonnyrat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gbororats
remember back in the day when everyone took speed, and no one took agility like S1-5, and then they changed it to make agility more important since no one trained it, I agree it looks bugged and like crap, but unless bort hard codes sharp cuts that's all that is happening, too much speed causing rounded turns. Its like trying to take a Lamborghini around a hair-pin turn at top speed... its not going to happen.

The pathing needs to be changed and that's the only way to fix it, waypoints need to be added so that the HB takes 5 steps to the weak side, and hard code a cut that takes you off to the next waypoint on the strong side which means a cookie cutter play with no variation. I'd personally take 4 yards a carry every time if it was guaranteed. the existence of counters damaged the sim in the first place


how much agility should a 155 speed HB have to make that cut when 140 speed and 80 agility guys do it with ease?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tonnyrat

how much agility should a 155 speed HB have to make that cut when 140 speed and 80 agility guys do it with ease?



I really think it has something to do with the defense, not a limitation on the HB as you are putting it.

Here are several plays where a 155+ guy makes the cut (note that with track star he is sitting at 158+ speed):

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1813153&pbp_id=3525178
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1816414&pbp_id=3915962
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1816414&pbp_id=3919122



Either that or it turns out you really need more Quick Cut.
Edited by tautology on Sep 13, 2011 18:09:39
Edited by tautology on Sep 13, 2011 18:03:36
 
tonnyrat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology

I really think it has something to do with the defense, not a limitation on the HB as you are putting it.

Here are several plays where a 155+ guy makes the cut (note that with track star he is sitting at 158+ speed):

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1813153&pbp_id=3525178
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1816414&pbp_id=3915962
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1816414&pbp_id=3919122



Either that or it turns out you really need more Quick Cut.


i only think it's HB related because some of these dots were on the test server last ssn testing the "run out of bounds when no one is around" bug. the bug was identified, replicated and sent to Bort for fixing by Catch (it still hasnt been addressed per the Changelog). it looked like the same type of momentum issues that might be causing these problems.

that or there is a gigantic world of difference between 8 Quick Cut and 10 QC plus 85 agility vs 95 agility makes no difference

also, a HB on Odessa last ssn had Slow Starter and Streaky. this type of SB Counter past the LOS would happen on positive Streaky days in the 4th Q with a full SS bonus, which also coincided with the fact that he would run out of bounds on pitches when no one was around him. he didn't run past the LOS on these plays and wouldnt run out of bounds w/o the full 11% bonus that took him to the 150+/90+ agi range.
Edited by tonnyrat on Sep 13, 2011 19:57:09
 
tonnyrat
offline
Link
 
still an issue at 95 Elusive

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1816447&pbp_id=4312533
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1816447&pbp_id=4312489
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
From experimenting, higher agility makes it worse imo. Not sure if first step plays into it. Seems weird but was easy to see when testing moving eq around on an HB

Tony- What is that odessa HB's Agility at? If it's at 95 like you mentioned and some of it is eq, do a test game and bring it down to 85-87 and see what happens. I bet you'll see him act normal again
Edited by chronoaug on Sep 15, 2011 14:55:55
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
From experimenting, higher agility makes it worse imo. Not sure if first step plays into it. Seems weird but was easy to see when testing moving eq around on an HB


It didn't always work that way either, something was changed early last season.

Despite the problems, it is still one of the most popular plays in the game. It's that and the weak I counter or bust!
 
tonnyrat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
From experimenting, higher agility makes it worse imo. Not sure if first step plays into it. Seems weird but was easy to see when testing moving eq around on an HB

Tony- What is that odessa HB's Agility at? If it's at 95 like you mentioned and some of it is eq, do a test game and bring it down to 85-87 and see what happens. I bet you'll see him act normal again


the dot i posted from odessa at 95 elusive "only" has 90 agility and unfortunately none of it is from EQ you bring up a great point though because that dot is worse at SB Counters than his counterpart that has 86 agility (who still sucks at it but will run the cut 0.5 yds past the LOS whereas the 90 agility dot does it 4 yds past the LOS).
 
dbreeze
offline
Link
 
friggin' bizarro ball.....
 
snakes22
offline
Link
 
My dot today
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1813237&pbp_id=4528969
 
SG✬21
offline
Link
 
why cant we get counters like this one ?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1781441&pbp_id=6380992

saw this replay and i was likehe actually ran the counter the way its supposed to work.

was said to have only 160 speed with 80 agility and 40 vision
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.