User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > New timeout system isn't set up right - ISSUE RESOLVED - CLOSED
Page:
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
The timeouts definitely need work.

Here was my suggestion laid out for how timeouts should work: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3801123&page=1#33688850

For this particular game, here's how it would have played out.

(SoCal BDC on offense, trailing by 2)
2:00 2nd & 5.5 OPP 45.5 Puta Madre pass to Dez Devine up the left side, thrown low, caught [missed diving tackle: James Armstrong] (31.5 yd gain) [tackle: Cougar Bait] (no timeout) correct
1:16 1st & 10 OPP 13.5 Craig "Ironhead" Heyward rush up the middle (2.5 yd gain) [tackle: Baby Gotback]
1:12 2nd & 7.5 OPP 11 Offensive Timeout Called: So Cal BDC Replay incorrect, no timeout should have been called here
1:12 2nd & 7.5 OPP 11 Craig "Ironhead" Heyward rush [missed tackle: Happy. Ending (Lower the Shoulder)] up the middle (7.5 yd gain) [tackle: Brandon Cash] Replay (no timeout) correct
0:33 3rd & inches OPP 4 Craig "Ironhead" Heyward rush up the middle (1 yd gain) [tackle: Pippin Pipin] Replay
0:29 1st & G OPP 3 Offensive Timeout Called: So Cal BDC Replay correct
0:29 1st & G OPP 3 Craig "Ironhead" Heyward rush up the middle (0.5 yd gain) [diving tackle: Tubbie Tackle] Replay (no timeout) correct
0:14 2nd & G OPP 2.5 Craig "Ironhead" Heyward rush [missed tackle: Brandon Cash (Power Through)] up the middle (1.5 yd loss) [diving tackle: Self Professed] (no timeout) incorrect, timeout should have been called with 5 seconds left

From the rules I laid out, there isn't any rule that would call an offensive timeout with more than 45 seconds left. That accounts for the first error (the early timeout).

And the last rule is ignored:
4th Quarter, Offense, Time <= 5
Score < 0

This is a critical rule and the fact that it wasn't used cost BDC the game here.

I think the problem stems from the fact that the game checks the clock at the end of the play but doesn't keep checking as the clock winds down. (I suspect this because I have seen similar problems with the AI in the past. )
For example, maybe Heyward is tackled with 11 seconds left. The sim checks the timeout logic and decides not to call a timeout with 11 seconds left. It then checks the AI and tries to run a play (probably a field goal) but it can't get a play off within 11 seconds. The sim doesn't check again with 5 seconds left. IT NEEDS TO. That type of issue needs to be dealt with if this system is going to work.

I wish this had been released on day 41, I could have tested it from day 41 to day 49.
 
Bloodfart
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
no, the problem is that the TO logic makes no sense. We don't control the timeouts, but if you need 3 points and you have less than 20 seconds left and you have a timeout remaining the sim logic should use the timeout so the clock doesn't run out. In the old sim you used the timeouts in rapid succession at the first opportunity so if you wanted to run the clock down you needed to get a first down, using your 3 timeouts in that first set of downs. That has changed, which is good. But if you have timeouts remaining you shouldn't just run to the locker room with 10 seconds left down 2 - use the damn timeout.


no, you said it's set up so that it will kick the FG only if there's 20 seconds left, and no time outs, correct? now let's say you were 2 down, and your D forced a fumble and you got the ball back on their 15, with 19 seconds left. If you had all 3 time outs, what would happen? Why wouldn't you just kick the fucking FG? You gonna pass or run it and risk a fumble or some shit?
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bloodfart
no, you said it's set up so that it will kick the FG only if there's 20 seconds left, and no time outs, correct? now let's say you were 2 down, and your D forced a fumble and you got the ball back on their 15, with 19 seconds left. If you had all 3 time outs, what would happen? Why wouldn't you just kick the fucking FG? You gonna pass or run it and risk a fumble or some shit?


Have you played this game before? Lots of games are lost because the opponent gets the ball back with 20 seconds left and all their timeouts and they throw the ball down the field, call timeouts and kick fg's or break a long one.

I had not yet adjusted my AI to the changes in the timeout logic, which is why we didn't kick the FG there. Totally user error on that part and I said as much. There is sim error as well though, because there is no way a team runs a play with :14 seconds left on the clock and doesn't call a timeout after that if they have one.

That needs to be fixed. Frankly I don't think we should have called a single timeout until we were stopping the clock with less than 10 seconds left. Nor was there any reason for us to run one play at :30 seconds left and then get in the hurry up and run another play with :14 seconds left. There was a reason to not just walk off the field holding a timeout though.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bloodfart
no, you said it's set up so that it will kick the FG only if there's 20 seconds left, and no time outs, correct? now let's say you were 2 down, and your D forced a fumble and you got the ball back on their 15, with 19 seconds left. If you had all 3 time outs, what would happen? Why wouldn't you just kick the fucking FG? You gonna pass or run it and risk a fumble or some shit?


and I don't think you quite understand what I'm talking about. I have no issue with the fact we didn't kick a FG - the AI did exactly what it was supposed to do. THAT DOESN'T CHANGE THE FACT THAT ANY 5 YEAR OLD PLAYING MADDEN WOULD HAVE KNOWN TO CALL A TIMEOUT WITH :10 LEFT RATHER THAN JUST LET THE CLOCK RUN OUT.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
and if there is any way to upload timeout logic/AI that the users are responsible for setting, I'd be happy to invest the 15 minutes or so it would take to make sure we didn't do anything stupid like walk off the field holding a timeout while we were in FG range.
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Honestly - Just go back to last seasons timeout logic!
 
Bloodfart
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13
Have you played this game before? .


yeah, it would appear I got a better handle on things than you do. You want the sim to override your instructions? How do we know it won't call a time out and kick a FG if some idiot doesn't tell it not to?


 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bloodfart
Originally posted by jdros13

Have you played this game before? .


yeah, it would appear I got a better handle on things than you do. You want the sim to override your instructions? How do we know it won't call a time out and kick a FG if some idiot doesn't tell it not to?


Blood, this isn't about the AI, it's about timeouts. Any way you slice it, the AI doesn't control the timeouts. And the timeouts are messed up.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bloodfart
yeah, it would appear I got a better handle on things than you do. You want the sim to override your instructions? How do we know it won't call a time out and kick a FG if some idiot doesn't tell it not to?




your reading comprehension is terrible. I even capitalized it for you to emphasize the point since you've missed it so far, but that didn't seem to help.

No team would let the final :10 seconds of a game run out while holding a timeout. If I could tell the sim to call a timeout there, I would but I can't. With that being the case, the timeout logic needs to be improved because that is something that no coach would ever do.
 
Bloodfart
offline
Link
 
I am just saying - if you hadn't put it as there be no time outs left, would it have kicked a FG? Like, if the input read - less than 20 seconds left / any number of time outs - kick FG - would it have kicked a FG? Or did it screw up cause you put in 'no time outs left' ? I know the damn thing should have called a time out, but did that cause it? Maybe Bort set this up so the last play of the game takes more than 14 seconds even when the other run play only took up 4 and it's causing the problem by conflicting with the new time out logic he's put in? I'm just trying to figure why it shat the bed.
But yeah, it's not right it didn't call the last time out. We should be able to be more specific as what we want it to do, like kneel out the clock and call a time out with 2 seconds left for a FG attempt and the like. Can't be too hard to fix.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
It should have called a time out with :10 left. I'll have Bort look at that part of the code.
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Agree the timeout logic needs to go back to what it was last season. I have already noticed it several times this season that the timeout logic is completely off.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bloodfart
I am just saying - if you hadn't put it as there be no time outs left, would it have kicked a FG? Like, if the input read - less than 20 seconds left / any number of time outs - kick FG - would it have kicked a FG? Or did it screw up cause you put in 'no time outs left' ? I know the damn thing should have called a time out, but did that cause it? Maybe Bort set this up so the last play of the game takes more than 14 seconds even when the other run play only took up 4 and it's causing the problem by conflicting with the new time out logic he's put in? I'm just trying to figure why it shat the bed.
But yeah, it's not right it didn't call the last time out. We should be able to be more specific as what we want it to do, like kneel out the clock and call a time out with 2 seconds left for a FG attempt and the like. Can't be too hard to fix.


the FG is irrelevant - I didn't have the AI set up the way I need to for the way the sim works now and that is fixed (there was another input for a FG with any number of TO's left under 10 seconds, but the clock ran out before that could happen. But again that is irrelevant.

Assuming we needed a TD in that situation, rather than a FG, we ran a play with :14 seconds left and never took our final timeout. No reason for that to happen.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
It should have called a time out with :10 left. I'll have Bort look at that part of the code.


Wanna lock before this gets over-heated?
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
Wanna lock before this gets over-heated?


I'm watching it and would like a little more civility on all sides tbh. Catch is looking into it, let's give him a little time please.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.