User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > D-League teams not filling with CPUs properly
Page:
 
caileanhawk
offline
Link
 
I completely agree with this, the team I am on has no players. My player is a DE and has to play both ways. Even with my player playing both ways there are not enough players to fill a roster. There are holes everywhere.

There should be at least one computer generated player for each position.
 
xhail2skinsx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ig
QB is just ridiculous in the D-Leagues right now.

I did a quick query of just Rookie-Soph D League #1 as I assume all leagues are similar. There are currently 102 QBs in D-League #1 (i.e., 16% of all the players in the league). Of those QBs, 44 are human and a whopping 58 are CPUs. So, despite there being enough human QBs for each team to have one--and almost enough remaining for half of the teams to have a second--the roster logic still thinks there should be almost an additional 2 CPU QBs per team.

The number of QBs makes even less sense considering only one QB can play at a time. Yet other positions such as G, OT, WR, DT, DE, LB, and CB commonly (if not always) use two players simultaneously. There are more CPU QBs than total players at any one of those positions. In fact, the only position to have more total players than CPU QBs is at the HB which is similarly broken (but not to the same degree).

Here's how the player numbers look for D-League #1:

QB = 102 players (44 human, 58 CPU)
HB = 65 players (33, 32)
FB = 31 players (8, 23)
C = 33 players (13, 20)
G = 35 players (10, 25)
OT = 33 players (10, 23)
TE = 32 players (7, 25)
WR = 39 players (21, 18)

DT = 36 players (15, 21)
DE = 35 players (17, 18)
LB = 36 players (16, 20
CB = 34 players (8, 26)
SS = 32 players (7, 25)
FS = 32 players (3, 29)

K = 32 players (9, 23)
P = 32 players (6, 26)


Summary:
- Each D-League team could have 1 or 2 human QBs, yet there are more CPU QBs in the D-Leagues than total players for each position except HB.


amirite
 
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=2271

This team has just 19 players, yet 4 of them are QBs (3 CPU). It can't be that hard to make D-League teams sign CPU players with some kind of logic.
 
Jay Gold
offline
Link
 
Vote time? ?
 
Chris465 DTD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EnglishArgo2007
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=2271

This team has just 19 players, yet 4 of them are QBs (3 CPU). It can't be that hard to make D-League teams sign CPU players with some kind of logic.


what's this "logic" you speak of?
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by EnglishArgo2007
http://goallineblitz.com/game/roster.pl?team_id=2271

This team has just 19 players, yet 4 of them are QBs (3 CPU). It can't be that hard to make D-League teams sign CPU players with some kind of logic.


glb doesnt believe in logic
 
ig
offline
Link
 
I'd propose logic something of the sort:

A. Make sure that each D-League team always had at least 26 roster spots filled, including for each position:

Offense: 1 QB, 1 HB, 1 FB, 1 C, 2 G, 2 OT, 1 TE, 3 WR
Defense: 2 DT, 2 DE, 3 LB, 3 CB, 1 SS, 1 FS
Special Teams: 1 K, 1 P

B. When a human-owned player signs to any of the listed positions, drop a CPU at that position if there is one.

C. When a human-owned player leaves the team, check to see whether a position dropped below the listed minimum, and if so sign a CPU to fill it in.

D. Otherwise ensure that the only way a team has more than the listed number of players at a position is if all of them are human owned players.

---------------------------------
NOTE: The per-position numbers in "A" are just an example. I could easily see setting different per-position minimums. I personally wouldn't go below those above, but can see why someone would set minimums of 2 for each of WR, LB, and CB. I can also see setting higher minimums (e.g., 2 QB, 3 G, 3 OT, 3 DT, 3 DE, etc.). The point is to have some predetermined logic in place so you don't end up with a roster of 15 CPU players, 4 of which are QBs.
Edited by ig on Jul 15, 2011 09:50:26
 
caileanhawk
offline
Link
 
Great idea
 
xhail2skinsx
offline
Link
 
Essentially that is exactly what the logic should be ig! Quoting that in the OP.
Edited by xhail2skinsx on Jul 15, 2011 16:19:24
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ig
I'd propose logic something of the sort:

A. Make sure that each D-League team always had at least 26 roster spots filled, including for each position:

Offense: 1 QB, 1 HB, 1 FB, 1 C, 2 G, 2 OT, 1 TE, 3 WR
Defense: 2 DT, 2 DE, 3 LB, 3 CB, 1 SS, 1 FS
Special Teams: 1 K, 1 P

B. When a human-owned player signs to any of the listed positions, drop a CPU at that position if there is one.

C. When a human-owned player leaves the team, check to see whether a position dropped below the listed minimum, and if so sign a CPU to fill it in.

D. Otherwise ensure that the only way a team has more than the listed number of players at a position is if all of them are human owned players.

---------------------------------
NOTE: The per-position numbers in "A" are just an example. I could easily see setting different per-position minimums. I personally wouldn't go below those above, but can see why someone would set minimums of 2 for each of WR, LB, and CB. I can also see setting higher minimums (e.g., 2 QB, 3 G, 3 OT, 3 DT, 3 DE, etc.). The point is to have some predetermined logic in place so you don't end up with a roster of 15 CPU players, 4 of which are QBs.


Excellent post, this is exactly how it should be. No way a team should have less than 11 offensive and 11 defensive players.
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jay Gold
Vote time? ?


according to catch there is absolutely 0 reason to vote. They don't give a damn what our vote comes out like, and they won't even give a response on whether or not they will be implementing it. So what the fuck is the point?
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00
according to catch there is absolutely 0 reason to vote. They don't give a damn what our vote comes out like, and they won't even give a response on whether or not they will be implementing it. So what the fuck is the point?


yeah, i see no reason to ever make another vote if they already have their minds made up before a single vote is cast.
 
1kwerdna
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Link
 
I heart ig

<3

This shouldn't even have to go to voting, this should be a bugs thread.
 
wil75
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00
according to catch there is absolutely 0 reason to vote. They don't give a damn what our vote comes out like, and they won't even give a response on whether or not they will be implementing it. So what the fuck is the point?


Very unhealthy business practice to not give a damn about paying customers.

...and I agree D league rosters are currently a joke.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.