Originally posted by chronoaug
As currently constructed, the sim can't deal with 160-170 attributes. Even if other attributes meant more, people would still have specialization guys with 160-170 (maybe not a whole fleet of them) and those guys still will break the sim as it was intended.
This is truth, because you can't get around the % bonuses from equipment and VAs. For instance, let's say you increased the value of vision, tackling, and agility and reduced the value of strength and momentum in the make tackle roll. You still have a situation, where you can have a much higher number in any one of those attributes, that help keep the score from being too low. Then throw on a huge +% to that score, and the penalty for having one of those attributes very low is gone.
The only way to really penalize players for having low attributes in one ability is to make it so that there is at least one aspect of every player's performance where 1 attribute is key.
For instance let's take WR
You might have to add a vision check for them to get off the LOS. If vision is too low, then maybe they don't even start moving until tick 3. Then you might need to make it so that they have a vision check for picking up the ball. The vision check could take place every 1/2 tick from time ball left QB to get to the WR, then they get a negative modifier to the make catch roll for every failed check. This negative would be in addition to any negative already felt by having a low attribute in the formula.
You could add a "confidence" check that WRs have to pass when being covered, and increase the roll needed to pass the check if there is double or triple coverage. So, if a WR is unable to get separation, he has to pass a confidence roll for each tick there is tight coverage on him or he takes a hit to all his attributes because he feels he can't get open and stops giving full effort.
I have a feeling that making changes like this would end up making current builds much more useless than putting limits on equipment and would take player building knowledge back to square 1 for just about everyone.