He missed the punt and had to run back to get it. I don't see any bug here, but I am going to kick it up for admin review.
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Returner gets warped 10 yards back with several defenders - FILED BUG - #413
Lensar
offline
offline
He missed the punt and had to run back to get it. I don't see any bug here, but I am going to kick it up for admin review.
Catch22
offline
offline
Definitely looks like fair catch logic could be looked at. In most of the replays here, the returner should have attempted a fair catch. Go ahead and file and we'll have Bort determine if it is an issue or not.
Catch22
offline
offline
The thread Punt coverage - tackle returner before he gets the ball. - DUPLICATE THREAD has been merged into this thread
KCChiefsMan
offline
offline
http://www.goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1596288&pbp_id=2795526&flash=1
so, what is this BS all about? I've seen it before somewhere but just not against me. In any type of football you can't just tackle the kick returner before he can field the ball.
so, what is this BS all about? I've seen it before somewhere but just not against me. In any type of football you can't just tackle the kick returner before he can field the ball.
alindyl
offline
offline
Ball went over his head, the punt team was much faster than he was so they just crowded around him. As soon as he touched the ball, someone slammed into him, popped it free and they got it back. That part isn't really a bug, since no defender was hitting him before he had a chance to touch the ball, they were just crowded in on him..
I have seen plays (in real life since you mention it) where someone didn't call for a fair catch and got smashed and lost the ball. Or was standing too close to where the ball was coming down, it hit them and the opposing team pounces on the ball. Not sure i can recall seeing this in the sim but it's a reasonable result to the play.
Perhaps he should have called for a fair catch, or allowed the other team to down it by contact but that would be more of a suggestion.
Probably shouldn't add your own bug designation to your title, doesn't help get your post more attention.
I have seen plays (in real life since you mention it) where someone didn't call for a fair catch and got smashed and lost the ball. Or was standing too close to where the ball was coming down, it hit them and the opposing team pounces on the ball. Not sure i can recall seeing this in the sim but it's a reasonable result to the play.
Perhaps he should have called for a fair catch, or allowed the other team to down it by contact but that would be more of a suggestion.
Probably shouldn't add your own bug designation to your title, doesn't help get your post more attention.
KCChiefsMan
offline
offline
Originally posted by alindyl
Ball went over his head, the punt team was much faster than he was so they just crowded around him. As soon as he touched the ball, someone slammed into him, popped it free and they got it back. That part isn't really a bug, since no defender was hitting him before he had a chance to touch the ball, they were just crowded in on him..
I have seen plays (in real life since you mention it) where someone didn't call for a fair catch and got smashed and lost the ball. Or was standing too close to where the ball was coming down, it hit them and the opposing team pounces on the ball. Not sure i can recall seeing this in the sim but it's a reasonable result to the play.
Perhaps he should have called for a fair catch, or allowed the other team to down it by contact but that would be more of a suggestion.
Probably shouldn't add your own bug designation to your title, doesn't help get your post more attention.
um, no.
Ball went over his head, the punt team was much faster than he was so they just crowded around him. As soon as he touched the ball, someone slammed into him, popped it free and they got it back. That part isn't really a bug, since no defender was hitting him before he had a chance to touch the ball, they were just crowded in on him..
I have seen plays (in real life since you mention it) where someone didn't call for a fair catch and got smashed and lost the ball. Or was standing too close to where the ball was coming down, it hit them and the opposing team pounces on the ball. Not sure i can recall seeing this in the sim but it's a reasonable result to the play.
Perhaps he should have called for a fair catch, or allowed the other team to down it by contact but that would be more of a suggestion.
Probably shouldn't add your own bug designation to your title, doesn't help get your post more attention.
um, no.
Androth
offline
offline
It's easier to tell here.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1596288&pbp_id=2795526
The ball went past him. He ran to pick it up. He even broke a tackle before the fumble was forced.
Your recount of what happened is not what the play says happened or showed. He was not tackled before touching the ball.
NOT LIKELY A BUG
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1596288&pbp_id=2795526
The ball went past him. He ran to pick it up. He even broke a tackle before the fumble was forced.
Your recount of what happened is not what the play says happened or showed. He was not tackled before touching the ball.
NOT LIKELY A BUG
Pwned
offline
offline
This is actually a Filed Bug.
A duplicate at that..
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4475797
A duplicate at that..
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4475797
one of the replays made me think this might be the issue...
is the returnman trying to block before he fields the punt? It seemed like in one of them he was blocking and got pancaked right before the ball landed.
just throwing that thought out there
is the returnman trying to block before he fields the punt? It seemed like in one of them he was blocking and got pancaked right before the ball landed.
just throwing that thought out there
Androth
offline
offline
This was sent to me the other day.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1761132&pbp_id=7403016
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1761132&pbp_id=7403016
stromstarhammer
offline
offline
Originally posted by Androth
This was sent to me the other day.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1761132&pbp_id=7403016
did I do that?
This was sent to me the other day.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1761132&pbp_id=7403016
did I do that?
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























