User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Defending the Screen Coverage Issue - RESOLVED BUG
Page:
 
ninja turtles
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saintedix
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1386312&pbp_id=4227282

On this play, for example. Who the heck is supposed to be covering the FB and TE?



Per the OP
Assignments
LOLB = TE then WR1
SS = HB Strong then FB Strong then WR2

there is a separate assignment for the HB and FB if they go weak side. there are no I-formation passing plays where the HB and FB both go to the strong side thus the SS is used to cover both with the WR2 being his 3rd assignment. He ignores his 1st 2 assignments and goes to his 3rd. My guess is that he sees both as blockers.

The LOLB appears to start to cover the TE but then realizes he's a blocker and runs up field to get to the WR1
Edited by ninja turtles on Oct 1, 2010 06:32:00
 
ninja turtles
offline
Link
 
his assignment is HB strong, FB strong and then WR2 so he passes over the 1st 2 assignments even though they are clearly making a move to the outside as if to run a route.

look at this play from yesterday's game on a "different" screen play.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1386303&pbp_id=4856692
CB3 has the HB as his 1st assignment and WR1 as his 2nd assignment. he immediately moves to cover the HB as soon as the play starts even though the HB is still inside the pocket - so on this screen play he does not ignore the 1st assignment.

Both are screens but seem to be coded differently in the way the assigned defenders are handling there assignments




Originally posted by Mike Rogers
This falls into the grey area, and its about the timing of the vision check.

I'll use this play for example : http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1386312&pbp_id=4227282 where you say the settings are HB Strong - WR2.

What you are basically asking for here is for the SS to vision check to see if the HB is running a route to the Strong side, and if he is not then cover WR2.

Watch the play frame by frame.

By the time the HB is outside of the pocket and could be considered to be running a route, WR2 is 5 yards downfield, which takes him beyond the SS starting position.

Given the SS starting position, he cant afford to cover the HB for this long and have any chance of covering the WR. (Remember that the WR is now one yard ahead and probably up to top speed, while the SS is pretty much on his heels if he has to cover the HB first)

At the point where he needs to make a decision to cover WR2, the HB is still in the backfield and looks to all intents to be doubling the LDE.
What makes it appear so buggy is that CB1 is already covering WR2, so the SS can afford to take more time.

But Technically your dot responded to the input correctly, hence not a stonewall Bug, and it is really very easily managed within the custom AI by just selecting the assignments more thoughtfully.

Most of the other examples posted have the same type of issue, and honestly, without wanting to hurt feelings, no one input should allow a player to cover a Screen pass to the HB AND a 40 yard WR streak (In a few examples that WR is also lining up on the other side of the field, fwiw.)

So the questions that need asking are;

A: When and how often are the vision checks happening on the Primary assignment.
B: When does the Secondary assignment vision check start.
C: Is there enough gap between the A and B to ensure that a player has at least a chance of spotting a screen?


If all thats fine, then we will live with it and adjust.




Edited by ninja turtles on Oct 1, 2010 06:43:00
 
robweiss
offline
Link
 
i personally think it works as intended to confuse and bewilder defensive players
 
ninja turtles
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4318902

similar issue in this thread
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Nice to see this thread sitting here. There is overwhelming evidence that this is not working correctly. When you have a guy set to HB strong side - and he just drops back as if he is in zone coverage - that is not right. Please fix this.
 
zero
offline
Link
 
AI does not think a HB going out for a screen is "HB right" in terms of the coverage assignment in DPC.

Here's some plays and the corresponding coverage assignments:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416718&pbp_id=5240354 MLB set to cover HB strong
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416718&pbp_id=5240934 SS set to cover HB strong
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416718&pbp_id=5238662 LOLB set to cover HB strong
and the list goes on... maybe it's a bug? sim doesn't think screens count as "HB strong"?
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
I think there's another thread on this in which they are looking for more examples.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
This is stupid. Obviously bort didn't test the new screen coding whatsoever. There are so many issues with it that the change wasn't even worth it. LEs sniffing out the screen but just freezing not going after the QB not following the HB but freezing completely out of the play until the HB catches it way out of his reach. Then it's impossible to sack a QB throwing a screen regardless if you're on aggressive or passive. The blitzer/rusher will just ignore the QB and run by him before he throws it. Then there are coverage issues where the coding doesn't recognize screens as HB strong i'm guessing so despite setting a man to cover the HB man on the strong side screens, they completely ignore he HB screen like it's not happening

We don't need a thousand examples. These aren't random bugs that are hard to recreate. It's just really poor hastily done coding that needs a bunch of tweaks. This kinda stuff should be first priority considering bort created all these problems with his changes
 
Link
 
i just dont understand why we'd live with the fact that screens are wonky for a number of different reasons for many seasons, and then bort has an idea, hastily implements it, tests it for 5 minutes and than pushes it out....

cause we couldnt wait another season for it to be properly tested?
 
zero
offline
Link
 
In case no one knows the second problem Chron is ranting about:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1416744&pbp_id=4617738

So yes, screens in general are ridiculously bugged. Nicely done GLB
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
obviously these are all bugs because of bort's hasty changes without seemingly any testing. i mean, it shouldn't require a bunch of simmed games to ask the question "is the QB capable of being sacked?"


also, to add to the equation, on new screen plays the blockers are all blocking the secondary defenders before the pass downfield and while the ball is in the air. that's definitely against the rules of football on all levels.


do we really need to go on? this is getting to be a little pathetic and reflects really poorly on the foresight and follow through of bort and catch22. How long do they really need to wait? I mean this change happened after the preseason so why wait till it is a problem for a whole season till maybe bort decides to look at it for season 19 or 20? This shouldn't even be a really in depth issue. Some of the problems are kinda simple

-allow qb to be sacked,
-don't allow blockers downfield to block defense until the ball is caught,
-don't have the LDE who sniffs out the screen freeze and stand at the old prechange screen intercept point but change it to the new intercept point,
-allow coding to recognize the HB strong screen for DPC inputs "man cover HB strong side" as messed up currently
- list goes on


imo this is more important than strange glitches that happen once because a really strange combination of events that can never be replicated because the player has 8stamina/vision/confidence and is playing against a SSB with much higher atts
 
ddingo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
i just dont understand why we'd live with the fact that screens are wonky for a number of different reasons for many seasons, and then bort has an idea, hastily implements it, tests it for 5 minutes and than pushes it out....

cause we couldnt wait another season for it to be properly tested?


Pretty sure excessive use of logic is ban worthy.

BTW, the OP is completely accurate. I'm not spending my time finding links to fix the shit that should have been checked before it was rolled out.
 
zero
offline
Link
 
Almost an entire day and no response by someone important?
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
obviously these are all bugs because of bort's hasty changes without seemingly any testing. i mean, it shouldn't require a bunch of simmed games to ask the question "is the QB capable of being sacked?"


also, to add to the equation, on new screen plays the blockers are all blocking the secondary defenders before the pass downfield and while the ball is in the air. that's definitely against the rules of football on all levels.


do we really need to go on? this is getting to be a little pathetic and reflects really poorly on the foresight and follow through of bort and catch22. How long do they really need to wait? I mean this change happened after the preseason so why wait till it is a problem for a whole season till maybe bort decides to look at it for season 19 or 20? This shouldn't even be a really in depth issue. Some of the problems are kinda simple

-allow qb to be sacked,
-don't allow blockers downfield to block defense until the ball is caught,
-don't have the LDE who sniffs out the screen freeze and stand at the old prechange screen intercept point but change it to the new intercept point,
-allow coding to recognize the HB strong screen for DPC inputs "man cover HB strong side" as messed up currently
- list goes on


imo this is more important than strange glitches that happen once because a really strange combination of events that can never be replicated because the player has 8stamina/vision/confidence and is playing against a SSB with much higher atts


Umm, Don't forget,, it's Beta..That means we are all doing the final testing. In big corporate game developments they have teams of people who sleep and eat at the console to get all the bugs out, but I'm guessing GLB doesn't make the $$ to have teams of testers.
 
ninja turtles
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4313773

same issue as my thread here
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.