User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > This was the best suggestion on how to balance extreme attributes...
Page:
 
sunder B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Disastermaster

Let the people build their players like they want, if someone wants to make a 170 speed WR than he should be able to do this, but has to live with the consequenses of having only 60 catching. So in other words make the minor attributes count more (without allowing the overpowered % EQ to override those shortcomings in the minor atts)


fixed your post
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sunder B
fixed your post


you forgot to add & VAs after % EQ
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
It's not as easy to punish low attributes as people think. Trying to build punishments in like that to be consistent will be very difficult in terms of sim balancing and making sure it doesn't happen too much or too little and also will make the lower lvl game even worse. If anything it'll make things even more volatile if you are supposed to have certain requirements to not fumble or something like that. The builds today aren't quite as dramatically unbalanced as people always assume.


I really don't see the big deal. We couldn't put 58 in an attribute via eq until very recently when the BT system changed, eq became free and bort made it easier to reach 72s. I really don't see how this is somehow an attack against people's rights. It's really not that big a deal. The sim wasn't meant to have 160attributes. It's really not that big a deal. I don't think people need to read the consitution and make big claims about freedom when they still can still have build diversity and freedom. Really not that big a deal to only put 40 or 45 eq into spd/str and then put the other 10 or so in something else like agility/vision/blocking.


As currently constructed, the sim can't deal with 160-170 attributes. Even if other attributes meant more, people would still have specialization guys with 160-170 (maybe not a whole fleet of them) and those guys still will break the sim as it was intended. Not to mention streaky giving 5% bonus and then the trackstar/workoutwarrior % VAs
Edited by chronoaug on Oct 21, 2010 08:16:05
 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Best way to balance extreme attributes is to make the sim that punishes them for their shortcomings in other areas, not by artificially forcing limits on them.


 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Who cares.. If they are extreme in one area, they are weak in a lot of others. Of course Bort says too much of one stat messes with the SIM so probably just cap how much a stat can be boosted by equipment is the best option.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Whats the point of it anymore. They should not have blanket attributes for every position. They should of put more thought into each position having unique attributes.

IDK, just thought it was always odd that every position had kicking and punting as an option, defensive and offensive postions have the same attributes, etc...
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KingDan23
Originally posted by GMathiasf

Best way to balance extreme attributes is to make the sim that punishes them for their shortcomings in other areas, not by artificially forcing limits on them.




I'm sure bort and catch want to make secondary atts be worth more as they've said before but they also don't want 160-170 atts to be a possibility for specialists. I'm guessing both will happen. Does the game really lose much by only being able to put 40-45 eq in an att. It has only been like 3-4 seasons people have even been able to put more than that due to new changes.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 


Originally posted by chronoaug


As currently constructed, the sim can't deal with 160-170 attributes. Even if other attributes meant more, people would still have specialization guys with 160-170 (maybe not a whole fleet of them) and those guys still will break the sim as it was intended.



This is truth, because you can't get around the % bonuses from equipment and VAs. For instance, let's say you increased the value of vision, tackling, and agility and reduced the value of strength and momentum in the make tackle roll. You still have a situation, where you can have a much higher number in any one of those attributes, that help keep the score from being too low. Then throw on a huge +% to that score, and the penalty for having one of those attributes very low is gone.

The only way to really penalize players for having low attributes in one ability is to make it so that there is at least one aspect of every player's performance where 1 attribute is key.

For instance let's take WR
You might have to add a vision check for them to get off the LOS. If vision is too low, then maybe they don't even start moving until tick 3. Then you might need to make it so that they have a vision check for picking up the ball. The vision check could take place every 1/2 tick from time ball left QB to get to the WR, then they get a negative modifier to the make catch roll for every failed check. This negative would be in addition to any negative already felt by having a low attribute in the formula.

You could add a "confidence" check that WRs have to pass when being covered, and increase the roll needed to pass the check if there is double or triple coverage. So, if a WR is unable to get separation, he has to pass a confidence roll for each tick there is tight coverage on him or he takes a hit to all his attributes because he feels he can't get open and stops giving full effort.


I have a feeling that making changes like this would end up making current builds much more useless than putting limits on equipment and would take player building knowledge back to square 1 for just about everyone.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
You don't think they could implement some of the other att changes in addition to putting an equipment cap? I mean, the game was never intended to have 58 in an att bringing totals to 150-170 and they even said that. It was just an unintended consequence of changes and ultra-efficient building the past 8seasons or so. I think both would be nice
 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
I don't see why guys with 160-170 in one area should be unpossible, we just need to move the engine to a point where success doesn't just depend on how high your 1st/2nd attributes are. I think Rage's post ^ is on the right lines, but maybe a bit extreme with vision. To stay on the same topic of WRs, there needs to be incentives for them to not just follow the typical speedster route. It's currently pointless to build a possession type guy because 1) they are so hard to get free/targeted and 2) speedster guys with stacked % catch ball are pulling balls in from double coverage anyways. Basically, strength/carrying/catching/vision/jumping need to play a much bigger role in how your WR performs than it does currently.

Similarly, a CB who is covering a WR with a legit possession type build should struggle unless they are built in a way to counter them. The only way to add some balance to building and the sim is to allow specialisation OR rounded builds and make them both viable, but with the knowledge that highly specialised players should be great at one aspect of the game but poor at another. Current speedster WRs should get a huge % knocked loose on them if the secondary has 68 strength and they only have 30, but similarly if the WR has 140 speed and the CB has 100 then the WR should be able to get free on a lot of occasions.

tl;dr there has to be a rock-paper-scissors element to each attribute and how high you take them.
 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 
All I hear in hear is the underline theme. Someone built a better dot than me and we need to nerf it. Capping attributes isn't the fix. Making some of the attributes more effective would be fine.
 
monsterkill
offline
Link
 
hold on, bort doesnt like people taking a single attribute to 160+?

then why the fuck did he change training to allow an easy route to 4 pieces of +3 aeq, and allow all your equipment to be applied to one attribute?
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
No one is arguing with that, it's just it was obviously not intended by GLB from the beginning or even from season 10 to have 160-170 in a single att or 56-58points from eq. I like the balancing rps stuff but still don't think them messing with the eq will hurt the game whatsoever. People will probably enjoy that their build isn't hurt a bunch because they couldn't find 4 +3att aeqs to all put in the same att. I don't think it'll hurt build diversity at all as you'll still have speedsters and super strength guys and high throwing dots but they'll just have to put their last 10-15eq in vision or agility or something.


What's the huge argument for 56-58eq in one att? Personal rights and freedoms? Honestly, it won't change a thing about GLB considering the the differences will probably be offset by future super efficient archetype builds so the builds will probably be just as fast/strong as they are now.

Not sure why it has to be "make secondary atts important" or "put a 40-45 cap on eq in a single att". They're not mutually exclusive
Edited by chronoaug on Oct 21, 2010 08:51:16
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kotoll
All I hear in hear is the underline theme. Someone built a better dot than me and we need to nerf it. Capping attributes isn't the fix. Making some of the attributes more effective would be fine.


Actually, many of us asking for change are some of the best builders in the game. We know how our DOTs have the potential to completely break the SIM. However, we are still going to build them, because we are competitors and know if we don't someone else will.

I built Dirty Deeds knowing that his build and others like it would at least force a change to the scat back VA. Instead those builds forced the removal of them. Although I kind of wish the removal had happened a couple seasons later so that I could see he could have had it for one season at full strength.

Now that I've played around with the new training system, I can't wait to build a defensive player with 150 strength, 105 agility, and 100 speed.

 
Rulabula
offline
Link
 
Which is fine Rage. If you know how to build it then you should be allowed to. Just because someone is clueless and doesn't know what levels they can take something doesn't mean it should be nerfed.

Least we get enough room to grow and make our players the way we want or at least a higher roof to push the limits.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.