I think they nerfed it a little too much,needs some tweaking.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Non-World League Passing Results: Stats
Mightyhalo
offline
offline
I like how my 42 elite team is passing so far, and they couldn't complete a pass for shit last season. That's my empirical data. 

Edited by Mightyhalo on Nov 15, 2010 16:46:55
Timetoshine-Metta
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
see look
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1444031
we had a completion rate of nearly 60% so it clearly is working as intended
probably because Texas has no defense
see look
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1444031
we had a completion rate of nearly 60% so it clearly is working as intended
probably because Texas has no defense
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta
probably because Texas has no defense
That hurt me on the inside.
probably because Texas has no defense
That hurt me on the inside.
Bladnach
offline
offline
So if a team that dominates another passes for 70% and the team that gets beat by 100 passes for 20% and we say the avg completion % is 45% i don't know if that's really a fair study.
Especially since this is the preseason and teams are trying different things, not actually gameplanning towards tendencies, with reset but not applied VAs and lots of player tactic testing.
Especially since this is the preseason and teams are trying different things, not actually gameplanning towards tendencies, with reset but not applied VAs and lots of player tactic testing.
Mightyhalo
offline
offline
Originally posted by chronoaug
So if a team that dominates another passes for 70% and the team that gets beat by 100 passes for 20% and we say the avg completion % is 45% i don't know if that's really a fair study.
Especially since this is the preseason and teams are trying different things, not actually gameplanning towards tendencies, with reset but not applied VAs and lots of player tactic testing.
Yep.
So if a team that dominates another passes for 70% and the team that gets beat by 100 passes for 20% and we say the avg completion % is 45% i don't know if that's really a fair study.
Especially since this is the preseason and teams are trying different things, not actually gameplanning towards tendencies, with reset but not applied VAs and lots of player tactic testing.
Yep.
OP'r, take stats from same lvl leagues, but casual. No Coordinating in casual outside of tactic settings, it's all about the sim.
After watching about 9 games so far, I have yet to see a QB throw it away(none of those where casual games BTW). Most those games where lvl26 and 34 minors, and the passing game does not seem much better or worse IMO, has varied game to game.
After watching about 9 games so far, I have yet to see a QB throw it away(none of those where casual games BTW). Most those games where lvl26 and 34 minors, and the passing game does not seem much better or worse IMO, has varied game to game.
flarsten
offline
offline
Maybe people should adjust their playbooks from what worked last season to something that'll work this season instead of complaining, basicall wanting Bort to do it for them.
ryanshaw
offline
offline
Originally posted by chronoaug
So if a team that dominates another passes for 70% and the team that gets beat by 100 passes for 20% and we say the avg completion % is 45% i don't know if that's really a fair study.
It would not be a fair study if that was what was actually done. However, I have taken the average percentage across the whole league, not two mismatched teams, and excluded games which were blowouts. If the average across the whole league is too low then it is too low, since the game is actually meant to be balanced for the teams that actually play in it.
So if a team that dominates another passes for 70% and the team that gets beat by 100 passes for 20% and we say the avg completion % is 45% i don't know if that's really a fair study.
It would not be a fair study if that was what was actually done. However, I have taken the average percentage across the whole league, not two mismatched teams, and excluded games which were blowouts. If the average across the whole league is too low then it is too low, since the game is actually meant to be balanced for the teams that actually play in it.
ryanshaw
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Well, not a mistake if it gives him the "stats" he wants.
I am not seeing you as Lead Tester anymore - have you been fired? If so it is well deserved. I made it clear that the leagues were selected at random and how they were picked. If your argument had the slightest merit you would produce stats for other leagues that proved that they were different than the leagues I have chosen. Obviously that would involve some work on your behalf...
Well, not a mistake if it gives him the "stats" he wants.
I am not seeing you as Lead Tester anymore - have you been fired? If so it is well deserved. I made it clear that the leagues were selected at random and how they were picked. If your argument had the slightest merit you would produce stats for other leagues that proved that they were different than the leagues I have chosen. Obviously that would involve some work on your behalf...
Bladnach
offline
offline
Originally posted by ryanshaw
Originally posted by chronoaug
So if a team that dominates another passes for 70% and the team that gets beat by 100 passes for 20% and we say the avg completion % is 45% i don't know if that's really a fair study.
It would not be a fair study if that was what was actually done. However, I have taken the average percentage across the whole league, not two mismatched teams, and excluded games which were blowouts. If the average across the whole league is too low then it is too low, since the game is actually meant to be balanced for the teams that actually play in it.
hint. most the leagues are extremely mismatched and include lots of 100point drubbings. If you were to take a look during the playoffs or at least reg season between the more competitive teams in the league i'd care more. The problem with the lower leagues is that the level of builds, gameplanning smarts, and overall care is so drastically different you can't really use it all like that.
Seems silly to include the teams not trying at all or the people who simply have not a single clue or don't really care that much in these results. WL results have varied wildly too with all the testing, tactic altering, and weird stuff thrown around.
Originally posted by chronoaug
So if a team that dominates another passes for 70% and the team that gets beat by 100 passes for 20% and we say the avg completion % is 45% i don't know if that's really a fair study.
It would not be a fair study if that was what was actually done. However, I have taken the average percentage across the whole league, not two mismatched teams, and excluded games which were blowouts. If the average across the whole league is too low then it is too low, since the game is actually meant to be balanced for the teams that actually play in it.
hint. most the leagues are extremely mismatched and include lots of 100point drubbings. If you were to take a look during the playoffs or at least reg season between the more competitive teams in the league i'd care more. The problem with the lower leagues is that the level of builds, gameplanning smarts, and overall care is so drastically different you can't really use it all like that.
Seems silly to include the teams not trying at all or the people who simply have not a single clue or don't really care that much in these results. WL results have varied wildly too with all the testing, tactic altering, and weird stuff thrown around.
Edited by chronoaug on Nov 15, 2010 18:31:57
-MITH- ~Cult~
offline
offline
The agents in my network LAUGH at passing before "Your last seasons in GLB"
Its getting harder and harder to get guys to make WR's when we make teams.
THIS GUY IS GREAT for minors though! Too bad he'll likely blow later on.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=2001932
loLPAssing
Its getting harder and harder to get guys to make WR's when we make teams.
THIS GUY IS GREAT for minors though! Too bad he'll likely blow later on.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=2001932
loLPAssing
LordEvil
offline
offline
Pee Wee is taking a time machine back to season 12
Gold League passing teams
26%
28%
22%
13%
30%
5%
26%
33%
35%
18%
19%
25%
33%
26%
55%
20%
45%
28%
25%
33% Against cpu defense
37% Against cpu defense
28% Against cpu defense
27%
44%
40%
Gold League passing teams
26%
28%
22%
13%
30%
5%
26%
33%
35%
18%
19%
25%
33%
26%
55%
20%
45%
28%
25%
33% Against cpu defense
37% Against cpu defense
28% Against cpu defense
27%
44%
40%
ryanshaw
offline
offline
Originally posted by chronoaug
hint. most the leagues are extremely mismatched and include lots of 100point drubbings. If you were to take a look during the playoffs or at least reg season between the more competitive teams in the league i'd care more. The problem with the lower leagues is that the level of builds, gameplanning smarts, and overall care is so drastically different you can't really use it all like that.
Seems silly to include the teams not trying at all or the people who simply have not a single clue or don't really care that much in these results. WL results have varied wildly too with all the testing, tactic altering, and weird stuff thrown around.
Actually, there were very few 100 (or 70) point drubbings and they were all excluded from the stats (I would say less than 10% of the games in these leagues were excluded). I also used Elite leagues so that they were more competitive by nature. It is of course impossible to do stats on these passing changes using regular season games since they have only just been made - however, if the balance is wrong and they don't change it now, a load of people are going to have to sit through the whole season watching the sim suck. So I am not sure I can agree with any of your criticism.
In respect of your general point (basically, the teams are mismatched) - so what? These are the leagues that GLB put people in. They need to balance the game based on that reality.
FWIW, there is virtually no evidence from the leagues I reviewed of games between more closely matched teams producing more realistic passing stats. The teams that got decent completion percentages were usually those who won by the highest margin.
hint. most the leagues are extremely mismatched and include lots of 100point drubbings. If you were to take a look during the playoffs or at least reg season between the more competitive teams in the league i'd care more. The problem with the lower leagues is that the level of builds, gameplanning smarts, and overall care is so drastically different you can't really use it all like that.
Seems silly to include the teams not trying at all or the people who simply have not a single clue or don't really care that much in these results. WL results have varied wildly too with all the testing, tactic altering, and weird stuff thrown around.
Actually, there were very few 100 (or 70) point drubbings and they were all excluded from the stats (I would say less than 10% of the games in these leagues were excluded). I also used Elite leagues so that they were more competitive by nature. It is of course impossible to do stats on these passing changes using regular season games since they have only just been made - however, if the balance is wrong and they don't change it now, a load of people are going to have to sit through the whole season watching the sim suck. So I am not sure I can agree with any of your criticism.
In respect of your general point (basically, the teams are mismatched) - so what? These are the leagues that GLB put people in. They need to balance the game based on that reality.
FWIW, there is virtually no evidence from the leagues I reviewed of games between more closely matched teams producing more realistic passing stats. The teams that got decent completion percentages were usually those who won by the highest margin.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























