User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Special Teams Exploit - NOT A BUG - CLOSED -
Page:
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Originally posted by beenlurken

Give me a fucking break... we are talking about low leveled punting. Obviously it makes no difference to high leveled leagues.



Ok, let's stick with my RR punter then. You see he punted both of the balls you posted 40+ yards right? I probably need to review my chart there, but one was a TD (against a high-leveled team no less) but most of the time they'll be held within 15 yards, and that's acceptable to me.


One was 36 and the other was 40... that game was at the end of the season and your punter was probably at or around level 30. For the entire season your punter averaged 32.6 yards per punt

Another punt from that same game...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1355564&pbp_id=13862466

Just admit you would have been better using a wr to punt it 10 yards and eliminate the possibility of a PR td.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Originally posted by beenlurken

it probably cost you guys the game.


Far from it actually, the interception, lost fumble, and two missed FG's went a helluva lot farther in contributing to that loss. I would rather put them on their side of the field then on mine by using a WR as punter. It's risk/reward. I got beat once, but it didn't cost me that game.


All of that other stuff is beyond your control... you can control (as proved in this thread) punt return tds. You could have eliminated that from the game... just by doing that you would have improved your chances of winning the game.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken

Just admit you would have been better using a wr to punt it 10 yards and eliminate the possibility of a PR td.


Not a chance dude. Give me a choice and I'll try and pin them deep everytime.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Originally posted by beenlurken


Just admit you would have been better using a wr to punt it 10 yards and eliminate the possibility of a PR td.


Not a chance dude. Give me a choice and I'll try and pin them deep everytime.


As long as you admit you are putting yourself at a disadvantage...
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Originally posted by beenlurken

That return team was not ideal... I already explained that the difference between a short return and a td on that play was a fast DL2. If that return had addressed that there is no doubt that would have been a td... everyone else was blocked.

Regardless... you miss the point... same game your punt coverage gave up a punt return td. Was it worth allowing them to return the punts? I say absolutely not... it probably cost you guys the game.


Yes it was as opposed to giving them the ball on my 40 each time. Seriously, you could go through every single PR my team has ever had and say "if this guy had blocked it's a TD" or "if that guy was faster it's a TD", but the point is, my punter is kicking it 40 yards and a majority of the time I stop them after 10.


You do realize punt distance is measured from the LOS... they would have been starting at their own 48 or the 50 in both those plays... not having had an opportunity to return it for a td.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
As long as you admit you are putting yourself at a disadvantage...


We're just gonna have to agree to disagree then. Use your WR if you like, I'll stick with my punter.

Either way, I stand by not likely a bug and another Bugs Mod will have to weigh in.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
I dont even now why I am arguing with someone who openly admits they dont pay attention to lower leveled league play... those are just slow build seasons right.

If you were trying to be competitive in those leagues and winning was a priority you would be able to see that there is no benefit to punting the ball... at least against strong competition (really the only games worth evaluating anyway).
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
openly admits they dont pay attention to lower leveled league play


Never said that, but feel free to put words in my posts.

I have my share of PeeWee and low-level non-lolgm trophies and they were all won with a punter back there. You just happen to be picking and choosing whatever you can to support your argument for this suggestion.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Originally posted by beenlurken

As long as you admit you are putting yourself at a disadvantage...


We're just gonna have to agree to disagree then. Use your WR if you like, I'll stick with my punter.

Either way, I stand by not likely a bug and another Bugs Mod will have to weigh in.


I have never used a WR... honestly I could give at rats ass about those leagues (much like yourself... they are just slow building farm time as far as you and I are concerned). That said, some users take those leagues seriously and are actively trying to win them. For their sake this should be addressed... and also for the sake of newbs with low leveled punters and returners that actually pay attention to how their players perform there.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Originally posted by beenlurken

openly admits they dont pay attention to lower leveled league play


Never said that, but feel free to put words in my posts.

I have my share of PeeWee and low-level non-lolgm trophies and they were all won with a punter back there. You just happen to be picking and choosing whatever you can to support your argument for this suggestion.


I am sorry... silly me to think you didnt care about low leveled league play outside of getting max XP for your players. What the hell was I thinking...



Originally posted by VolBrian
I don't know, that's not my team and I pay no attention to the ST's there just the offense. On top of that, that's a slowbuild team, so I'm not sure anybody is really paying attention to stopping the returners, just getting our dots as many plays as possible.


Originally posted by VolBrian
You're looking at the wrong team man. That team is serious slowbuild. Nobody did anything last season to make adjustments anywhere. That punter is being built to extremes so he had no strength last season. The only thing we did last season was make sure everyone got max xp. I haven't ever looked at the ST chart, but I wouldn't be surprised to find a QB or something on there in coverage......


Originally posted by VolBrian
(another slowbuild team btw, but better than the first you posted)
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by beenlurken
Originally posted by VolBrian

Originally posted by beenlurken


openly admits they dont pay attention to lower leveled league play


Never said that, but feel free to put words in my posts.

I have my share of PeeWee and low-level non-lolgm trophies and they were all won with a punter back there. You just happen to be picking and choosing whatever you can to support your argument for this suggestion.


I am sorry... silly me to think you didnt care about low leveled league play outside of getting max XP for your players. What the hell was I thinking...



Originally posted by VolBrian

I don't know, that's not my team and I pay no attention to the ST's there just the offense. On top of that, that's a slowbuild team, so I'm not sure anybody is really paying attention to stopping the returners, just getting our dots as many plays as possible.


Originally posted by VolBrian

You're looking at the wrong team man. That team is serious slowbuild. Nobody did anything last season to make adjustments anywhere. That punter is being built to extremes so he had no strength last season. The only thing we did last season was make sure everyone got max xp. I haven't ever looked at the ST chart, but I wouldn't be surprised to find a QB or something on there in coverage......


Originally posted by VolBrian

(another slowbuild team btw, but better than the first you posted)


It is silly of you to pick two teams that I'm doing that with. Try looking at VS where I run the offense or any of my PeeWee success I had back in the day.

Claiming I don't care about lower-level leagues is patently offensive to me because it's my job to look at issues in all leagues from PeeWee to World.

Just because I have two teams that are building to extreme caps for WL play doesn't mean I don't care. You want to get examples? Search for playoff teams from whatever league you choose. Don't pick out just two of my own low-level admittedly slow-building teams to try and prove your argument.
 
beenlurken
offline
Link
 
Ok... I just looked a VS...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1365253

Are you telling me it was worth punting with a punter in that game?

Why not take the automatic fair catch and make them work for the td?
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Dude, lolpreseason, something I really don't care about tactics wise at any level. We win that game by 50 if the AI's were on.

I'm telling you. If you want to really prove your point, you're gonna have to select random leveled playoff teams and compute the punting averages with the return averages. If what you're saying is true, then all of those teams will be giving up 20+ yards per return every game and having a punting average less than 40 every game. Even then, it's a matter of opinion which strategy is worth what to each user, no exploit.
 
doobas
™
offline
Link
 
Calm down, guys. It's not worth getting all angry over.

I'm still unsure as to whether this is a bug, but it can be exploited at the lower levels, without a doubt.

doobas™
 
calamnet
offline
Link
 
I imagine this could be exploited at all levels TBH
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.