User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Does slow starter work?
Page:
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by willtopps
No, and anyone who says they do is lying.


It's not hard to figure out with the speed script:

I'll use a hypothetical receiver with 90 base speed and +40 equipment in speed and +10 equipment in Strength as an example.

Figure out ahead of time how the base speed will be affected:
90(.95)= 85.5
90(1.06)= 95.4

So you'll see a difference in his speed attribute of around 10. This doesn't mean he'll be 11% faster only that his speed is increased by 10, and the speed attribute doesn't correlate linearly with sim speed otherwise an 8 speed dot would be 1/10 the speed of an 80 speed dot.

Play a scrim where the dot gets 15 snaps in the 1st and takes some plays off in the 2nd, and then look for plays in the 1st and 3rd where the player has similar energy/morale numbers. You'll see a slight swing maybe 5-6% on the speed script.

Now switch the +10 strength equipment back into speed so the dot has +50 speed from equipment and his speed script numbers in the 1st quarter of the next game should equal his speed script numbers from the 3rd quarter of the previous game.
Edited by Saris on Sep 20, 2010 10:54:59
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by willtopps

No, and anyone who says they do is lying.


It's not hard to figure out with the speed script:

I'll use a hypothetical receiver with 90 base speed and +40 equipment in speed and +10 equipment in Strength as an example.

Figure out ahead of time how the base speed will be affected:
90(.95)= 85.5
90(1.06)= 95.4

So you'll see a difference in his speed attribute of around 10. This doesn't mean he'll be 11% faster only that his speed is increased by 10, and the speed attribute doesn't correlate linearly with sim speed otherwise an 8 speed dot would be 1/10 the speed of an 80 speed dot.

Play a scrim where the dot gets 15 snaps in the 1st and takes some plays off in the 2nd, and then look for plays in the 1st and 3rd where the player has similar energy/morale numbers. You'll see a slight swing maybe 5-6% on the speed script.

Now switch the +10 strength equipment back into speed so the dot has +50 speed from equipment and his speed script numbers in the 1st quarter of the next game should equal his speed script numbers from the 3rd quarter of the previous game.


I did almost this exact test. There was no increase in speed between the 1st and 3rd Qs. The player had streaky too fwiw.
 
NiteRider
offline
Link
 
I hope Catch see's this thread. If it's not working as intended a reset would be mandatory. A Rage quit would follow if it's ignored.
 
BengalFish
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
Does time on special teams in the first quarter add plays to the bonus applied in the 4th?


Originally posted by Catch22
yes - any plays played count towards the bonus.




Originally posted by tragula
Does it stack with streaky ?


Originally posted by Catch22
Yes.


from Sept. 20th or yesterday
This is taken from the "Discuss GLB issues with Catch" private forum
Edited by BengalFish on Sep 21, 2010 09:35:49
 
NiteRider
offline
Link
 
Those are his answers but why are we not seeing any gain with the speed script? Something is fishy here.
 
drdutko
offline
Link
 
I own all of the players on my team. I gave a bunch of my guys slow start one season and saw no difference (it even seemed to make those players worse than usual). I did not run any numbers and have no data - it was just an observation on my part.
 
bobblehead
offline
Link
 
Catch's reply - surprisingly in the 'Ask Catch' forum.....basic point - used to work, nothing changed, and anyone doing analysis with non-GLB tools (are there any GLB tools?) is wasting their time. Math and scripting nerds - you may now put down the sliderule and respond to those match.com responses.....

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4298617&page=1#38598906
Edited by bobblehead on Sep 24, 2010 07:52:14
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Actual quote for anyone not in that forum...

Originally posted by Catch22
I used Slow Starter + Streaky to great effect back when I had teams which was right before I was hired as an Admin. We haven't touched a thing with either since I've been on board so my general reaction to that thread is people are seeing things, overreacting, and relying too much on a non GLB user script to determine if something is working or is not working.


 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
It probably causes teams to get behind early and they can't overcome the morale spiral. If you are relying on slow starter you should fail imo.
 
monsterkill
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
Actual quote for anyone not in that forum...

Originally posted by Catch22

I used Slow Starter + Streaky to great effect back when I had teams which was right before I was hired as an Admin. We haven't touched a thing with either since I've been on board so my general reaction to that thread is people are seeing things, overreacting, and relying too much on a non GLB user script to determine if something is working or is not working.




lol, so the non glb user script shouldn't be used to determine effect...what was he using to determine that he was having 'great effect'? eyeballing it?
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Pierre T told me he was using it back in Season 12 in this game and it seemed to work
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=896581

We contained Julius Midway Monster at DT for the first half but in the second half he got 4 tackles, a sack, a FF, a PD and a TFL.

He had 11 first quarter plays.



 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by monsterkill
Originally posted by AirMcMVP

Actual quote for anyone not in that forum...

Originally posted by Catch22


I used Slow Starter + Streaky to great effect back when I had teams which was right before I was hired as an Admin. We haven't touched a thing with either since I've been on board so my general reaction to that thread is people are seeing things, overreacting, and relying too much on a non GLB user script to determine if something is working or is not working.




lol, so the non glb user script shouldn't be used to determine effect...what was he using to determine that he was having 'great effect'? eyeballing it?


Originally posted by csull36
Regardless of how the data is measured (obviously as a user-base we have no other means to measure than with post-logic user built scripts.), don't you think an 11% swing in attributes would at least show some tangible evidence?

It's not like nothing has ever slipped past the dev team before only to be discovered by the userbase (lack of server side validation that lead to basically unlimited sp, weight-gate, mentor-gate, +10 gate, the list goes on...). Saying "don't rely on what you see, just trust us" isn't a very good answer.


 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
A consistent problem seems to be that there is not a great way of testing these things on the test server.
 
Bladnach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
The 11% swing is there from the 1st to the 3rd, but there's still something very off with this VA because dots should be faster in the 3rd and 4th than they are, my guess is that it doesn't stack with Streaky.


The only variable could be energy/morale but morale isn't a big factor and from what i've seen every 10energy last season was about 1.3 speed script approx. WRs lose energy pretty quick and are often in the low 70s in the 3rd and 60s in the 4th if you're a pass heavy team who go deep a lot. (especially in games with lots of drives).

Still, slow starter seems kinda weird. Dunno if the streaky thing is affecting it but lately i haven't liked it as much as 6-7 seasons ago.



Bhall- Apine definitely was snakebit in terms of WR streaky during the playoffs it seemed. Even on days that didn't seem like bad days they ran slower than they normally did. Maybe it was just some bad luck though.
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug


Bhall- Apine definitely was snakebit in terms of WR streaky during the playoffs it seemed. Even on days that didn't seem like bad days they ran slower than they normally did. Maybe it was just some bad luck though.


Streaky in the playoffs has been a thorn in my side for a long time...since season 12. >_>
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.