I was just wondering if this year we are going to include GM or owner of the year? I think it would be a pretty cool thing, but it would be kind of hard to pull off....
Forum > Southeast Asia AAA Leagues > Southeast Asia AAA #2 > Pro Bowl/MVP ideas for this season here
Originally posted by creeker22
I was just wondering if this year we are going to include GM or owner of the year? I think it would be a pretty cool thing, but it would be kind of hard to pull off....
while this is an awesome idea, i think it would be a complete and absolute travesty if anyone but plank and hurricane won this... and i'm sure there are others who feel the same in regards to their own GM's.
I was just wondering if this year we are going to include GM or owner of the year? I think it would be a pretty cool thing, but it would be kind of hard to pull off....
while this is an awesome idea, i think it would be a complete and absolute travesty if anyone but plank and hurricane won this... and i'm sure there are others who feel the same in regards to their own GM's.
Raider Nation
offline
offline
Originally posted by creeker22
I was just wondering if this year we are going to include GM or owner of the year? I think it would be a pretty cool thing, but it would be kind of hard to pull off....
Once you get into this, you get into a whole world of issues. I don't think it's a good idea.
I was just wondering if this year we are going to include GM or owner of the year? I think it would be a pretty cool thing, but it would be kind of hard to pull off....
Once you get into this, you get into a whole world of issues. I don't think it's a good idea.
creeker22
offline
offline
Originally posted by Raider Nation
Originally posted by creeker22
I was just wondering if this year we are going to include GM or owner of the year? I think it would be a pretty cool thing, but it would be kind of hard to pull off....
Once you get into this, you get into a whole world of issues. I don't think it's a good idea.
I figured as much...
Originally posted by creeker22
I was just wondering if this year we are going to include GM or owner of the year? I think it would be a pretty cool thing, but it would be kind of hard to pull off....
Once you get into this, you get into a whole world of issues. I don't think it's a good idea.
I figured as much...
TaintStick
offline
offline
Originally posted by Raider Nation
Originally posted by creeker22
I was just wondering if this year we are going to include GM or owner of the year? I think it would be a pretty cool thing, but it would be kind of hard to pull off....
Once you get into this, you get into a whole world of issues. I don't think it's a good idea.
What kind of issues would we get into? It's still just voting based on someone's opinion of what has happened during the season. I think it's a great idea to have Owner/GM's recogninzed for the hard work they have been doing all year.
Originally posted by creeker22
I was just wondering if this year we are going to include GM or owner of the year? I think it would be a pretty cool thing, but it would be kind of hard to pull off....
Once you get into this, you get into a whole world of issues. I don't think it's a good idea.
What kind of issues would we get into? It's still just voting based on someone's opinion of what has happened during the season. I think it's a great idea to have Owner/GM's recogninzed for the hard work they have been doing all year.
denny_32
offline
offline
Originally posted by HurricaneBear
Since last season took awhile to get everyone to agree, and then we didn't get full participation, wanted to get this started early this season.
How do you guys want to run this this season? Same as last? For those that weren't here this is what we did.
Two threads (one for alpha squad, one for zeta) and 1 vote per team per position for 2 pro bowl squads. Votes were counted the day of the first playoff game. All votes were placed in the threads so that no funny business could go down and I counted all the votes before the playoff game as said.
MVP voting didn't have enough interest so we didn't do it.
What's the ideas for this season? Any new ones or staying with last years formula?
The real question is...will Naint continue to lose out on his Pro Bowl fantasy again this year to Ramon?
Since last season took awhile to get everyone to agree, and then we didn't get full participation, wanted to get this started early this season.
How do you guys want to run this this season? Same as last? For those that weren't here this is what we did.
Two threads (one for alpha squad, one for zeta) and 1 vote per team per position for 2 pro bowl squads. Votes were counted the day of the first playoff game. All votes were placed in the threads so that no funny business could go down and I counted all the votes before the playoff game as said.
MVP voting didn't have enough interest so we didn't do it.
What's the ideas for this season? Any new ones or staying with last years formula?
The real question is...will Naint continue to lose out on his Pro Bowl fantasy again this year to Ramon?
Raider Nation
offline
offline
Originally posted by TaintStick
What kind of issues would we get into? It's still just voting based on someone's opinion of what has happened during the season. I think it's a great idea to have Owner/GM's recogninzed for the hard work they have been doing all year.
1. I don't think a lot of teams care enough about other GM's to garner a vote.
2. How is one GM on any team more important than another. I mean, a team with 5 or 6 GMs, or more, how would they choose?
3. What makes a good GM? Making a bunch of moves? Keeping a team together? Getting Wins? Signing the most players?
What kind of issues would we get into? It's still just voting based on someone's opinion of what has happened during the season. I think it's a great idea to have Owner/GM's recogninzed for the hard work they have been doing all year.
1. I don't think a lot of teams care enough about other GM's to garner a vote.
2. How is one GM on any team more important than another. I mean, a team with 5 or 6 GMs, or more, how would they choose?
3. What makes a good GM? Making a bunch of moves? Keeping a team together? Getting Wins? Signing the most players?
Jayden
offline
offline
yes i agree Raider, the gm idea is too complicated. For example, WWAA have like 20 gms how are we supposed to know what each one did, who they picked up, etc. As the main FA GM who helped improve Tokyo this offseason, it'd be a cool idea but too difficult to vote on. Owner on the other hand would be easy as theres only 1 a team.
For players just have each team nominate a max of 8 players (doesnt matter how many O or D)and perhaps post player links?? then itd be easy to research players and vote. I think the ballots should be same as last year.
And only vote for the conference you're in since noone really can honestly say they know much about the other conference
For players just have each team nominate a max of 8 players (doesnt matter how many O or D)and perhaps post player links?? then itd be easy to research players and vote. I think the ballots should be same as last year.
And only vote for the conference you're in since noone really can honestly say they know much about the other conference
Originally posted by coach_schaar
GMs/Owners do recognized for their hard work....Its called WINS!
wurd
GMs/Owners do recognized for their hard work....Its called WINS!
wurd
denny_32
offline
offline
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
Originally posted by coach_schaar
GMs/Owners do recognized for their hard work....Its called WINS!
wurd
Nothing to add but nice avatar RT!
Originally posted by coach_schaar
GMs/Owners do recognized for their hard work....Its called WINS!
wurd
Nothing to add but nice avatar RT!
Nildo
offline
offline
Prediction:
At least 1 of the CB's that wins will be chosen because he's got a ridiculous number of tackles...which is actually a sign that he wasn't that good, got thrown at a lot and built up a lot of stats.
At least 1 of the CB's that wins will be chosen because he's got a ridiculous number of tackles...which is actually a sign that he wasn't that good, got thrown at a lot and built up a lot of stats.
HurricaneBear
offline
offline
So far i'm leaning towards running just an O, D, and ST's MVP vote as we didn't do one last year.
If aeakers can still do a web poll, or someone wants to help me with a Pro Bowl type(or whatever is decided vote) we can do both. What do you guys think? Would love to have both we just need to expand on it more. Sounds like for the most part, we would either nominate a certain number of "Pro Bowl candidates" from the teams then vote(maybe an open vote to everyone this year?) or just go with the same format from last year. I think the web poll has the most potential but not sure how it would work exactly.
For the MVP, it would be similar to last years, except teams would nominate 1 player from offense, defense, and special teams as there "MVP" for each. Then I would send all the nominees to the owners, and have them vote for players NOT on there teams and determine the 3 MVPs.
If aeakers can still do a web poll, or someone wants to help me with a Pro Bowl type(or whatever is decided vote) we can do both. What do you guys think? Would love to have both we just need to expand on it more. Sounds like for the most part, we would either nominate a certain number of "Pro Bowl candidates" from the teams then vote(maybe an open vote to everyone this year?) or just go with the same format from last year. I think the web poll has the most potential but not sure how it would work exactly.
For the MVP, it would be similar to last years, except teams would nominate 1 player from offense, defense, and special teams as there "MVP" for each. Then I would send all the nominees to the owners, and have them vote for players NOT on there teams and determine the 3 MVPs.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























